# Why should physicists study history?

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/why-should-physicists-study-history-

- **Authors:** Matthew Stanley
- **Published:** 2016
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1699211037636-6t5u0l1djke-017fc8ccc88d9e9376db2a195b669cc3%2F38_1_online.pdf
- **Pages:** 7
- **Annotations:** 7 comments in 7 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/why-should-physicists-study-history-

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “And a more human physics is a good thing. For starters, it makes physics more accessible, particularly for students. Many promising students drop out of the sciences because the material seems disembodied and disconnected from their lives. Science education researchers have found that those lost students “hungered— …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-11-05):

> ### TL;DR
>
> This paper argues that studying the history of science provides valuable insights into the practice of physics beyond the technical facts. It emphasizes that history can teach physicists about the social dimensions of scientific work, the attachment to certain scientific ideas despite evidence to the contrary, and the influence of wider societal issues like war and nationalism on scientific collaboration and progress. It advocates for a historical perspective as a tool for understanding the collaborative and often messy nature of scientific endeavo

### Annotation 2 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Understanding the human side of physics will also be"er prepare students for what physicists actually do. Physicists work in groups. They need to talk. Physics is a social endeavor. Ideas and experimental equipment are exchanged constantly. In the early days of general relativity, it was extremely diﬃcult to become …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-11-05):

> The concept of the ether was a cornerstone of 19th-century physics as a supposed medium for light waves to travel through, similar to how sound waves travel through air. Despite extensive efforts, no experimental evidence supported the ether's existence. The most notable failure to detect the ether was the Michelson-Morley experiment in 1887, which found no evidence of the Earth moving through such a medium.
>
> Nonetheless, the scientific community continued to hold onto the ether concept because it was deeply embedded in the prevailing physics frameworks of the time. It wasn't until Albert Einstein's theory of special relativity in 1905 that the notion of the ether was challenged decisively. Einstein showed that the speed of light is constant in all frames of reference, negating the need for an ether.
>
> However, old theories die hard, and despite Einstein's breakthrough, the ether theory lingered for a while as the scientific community slowly shifted toward the new paradigm that Einstein's theory offered.

### Annotation 3 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Every discovery has come out of a messy mix of people, ideas, accidents, and arguments. Generally it takes a great deal of effort to understand what an observation or theory means. The Millikan oil drop experiment, for example, appears in textbooks as a model of clear experimental design and immediately persuasive …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-11-05):

> Robert Millikan's oil-drop experiment, conducted in 1909 to measure the electric charge of a single electron, was a triumph of precision measurement but not without difficulty.
>
> The experiment required exacting conditions: observing tiny oil droplets suspended between two electric plates, adjusting the voltage to precisely control their fall speed, and accounting for variables like air pressure and temperature.
>
> Millikan's meticulous approach demanded considerable patience and skill, as he had to ensure that the oil droplets were clean, properly illuminated, and observed through a microscope.
>
> He also faced practical challenges, such as the need to prevent the oil from evaporating and to account for the effects of air currents. Moreover, the task of calculating the charge of the electron from his observations was arduous due to the complex mathematical corrections required.

### Annotation 4 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “The history of physics suggests that there are usually several ways to approach a problem. Quantum electrodynamics emerged from its predecessors not because it was clearly superior but because Freeman Dyson showed that the renormalization approaches of Richard Feynman, Julian Schwinger, and Sin-itiro Tomonaga were all …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-11-05):

> Dyson showed that all three formulations, although conceptually different, were mathematically compatible and could be used interchangeably. This was an important synthesis, as it meant that calculations could be performed using the most convenient form from any of the three methods, providing physicists with flexible tools to predict the outcomes of experiments. It validated the renormalization techniques used to deal with infinities that arose in perturbative calculations within the theory.
>
> His exposition of QED helped solidify the theory's place as one of the most accurate and predictive physical theories ever developed. Dyson didn't receive a Nobel Prize for his work, which some in the physics community consider an oversight, but his role in developing QED is widely acknowledged and respected. His contributions went beyond unifying the theory; they also extended to clarifying the philosophical implications of quantum mechanics and its impact on our understanding of the physical world.

### Annotation 5 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “FIGURE 2. ROBERT WILSON (LEFT) AND ARNO PENZIAS inspect their radio antenna. The two men shared half of the 1978 Nobel Prize in Physics “for their discovery of cosmic microwave background radiation.” What they actually saw, though, was low-frequency noise from the antenna. Only with suitable interpretation was the …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-11-05):

> Luis Alvarez was a prominent figure in the field of particle physics and won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1968 for his work in the discovery of a large number of resonance states, which are high-energy particles. His expertise in detecting and analyzing different isotopes, which are variants of chemical elements with different neutron numbers, led to a collaboration with his son, Walter Alvarez, a geologist.
>
> Walter was studying the boundary layer between the Cretaceous and Tertiary geological periods, known as the K-T boundary, which marks a major event in Earth's history approximately 66 million years ago, where a sharp decline in the diversity of fossilized life is observed. This event coincided with the mass extinction of dinosaurs, amongst other species, but the cause of this extinction was a matter of scientific debate and had long puzzled scientists.
>
> Luis Alvarez's expertise in isotopes came into play when he and Walter proposed a hypothesis that linked a layer of iridium found in the K-T boundary to an extraterrestrial source. Iridium is relatively scarce in the Earth's crust but is abundant in asteroids and certain types of meteorites. By analyzing the varying levels of iridium concentration across different geological layers, they were able to provide evidence that supported their asteroid impact hypothesis.
>
> The father-son team, with chemist Frank Asaro and nuclear physicist Helen Michel, published their findings in 1980, suggesting that a large asteroid had struck the Earth, leading to significant climate changes that were responsible for the mass extinction. The dust and debris thrown up by the impact would have blocked sunlight, leading to a drastic, prolonged cooling and darkening of the Earth—a "nuclear winter" scenario—disrupting photosynthesis-based food chains and climate patterns.
>
> The Alvarez hypothesis spurred a revolution in our understanding of Earth's geological history and mass extinctions. The discovery of the Chicxulub crater on the Yucatán Peninsula provided strong evidence in favor of their theory, as the crater's age corresponded to the timing of the extinction event.

### Annotation 6 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “presented as a list of things that physicists think are true. We call those lists “textbooks.” They do a terrible job of showing what physicists and other scientists actually do—try to solve puzzles. Instead of talking about the things physicists already know, textbooks could emphasize what is still unknown about a …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-11-05):

> David Kaiser's "How the Hippies Saved Physics: Science, Counterculture, and the Quantum Revival" is a historical account of the fundamental role that the counterculture movement of the 1970s played in reinvigorating the study of quantum mechanics. The book narrates the story of a group of eccentric physicists in the San Francisco Bay Area who called themselves the "Fundamental Fysiks Group." They were influenced by the freewheeling, psychedelic vibe of the era and were driven by a desire to explore the philosophical underpinnings and weirder implications of quantum theory—topics that had largely fallen out of favor among mainstream physicists by the mid-20th century.
>
>
> Kaiser weaves a narrative around this group, showing how they delved into subjects like Bell's theorem and quantum entanglement, areas not considered particularly worthwhile or promising by their contemporaries. The book illustrates how their unconventional, interdisciplinary approach to physics—encompassing aspects of Eastern philosophy, parapsychology, and even telepathy—eventually contributed to what is known as the "quantum information revolution."
>
>
> Through their informal gatherings, public lectures, and brainstorming sessions, the members of the Fundamental Fysiks Group challenged the status quo, bringing attention back to the foundational issues of quantum mechanics. Their curiosity-driven research laid the groundwork for what would become the hotbeds of quantum computing, cryptography, and teleportation theories.
>
>
> Kaiser points out that, despite the group's initial marginalization, their ideas eventually permeated the academic mainstream. The members of the group, which included notable figures like Jack Sarfatti, Fred Alan Wolf, and Nick Herbert, among others, were instrumental in bringing about a renaissance in quantum theory, which has had lasting implications for modern science and technology.
>
>
> The book also sheds light on the broader social and intellectual currents of the time, offering insight into how shifts in culture can impact scientific development. Kaiser, as a historian of science, uses the story of the Fundamental Fysiks Group to argue for the value of speculative and philosophical approaches in scientific inquiry, particularly when tackling questions as deep and mysterious as those posed by quantum physics.

### Annotation 7 (page 7)

Beside the passage: “will continue into the future, and it is helpful to know what has been asked so far. I would be remiss not to mention that history of science is, frankly, fun. It is full of fascinating stories that will captivate you. Who doesn’t want to know more a!er learning that in his experiments James Joule (ﬁgure 6) relied on …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-11-06):

> James Joule was an English physicist, most famous for his research in thermodynamics and for the principle that would later bear his name—the Joule effect. What is less commonly known is that Joule's scientific journey was profoundly influenced by his background in the brewing industry. His family owned a brewery, and it was in managing the brewery's operations that Joule developed a practical interest in the efficiency of engines and the transfer of heat—principles critically relevant to his later experiments and theories.
>
> In the context of his brewing work, Joule became fascinated with the potential for improving the efficiency of the steam engines used in brewing. His expertise in this area led him to experiment with the conversion of mechanical energy into heat, which had direct applications for his business in terms of improving processes and saving on fuel costs.
>
> Joule's knowledge of beer production meant that he was well-versed in the temperatures and conditions necessary for fermentation, a process that is both influenced by and generates heat. This gave him a practical grounding in the need for precise temperature control and an understanding of how energy moves and transforms—a key concept in his scientific work.
>
> The act of brewing, with its combination of chemical and physical processes, provided Joule with a familiar and accessible framework for his studies in physics. His experiments often used equipment adapted from the brewery, and he applied the same careful and innovative approach to his scientific inquiry that he used in his brewing practice.
>
> Through careful observation and meticulous experimentation, often conducted with improvised apparatus, Joule was able to quantify the relationship between heat and mechanical work. This relationship, now fundamental to the laws of thermodynamics, was at the time a pioneering insight that challenged the established caloric theory of heat.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

Just as physics is not a list of facts about the world,

history is not a list of names and dates. It is a way of

thinking that can be powerful and illuminating.

Why should physicists

study history?

S

GALILEO GALILEI SHOWS THE DOGE OF VENICE how to use a telescope in this 1858 fresco by Giuseppe Bertini.

Matthew Stanley

05 November 2023 19:01:36

#### Page 2

JULY 2016 | PHYSICS TODAY 39

Matt Stanley is a professor of the history of science at New York University ’s G allatin School of Individualize d Study in New York City.

History can help. An entire academic discipline—history of science—studies the rough edges. We historians of science see ourselves as illustrating the power of stories. How a community tells its history changes the way it thinks about itself. A historical perspective on science can help physicists understand what is going on when they practice their cra!, and it provides numerous tools that are useful for physicists themselves.

Physics is a social endeavor Research is done by people. And people have likes and dislikes, egos and prejudices. Physicists, like everyone else, get a"ached to their favorite ideas and hang on to them perhaps long a!er they should let them go. A classic case is the electromagnetic ether, an immensely fruitful concept that dominated physics for most of the 19th century. Even as it became clear that ether theory was causing more problems than it solved, physicists continued to use it as a central explanatory tool—even for many years a!er Einstein’s 1905 theory of special relativity declared it superﬂuous. The history of physics is li"ered with beautiful theories that commanded great loyalty.

People come from places too, and physicists want to protect their homes as much as anyone else. It is easy to forget that 100 years ago during World War I, British scientists refused to talk to their German colleagues on the other side of the trenches. Even a!er the end of the ﬁghting, Germans and their wartime allies were oﬃcially forbidden from joining international scientiﬁc organizations. During World War II, the specter of an atomic bomb in the hands of Adolf Hitler terriﬁed Allied physicists into opening the Pandora’s box of nuclear weapons. Many of the scientists involved bemoaned their actions a!erward, but war and nationalism make for a potent impetus.

Those incidents are not exceptions. Physicists are not disinterested ﬁgures without political views, philosophical preferences, and personal feelings. The history of science can help dismantle the myth of the purely rational genius living outside

the everyday world. It makes physics more human.

And a more human physics is a [Annotation 1] good thing. For starters, it makes physics more accessible, particularly for students. Many promising students drop out of the sciences because the material seems disembodied and disconnected from their lives. Science education researchers have found that those lost students “hungered— all of them—for information about how the various methods they were learning had come to be, why physicists and chemists understand nature the way they do, and what were the connections between what they were learning and the larger world.” 1 Students can potentially lose the wonder and curiosity that drew them to science in the ﬁrst place. Historical narratives naturally raise conceptual, philosophical, political, ethical, or social questions that show the importance of physics for the students’ own lives. A ﬁeld in which people are acknowledged as people is much more appealing than one in which they are just calculating machines.

Understanding the human side of physics will also be"er prepare students for what physicists actually do. Physicists work in groups. They need to talk. Physics is a social endeavor. Ideas and experimental equipment are exchanged constantly. In the early days of general relativity, it was extremely diﬃcult to become proﬁcient in the theory without direct contact with Albert Einstein or his inner circle. [Annotation 2] 2 And since the Great War was raging, few physicists could obtain that contact. General relativity became widely known only a!er Willem de Si"er, in the neutral Netherlands and in personal contact with Einstein, passed his relativistic skills on to Arthur Eddington in the UK. Fortunately, Eddington was a Quaker paciﬁst and one of the few British scientists willing to look at a German theory. 3 Physics works only when people talk to each other, and communication is not always easy.

Physics isn’ t obvious Everything seems obvious in retrospect. Textbooks present experimental results as being self-evident and theories as needing at most a few pages of math to be proven true. But crystalclear expositions conceal the enormous amount of work and confusion that goes into reaching scientiﬁc conclusions. The history of physics can remind us how diﬃcult it is to justify ideas—from heliocentrism to atomic theory—that now seem so obvious.

Complexity, not simplicity, has ruled the practice of science.

ome things about physics aren’t well covered in a physics

education. Those are the messy, rough edges that make everything difficult: dealing with people, singly or in groups; misunderstandings; rivals and even allies who won’t fall in line. Physicists often do not see such issues as contributing to science itself. But social interactions really do influence what

scientists produce. Often physicists learn that lesson the hard way. Instead, they could equip themselves for the actual collaborative world, not the idealized solitary one that has never existed.

S

05 November 2023 19:01:36

#### Page 3

40 PHYSICS TODAY | JULY 2016

Every discovery has come out of a messy mix of people, ideas, accidents, and arguments. Generally it takes a great deal of effort to understand what an observation or theory means. The Millikan oil drop experiment, for example, appears in textbooks as a model of clear experimental design and immediately persuasive theoretical interpretation. However, even a quick look at Robert Millikan’s lab notebooks shows how immensely diﬃcult it was for him to make his experiment work. (Figure 1 shows a sample notebook page.) [Annotation 3]

Nature rarely gives a straight answer. So researchers in science sometimes follow blind paths and usually need trial and error and second guessing. Once a robust result has been achieved, scientists tend to downplay all the hard work that went into it; simplicity seems more persuasive than complexity. But the complexity is actually quite reassuring. Students and young researchers are o!en heartened to learn that physics is hard work and that it is okay for their own eﬀorts not to look like a textbook presentation. 4 Messiness is the standard. Mistakes are normal. The great advances in sciences are much more remarkable when coupled with an appreciation that they came out of struggles and screwups instead of ﬂashes of insight. The results of physics are not self-evident.

Every time physicists disagree on how to interpret a set of data, they provide fresh proof that physics isn’t obvious. Some

data only have signiﬁcance from a certain point of view. Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson saw excess low-frequency noise in their antenna (shown in ﬁgure 2), not the cosmic microwave background. It was only when they looked at the noise in light of Big Bang cosmology that it seemed important.

The history of physics suggests that there are usually several ways to approach a problem. Quantum electrodynamics emerged from its predecessors not because it was clearly superior but because Freeman Dyson showed that the renormalization approaches of Richard Feynman, Julian Schwinger, and Sin-itiro Tomonaga were all equivalent. None of those independent approaches were wrong, they just needed to be reframed. Even the now-indispensable Feynman diagrams were not obviously useful when they ﬁrst appeared. They were confusing, and it was not clear how to use them. Dyson, again, was instrumental to the acceptance of a new idea: He had to teach everyone what Feynman diagrams were good for and to evangelize about their importance. Things that now seem essential and obvious never started out that way. 5 [Annotation 4]

Physics needs many kinds of people Turning complexity into good physics requires creativity. You can never tell what weird idea will help clarify a confusing observation or provide the key to interpreting an equation. His-

tory uncovers the strange stew of concepts that were necessary for the development of physics. Consider the second law of thermodynamics. Its formulation and interpretation were largely due to Lord Kelvin (ﬁgure 3). But Kelvin did not come to thermodynamics as a blank slate. He came to it as a Victorian obsessed with waste and engineering eﬃciency. He came to it as a religious ﬁgure who studied the heat death of the universe because it made sense in light of Psalm 102, which acknowledges that the heavens and Earth will all wear out like a garment. 6 His personal background gave him the tools he needed to grapple with the puzzling phenomena now a"ributed to the second law. You can see the importance of Kelvin’s particular point of view when you compare his work with that of, say, German physicists working on thermodynamics. They brought very diﬀerent ideas to the table and came up with diﬀerent conceptions. The interplay of various approaches is what brought us

WHY STUDY HISTORY?

FIGURE 1. ROBERT MILLIKAN’S LAB NOTEBOOKS are filled with pages like this, jampacked with data, calculations, corrections, and occasional comments. Despite the impression textbook presentations may give, perfecting the famous oil-drop experiment and obtaining the charge of the electron was a long, arduous task. This notebook entry is from 27 February 1912. (Courtesy of the Archives, California Institute of Technology.)

—— ——

05 November 2023 19:01:36

#### Page 4

our modern view, which we wouldn’t have if not for Kelvin’s now-strange ideas.

Strange but ultimately useful perspectives o!en come from ﬁelds and disciplines apparently distant from the problem at hand. James Clerk Maxwell learned about statistical variation from historians. Particle physicist Luis Alvarez brought expertise in isotopes to his son Walter’s geological work and helped solve the mystery of the dinosaurs’ extinction. The history of science shows how important it is for scientists across diﬀerent ﬁelds to talk to each other. Conversation among separate groups is healthy. Apparently isolated problems are o!en closely tied together, and you never know where you will ﬁnd the weird idea that solves your diﬃculties.

The best strategy for encouraging diverse ideas is to cultivate a diverse community. Underrepresented groups that oﬀer diﬀerent ways of thinking are o!en the sources of fresh insights and novel methods. Numerous striking examples exist, and they have led to representatives of marginalized communities becoming visible in the mainstream. For instance, how Marie"a Blau developed the nuclear emulsion technique—critical to the emergence of the ﬁeld we now call particle physics—was distinctive of someone on the periphery. As a Jewish woman in interwar Austria, Blau, shown in ﬁgure 4, was doubly excluded. Women were o!en refused entrance to laboratories, sometimes on the grounds that their hair was too ﬂammable. Jews were rarely allowed to hold high-ranking positions even before the rise of the Nazis. Such restrictions meant that if Blau wanted to study particles, she had to develop cheap, portable detectors that could be made with commonly available materials. With her techniques from the margins, she created an essential observational tool that was u"erly surprising to those in the largely homogenous physics community of the time. 7 Underrepresented groups are usually marginalized because of cultural inertia or deliberate decisions made long ago. For that reason, many working to increase diversity in physics see themselves as helping to right a social wrong. Feynman was denied admission to Columbia University because someone there decided it had too many Jewish students—a decision that now seems absurdly wrongheaded. Surely his alma mater, MIT, beneﬁted from its decision to accept someone on the margins.

In 2015 John Roberts, chief justice of the US Supreme Court, was puzzled by the idea that diversity could be helpful in physics. (See P HYSICS TODAY, March 2016, page 10.) Roberts’s remarks were disappointing even if the idea behind them is not uncommon: The ideal of science as a monolithic enterprise of pure rationality eﬀectively hides the importance of diﬀerent perspectives and outlooks. However, that importance is clearly documented in the history of science, which can help clarify both why physics is mostly done by white men and why that can o!en be a limiting factor for future progress. The history of physics is a fantastic example of the importance of intellec-

tual and institutional diversity. Many diﬀerent ways of thinking can be brought to bear on a problem, and they should be encouraged.

Physics isn’ t finished The diversity of ideas and interpretation serves as a reminder that physics is a work in progress. Knowledge is provisional. There are always new ways to tackle a problem, and there is always more to be learned. The history of physics should make one hesitant to claim that current theories will hold forever.

Some worry that such admissions of uncertainty make science less a"ractive. Actually, the opposite is true. If physics is nearly done, why pursue it? Placing the last few bricks in an almost-complete wall is not always exciting, but expanding an unconstrained structure is a thrilling challenge. 8 It is heartening to know that not everything has been discovered.

Accepting uncertainty would require changes in how physics and, more generally, science is taught. Physics is typically

JULY 2016 | PHYSICS TODAY 41

FIGURE 2. ROBERT WILSON (LEFT) AND ARNO PENZIAS [Annotation 5] inspect their radio antenna. The two men shared half of the 1978 Nobel Prize in Physics “for their discovery of cosmic microwave background radiation.” What they actually saw, though, was low-frequency noise from the antenna. Only with suitable interpretation was the observation worthy of a Nobel. (Courtesy of the AIP Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, P HYSICS TODAY Collection.)

05 November 2023 19:01:36

#### Page 5

presented as a list of things that physicists think are true. We call those lists “textbooks.” They do a terrible job of showing what physicists and other scientists actually do—try to solve puzzles. Instead of talking about the things physicists already know, textbooks could emphasize what is still unknown about a subject. They could talk about how much work still remains: What are the mysteries yet to be uncovered? What is the problem that can’t seem to be cracked? Curiosity should be rewarded, and everyone should be encouraged to ask, [Annotation 6] “What else?”

One eﬀect of such a pedagogical shi! would be less of a focus on proof. Few things can be strictly proven true. In practice, scientists accumulate evidence for a particular claim. That evidence provides some level of conﬁdence. Insisting that every scientiﬁc concept meets or even should meet the standard of proof is dangerous; it makes knowledge easily a"acked, since virtually every claim has some possible doubt.

If scientists are not explicit and honest about their doubts, a crisis of conﬁdence arises when that uncertainty is revealed. That psychological reality is used to great advantage by, for example, those opposed to teaching evolution in schools. Talking about varying levels of evidence and doubt, instead of about proof or its absence, will actually make science more powerful in the public sphere.

Physics wasn’ t always as it is The ﬂip side of accepting that physics will be diﬀerent in the future is accepting that it was diﬀerent in the past. Everyone has a tendency to assume that the way things are now is the norm. But history makes it clear that things were not always this way. An understanding of why people used to think diﬀerently is a powerful tool for understanding people today. By

drawing a"ention to older, unspoken assumptions, history shows us how to start paying a"ention to our own.

No less a personage than Einstein advocated for that historical method. As a young man, he read Ernst Mach’s writings on the history of science, and he credited Mach with teaching him how to think critically about scientiﬁc principles: “A knowledge of the historic and philosophical background,” Einstein once wrote, “gives that kind of independence from prejudices of his generation from which most scientists are suﬀering.” (See the article by Don Howard, P HYSICS TODAY, December 2005, page 34.) He complained that physicists tended to regard currently accepted ideas as unalterable givens. Instead, he suggested, they should study the history of those ideas and understand the circumstances in which they were justiﬁed and found useful. In that way, a young physicist on the margins—say, one serving as a patent clerk in 1905— will feel emboldened to strike out into new areas and oﬀer creative new suggestions.

History trains you to think critically about received ideas. History provides evidence of roads not taken. There are many ways to think about the mysteries of quantum physics. The ubiquity of the Copenhagen interpretation does not make it the best one, and it is certainly not the only useful one. Einstein himself would want physicists to take a critical approach to the foundations of quantum mechanics.

Historian and philosopher Hasok Chang argues that science’s plurality of interpretations can make the history of science a resource for modern scientiﬁc research. He calls his approach complementary science—recovering forgo"en and unsolved puzzles from the past. Some earlier ideas and observations, such as the reﬂection of cold, were simply abandoned rather than being investigated thoroughly and dropped for good reasons. 9 Pu"ing complementary science into practice demands diﬃcult self-examination. Thinking deeply and critically about assumptions and accepted knowledge can be hard to do in professional scientiﬁc contexts, but history is a mode in which it is encouraged.

David Kaiser’s How the Hippies Saved Physics is a fascinating example of how that kind of critical thinking can happen. 10 Some physicists in the 1960s and 1970s were dissatisﬁed with the “shut up and calculate” culture of the ﬁeld (four of them are shown in ﬁgure 5). They were interested in the deeper philosophical meaning behind their equations. To ﬁnd that meaning, they engaged with both the mystical counterculture of the era and the history of quantum physics. Along the way, they helped to instigate broader interest in Bell’s theorem and quantum entanglement. The simple realization that people used to think diﬀerently can be quite powerful.

Physics doesn’ t have rigid rules People encountering the history of science for the ﬁrst time are o!en shocked that the actual practice of science bears so li"le resemblance to the step-by-step scientiﬁc method they learned in school. Scientists simply do not follow a rigid, linear problem-solving system. Sometimes they start with a hypothesis, sometimes with a strange observation, sometimes with a weird anomaly in an otherwise straightforward experiment. Einstein himself reﬂected late in life that a scientist must be an “unscrupulous opportunist,” adopting and adapting various approaches as new challenges arise. 11

42 PHYSICS TODAY | JULY 2016

WHY STUDY HISTORY?

FIGURE 3. LORD KELVIN (1824–1907) approached thermodynamics with tools reflecting his religious and engineering background. This portrait was painted by Hubert von Herkomer.

05 November 2023 19:01:36

#### Page 6

Instead of applying a rigid method, scientists work with whatever evidence they have and make the best explanation possible. Consider the claim that theories are disproved by contrary observations. In the early 19th century, Uranus’s orbit seemed incompatible with Newtonian gravity. One reaction would have been to declare that Newtonian gravity had been disproved. Of course, very few people did that. The Newtonian theory of gravity had proven so fruitful that much more than one anomalous observation would be needed to discard it. An easier resolution to the problem was that a new planet, Neptune, was hidden in the darkness. So it seemed obvious that a later discrepancy in Mercury’s orbit should be explained the same way. To again redeem Newtonian gravity, astronomers searched for a planet Vulcan hidden in the Sun’s light. Eventually, however, Einstein proposed that Mercury’s orbital anomaly was a good reason to scrap Newton in favor of his own theory. 12 Sometimes a discrepancy is a good reason to discard a theory, and sometimes it is worth inventing a whole new entity to save a theory. Diﬀerent situations call for diﬀerent approaches. Physicists usually have good reasons for making their choices, but they need to acknowledge the diﬃculty and complexity of those choices.

The stories told about scientiﬁc discoveries ma"er. One can easily ﬁnd completely diﬀerent versions of the origin of special relativity. Was it a straightforward deduction from the results of the Michelson–Morley experiment? Or did it come from Einstein’s philosophical ponderings of the nature of space and time? Or, historical origins notwithstanding, should it just be derived abstractly from Maxwell’s equations? You conceptualize physics in diﬀerent ways depending on which story you hear. Those who do the telling should make sure their stories are the ones best supported by the historical evidence.

One should not get too anxious about work that seems to endanger the scientiﬁc method. There are many ways to go about doing physics, and it was probably not fair to a"ack string theory for violating methodological guidelines, though string theorists might want to heed the earlier warnings about being overly a"ached to beautiful theories. Physicists nowadays are typically not trained in the philosophy of science— although both Einstein and Niels Bohr were— and the philosophical principles they invoke are usually far out of date. Karl Popper’s notion that the mark of science is falsiﬁability doesn’t do much work anymore—for example, astrology is perfectly falsiﬁable, but it’s not considered science. Even the currently popular Bayesianism can only take one so far. The history of science shows how deﬁnitions and standards of science have shi!ed over time and, hopefully, provides some impetus to

engage with the important work being done today by philosophers of science.

Ideas on their own terms History teaches that knowledge is not ﬁxed. Historical thinking involves asking incisive questions: Why did people in the past think that was true? Why do I think the opposite is true?

Engaging with history will teach you to understand ideas on their own terms. Aristotle wasn’t a man who was bad at Newtonian physics, he just had a completely diﬀerent perspective. People in the past worried about diﬀerent things and tried to solve their problems in diﬀerent ways. The bugbear of historians is the so-called Whig history that judges everything in the past by how much it looks like the present. Eschewing that kind of judgment is an amazing tool for making sense

of the world and its people. If you can understand why people believed heat was a form of ma"er, you can understand why your colleague is being intractable in a meeting.

Historical thinking makes its subject dynamic. It helps you think about science as a series of questions rather than a series of statements. Those questions

JULY 2016 | PHYSICS TODAY 43

FIGURE 4. MARIETTA BLAU (1894–1970), as a Jewish woman in interwar Austria, was excluded from the center of physics action. From the margins, she created the nuclear emulsion technique. (Photograph, from 1937, courtesy of the AIP Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, gift of Eva Connors.)

FIGURE 5. THE FUNDAMENTAL FYSIKS GROUP,founded in Berkeley, California, in 1975, explored both mysticism and foundational quantum physics. Shown here are four members: Standing, left to right, are Jack Sarfatti, Saul-Paul Sirag, and Nick Herbert; seated is Fred Alan Wolf. (Photograph by Fred Alan Wolf.)

———

— —

———

05 November 2023 19:01:36

#### Page 7

will continue into the future, and it is helpful to know what has been asked so far. I would be remiss not to mention that history of science is, frankly, fun. It is full of fascinating stories that will captivate you. Who doesn’t want to know more a!er learning that in his experiments James Joule (ﬁgure 6) relied on his expertise in beer, or that Newton stuck a dagger into his eye to learn more [Annotation 7] about colors?

I’ve heard concerns, though, that such stories are a distraction that take time away from science instruction or quantitative research. A good strategy is to integrate history into teaching and thinking. Doing so will make physics majors and physicists be"er citizens of the world and help a"ract sharp students to science careers. Even for nonscience majors, history of science is an excellent way to increase science literacy and engagement with scientiﬁc ideas.

In the end, history of science exposes scientists to new ways of thinking and forces them to reexamine what is already known. Such intellectual ﬂexibility is essential for any discipline, but it is particularly important for ﬁelds as inﬂuential and authoritative as physics and other sciences. How do we know what we know, and how might it be otherwise?

REFERENCES 1. S. Tobias, They’re Not Dumb, They’re Different: Stalking the Second

Tier, Research Corp (1990), p. 81. 2. A. Warwick, Masters of Theory: Cambridge and the Rise of Mathe-

matical Physics, U. Chicago Press (2003). 3. M. Stanley, Isis 94, 57 (2003). 4. X. Lin-Siegler et al., J. Educ. Psychol. 108, 314 (2016). 5. D. Kaiser, Am. Sci. 93, 156 (2005). 6. C. Smith, M. N. Wise, Energy and Empire: A Biographical Study of

Lord Kelvin, Cambridge U. Press (1989). 7. P. Galison, Image and Logic: A Material Culture of Microphysics,

U. Chicago Press (1997). 8. M. Gleiser, The Island of Knowledge: The Limits of Science and the

Search for Meaning, Basic Books (2014). 9. H. Chang, Inventing Temperature: Measurement and Scientific

Progress, Oxford U. Press (2004). 10. D. Kaiser, How the Hippies Saved Physics: Science, Counterculture,

and the Quantum Revival, W. W. Norton (2011). 11. A. Einstein, in Albert Einstein: Philosopher–Scientist, P. A. Schilpp,

ed., Library of Living Philosophers (1949), p. 684. 12. See, for example, T. Levenson, The Hunt for Vulcan . . . and How

Albert Einstein Destroyed a Planet, Discovered Relativity, and Deciphered the Universe, Random House (2015). PT

44 PHYSICS TODAY | JULY 2016

FIGURE 6. JAMES JOULE’S 19th-century exploration of energy conservation was informed by his expertise in beer. History of science reveals such tidbits, which makes

the study of physics more

enjoyable. This etching

of Joule first appeared in the May 1874 issue of the Popular Science Monthly.

WHY STUDY HISTORY?

— —

Some Distinctions of Michael E. Fisher

Wolf Prize in Physics, 1980

Boltzmann Medal, IUPAP Commission on Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics, 1983

Royal Medal, Royal Society of London, 2005

Docteur Honoris Causa, École Normale Supérieure de Lyon, 2012

386pp | Oct 2016 9789813144897 | US$88 9789813144903(pbk) | US$46

Michael Fisher’s talents as a reviewer may be judged from the selection of best articles collected in this book including:

• Walks, Walls, Wetting and Melting

• Molecular Motors: A theorist’s Perspective

• Phases and Phase Diagrams: Gibbs’s Legacy Today

• Renormalization and Ken Wilson as I knew him

• Statistical Physics in the Oeuvre of C.N. Yang

05 November 2023 19:01:36

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/why-should-physicists-study-history-. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
