
NETWORK SCIENCE
Quantifying reputation
and success in art
Samuel P. Fraiberger
1,2
, Roberta Sinatra
1,3,4,5
, Magnus Resch
6,7
,
Christoph Riedl
1,2
*, Albert-László Barabási
1,3,8,9
*
In areas of human activity where performance is difficult to quantify in an objective
fashion, reputation and networks of influence play a key role in determining access to
resources and rewards. To understand the role of these factors, we reconstructed the
exhibition history of half a million artists, mapping out the coexhibition network that
captures the movement of art between institutions. Centrality within this network captured
institutional prestige, allowing us to explore the career trajectory of individual artists
in terms of access to coveted institutions. Early access to prestigious central institutions
offered life-long access to high-prestige venues and reduced dropout rate. By contrast,
starting at the network periphery resulted in a high dropout rate, limiting access to central
institutions. A Markov model predicts the career trajectory of individual artists and
documents the strong path and history dependence of valuation in art.
T
he Man with the Golden Helmet, an 18th-
century painting attributed to Rembrandt,
was Berlin’s most famous artwork for dec-
ades. Once evidence emerged, in the 1980s,
that the painting was not by Rembrandt, it
lost much of its artistic and economic value, even
though the artwork itself had not changed (1).
Quality in art is elusive; art appeals to individual
senses, pleasures, feelings, and emotions. Recog-
nition depends on variables external to the work
itself, like its attribution, the artist’sbodyofwork,
the display venue, and the work’srelationshipto
art history as a whole (2, 3). Recognition and value
are shaped by a network of experts, curators, col-
lectors, and art historians whose judgments act as
gatekeepers for museums, galleries, and auction
houses (4). Given the fragmented and often secre-
tive nature of transaction records, quantitative
analyses of the art world have been difficult (5, 6).
Although artists’ reputation is known to affect
auction outcomes, our current understanding
of these processes is based on small samples
spanning short periods and limited to a coun-
try or region (7–9).
Our dataset was collected by Magnus (www.
magnus.net) and combines information on artists’
exhibitions, auction sales, and primary market
quotes. It offers information on 497,796 exhi-
bitions in 16,002 galleries, 289,677 exhibitions in
7568 museums, and 127,208 auctions in 1239 auc-
tion houses, spanning 143 countries and 36 years
(1980 to 2016, fig. S1), allowing us to reconstruct
the artistic career of 496,354 artists (see supple-
mentary text S1 for additional description and
validation and fig. S1a for an example) (10, 11).
The number of exhibitions for an artist followed
a fat-tailed distribution; whereas 52% of the
artists had one recorded show, a few high-profile
artists were exhibited at an exceptional number
of venues (fig. S1, c and d). Although half of
the auctioned artworks sold for less than $4000,
the price for art was as high as $110,500,000
(fig. S1 f).
Prestigious institutions have access to well-
regarded artists, and influential artists in turn
tend to seek out prestigious institutions. Yet,
institutional prestige is also highly subjective,
determined by factors like history, leadership, re-
sources, and geogr aphic location. Given that
major institutions act as art portfolios, we can
uncover the slowly changing institutional pres-
tige from frequent artwork exchanges, an ap-
proach called “adiabatic approximation” (12). For
this, we define an order t coexhibition network,
whose nodes are museums and galleries, con-
nected by weighted directed links (i, j) that rep-
resent the number of artists that exhibited first
in i then in j within a window of t exhibits (fig.
S2, a and b) (13). The obtained order t = 1
coexhibition network, connecting 16,002 galleries
and 7568 museums as nodes via 19,031,332 links,
incorporates all art movement in our dataset. A
subset of this network revealed the clustering
inherent in the art world (Fig. 1 and figs. S3 and
S4). The network core was a dense community of
major European and North American institu-
tions,
underlying their access to a common pool
of artistic talents. Movement between the hubs in
thecorewasexceptionallyhigh:Thelinkweight
between Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) and
Guggenheim was 33 times highe r than expected
if artists would move randomly between insti-
tutions (supplementary text S2.1), reflecting a
highly concentrated movement of selected artists
between a few prominent institutions. Multiple
dense regional communities of institutions in
Europe, Asia, South America, and Australia were
relatively isolated from the core, indicating that
members of these communities share artists
mainly among themselv es.
A network-based ranking using each institu-
tion’s eigenvector centrality (14) was strongly
correlated with known prest ige measures (sup-
plementary text S2.4 and fig. S5): (i) N =9392
institutions were independently assigned grades
from A to D by a team of experts at Magnus based
on criteria including longevity, the artists exhib-
ited, size and quality of exhibition space, and art
fair participation. A-rated institutions had high
network-based ranking, whereas those rated D
were at the bottom half (Fig. 2A). (ii) For each
institution, we computed the maximum relative
price taken across all the artworks exhibited,
observing a high correlation between network-
based ranks and economic value of the exhibited
artists artworks (Fig . 2B). The top 10–ranked
institutions had the highest cumulative sales
values (Fig. 2C and fig. S6), indicating that the
coexhibition network, though its construction is
agnostic to price, identified institutions that have
access to highly valued artists. In general, an in-
stitution’sgeographicdistancetooneofthe10
largest hubs showed no relationship with pres-
tige (fig. S7, a and b). By contrast, the network-
based distance of an institution to one of the top
10 institutions was closely linked to its prestige
(fig. S7, c and d). Thus, network effects play a
defining role in influencing the evolution of an
artist’s reputation and valuation.
To show that artistic careers can be interpreted
within the context of the institutions to which
they have acces s, we grouped artists by the av-
erage prestige of their first five exhibits. We
assigned an artist a high initial reputation if
her work was on average exhibited in the top
20% of institutions as defined by network rank-
ing; an artist had low initial reputation if his
work was shown on average in the bottom 40%
(supplementary text S3.1). A decade after their
fifth exhibit, 39% of the high –initial reputation
artists continued to exhibit (Fig. 2D). For low–
initial reputation artists, only 14% remained
active 10 years later. Next, we selected 31,794
artists, born betwee n 1950 and 1990 with at
least 10 exhibitions (Fig. 2E). As a group, high–
initial reputation artists had continuous access
to high-prestige institutions during their entire
career (Fig. 3A). Of the 4058 high–initial reputa-
tion artists, 58.6% remain in high-prestige ter-
ritory until the end of their recorded career, and
only 0.2% had the average prestige of their five
most recent exhibits in the bottom 40% (Fig. 2F).
This lock-in effect was largely absent for low–
initial reputation artists: Their reception improved
with time, advancing slowly to institutions of
increasing prestige (Fig. 3A). Only 10.2% of low–
initial reputation artists had the average pres-
tige of their five most recent exhibits in the top
20% (Fig. 2F). Overall, initial reputation (first five
exhibits) predicted success across a variety of
RESEARCH
Fraiberger et al., Science 362, 825–829 (2018) 16 November 2018 1of5
1
Network Science Institute, Northeastern University, Boston,
MA, USA.
2
Harvard Institute for Quantitative Social Sciences,
Cambridge, MA, USA.
3
Department of Mathematics and its
Applications and Center for Network Science, Central
European University, Budapest, Hungary.
4
Complexity
Science Hub, Vienna, Austria.
5
ISI Foundation, Turin, Italy.
6
University of St Gallen, St. Gallen, Switzerland.
7
Zagreb
School of Economics and Management, Zagreb, Croatia.
8
Division of Network Medicine, Department of Medicine,
Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
9
Department of
Network and Data Science, Central European University,
Budapest, Hungary.
*Corresponding author. Email: alb@neu.edu (A.-L.B.); c.riedl@
neu.edu (C.R.)
on January 25, 2019 http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from