# Quantifying reputation and success in art

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/quantifying-reputation-and-success-in-art

- **Authors:** Samuel P. Fraiberger, Roberta Sinatra, Magnus Resch, Christoph Riedl, and Albert-László Barabási
- **Published:** 2018
- **Topic:** Mathematics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1679053414598-pbufrdctjqp-66be563ebb3b03c1705fce5d6b7945dd%2FFraiberger_2018.pdf
- **Pages:** 6
- **Annotations:** 7 comments in 7 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/quantifying-reputation-and-success-in-art

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Quantifying reputation”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2023-04-03):

> Reputation and networks of influence play an important role in determining access to resources and rewards in fields where objective performance measurement is difficult. To understand this, the exhibition history of half a million artists was analyzed, creating a coexhibition network that shows movement of art between institutions. Centrality in this network indicates institutional prestige, and early access to prestigious institutions offers lifelong access to high-prestige venues and reduces dropout rates. Starting at the network periphery results in a high dropout rate and limited access to central institutions. A Markov model predicts the career trajectory of individual artists and shows the strong path dependence of valuation in art.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “In areas of human activity where performance is difficult to quantify in an objective fashion, reputation and networks of influence play a key role in determining access to resources and rewards. To understand the role of these factors, we reconstructed the exhibition history of half a million artists, mapping out the …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2023-04-16):

> A Markov model is a mathematical framework used to model a system whose state changes over time in a stochastic (random) manner. In this framework, the probability of transitioning from the current state to a future state depends only on the current state and not on any past states. This is known as the Markov property.
>
> The Markov model consists of a set of states and a set of transitions between those states, each associated with a probability. The state of the system at any given time is determined by which state it was in at the previous time step and the probability of transitioning to a new state. These probabilities are often represented in a transition matrix, where each element represents the probability of moving from one state to another.
>
> The Markov model is widely used in a variety of fields, including finance, economics, engineering, and biology, to model complex systems and predict their behavior over time. For example, it can be used to predict stock prices or weather patterns, to design control systems for manufacturing processes, or to model the spread of infectious diseases in a population.

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “he Man with the Golden Helmet, an 18thcentury painting attributed to Rembrandt, was Berlin’s most famous artwork for decades. Once evidence emerged, in the 1980s, that the painting was not by Rembrandt, it lost much of its artistic and economic value, even though the artwork itself had not changed (1). Quality in art …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2023-04-03):

> Some background on "The Man with the Golden Helmet " painting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_with_the_Golden_Helmet

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “he Man with the Golden Helmet, an 18thcentury painting attributed to Rembrandt, was Berlin’s most famous artwork for decades. Once evidence emerged, in the 1980s, that the painting was not by Rembrandt, it lost much of its artistic and economic value, even though the artwork itself had not changed (1). Quality in art …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2023-04-03):

> > "Quality in art is elusive; art appeals to individualsenses, pleasures, feelings, and emotions. Recognition depends on variables external to the work itself, like its attribution, the artist’s body of work, the display venue, and the work’s relationship to art history as a whole (2, 3). Recognition and value are shaped by a network of experts, curators, col-lectors, and art historians whose judgments act as gate keepers for museums, galleries, and auction houses (4). Given the fragmented and often secretive nature of transaction records, quantitative analyses of the art world have been difficult (5, 6).
> Although artists’ reputation is known to affect auction outcomes, our current understanding of these processes is based on small samples spanning short periods and limited to a country or region."

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “To show that artistic careers can be interpreted within the context of the institutions to which they have acces s, we grouped artists by the average prestige of their first five exhibits. We assigned an artist a high initial reputation if her work was on average exhibited in the top 20% of institutions as defined by …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2023-04-03):

> In 2017, Basquiat's untitled painting of a skull was sold for 110.5 million dollars.
>
> For more: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/05/19/529096175/at-110-5-million-basquiat-painting-becomes-priciest-work-ever-sold-by-a-u-s-arti

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “he Man with the Golden Helmet, an 18thcentury painting attributed to Rembrandt, was Berlin’s most famous artwork for decades. Once evidence emerged, in the 1980s, that the painting was not by Rembrandt, it lost much of its artistic and economic value, even though the artwork itself had not changed (1). Quality in art …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2023-04-03):

> The adiabatic approximation is a technique used in quantum mechanics to simplify the description of a system that evolves slowly compared to the characteristic timescales of its environment. In this approximation, it is assumed that the system remains in its instantaneous ground state as it evolves, so that its energy and wavefunction change only gradually in time. This allows us to treat the system as being in a sequence of static ground states, each corresponding to a different instant in time, rather than having to solve the time-dependent Schrödinger equation explicitly.
>
> The adiabatic approximation is useful because it can significantly simplify the calculations required to describe the behavior of a system, and it can also provide insight into the physical mechanisms underlying its evolution. However, it is only valid under certain conditions, such as when the energy gap between the ground state and the excited states is much larger than the characteristic rate of change of the system, and when there is no degeneracy or avoided crossings in the energy spectrum. If these conditions are not met, the adiabatic approximation may break down, and a more sophisticated approach may be required to describe the system’s behavior accurately.

### Annotation 7 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “Our analysis focused on art sur veyed by galleries, museums, or auction houses, so nonobject–based art, like performance art, was underrepresented. We also focused on success measures tied to institutional access, ignoring multiple dimensions through which art and artists enrich our society (18). Yet, even with this …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2023-04-16):

> > "Our analysis focused on art sur veyed by galleries, museums, or auction houses, so non-object–based art, like performance art, was underrepresented. We also focused on success measures tied to institutional access, ignoring multiple dimensions through which art and artists enrich our society (18). Yet, even with this limited focus, our results codify the stratification of the art world, which limits access of artists to institutions that would be beneficial to their career. Quantifying these barriers and the mechanism of access could help establish policies to level the playing field."

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

NETWORK SCIENCE

Quantifying reputation [Annotation 1]

and success in art

Samuel P. Fraiberger 1,2 , Roberta Sinatra 1,3,4,5 , Magnus Resch 6,7 , Christoph Riedl 1,2 *, Albert-László Barabási 1,3,8,9 *

In areas of human activity where performance is difficult to quantify in an objective fashion, reputation and networks of influence play a key role in determining access to resources and rewards. To understand the role of these factors, we reconstructed the exhibition history of half a million artists, mapping out the coexhibition network that captures the movement of art between institutions. Centrality within this network captured institutional prestige, allowing us to explore the career trajectory of individual artists in terms of access to coveted institutions. Early access to prestigious central institutions offered life-long access to high-prestige venues and reduced dropout rate. By contrast, starting at the network periphery resulted in a high dropout rate, limiting access to central [Annotation 2] institutions. A Markov model predicts the career trajectory of individual artists and documents the strong path and history dependence of valuation in art.

T

he Man with the Golden Helmet, an 18thcentury painting attributed to Rembrandt, [Annotation 3] was Berlin’s most famous artwork for decades. Once evidence emerged, in the 1980s, that the painting was not by Rembrandt, it lost much of its artistic and economic value, even though the artwork itself had not changed (1). Quality in art is elusive; art appeals to individual senses, pleasures, feelings, and emotions. Recog- [Annotation 4] nition depends on variables external to the work itself, like its attribution, the artist’sbodyofwork, the display venue, and the work’srelationshipto art history as a whole (2, 3). Recognition and value are shaped by a network of experts, curators, collectors, and art historians whose judgments act as gatekeepers for museums, galleries, and auction houses (4). Given the fragmented and often secretive nature of transaction records, quantitative analyses of the art world have been difficult (5, 6). Although artists’ reputation is known to affect auction outcomes, our current understanding of these processes is based on small samples spanning short periods and limited to a country or region (7–9). [Annotation 6]

Our dataset was collected by Magnus (www. magnus.net) and combines information on artists’ exhibitions, auction sales, and primary market quotes. It offers information on 497,796 exhibitions in 16,002 galleries, 289,677 exhibitions in 7568 museums, and 127,208 auctions in 1239 auc-

tion houses, spanning 143 countries and 36 years (1980 to 2016, fig. S1), allowing us to reconstruct the artistic career of 496,354 artists (see supplementary text S1 for additional description and validation and fig. S1a for an example) (10, 11). The number of exhibitions for an artist followed a fat-tailed distribution; whereas 52% of the artists had one recorded show, a few high-profile artists were exhibited at an exceptional number of venues (fig. S1, c and d). Although half of the auctioned artworks sold for less than $4000, the price for art was as high as $110,500,000 (fig. S1 f).

Prestigious institutions have access to wellregarded artists, and influential artists in turn tend to seek out prestigious institutions. Yet, institutional prestige is also highly subjective, determined by factors like history, leadership, resources, and geogr aphic location. Given that major institutions act as art portfolios, we can uncover the slowly changing institutional prestige from frequent artwork exchanges, an approach called “adiabatic approximation” (12). For this, we define an order t coexhibition network, whose nodes are museums and galleries, connected by weighted directed links (i, j) that represent the number of artists that exhibited first in i then in j within a window of t exhibits (fig. S2, a and b) (13). The obtained order t = 1 coexhibition network, connecting 16,002 galleries and 7568 museums as nodes via 19,031,332 links, incorporates all art movement in our dataset. A subset of this network revealed the clustering inherent in the art world (Fig. 1 and figs. S3 and S4). The network core was a dense community of major European and North American institutions, underlying their access to a common pool of artistic talents. Movement between the hubs in thecorewasexceptionallyhigh:Thelinkweight between Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) and Guggenheim was 33 times highe r than expected if artists would move randomly between institutions (supplementary text S2.1), reflecting a

highly concentrated movement of selected artists between a few prominent institutions. Multiple dense regional communities of institutions in Europe, Asia, South America, and Australia were relatively isolated from the core, indicating that members of these communities share artists mainly among themselv es.

A network-based ranking using each institution’s eigenvector centrality (14) was strongly correlated with known prest ige measures (supplementary text S2.4 and fig. S5): (i) N =9392 institutions were independently assigned grades from A to D by a team of experts at Magnus based on criteria including longevity, the artists exhibited, size and quality of exhibition space, and art fair participation. A-rated institutions had high network-based ranking, whereas those rated D were at the bottom half (Fig. 2A). (ii) For each institution, we computed the maximum relative price taken across all the artworks exhibited, observing a high correlation between networkbased ranks and economic value of the exhibited artists artworks (Fig . 2B). The top 10–ranked institutions had the highest cumulative sales values (Fig. 2C and fig. S6), indicating that the coexhibition network, though its construction is agnostic to price, identified institutions that have access to highly valued artists. In general, an institution’sgeographicdistancetooneofthe10 largest hubs showed no relationship with prestige (fig. S7, a and b). By contrast, the networkbased distance of an institution to one of the top 10 institutions was closely linked to its prestige (fig. S7, c and d). Thus, network effects play a defining role in influencing the evolution of an artist’s reputation and valuation.

To show that artistic careers can be interpreted [Annotation 5] within the context of the institutions to which they have acces s, we grouped artists by the average prestige of their first five exhibits. We assigned an artist a high initial reputation if her work was on average exhibited in the top 20% of institutions as defined by network ranking; an artist had low initial reputation if his work was shown on average in the bottom 40% (supplementary text S3.1). A decade after their fifth exhibit, 39% of the high –initial reputation artists continued to exhibit (Fig. 2D). For low– initial reputation artists, only 14% remained active 10 years later. Next, we selected 31,794 artists, born betwee n 1950 and 1990 with at least 10 exhibitions (Fig. 2E). As a group, high– initial reputation artists had continuous access to high-prestige institutions during their entire career (Fig. 3A). Of the 4058 high–initial reputation artists, 58.6% remain in high-prestige territory until the end of their recorded career, and only 0.2% had the average prestige of their five most recent exhibits in the bottom 40% (Fig. 2F). This lock-in effect was largely absent for low– initial reputation artists: Their reception improved with time, advancing slowly to institutions of increasing prestige (Fig. 3A). Only 10.2% of low– initial reputation artists had the average prestige of their five most recent exhibits in the top 20% (Fig. 2F). Overall, initial reputation (first five exhibits) predicted success across a variety of

RESEARCH

Fraiberger et al., Science 362, 825–829 (2018) 16 November 2018 1of5

1 Network Science Institute, Northeastern University, Boston, MA, USA. 2 Harvard Institute for Quantitative Social Sciences, Cambridge, MA, USA. 3 Department of Mathematics and its Applications and Center for Network Science, Central European University, Budapest, Hungary. 4 Complexity Science Hub, Vienna, Austria. 5 ISI Foundation, Turin, Italy. 6 University of St Gallen, St. Gallen, Switzerland. 7 Zagreb School of Economics and Management, Zagreb, Croatia. 8 Division of Network Medicine, Department of Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA. 9 Department of Network and Data Science, Central European University, Budapest, Hungary. *Corresponding author. Email: alb@neu.edu (A.-L.B.); c.riedl@ neu.edu (C.R.)

on January 25, 2019 http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from

#### Page 2

Fraiberger et al., Science 362, 825–829 (2018) 16 November 2018 2of5

Fig. 1. Coexhibition network. Force-directed layout of the order t = 1 coexhibition network, whose nodes are institutions (galleries, museums). Node size is proportional to each institution’s eigenvector centrality. Nodes are connected if they both exhibited the same artist, with link weights being equal to the number of artists’ coexhibitions. Node colors encode the region in which institutions are located. Links are of the same colors as their end nodes, or gray when end nodes have different colors. For

visualization purposes, we only show the 12,238 nodes corresponding to institutions with more than 10 exhibits; we pruned the links by keeping the most statistically significant links (20) (supplementary text S2.2). We implemented community detection on the pruned network (21), identifying 122 communities (supplementary text S2.3). We highlighted five of them, the full community breakdown being shown in fig. S3. We also show the names of the most prestigious institution for each community.

RESEARCH | REPORT

on January 25, 2019 http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from

#### Page 3

measures: High–initial reputation artists had twice as many exhibitions as low–initial reputation artists (Fig. 2G); 49% of the exhibitions of high–initial reputation artists occurred outside of their home country, compared to 37% for low– initial reputation artists (Fig. 2G), and high– initial reputation artists showed more stability in institutional prestige (Fig. 2H ). The work o f a high–initial reputation artist was traded 4.7 times more often at auctions than that of a low–initial reputation artist (Fig. 2 I), at a maximum price that was 5.2 times higher (Fig. 2I). We also collected 442,314 prices of artworks displayed i n galleries, finding that the average maximum price of high–initial reputation artists was $193,064, compared to $40,476 for low–initial reputation artists (Fig. 2H). Thus, art car ee rs were characterized by strong path dependence; artists starting in high-prestige institutions located at the center of the netw o r k

showed a lower dropout rate and tended to maintain their status. By contrast, those starting at the periphery of the network showed a high dropout rate, but if they persisted, their access to top institutions gradually improved.

To model how reputation emerges in the art world, let p½i tþ1 ji t  be the probability that an artist, currently exhibited at institution i t , next exhibits at institution i t+1 . We assume that the only institutions i t+1 reachable for the artist are those that have exhibited an artist from institution i t before. We can therefore model an artistic career as a random walk on t he order t =1network (15, 16), the probability of moving to i t+1 being proportional to the number of previous artists who transitioned from i t to i t+1 (fig. S2). We assume that the network captures the connections between curators and institutions, guiding access to specific institutions. Independently of where artists started their career, this model

directs them toward institutions of median prestige (Fig. 3B), failing to capture the lock-in effect observed in real careers. This suggests that access to institutions also depends on the artist’sprevious exhibition histor y, not only on current exhibition venue. To consider an artist’sprevious exhibition history i 1 , i 2 ,…, i t (17), we write the probability of the i t → i t+1 transition as

p½i tþ1 ji t ; …; i 1 ¼K  m½p i tþ1 ; m t p½i tþ1 ji t ð1Þ

where K is a normalization factor and the second term on the right-hand side captures the memory of the system about artists’ reputations, written as

m½p i tþ1 ; m t ¼ p½p i tþ1 jm t  p½p i tþ1  ð2Þ

where

Fig. 2. Quantifying artistic careers. (A) Network-based prestige ranks, captured by eigenvector centrality, for institutions that were independently assigned different grades. (B) The relationship between sales-based ranks and eigenvector centrality-based network ranks, binned in 100 intervals, showing a high Spearman’s correlation (r S = 0.88). We report mean (black line) and standard error (gray shading) within each bin. (C) Data on top 10 institutions as predicted by the network-based ranking. Colors capture geographical location, as shown in Fig. 1. ( D) Survival curves, showing the fraction of artists that continue to exhibit in the years following their first five exhibits based on the career of 99,265 artists with more than five exhibits. (E) Probability density function of average prestige during the first five exhibits for the 31,794 artists with more than 10 exhibits born between 1950 and 1990. (F) Diagram illustrating how the

career high– and low–initial reputation artists evolves, showing the fraction of those artists whose final reputation (last five recorded exhibits) is either low or high. To show how the early career determines various success measures across a career, we consider as control variable the average prestige of the first five exhibits of an artist, and report (G) the total number of exhibits (left), the percentage of these exhibits outside of their home country (right), (H) the standard deviation of their exhibition prestige (left), the maximum price at which they are currently quoted in a gallery (in $, right), (I) the total number of their works that were sold in the auction market (left), and the maximum price (relative to the average market price) at which their work sold in the auction market (right). Each panel demonstrates the important role that initial reputation plays in shaping later access to institutions and financial reward.

RESEARCH | REPORT

on January 25, 2019 http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from

#### Page 4

m t ¼ 1 t

X n t

k¼1

p i tkþ1 ð3Þ

is the aver ag e reput at io n , representing the average prestige of the artist’spastn t exhibitions. In other words, memory acts as a multiplicative weight that depends on the average past reputation of the artist and the prestige of the target institution. This allows us to measure the memory term m½p i tþ1 ; m t  directly from the data, helping us document strong reputation effect for all artists (supplementar y text S3.2 and Fig. 3, D to F). Consider an artis t whose previous exhibitions conferred an average reputation in the bottom decile, e.g., m =0.1(Fig.3D).Hischances of exhibiting next at an institution whose prestige p is in the bottom decile was 3.4 times higher than expected by chance, and his probability of moving to a top-decile institution was only one-fifth of that expected by chance. The monotonically decreasing m½p i tþ1 ; m t  with prestige p indicates that an artist with low previous reputation had a 17 times higher chance of moving next to a low-prestige institution than

to a high-prestige one. We observe the opposite trend for an artist whose previous reputation was in the top decile, e.g., m =0.9(Fig.3F):Her relative chances of exhibiting once again at a highprestige institution were 42 times higher than moving to a low-prestige institution.

To test the role of reputation, we simulated the career of each artist in our sample, using as input only their first five exhibits and the universal (artist-independent) m½p i tþ1 ; m t fu nctions to decide where they would exhibit next. The model accurately captured the lock-in effect observed in real careers (Fig. 3C). The forecast error saturated beyond n t = 12 (supplementary text 3.3 and fig. S8a), indicating that the past 12 exhibitions offered an optimal memory to capture the role of reputation in artistic careers. The modeling framework did not predict the specific institutions that exhibit an artist, but only their level of prestige (figs. S8, b to h, and S9). This is partly because there are many institutions within each community, with comparable prestige.

As Fig. 2F illustrates, 240 artists who began their career in low-prestige institutions did break through, having the average prestige of their last

five recorded exhibits in high-prestige institutions. We find that those who do break through do so within the first 10 years of their careers (fig. S10a). We also find that among their first five exhibits, breakout artists exhibit in institutions with a wider range of rankings, their initial prestige standard deviation being 18.6%, compared to 10.3% for those who did not break through (p = 10 −22 , fig. S10b); they exhibit in more distinct institutions, their initial fraction of exhibitions in distinct institutions being 70.3%, compared to 49.3% (p =10 −21 , fig. S10c); have higher maximum exhibition prestige (0.60 compared to 0.41, p =10 −25 ,fig.S10d);andtheirnetworkdistanceto MoMA is equal to 0.48, compared to 0.60 (p = 10 −26 , fig. S10e). In other words, later access to high-prestige institutions is improved by an intensive early “shopping around.”

Although talent is difficult to measure, we expect an artist’s talent to be uncorrelated with their country of origin, implying that the distribution of initial reputation should not vary across artists of different origin. However , initial reputation was not equally distributed across artists of different country of origin (Fig. 3G). In many

Fraiberger et al., Science 362, 825–829 (2018) 16 November 2018 4of5

Fig. 3. Modeling the emergence of reputation. (A) For a random sample including 30% of the 31,794 artists with more than 10 exhibits born between 1950 and 1990, we show the evolving exhibition prestige over time. (B) Evolving exhibition prestige predicted by the random walk model (memoryless), documenting its failure to capture real careers. (C) The memory model predicts the evolution of prestige. We use the first five exhibits to initialize the models. The sequence of dates at which an artist’s exhibitions occur was matched to the one we observe in the data. (D to F) Variation of the memory component with the prestige of the ne xt exhibit p,for differ ent ranges of values for past reputation m. p and m are reported in decile. (G) Probability density function of averag e prestige during the first five exhibits for the 31,794 artists, and the subset of those artists who were born in the United States, Canada, and India. (H)Finalreputation ver sus initial reputation for artists of different country of origin.

RESEARCH | REPORT

on January 25, 2019 http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from

#### Page 5

countries, artists start and end their career in lowprestige institutions (Fig. 3H); those, however, born in countries with better access to the art network have a higher chance of starting and ending their career at the top.

Our analysis focused on art sur veyed by galleries, museums, or auction houses, so nonobject–based art, like performance art, was underrepresented. We also focused on success measures tied to institutional access, ignoring multiple dimensions through which art and artists enrich our society (18). Yet, even with this limited focus, our results codify the stratification of the art world, which limits access of artists to institutions that would be beneficial to their career. Quantifying these barriers and the mechanism of acces s could help establish policies to level the playing field. For example, the ar t world [Annotation 7] could benefit from the implementation of lot tery systems that offer some underrepresented artists access to high-prestige venues, or blind selection procedures, successfully implemented in clas sical music (19), enhancing the inclusion of neglected works and artists.

REFERENCES AND NOTES 1. H. Bonus D. Ronte, J. Cult. Econ. 21, 103 (1997). 2. P. Bourdieu, The Field of Cultural Production (Columbia Univ.

Press, 1993).

3. O. Velthuis, Rev. Austrian Econ. 17, 371–386 (2004). 4. V. A. Ginsburgh, J. C. van Ours, Am. Econ. Rev. 93, 289–296

(2003). 5. M. Schich et al., Science 345, 558–562 (2014). 6. M. Schich, I. Meirelles, Leonardo 49, 445 (2016). 7. N.F.Campos,R.L.Barbosa,Oxf. Econ. Pap. 61,28–51

(2009). 8. N. Marinelli, G. Palomba, Q. Rev. Econ. Finance 51, 212–224

(2011). 9. F. Etro, L. Pagani, J. Cult. Econ. 37, 391–415 (2013). 10. R. Sinatra, D. Wang, P. Deville, C. Song, A.-L. Barabási, Science

354, aaf5239 (2016). 11. L. Liu et al., Nature 559, 396–399 (2018). 12. C. Castellano, S. Fortunato, V. Loreto, Rev. Mod. Phys. 81,

591–646 (2009). 13. V. Sekara, A. Stopczynski, S. Lehmann, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.

113,9977–9982 (2016). 14. P. Bonacich, Am. J. Sociol. 92, 1170–1182 (1987). 15. N. Masuda, M. A. Porter, R. Lambiotte, Phys. Rep. 716-717,1–58

(2017). 16. R. Sinatra, J. Gómez-Gardeñes, R. Lambiotte, V. Nicosia,

V. Latora, Phys. Rev. E Stat. Nonlin. Soft Matter Phys. 83, 030103 (2011). 17. M. Szell, R. Sinatra, G. Petri, S. Thurner, V. Latora, Sci. Rep. 2,

457 (2012). 18. D. W. Galenson, OldMastersandYoungGeniuses:TheTwo

Life Cycles of Artistic Creativity (Princeton Univ. Press, 2011). 19. C. Goldin, C. Rouse, Am. Econ. Rev. 90,715–741

(2000). 20. M. A. Serrano, M. Boguñá, A. Vespignani, Proc. Natl. Acad.

Sci. U.S.A. 106, 6483–6488 (2009). 21. V. D. Blondel, J.-L. Guillaume, R. Lambiotte, R. Lefebvre,

J. Stat. Mech. 2008, P10008 (2008).

22. S. Fraiberger, Replication Data for: Quantifying Reputation and

Success in Art. Harvard Dataverse, V5 (2018).

AC KN OW LE D GM E NT S We thank S. Balietti, J.A. Evans, M. Santolini, and M. Szell for their discussion and feedback and A. Grishchenko and K. Albercht for their help with visual design. Funding: This work was supported by NSF grant IIS-1514283 (C.R.), Air Force Office of Scientific Research grants FA9550-15-1-0077 and FA9550-15-1-0364 (A.-L.B. and R.S.), European Commission, H2020 Framework program, grant 641191 CIMPLEX (R.S., A.-L.B.), Templeton Foundation grant no. 61066 (R.S., A.-L.B.), and the ITI project “Just Data” funded by Central European University (R.S.). Author contributions: All authors discussed the results and commented on the manuscript. S.P.F. analyzed the data, developed the models and methods, and wrote the manuscript. R.S. analyzed the data and developed the methods. M.R. provided that data. A-L.B. and C.R. directed the research and wrote the manuscript. Competing interests: M.R. is CEO and Founder of magnus.net. Data and materials availability: The data necessary to replicate the research are available at Harvard Dataverse (22). Access to this dataset is only for noncommercial use or for replicating the results of the manuscript.

SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS www.sciencemag.org/content/362/6416/825/suppl/DC1 Materials and Methods Supplementary Text Figs. S1 to S10 Reference (23)

13 February 2018; resubmitted 9 July 2018 Accepted 27 September 2018 Published online 8 November 2018 10.1126/science.aau7224

Fraiberger et al., Science 362, 825–829 (2018) 16 November 2018 5of5

RESEARCH | REPORT

on January 25, 2019 http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from

#### Page 6

Quantifying reputation and success in art Samuel P. Fraiberger, Roberta Sinatra, Magnus Resch, Christoph Riedl and Albert-László Barabási

originally published online November 8, 2018DOI: 10.1126/science.aau7224 (6416), 825-829.362Science

, this issue p. 825Science access to elite institutions among those who started their career at the network periphery. a lock-in effect among highly reputed artists who started their career in high-prestige institutions and a long struggle for study and model the career trajectory of individual artists relative to a network of galleries and museums. They observed used an extensive record of exhibition and auction data toet al.Art appreciation is highly subjective. Fraiberger The science of art advancement

ARTICLE TOOLS http://science.sciencemag.org/content/362/6416/825 MATERIALS SUPPLEMENTARY http://science.sciencemag.org/content/suppl/2018/11/07/science.aau7224.DC1 REFERENCES http://science.sciencemag.org/content/362/6416/825#BIBL This article cites 20 articles, 4 of which you can access for free PERMISSIONS http://www.sciencemag.org/help/reprints-and-permissions

Terms of ServiceUse of this article is subject to the

is a registered trademark of AAAS.Science licensee American Association for the Advancement of Science. No claim to original U.S. Government Works. The title Science, 1200 New York Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20005. 2017 © The Authors, some rights reserved; exclusive (print ISSN 0036-8075; online ISSN 1095-9203) is published by the American Association for the Advancement ofScience

on January 25, 2019 http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/quantifying-reputation-and-success-in-art. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
