# Why can’t you separate interleaved books?

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/why-can-t-you-separate-interleaved-books-

- **Authors:** Kari Dalnoki-Veress, Thomas Salez, and Frédéric Restagno
- **Published:** 2016
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1669598183274-l46yvitr9k-0a8be8b17fa67f5dd483c4707b58d405%2Fdalnoki-veress2016.pdf
- **Pages:** 2
- **Annotations:** 4 comments in 4 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/why-can-t-you-separate-interleaved-books-

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “measuring device such as a spring balance. If your device is sensitive enough, you will ﬁnd that when alternating sheets are removed from each notebook and the remaining sheets are all parallel to each other, the traction force scales linearly with the number of sheets. The friction at each interface is small, so it …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2022-12-03):

> Tabor, who was a physicist and engineer, first proposed this idea in 1950, based on his observations of the behavior of friction in a number of different systems. He observed that the force of friction acting on an object is proportional to the normal force (the force that a surface exerts on an object), but is independent of the surface area of the object.
>
> Bowden, who was a physicist, later confirmed Tabor's observations through experiments in which he measured the force of friction acting on objects of different sizes and shapes. He found that the force of friction was always proportional to the normal force, but did not depend on the surface area of the object.

### Annotation 2 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “FIGURE 2. WHEN SUITABLY SCALED, the friction of interleaved books obeys a universal law. (a) As this schematic shows, when interleaved books are separated by a distance d, the nth sheet makes an angle θ n as it goes from the overlap region to a binding clamp. Here, T n denotes the local traction force on the nth …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2022-12-05):

> The angles that the sheets make as they approach the contact region are crucial for the geometrical amplification of friction in interleaved books. The traction forces create loads perpendicular to the paper-paper interfaces through these angles, resulting in large self-created friction forces. This can be verified by creating an interleaved-book system with $θ_n = 0$ by removing alternating sheets in two notepads. In this case, the books can be easily pulled apart, which is consistent with the theory presented.

### Annotation 3 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “sheets ranged from 24 to 200. A tensile tester measured the total traction force as the notebooks were pulled vertically at a constant velocity, typically 1 mm per minute. We stopped pulling intermi"ently so that we could probe the coeﬃcient of friction at various distances d separating the clamp of one book from the …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2022-12-05):

> Here's an example of the Chinese finger trap - the only way to release the fingers is to push the ends toward the middle, which enlarges the openings and reduces the traction.
>
> ![](https://i.makeagif.com/media/3-03-2019/vhBaV6.gif)

### Annotation 4 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Summing over all the local tractions yields the total traction T. To proceed analytically, we use a continuum description corresponding to a large M. Introducing the quantities z = n/M, T(z)=T n , and the dimensionless ampliﬁcation parameter α =2µεM 2 /d yields the ordinary diﬀerential equation T′(z)+2αzT(z)=0, where …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2022-12-05):

> In order to better understand how to derive the differential equation for this problem it's useful to analyze the following diagram.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/2db83HI.png)
>
> The first thing to note is that the problem is symmetric with respect to the central line of the book. We start by indexing each sheet of a given book by $n$ ($n=1$, middle of the book to $n = M$ at one extremity). We also define $H_n \equiv h_n/d = n/d $, where $h_n$ is the shift in position of the $n^{th}$ sheet in the contact zone with respect to its position of clamping.
>
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/HsWnXbJ.png)
>
> As a consequence, we can build a triangle with angle $\theta_n$ and sides $1$ and $h_n/d$ such that the nth sheet satisfies $\sin \theta_n = H_n/\sqrt{1 + H^2_n}$ and $\cos \theta_n = 1/\sqrt{1 + H^2_n}$.
>
> According to Amontons-Coulomb law, this leads to a self-induced inner friction force that resists the traction when an operator pulls on an object. At the onset of sliding, the change in traction with respect to the index n can be calculated using these principles.
>
> $$
> T_n − T_{n+1} = 4 \mu H_n T_n
> $$
>
> where $\mu$ is the coefficient of kinetic friction, and the two factors of 2 come from the identical contributions of the two books and the two pages of one sheet. The boundary condition is given by $T_M = T^{*}$, where $T^{*}$ is the unknown traction exerted on the outer sheet, and the total traction force is defined by $ \Gamma = 2\sum_{k=1}^M T_k$.
>
> We introduce the variable $z= n/M$ and the dimensionless amplification parameter $\alpha = 2 \mu M^2/d$. In order to use a continuous description, we replace $T_n$ with $T(z)$, since M is much greater than 1. This allows us to obtain the following ordinary differential equation:
>
> $$
> T'(z)+2\alpha z T(z) = 0
> $$
>
> When the boundary condition $T(1) = T^{*}$ is applied, the local traction force $T(z)$ can be found by integration: $T(z) = T^{*}e^{\alpha(1 − z^2)}$. Using this result, we can calculate the total traction force $\Gamma = 2M \int^1_0 dz T(z)$
>
>
> $$
> \frac{\Gamma}{2MT^{*}}=\sqrt{\frac{\pi}{4\alpha}}e^{\alpha}erf({\sqrt{\alpha}})
> $$
>
> Two intersting things about this last expresion: it tends to 1 as alpha approaches 0, meaning that it represents the geometrical amplification of friction compared to a simple linear collection of 2M independent flat sheets with local friction $T^{*}$. Secondly, it depends solely and almost exponentially on the amplification parameter alpha, which is therefore the central dimensionless parameter of this study.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

F

riction has a long scientiﬁc pedigree. Leonardo da Vinci established that the friction force, or traction, T applied when an object begins to slide is given by the simple formula T = µN, where N is the load, or normal force, and µ is the coeﬃcient of friction. Leonardo had suggested that µ = 1 ⁄4 always, but Guillaume Amontons and Charles Augustin Coulomb later showed that µ is not universal; rather, it depends on the nature of the sliding object and the surface on which it slides. In total, the classic Amontons– Coulomb laws state that the friction force during sliding is independent of both the area of contact and the sliding velocity and that it is proportional to the load.

The independence of T from the contact area is hardly intuitive; indeed, it was not fully explained until the mid-20th century, in work by David Tabor and Frank Philip Bowden. More recently, theoretical and computational progress, in conjunction with technological advances such as the atomic force microscope, surface forces apparatus, and quartz crystal microbalance, have renewed interest in friction and improved scientists’ understanding. Many systems, we now know, exhibit behavior much more complex than envisioned in the Amontons– Coulomb laws—particularly at or near the nanoscale. Multiwalled nanotubes furnish an example. In stunning experiments (see the ﬁnal two additional resources), inner and outer tubes were slid along each other to study true molecular friction. Those investigations and others have shown area dependence and vanishing friction. Nevertheless, the classic laws apply in many cases.

A simple, striking experiment Take two phone books, interleave their sheets, and a"empt to separate the books by pulling on their spines. You cannot do it. The accumulated friction between the pages is so great that, as ﬁgure 1 shows, even the weight of a car cannot pull the phone books apart.

Less spectacular than li#ing a car, but more instructive, is a pair of experiments you can try with two perfect-bound notebooks (that is, having rigid spines) whose sheets can be easily removed. Interleave the sheets and you will ﬁnd that the traction force needed to separate the two books is immense. Next, remove every other sheet in each notebook and repeat the experiment. In that case you will have no trouble separating the notebooks.

If you want to go one step further, set up a simple traction-

measuring device such as a spring balance. If your device is sensitive enough, you will ﬁnd that when alternating sheets are removed from each notebook and the remaining sheets are all parallel to each other, the traction force scales linearly with the number of sheets. The friction at each interface is small, so it is easy to separate the books. In contrast, when sheets are not removed, they fan out as they approach the overlap region. As a result, the traction force is greater than in the sheets-removed case, and it increases dramatically with the number of sheets. In fact, our research team—which includes Héctor Alarcón, Christophe Poulard, Jean-Francis Bloch, and Élie Raphaël— showed that in some cases a 10-fold increase in the number of sheets results in a traction force that is increased by more than four orders of magnitude. [Annotation 1]

The enigma of the interleaved phone books, though o#en demonstrated, had not received much quantitative and theoretical a"ention, a circumstance that delighted, perplexed, and, at times, frustrated us. As we will now discuss, the secret to the ampliﬁcation of friction lies in the angles the sheets make as they approach the overlap region.

The Hercules number In our laboratory experiments, we prepared booklets from identical sheets of paper having a width w = 12 cm, length L = 25 cm, and thickness ε = 0.01 mm. The total number 2M of

74 PHYSICS TODAY | JUNE 2016

Kari Dalnoki-Veress is a professor in the department of physics and astronomy at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. Thomas Salez is a CNRS research associate at ESPCI ParisTech in Paris. Frédéric Restagno is a CNRS research associate at Université Paris–Sud in Orsay, France.

QUICK STUDY

Why can’t you separate interleaved books?

Kari Dalnoki-Veress, Thomas Salez, and Frédéric Restagno

Because of the way interpenetrating sheets deform, the harder you pull, the greater the friction force resisting separation.

FIGURE 1. THE FRICTION FORCE generated by the two interleaved phone books on the left is enough to support a car, as illustrated in the scene at right from the show On n’est pas que des cobayes!, aired in France on 2 May 2014. (© France 5/2P2L, used with permission.)

#### Page 2

JUNE 2016 | PHYSICS TODAY 75

sheets ranged from 24 to 200. A tensile tester measured the total traction force as the notebooks were pulled vertically at a constant velocity, typically 1 mm per minute. We stopped pulling intermi"ently so that we could probe the coeﬃcient of friction at various distances d separating the clamp of one book from the overlap region. Figure 2a shows the geometry of the inter- [Annotation 3] leaved books and some of the important parameters used in our analysis. Figure 2b presents our measurements. It clearly shows the nonlinear variation of T with both the number of sheets and the separation distance.

The mechanism leading to ampliﬁed friction can be understood with the help of ﬁgure 2a. The index n labels individual sheets in a booklet, and the nth sheet makes an angle θ n as it goes from the clamp at the end of the notebook to the overlap region. Therefore, a component of the local traction T n exerted on a sheet by an external operator at point A results in a local normal force T n tanθ n exerted on the stack of sheets below it at point B. The result is a self-ampliﬁed friction force that resists the traction: The harder the operator pulls, the greater the local loads and frictional resistance.

Summing over all the local tractions yields the total trac- [Annotation 4] tion T. To proceed analytically, we use a continuum description corresponding to a large M. Introducing the quantities z = n/M, T(z)=T n , and the dimensionless ampliﬁcation parameter α =2µεM 2 /d yields the ordinary diﬀerential equation T′(z)+2αzT(z)=0, where the prime denotes diﬀerentiation with respect to z. To integrate and solve that equation, one needs a boundary condition T ∗ for the traction on the outermost sheet of the stack. The source of that bounding traction could be friction introduced by the elasticity of the paper as it bends or by any tiny adhesion. Upon integration, we obtain the total traction force T =2MT ∗ ·(π/4α) 1/2 · e α ·erf(√ ‾ α), where “erf” denotes the error function.

Note that as α approaches zero, which corresponds to par-

allel sheets and small angles, T =2MT ∗ . That makes sense: As the angles tend to zero, the friction force is due to all the independent sheets, each experiencing local friction T ∗ . In general, however, the total traction force depends nearly exponentially on a single quantity—the dimensionless ampliﬁcation parameter α, which has been given the lovely name “Hercules number.” And as the inset to ﬁgure 2b shows, when the appropriately normalized traction is plo"ed against α, the results of all our experiments collapse onto a single master curve.

Not just a compelling muse We began our phone-book study because we wanted to solve an intriguing popular mystery. But the eﬀect we have studied can be seen in many other systems in which a pulling force results in an orthogonal load that enhances friction. An example is a toy known as the Chinese ﬁnger trap. Fingers inserted into the trap—a braided tube—are diﬃcult to extract because tension tightens the tube. Surgeons use so-called ﬁnger-trap sutures based on that principle. Likewise, a ship can be moored to a capstan because the rope can tighten around the capstan and thereby increase friction. The friction-amplifying mechanism also recalls catch bonds, biomolecular links that strengthen with tensile stress and facilitate cell adhesion. We hope that our study, in addition to elucidating the long-standing and fun phone-book puzzle, will help to clarify the mechanical behavior of more complex interleaved systems involving textiles, biological entities, and nanoscale mechanical devices.

Additional resources ‣ ”Mythbusters—Phone Book Friction,” www.youtube.com /watch?v=AX_lCOjLCTo. ‣ Q. J. Wang, Y.-W. Chung, eds., Encyclopedia of Tribology, Springer (2013). ‣ A. A. Pitenis, D. Dowson, W. G. Sawyer, “Leonardo da Vinci’s friction experiments: An old story acknowledged and repeated,” Tribol. Le%. 56, 509 (2014). ‣ H. Alarcón et al., “Self-ampliﬁcation of solid friction in interleaved assemblies,” Phys. Rev. Le%. 116, 015502 (2016). ‣ J. Cumings, A. Ze"l, “Low-friction nanoscale linear bearing realized from multiwall carbon nanotubes,” Science 289, 602 (2000). ‣ A. Niguès et al., “Ultrahigh interlayer friction in multiwalled boron nitride nanotubes,” Nat. Mater. 13, 688 (2014). PT

FIGURE 2. WHEN SUITABLY SCALED, the friction of interleaved books obeys a universal law. (a) As this schematic shows, when interleaved books are separated by a distance d, the nth sheet makes an angle θ n as it goes from the overlap region to a binding clamp. Here, T n denotes the local traction force on the nth sheet. (b) Total traction force T is measured as a function of distance d. From bottom to top, the number 2M of sheets in each book is 24, [Annotation 2] 30, 46, 54, 100 (two data sets), 150, and 200. As the inset shows, when the total traction is appropriately scaled and plotted as a function of the Hercules number α =2μεM 2 /d, all the curves from the unscaled-traction plot coincide. The solid black line corresponds to the expression for T given in the text.

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/why-can-t-you-separate-interleaved-books-. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
