# Where is everybody? An account of Fermi's question

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/where-is-everybody

- **Authors:** Eric M. Jones
- **Published:** 1985
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1498691958333-wh4iqye10v9-39ad9d1c57e6e78e52f9805f01802717%2Fpaper_fermi_paradox_copy.pdf
- **Pages:** 12
- **Annotations:** 10 comments in 7 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/where-is-everybody

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: ““WHERE I EVERYBODY A NACCOUNTO FERMI QUESTI”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2017-10-29):

> There are **100,000 Earth-like planets capable of intelligent life in our Galaxy**, the Milky Way. (*see guestimations below*)
>
> ### Where is everybody? How come we have never made an "encounter" with extraterrestrial life? Any ideas? 🤓 🤔
> (*Feel free to comment below*)
>
> ---------------------

**Reply** by Mike Chu (2017-10-31):

> In this matter I tend to go with the hypothesis that there's extraterrestrial life in other places in the Universe but we just  haven't been able to detect it. It's also very unlikely that we are the most developed civilization out there so I agree with Freeman Dyson's theory that a sufficiently developed species will try to harness a large part of the energy produced by a star by enclosing it in some sort of shell - [a Dyson Sphere](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dyson_sphere). This will shift the energy emission spectrum around the star towards infrared which in theory should be detectable at a relatively long distance. We just need to map a large portion of sky for a long enough time to capture the signals from these spheres :)

**Reply** by Trevor Sousa (2017-10-31):

> Most likely because there's a more advanced civilization that is able to simulate a Universe where we are the single intelligent species (also called the Planetarium hypothesis). This grew stronger in me after reading [Nick Bostrom's paper](http://fermatslibrary.com/s/are-you-living-in-a-computer-simulation) that has been featured a few months ago.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: ““WHERE I EVERYBODY A NACCOUNTO FERMI QUESTI”

**Annotation** by João Rico (2017-10-31):

> Here's a couple of recent links, somewhat zany, in different directions regarding Fermi's paradox:
>
> Dissolving the Fermi Paradox (Future of Humanity Institute, Oxford)
> https://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/computing/hardware/computing-and-the-fermi-paradox-a-new-idea-emergestheyre-all-asleep
>
> Runaway consumerism explains the Fermi Paradox
> https://www.edge.org/q2007/q07_print.html#miller
>
> What Donald Trump Teaches Us About the Fermi Paradox
> http://nautil.us/blog/what-donald-trump-teaches-us-about-the-fermi-paradox

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Fermi’s famouquestion ocentrt debaa bt prev o fextraterrestriacivilizatioaroduria luncconve withEm iKonopinskiEdwaTellea nHerbY oi t s u o f1950Fermi’companioo thad ah aprovaccoo t incident.”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2017-10-27):

> Enrico Fermi was an Italian-American physicist. He was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1938. He is the creator of the world's first nuclear reactor and worked on the Manhattan project during WW II. Fermi is famous for his back of the envelope calculations and his impressive ability to estimate the magnitude of answers to complex problems. A great example of this ability is this article he wrote guesstimating the power dissipated by the explosion of the first atomic bomb with simple sheets of paper: **[My observations during the explosion at Trinity](http://fermatslibrary.com/s/my-observations-during-the-explosion-at-trinity)**
>
> ![Fermi Teller](https://i.imgur.com/16Spiv9.jpg)
> *Edward Teller (left) with Enrico Fermi in 1951.*
>
>
> You can learn more about Fermi here: [Enrico Fermi](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enrico_Fermi)

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Parto fthecurrentdebateabouttheexistencea nprevaleno extraterre conc interstellartravelandsettlement. 1-3I n1975MichaeH aargut h interst traw o b efeasiblefora technologicallyadvancedcivilizatioa nthaa migratwouf it G a i na fewmillionyears.4Sincethatintervali shorcomparewitt ha go t hGalh t h concludedthattheabsenceo …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2017-10-28):

> Travelling to distant Galaxies to meet other intelligent civilization would take billions of years and is practically impossible. So let's focus on our home Galaxy, the Milky Way. **How many intelligent civilizations are there in our Galaxy?** We can *guesstimate* the number of planets harboring intelligent life in the Milky Way:
>
> - there are **$100 \times 10^{9}$ Stars in our Galaxy**  ⭐️
> - if 5% of all stars are Sun-like then there are **$5 \times 10^{9}$ Sun-like stars in our Galaxy** ☀️
> - if 20% of all Sun-like stars are orbited by an Earth-like planet then there **$10^{9}$ Earth-like planets** 🌎
> - if only 1% of these Earth-like planets harbor life then there would be **$10\times 10^{6}$ planets with life in the Milky Way**  🐋
> - if 1% of those develop intelligent life then **there are 100,000 intelligent civilizations in our Galaxy**  🤓
>
> If there are 100,000 intelligent civilization in the Milky Way, then the question arises **where are all the Aliens?**
>
> This is the **Fermi Paradox**.
>
> You can learn more about the Fermi Paradox:
> - [Fermi Paradox](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox)
> - [SETI - The Fermi Paradox](https://www.seti.org/seti-institute/project/details/fermi-paradox)
> - [Wait But Why - The Fermi Paradox](https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/05/fermi-paradox.html)

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

Beside the passage: ““ IrememberhavingwalkedoverwithFerma nothert t hFullLod f o lunW h w ewalkedover,therewasa conversationwhicI believt hav bee quibria supe o na subjectonlyvaguelyconnectedwithspactravelI hava vagrecollecw hm notb eaccurate,thatw etalkedaboutflyingsaucera nt hobviostatemt ht fly saucersarenotreal.I …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2017-10-19):

> **Fermi is famous for his guesstimations** and his impressive ability to estimate the magnitude of answers to complex problems. He had an uncanny ability to take problems apart and describe them in simple terms. Fermi tried to inculcate this facility in his students. Some famous Fermi questions:
> - How many grains of sand are there on the world’s beaches?
> - How many piano tuners are there in Chicago?
> - How far can a crow fly without stopping?
> - How many atoms of Caesar's last breath do you inhale with each lungful of air?

### Annotation 6 (page 3)

Beside the passage: ““Itwasafterw ewerea ttheluncheon table,”Konopinsk recall“thFersurpu withthequestion‘butwherei severybody?’I w ah iw ao puttii t hd rlauf ru”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2017-10-26):

> ### Where is everybody?
>
> *"So there are 100 Earth-like planets in the Universe for every grain of sand in the world. Think about that next time you’re on the beach."*
>
> There are 100,000 Earth-like planets capable of intelligent life in our Galaxy, the Milky Way. How come we have never made an "encounter" with extraterrestrial life? Any ideas? *(feel free to comment below)*

**Reply** by Ruaridh Macdonald (2017-11-02):

> It seems to depend a lot on how mobile everyone is, or how long they've been sending out messages. Are all 100,000 civilizations whizzing around in FTL ships or just sending signals out at *only* the speed of light?
>
> Assuming the latter makes the situation a lot harder. If we imagine sending ships in all directions looking for a planet with intelligent life, we can estimate the number of planets we would need to visit as a binomial random variable.
>
> If we visit N planets, where we expect $\lambda = \frac{1e5}{1e11}$ planets to harbour intelligent life, the probability of finding intelligent life is:
>
> $p = 1 - Bino[0,N,\lambda] = 1-(1-\lambda)^N$
>
> Alternatively, $N = \frac{\text{log}(1-p)}{\text{log}(1-\lambda)}$
>
> So now we know how many planets we have to visit, how far do we have to travel? If the Milky Way is approximately a 150k-light year diameter disk, with all the planets equally spaced out and us in the center (all not true, so our number may be generous to us), then the radius of our search from Earth must be:
>
> $R\approx\sqrt{\frac{N}{N_{total}}}\frac{150}{2}\text{kly} = \sqrt{\frac{\frac{log(1-p)}{log(1-\lambda)}}{1e11}}75\text{kly}$
>
> $R\approx\frac{0.75}{\sqrt{10}}\sqrt{\frac{log(1-p)}{log(1-\lambda)}}$light years
>
> You can plot this to see how the distance changes with your confidence of finding life. Searching in all directions is pretty similar to sending a message into space. The earliest man-made radio signals from about 150 years ago have a 1-in-3 chance of reaching an intelligent civilization (if they're still strong enough). You need to travel 200 light years in all directions to have a 50/50 likelihood. Being 99% sure requires a 510 light year search radius.
>
> Unless our neighborhood aliens are mobile and able to come find us, or very old and have been transmitting information for a long time (which isn't so crazy), it seems pretty unlikely that we'll find them soon.

### Annotation 7 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “I nsummary,Fermididaskthequestion,a nperhapn osurprisinisss tdeb todaywereparto fthediscussion.Certainly,t hlino argume tha Y orememb e familiara decadelatera stheDrake-Greenbank Equation.6’”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2017-10-27):

> The Drake equation provides an estimate of the number of communicating civilizations in the Milky Way. The equation is composed of 7 terms. The first 6 are used to compute the rate at which intelligent civilizations are being created and the final term identifies how long each lasts on average as a broadcasting civilization. The Drake equations can be written as:
>
> $$ N = R × f_p × n_e × f_l × f_i × f_c × L $$
>
> where:
> - N is the number intelligent civilizations that are broadcasting their presence
> - $R$ is the yearly rate at which stars form in the Galaxy
> - $f_p$ is the fraction  of stars that possess planets
> - $n_e$ is the number of planets with environments suitable for life
> - $f_l$ is the fraction of suitable planets on which life actually develops
> - $f_i$ is the fraction of these planets on which life develops intelligence
> - $f_c$ is the fraction of intelligent life-forms that develop a culture capable of interstellar communication
> - $L$ is the time that such a culture will devote to communication
>
>
> There is a lot of uncertainty associated with the parameters and the Drake equation can give a very wide range of values, depending on the assumptions and the values.
>
>
> To learn more about the Drake equation:
> - [Drake equation tutorial](http://www.astrodigital.org/astronomy/drake_equation.html)
> - [SETI - The Drake Equation](http://www.seti.org/drakeequation)
> - [Drake equation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_equation)

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

“WHERE [Annotation 1] I EVERYBODY A NACCOUNTO FERMI [Annotation 2] QUESTI

b

EriM Jon

ABSTR

I

Fermi’s famouquestion ocentrt debaa bt prev o fextraterrestriacivilizatioaroduria luncconve [Annotation 3] withEm iKonopinskiEdwaTellea nHerbY oi t s u o f1950Fermi’companioo thad ah aprovaccoo t incident.

Parto fthecurrentdebateabouttheexistencea nprevaleno extraterre conc interstellartravelandsettlement. 1-3I n1975MichaeH aargut h interst traw o b efeasiblefora technologicallyadvancedcivilizatioa nthaa migratwouf it G a [Annotation 4] i na fewmillionyears.4Sincethatintervali shorcomparewitt ha go t hGalh t h concludedthattheabsenceo fsettIerso revidenco theiengineerprojei t S o Systemmeantthattherearen ocxtraterrestrials.

Newman,Sagan,andShklovski2”5recallthaa legeno scien say t hEnrF ea s thequestion,“Wherearethey?”duringa visit L oAlamodurit hSecW oW o shortlythereafter.Fermi’squestionhasbeenmentionei severothrecpublicb historicalbasisfortheattributionhasnotbee established Thant t hexcelmemo HansMark,whohadhearda retellinga t Los Alamoi t hearl1950w nowlmoF e didmaketheremarkduringa lunchtime conversation abou195H icompanw e E m Konopinski,EdwardTeller,andHerbertYorkA lthrehavprovidaccouo t inci

W ebeginwithKonopinski:“ Ihaveonlyfragmentarrecollectiabot hocca. . . I d ohavea fairlyclearmemoryo fhowthediscussioo extra-terrestrg ostarted Enrico,Edward,HerbYork,andI werewalkingt Iunca FullLodg

“WhenI joinedtheparty,I foundbeingdiscusseevidenaboflyisaucT h immediatelybroughtt om yminda cartoonI h arecentlseei t hN eYork expla whypublictrashcansweredisappearing from t hstreeto N e Yor CitT hN Y op a weremakinga fussaboutthat.Thecartoonshowewhaw aevidena flysausiti thebackgroundand,streamingtowardit,‘littlgreemen(endoww iantencar thetrashcans.MoreamusingwasFermi’scommentthai w aa verreasonthes ii accountedfortwoseparatephenomena:t hreporto flyinsaucea w ea t h disapp o fthetrashcans.Thereensueda discussiona t whethet hsaucecousome exc t speedo flight.”

1

#### Page 2

w..,,... , ~,,..:.f.. :..$;.>:... , ..:.;* . ’..---.--,-:,-. .... . . .- ●. . .... , !.:..*aA*,*: %..:.

Drawib A lDunQ i951 9 =@, T hN eYorkMagazI n — --

Tellerremembers:“Myrecollectiono ft heveninvolviFer. . . i cleb o npar T obeginwith,I wasthereattheincident.I believi occurrshortaftt he o t w o a visito fFermit otheLaboratory,which quite possiblmighhavb edura sum

“ IrememberhavingwalkedoverwithFerma nothert t hFullLod f o lunW h w ewalkedover,therewasa conversationwhicI believt hav bee quibria supe o na subjectonlyvaguelyconnectedwithspactravelI hava vagrecollecw hm notb eaccurate,thatw etalkedaboutflyingsaucera nt hobviostatemt ht fly saucersarenotreal.I alsorememberthatFermexplicitlraist hquesti a n I t hh directedi ta tme,‘Edward,whatd oyouthink?H oprobabi i tha witht hn et y e w eshallhaveclearevidenceo fa materialobjecmovinfastthalighI remet hm answerwas10-6.’Fermisaid,‘Thisi smucht olowT hprobabili m ol it per [Annotation 5] (thewellknownfigurefora Fermimiracle.)”

Konopinskisaysthath edoesnotrecallt hnumericavalue“excet ht hcha rapidlya sEdwardandFermibouncedargumentso feacothe”

Tellercontinues:“Theconversation, according t m memorw ao nvaguconn withastronauticspartlyo naccounto fflyingsaucermighb d ut extraterrepeo (hereI believetheremarkswerepurelynegative)partlbecauexceedligvelow o makeinterstellartravelonedegreemorereal

“WethentalkedaboutotherthingswhichI d n orememba nmayapproxie i o fu ssatdowntogetherforlunch.” Konopinskia nYora rquicertt ht hw e o n fouro fthem.

2

#### Page 3

“Itwasafterw ewerea ttheluncheon [Annotation 6] table,”Konopinsk recall“thFersurpu withthequestion‘butwherei severybody?’I w ah iw ao puttii t hd rlauf ru

York,whodoesnotrecallthepreliminaryconversatioo t h wal t FulLodd o rememberthat“virtuallyaproposo fnothingFermsaid‘Dony oe vwonw h everybodyis?’Somehow. . . w eallknewh meanextra-terrestria”

Tellerremembersthequestioni nmucht hsamway“Thdiscussh a noth t d w astronomyo rwithextraterrestrialbeings.I thini w asomdown-to-etopT hi t middleo fthisconversation,Fermicameo uwitt hquitunexpecquest‘Whi everybody?’. . . Theresulto fhisquestionw ageneraIaughterbecao t h stra f a t h i spiteo fFermi’squestioncomingfromthecleablueeveryboarout htabseet understanda toncethath ewastalkingabout extraterrestria lif

“ Id onotbelievethatmuchcameo fthisconversationexceperhaa statet ht distancest othenextlocationo flivingbeingsmaybvergreaa nthaindea f a o galaxyi sconcerned,w earelivingsomewherei t h sticks f aremovf rt h metrop areao fthegalacticcenter.”

YorkbelievesthatFermiwassomewhatmorexpansiva n“follou w ia sero calculationso ntheprobabilityo fearthlikeplanetst h probabili o l igiva eart probabilityo fhumansgivenlife,thelikelyrisa n duratio o higtechnola s o H concludedo nthebasiso fsuchcalculationsthaw ought hav bee visil oa a m timesover.A SI recall,h ewento nt oconcludethat hreasow hadnb evisim ib thatinterstellarflighti simpossible,or, i f i i possible alway judgt b n ow ot eff o rtechnologicalcivilizationdoesn’tlastlonenougf oi t happe” Y oconfet b e hazyabouttheselastremarks.

I nsummary,Fermididaskthequestion,a nperhapn osurprisinisss tdeb [Annotation 7] todaywereparto fthediscussion.Certainly,t hlino argume tha Y orememb e familiara decadelatera stheDrake-Greenbank Equation.6’

A finalpoint:thedateo ftheconversation.Yori cleareo t hdat“ Tconverw eitheri nthesummero f1950,1951,o r 1952, ver probabl 195a nt opla. . . w hI wasvisitingIASLi nconnectionwiththe forthcoming Greenhoutests—specift Georgeshot.” TheGeorgetestoccurred o n M a8 1951suggesti1 9datSurv correspondencefromthetimeindicatesthaFermw aa annusummvisidurt y e i nquestion.Unfortunately,attendanceandtraverecordf othoyeah ab edest However,w ehavetheevidenceo fthecartoonKonopinsk mention Drab A lD ui w publishedi ntheMay20,1950,issueo f TheNewYorkerI seem qui proba t ht incidento fFermi’squestionoccurredi nt hsummeo 1950

I a mgratefult oHansMarkandt othethreesurvivinparticipaf otheaccouT h accounts,togetherwithm yletterso finquiry,a r reproduce i t hfollowpag

3

#### Page 4

A nEqualOpporlunllyEmploywlOperatodb yUnlvarsllyo f C M fOrn1

Loala

LosAlaNatio Labor

5 LosAlamosMexic

DAT Sep2 1 I NREPLYREFERT O E S:84 MAILSTO F TELEPHONE( 56 6

( F8 4

D rE mKonopi IndiUniver Departo Phys SwaW e- R o 1 1 BloominT 474

D eD rKonopi

I recen g oa letf rH eY oconft h w preaa a luncconverinvohimF eT e a ny oa convers t hh beca f ai t S ( s f oextraterrintellcomma “ Na t A p Accort a popuvert hw a odiso f l sauca nt hlikF ebecengri a calc a suddeaskWeli y a rigt hw hi eveT modimplici t hi intert ri fea t t hSolSysougt h ab eviaa a em t i t hpassometw s n convevio

D y oremet inciI s I w og rappa writaccowhiI w ou a lw iY oa T e( c encloi compoa “trvero t F eS t T c uosiw iamei t Droceo a confc a“In ,–—– . . Migraa nt h Hum Exper‘ b pub CalifoPrei Sept1 9B F i( t hUnivero Hawa a 1 a t edi

Thay of oy oh e

b t Unio antha

Siny o

E M J o

EMJ:

E Nals

C TCRM( 2w /E nM A I

E M JonESSM F 6 ESSF i( 2

4

#### Page 5

DEPAO P H S wHal1 BIeemington,I n4 7

( 8335

Oct1 1

D r E rM Jon L oAlaaNatiLabor M F 6 L oAlamN eMex 8 7

DearD rJon

I h ao nfragmerecolla bt o c t hy oletreft I @ ha f ac lm eo b ot hdiscuso extra-teg start EnriEdwaH eY o a I w ewalt l ua FullLod

W hI joi t b p aI f ob edise v aboflysauc T himmed bro t m m a cartI h a recentlyseeni t hN eYorkeexplaiw publictrashcansweredisappearingfrot hatreo N Y oCitT hN eY opapw em aa f a b t T hcartshow hw evida f ls as i i t hbackgra natret oi “ lg m (endow iantencarrt t rc aM a m w aFermcomm t hi w a v e reas t hs i accouf ot wsepaphent r eo f l sauca w ea t disappo t t rc a

Theensa discua t whet s ac someexct hs po l ia i w a fw w a t hlunchtabt hF esurpu w t q u “ Bwhei everyb I w h w o p ui t d r laug f ru aI t ht hwero t f o u j ua H eY o remem i

I b a absolu n recolo t num estimat hEdwment e xt ht c h rapia Edw a n F ebouargo e o t

Sinc

E m Kono

EK:d

5

#### Page 6

r

I

I

6

Losm

LosAlaNatioLabora l-&s$;6m#Mex875

ESS-5:84-O

J u1 31 9

D rEdwaTell PhysiDepart Universo Califo BerkelC 947

DeaD rTell

Thei a stoaboFerd ai L A lt i m a t hrouni t hS E(seaf extrateinte communiwhih aunfortulits ob aI w S w hfiru si i h ib ow iShklb C a h for wheo f rw hh heai AlthH aM ah g im a secondhaccof ra retel h h ei t e af tI havfoun o nw icloknowo t t aS ep e havsuggest hy omigb a sou

T hw at hstoi bei t ot hd ai t t lun conversaturt t hpossio intert ra n signaliFerbecengroi a q ucalca t announ“Ifya rrigt hw hi everT imp o t hquesti t hi inters tra i feat t Galaxywouh ab efill oa b b ew oris wheels

D y oh aa nfirstinfora bt hl it aI s oy oh e anda writdescro t e va y k t woub o grehelT hs ti slit r ai l e a nchanw ie aretel I a curredit pro o a confercal“IntersMigra t H uExp whiw ah eh el ayeaT b ow ib pubb t Universo Califopren ey ea I w ov m l t inclua accuraccoo t F eS t

Thay of oy ohel

EMJ/

C yCRM( 2M A 1

E M JoneESSM F 6 ESSF i( 2

MEqualOppodunlWEmployer/Owa!edb yUnNarallyofCdilOrnla

Siny o

G

E M J o

#### Page 7

L wreLive N aLab

A u1 1

Dr.EricM .Jones LosAlamosNationalLaboratory M SF665 LasAlamos,NewMexico87545

DearErie

M yrecollectiono ftheeventinvolvingFermithay owrott m aboi cleb onlypartial.

T obeginwith,I wastherea ttheincident.I believi occurr short aftt e o fthewaro na visito fFermit otheLaboratory,whicquitpossibmigh ab e duringa summer.

1 rememhavingwalkedoverwithFermia nothert t hFullLodf o lunch.Whilew ewalkedover,therewasa conversationwhicI beliet h ab eq u briefandsuperficialo na subjectonlyvaguelyconnectewitspac trave I h aa vaguerecollection,whichmaynotb eaccurate,thaw talkeaboflyisauca theobviousstatementthattheflyingsaucersa rn orealI als rememb t h Fer explicitlyraisedthequestion,andI thinkh e directed i a m e~~Edwaw hd y o think.Howprobablei si tthatwithinthenextt eyearw shalhavcle evide o a materialobjectmovingfasterthanlight?!tI remembetham answw a~llO Fermisaid,“Thisi smuchtoolow.Theprobabilityi morlikt epercen( tw e knownfigurefora Fermimiracle).

ThisincidentI haveclearlyi nmindandI believi w ao t hsamoccasw h theotherquestionarosewhichyouhavementioned.ThilattepoinhowevI a n certainof.

A tanyrate,theconversation,accordingt m memoryw aonlvagucome withastronauticspertlyo naccounto fflyingsaucermighb d ut extraterre people(hereI believetheremarkswerepurelynegative)partlbecauexceel i velocitywouldmakeinterstellartravelone degree morreal

W e t htalkabooththiwhichI d n oremembea nmay approxim eighto fu ssatdowntogetherforlunch.Thediscussioh anothit d w iastro o rwithextraterrestrialbeings.I thinki twassomdown-to~artopi

Then,i nthemiddleo fthisconversation,Fermcamo uwitt hqui unexpe question“Wherei severybody?llWhatI a msureo i thayouquot‘ Ty oa rrig thenwherei severybody?”,i swrong.Fermi did n ot ih iquestit a nconvers whichwasthengoingon.Theresulto fhisquestionw a genera laughtbecao t strangefactthati nspiteo fFermi%questioncominfrot h clea bluevery aroundthetableseemedt ounderstanda toncethah w atalkiabo extraterre

An.EquslQqwtmua-wdc.afmns.~ammuiwm ~945W*Tde@ins(415)422-110●Twx910-3WS3391L

7

#### Page 8

Dr.EricM .Jones Page2 August13,1984

life.I d n obelit hm uc ao t h conver e xp ea s t that hdistant t hn eloca o flivinbeingm ab vergrea n tha indeed,a sfara sourgalaxyi sconcerned,w a rlivinsomewhei t hsticf removedfromthemetropolitanareao fthegalacticenter

I canfullyconfirmthatthequestionw abroughu b Fermi FullLoda lunch,probablybefore1950.

Hopingthatthisi stheinformationyouwanted

Witbesregar

Edwar Tell

P.S.Goodo fyout oaska quesIc ansThesdayi happea lt orar

8

#### Page 9

140mw

LosAlaNatioLabora L oAlamos, Mex!co8

EarthandSpaceSciencesDivision GeoanelysisGroup

D rHerbY o PhysDepsrt Univero Califa S D i L JollC 920

D eD rYor

Sep 4 1 ESS-5:84-O MsiS tF 6 (50667-6 @TS843-6

Therei a storyaboutFermi’s days i L oAlsmothai makt roundsi ntheSETI(searchforextraterrestrialintelligencommun whichhas,unfortunately,littleaolidbasis I w aSagw hfiru s i ti nhisbookwithShklovski,butCarlh a forgotte wheo f rw hh heardit. HansMarkhasgivenm ea secondhand accoufroa retel h eheardi ntheearlyfifties;EdwardTelleh aalsprovidh ir e ollectiono ftheevent. Severalpeoplehavsuggestthay omigb a source.

T hw at hstoi b et ot hd ai t t lun conversturt t possio inter t rpar faster-thantravF ebecengri a q ucala t hannou“ Iy oa rigt hw hi everT imp o t hquesti thati finterstellart ri feat t G a wouh ab efill oa b beiw origaome Tella at ht hconverh m oo w h F ea s“ Wi everybo o uo t hb la witt qual H s t w agenelaug beca everrea t h F ew t a aboextraterre( enca c oo Tellet

D y oh aa nfirsinfora bt l it I s y oh ea na writdescro t e va y k t w b o grehel l % sto i slipt rapi l ea c h w ie aretellI a curredit proco a c o call “InterstMigra a t H uExpew hw h h l ayea T hb ow ib publb t Univo Calp n eyeaa nI wouv em ul it inca acca co t FerSto

Thay of oy oh e

EMJ: E Na l C T CRM( 2w iEncM A 1 E M JonESSM F 6 ESSF i( 2

Sinceryou

&

E M J

A nEqualOpwnunlWtiployw/OptiatdWUnMwollyofCalifOmla

9

#### Page 10

UNIVERSITYO CALIFORN INSTITUTEO NGLOBALCONFLICTA NCOOPERATI

BSSKSIZY. DAVIS. mvmc. LosANCEI.I!.9. SNESSIDE. SAWDIECO. SANFSANCISCO SASTn . SANCSU

HerbertF .York Director

E rM Jon Eara nSpaScieDivi GeoanalGro L oAlaNatiLabor M aS tF665 LosAlamoa,New

DearEric:

M yrecollection f Ollows:

Mex87545

o Ferrem

IGCCCENTRALOFFICEQ.06 UNIVERSITYO FCALIFORNIAS ADIE L AJOLLA,CALIFORNIA92093 (619)452.3352

Sept 1 1

a b“ wevei i a

A ta lunchi t hL ow hincj uf p eF eT e E mKonopia nmysF es avira po n o ‘Dony oe vwonw heveri s Som ( p ei w aconnet t hp rconvei t w y dese thouI d n oremet hw a k nh m eextra- H t hfollu w ia sero calcuo t pro o earthplant probao l ig ia e at probabio humg il it l i r i a d uo h technola na o H conco t b ao s cal t hw ougt h ab evisl oa a m t io A I recah w eo t conct ht r ew h ab viaimigb t hintersf li impoo i i i poaaialwjudt b n w ot e fo tech civilizdoesl al oenof i t h a I a m haziabothel arem a o

The conversw aeiti t proba195a nt op la a i connecw it forth t hGeosho

y s hprod it

s uo 1 91 o 1 v t iw hI w visL Greet e(spe

HFY:

1 0

I

#### Page 11

INDIANAUNIVERSITY DEPAO P H S wHal1 BloomI n4 7 ( 8335

Februar1 1

D . E rM Jones EarthandSpaScieDiv Geoanal Gro L oAla L oAlaNati Labor L oAlamN M 8 7

De a rD rJon

T hcarty f oi i nt o I refert oI a ls et d ao t discuss sinI a n cer t h i t plai t hsumo 1950t c aw stiquifrei m m i

M yb ew i

- - 2 ifiL E rKono

EK:d

1

#### Page 12

REFERENCES 1 .M .H .HartandB .Zuckerman(eds.), Ext ra t errest ri Wbe A r T b(PergP r Inc.,NewYork,1982),p .182. 2 .W .T .NewmanandC .Sagan,Ic a r u4 6293-3(1 9 8 3 .E .M .Jones,Ic a r t z s 4 6 ,328-336(1981). 4 .M .H .Hart, Qua rterly Journa l oftbeRoyalAstronomicaZSo 1 6128-(19 5 .I .S .ShklovskiandC .Sagan, In t e l l ig eLz Yi t bUnive(Holden- Inc S Fran 1968),p .448. 6 .W .Sullivan, WeAreNotAlone(Mc G r a w -HBooCo.NewYor196 7 .F .D .Drake,“TheRadioSearchforIntelligentExtraterrestriLifei Cur Asp o Exobiology,G MamikunianandM .H Brigg(eds.,JePropulsLaboratech report32-428(1965),pp.323-346.

1

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/where-is-everybody. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
