# Voyager Mission Telecommunication Firsts

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/voyager-mission-telecommunication-firsts

- **Authors:** Posner et al
- **Published:** 1990
- **Topic:** Computer Science
- **Original:** https://www.dropbox.com/s/h5k1r9vpsp7s8sv/posner1990.pdf?dl=1
- **Pages:** 6
- **Annotations:** 12 comments in 12 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/voyager-mission-telecommunication-firsts

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Edward C. Posner”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> The Voyager program involved sending two space probes, Voyager 1 and Voyager 2 to study the outer solar system. Both probes were launched in 1977 ( Voyager 2 was actually launched before Voyager 1) within the 3 year period that occurs once every 176 years when a unique alignment of Earth, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune presents the opportunity for a “grand tour”. Only Voyager 2 would go on to explore the planets beyond Saturn.
> ![flight paths](https://i.imgur.com/nYSEQFR.png)
> *Voyager flight paths*

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Fig. 1. Blue Neptune. Color image ofNeptune taken by Voyager 2 when it was 7 inillion kin (4.4 million miles) from Neptune’s surface. The Great Dark Spot is visible in the center, accompanied by white high-altitude clouds. Two color.filters (green and orange) were used, and about 2 inillion hits were sent,for each …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> Here are a few images of Neptune taken by Voyager 2
>
> *Neptune Full Disk View*
> ![Neptune Full Disk View](https://photojournal.jpl.nasa.gov/jpeg/PIA01492.jpg)
> *Crescents of Neptune and Triton*
> ![Crescents of Neptune and Triton](https://photojournal.jpl.nasa.gov/jpeg/PIA02215.jpg)
> *Neptune Clouds*
> ![Neptune Clouds](https://photojournal.jpl.nasa.gov/jpeg/PIA00058.jpg)
> You can see more pictures taken by Voyager at the [JPL photojournalist website](https://photojournal.jpl.nasa.gov/targetFamily/Neptune?subselect=Mission%3AVoyager%3ATarget%3ANeptune)

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “1 HIS ARTICLE TELLS ABOUT THE COMMUNICATIONS firsts of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration’s (NASA’s) Voyager mission. This dual-spacecraft mission to Jupiter. Saturn. Uranus, Neptune, and their moons and rings was launched in 1977 and completed its planetary phase some I7 years later with the Voyager 2 …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> Voyager was the first of a class of NASA spacecrafts that could be reprogrammed. This actually ended up being massively important to the mission. For instance, when voyager launched there was no plan to send back images of planets after Saturn. This was only made possible by software uploaded to Voyager 2 after launch.

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “1 HIS ARTICLE TELLS ABOUT THE COMMUNICATIONS firsts of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration’s (NASA’s) Voyager mission. This dual-spacecraft mission to Jupiter. Saturn. Uranus, Neptune, and their moons and rings was launched in 1977 and completed its planetary phase some I7 years later with the Voyager 2 …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> The **Deep Space Network (DSN)** is NASA’s international array of giant radio antennas that supports interplanetary spacecraft missions.
> The DSN consists of three facilities spaced equidistant from each other (approximately 120 degrees apart in longitude) around the world. These sites are:
> - Goldstone, California
> - Madrid, Spain
> - Canberra, Australia
>
> The strategic placement of these sites permits constant communication with spacecraft as our planet rotates – before a distant spacecraft sinks below the horizon at one DSN site, another site can pick up the signal and carry on communicating.
>
> You can go [here](https://eyes.nasa.gov/dsn/dsn.html) to see, in real time, which antennas are currently in use, which spacecraft is communicating with the DSN, data rates etc.
> ![dsn](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/de/Canberra_Deep_Dish_Communications_Complex_-_GPN-2000-000502.jpg)
> *Canberra DSN complex*

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “pect of a deep-space mission would be possible without telecommunication, but by “telecommunication firsts” we mean first-time accomplishments specifically relating to or interacting with the telecommunication system.”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> Voyager took photographs in black and white. Color images were reconstructed by making a computer composite of three black and white images taken through orange, green, and violet filters.

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “0 163-6804/90/0009-0022 $01 .OO a 1990 IEEE”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> **Pioneer 10** and its twin probe, **Pioneer 11**, were the first NASA space probes to be designed for exploring the outer Solar System. Launched in 1972 and 1973 respectively they ended up serving as a fantastic preparation for the Voyager mission. The initial goals of the Pioneer program were:
> Explore the interplanetary medium beyond the orbit of Mars
> Investigate the nature of the asteroid belt from the scientific standpoint and assess the belt's possible hazard to missions to the outer planets
> Explore the environment of Jupiter
>
> Later on, the planning for the encounter with Saturn added more goals.
>
> ![Pioneer 10 image of Jupiter](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/34/Pioneer_10_-_p146.jpg)
> *Pioneer 10 image of Jupiter*
> ![Artist rendition of the pioneer space craft at Jupiter](https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/thumbnails/image/pioneer10_art.jpg)
> *Artist rendition of the Pioneer 10 space craft at Jupiter*

### Annotation 7 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “craft, built by TRW for the Pioneer project at NASA’s Ames Research Center. However, the Voyager spacecraft, built and managed by JPL for NASA, have much larger downlink datarate capability at all distances due to their 20 W transmitters and larger 3.66 m antennas (a deep-space first) with X-band downlink frequency (a …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> Sputnik 1 (the first satellite to orbit the earth) carried two radio beacons on frequencies of 20MHz and 40MHz. At these frequencies, amateur radio enthusiasts could easily tune into its transmissions as it passed overhead (you can listen to samples [here](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-YSm2qFwRpI) ). The Explorer earth orbiter missions used VHF (~100MHz). The first Lunar probe (Pioneer III) used UHF (960MHz). Over time the tendency was to increase the frequency, first to S-band (2.3 GHz) and then to X-Band (8.4GHz). The two main reasons for this was competition for frequency allocations at lower frequencies (the frequencies you can use to communicate with are tightly regulated) and the need for more spacecraft antenna directivity.

### Annotation 8 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “The Earth-based part of the Voyager telecommunication system also achieved many firsts. The three 70-m DSN antennas have the lowest ever system noise temperature of an operational X-band (8.5 GHz) receiving system for space or any other X-band communication-20.9 Kat 90 degrees elevation and 25.5 K at 30 degrees …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> ### Elevation Angle
> This is “up” and “down” angle from a reference plane, generally the horizon.
> ![elevation angle](https://i.imgur.com/P0GNhH9.gif)
>
> ### Noise Temperature
> The noise in a system can be expressed as an equivalent noise temperature. Higher noise in the system would mean a higher noise temperature.
> The reason why “temperature" is used is because of *thermal noise*. A higher temperature means that the electrons in the medium are moving around more and therefore generate observable noise. For most noise processes you can express them (at least in part) by an equivalent thermal noise.

### Annotation 9 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “craft, built by TRW for the Pioneer project at NASA’s Ames Research Center. However, the Voyager spacecraft, built and managed by JPL for NASA, have much larger downlink datarate capability at all distances due to their 20 W transmitters and larger 3.66 m antennas (a deep-space first) with X-band downlink frequency (a …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> **EIRP** (Effective Isotropic Radiated Power) is the measured radiated power of an antenna in a specific direction.

### Annotation 10 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “During the entire mission, the telemetry downlink channel code was the NASA Standard constraint-length 7, rate 1/2 convolutional code using a real-time hardware Viterbi decoder (first space-based short-constraint-length convolutional code Viterbi decoded) at each receiving station. For the Voyager Jupiter and Saturn …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> **Convolutional codes** are a type of error-correcting codes. In other words, they provide you with a way of encoding a message you want to send so that it is resistant (to an extent) to errors that might be introduced by noise. If you wish to learn more about convolutional codes I suggest you read [chapter 7 of MIT’s Digital Communication Systems class notes](https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-computer-science/6-02-introduction-to-eecs-ii-digital-communication-systems-fall-2012/readings/MIT6_02F12_chap07.pdf).

### Annotation 11 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Fig. 3. Dual X/Sspacecraft antenna with feeds. The feed on the tripod is the S-band.feed, while the dual-polarization X-band feed is located on the reflector itse&”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> *Diagram of Voyager’s High Gain Antenna*
> ![High Gain Antenna](https://i.imgur.com/CN3vvdA.png)

### Annotation 12 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “At Neptune, Voyager carried out the longest-distance Radio Frequency (RF) probe of a medium and used the first array of ground antennas for radio science, Canberra and Usuda (Japanese Institute of Space and Astronautical Sciences, ISAS) at S-band (non-real-time). To meet the exacting radio science requirements for …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2018-03-27):

> **MASER** (acronym for Microwave Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation) is a device that produces coherent electromagnetic waves through amplification by stimulated emission. A LASER is a MASER that works with higher frequency photons in the ultraviolet or visible light spectrum. A hydrogen maser, also known as hydrogen frequency standard, is a specific type of maser that uses the intrinsic properties of the hydrogen atom to serve as a precision frequency reference.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

Vovager

Firsts

Mission Telecommunication

Edward [Annotation 1] C. Posner

Lawrence L. Rauch

Boyd D. Madsen

1 HIS ARTICLE TELLS ABOUT THE COMMUNICATIONS firsts of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration’s (NASA’s) Voyager mission. This dual-spacecraft mission to Jupiter. Saturn. Uranus, Neptune, and their moons and rings was launched in 1977 and completed its planetary phase some I7 years later with the Voyager 2 Neptune encounter in August 1989 (see Figure I). Although the spacecraft hardware represents early 1970s technology (see Figure 2), the absolutely outstanding system design included computer control of almost all spacecraft ar?d instrument functions. This provided the flexibility for recovering from a wide range of malfunctions. The potential was also created to effectively almost redesign the spacecraft and its instrument data systems in flight via uplinked software (a first) to take advantage of post-launchdeveloped technology (such as image compression) and also of new requirements developed later in the mission. This was especially valuable because the original mission commitment did not include Uranus or Neptune. Half of the Voyager telecommunication system [Annotation 3] is located on Earth (downlink receiver and uplink transmitter). For the better part of a decade and a half after the spacecraft hardware design was frozen, the technology of the ground system could continue to develop to meet the needs associated with steadily decreasing received signal strength and also to improve navigation techniques in the face of the increasing round-trip light time to the spacecraft. Significant parts of the ground-system technology in use for the Uranus and Neptune encounters were simply unavailable when the spacecraft was launched. The ground system is embodied in the Deep Space Network (DSN), which the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) develops and operates for NASA’s Office of Space Operations. JPL designed and built the two Voyager spacecraft for NASA’s Office of Space Science and Applications. [Annotation 4]

This technology flexibility in both the Voyager spacecraft and ground systems enabled a mission which, along its way to becoming a truly remarkable success, established many firsts associated with its telecommunication system. Ofcourse no as-

This article represents the results of one phase of research carried out at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, sponsored by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.

22 September 1990 - IEEE Communications Magazine

Fig. [Annotation 2] 1. Blue Neptune. Color image ofNeptune taken by Voyager 2 when it was 7 inillion kin (4.4 million miles) from Neptune’s surface. The Great Dark Spot is visible in the center, accompanied by white high-altitude clouds. Two color.filters (green and orange) were used, and about 2 inillion hits were sent,for each ,filter, totalling almost 4 million hits.

pect of a deep-space mission would be possible without telecommunication, but by “telecommunication firsts” we mean first-time accomplishments specifically relating to [Annotation 5] or interacting with the telecommunication system.

Radio Telemetry

The two Voyager spacecraft were not the first to send images from Jupiter and Saturn, nor the first to leave the solar system-these records belong to the Pioneer 10 and 1 1 space-

0 [Annotation 6] 163-6804/90/0009-0022 $01 .OO a 1990 IEEE

#### Page 2

craft, built by TRW for the Pioneer project at NASA’s Ames Research Center. However, the Voyager spacecraft, built and managed by JPL for NASA, have much larger downlink datarate capability at all distances due to their 20 W transmitters and larger 3.66 m antennas (a deep-space first) with X-band downlink frequency (a deep-space first) providing an antenna gain of 48.2 dB. The resulting largest ever Effective Isotropic Radiated Power (EIRP) of 1.32 MW from deep space permitted the transmission of almost 80,000 high-resolution images during the mission; the current runner-up is the Mars Viking dual orbitedlander mission [Annotation 7] (1 976 encounter) with almost 60,000 images. Actually, the Voyager cameras had about 97,000 shutter activations-some exposures were not trans- [Annotation 9] mitted and others were combined to form color images.

The Voyager two-spacecraft mission also holds the records for the most planets visited (4), most bodies imaged (58, counting the four ring sets around the four target planets, as well as Earth and its moon), and the most data bits (about 200 Gb) transmitted from deep space over the life of a mission. This last record, however, is expected to be bested by the end of the Magellan prime mission, a radar mapper of Venus which went into Venus orbit on August IO, 1990. The Voyager Uranus (January 1986) and Neptune encounters established at those times the records for the most distant image transmission ever, 2.75 billion miles from Neptune. The data rate of 2 1,600 b/s from Neptune established a record for the largest distance-normalized data rate, 4.2E23 (b/s x km2). For example, at synchronous Earth satellite altitude this would give a data rate of greater than 1 E 14 b/s. Because of the wide range of distances for the Voyager mission, the spacecraft made use of the largest array of data rates of any deep-space mission (and probably of any space mission, but this is hard to check). In addition to the 2 1,600 b/s rate, rates from 40 b/s to 1 15,200 b/s were used by the Voyagers at various times, for a total of 28 telemetry rates. Other firsts for the Voyager spacecraft radio hardware include the dual X-band&-band (8.5 GHz/2 GHz) antenna feed (see Figure 3) with the former providing left- as well as righthand circular polarization to rely on polarization isolation instead of on less reliable antenna switches for the two X-band transmitters. There was also the first use of RF channel selection by a spacecraft (the X-band channels numbered 14 and 18), and the first use of modulation index selection, including the possibility of fully suppressed carrier. This was used not for telemetry but in connection with “delta Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI)” for radio navigation’ (see Figure 4), another first.

The spacecraft transponder provided the first use of the two-way non-coherent mode and the subcarriers were selectable. There were two power amplifiers for X-band and two for S-band with one of the latter two being a solid-state amplifier (a deep-space first). The spacecraft transponder also included the most stable oscillator (2 parts in lE12 over 100 s, aptly named the Ultra-Stable Oscillator-USO) ever yet used in deep space, and at the time the best in space (GPS cesium devices are now an order of magnitude better), as well as the first application of a Surface Acoustic Wave (SAW) filter in deep space, used in the transponder multiplier chain.

‘The direction of a spacecraft with respect to the baseline between two DSN antennas is determined by measuring the time difference between the two one-way paths from the spacecraft to the antennas. To do this, the spacecraft transmits a wideband signal (in this case the telernetering signal was used). The signals from the two antennas are cross-correlated. The “delta” in “delta VLBI” refers to the procedure whereby the system is calibrated in real time by alternately observing both the spacecraft and some directionally nearby quasar that is part of a quasar “grid.” The grid was very accurately determined over a long period of time by ordinary VLBI. This navigation application of VLBI is often called “delta Differenced One-way Ranging (DOR).”

The Earth-based part of the Voyager telecommunication system also achieved many firsts. The three 70-m DSN antennas have the lowest ever system noise temperature of an operational X-band (8.5 GHz) receiving system for space or any other X-band communication-20.9 Kat 90 degrees elevation and 25.5 K at 30 degrees elevation (in clear dry weather). The same antennas provided the first operational use of hydrophobic coating on feedhorn covers to mitigate weather-dependent microwave system noise increase during rain. Also, for the Voyager mission, the DSN made the most advanced and delicate use of multisite weather probability estimates to improve [Annotation 8] weather-dependent X-band performance during rain. The X-band arraying of the National Science Foundation/National Radio Astronomy Observatory’s (NSFINRAO’s) Very Large Array (VLA) in New Mexico with the 70 m and 34 m antennas at the Goldstone Complex for the Neptune encounter involved the first operational space use of High Electron Mobility Transistor (HEMT) amplifiers; these were at each ofthe 27 VLA antennas.

This arraying with the VLA (see Figure 5) established a number of records: the most antennas (29) ever arrayed anywhere at once (27 VLA plus 2 at Goldstone); the largest fullysteerable equivalent aperture (1 5 1 m) ever used for a communications link (the overall record belongs to the Cornell- Arecibo 300-m antenna used for the S-band International Cometary Explorer in 1985, but the Arecibo antenna is not fully steerable).

Also, the VLA arraying was the longest (aperture separation) array- 1,200 miles-ever used for communications, or, in real time, for anything else. The prior record was Canberra/ Parkes for Voyager Uranus, 200 miles via ground microwave link; Parkes, a 64-m antenna, is operated by the Australian Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO). Finally, this was the first arraying for telemetry via satellite (real-time VLA to Goldstone; see Figure 6).

The 70 m antenna at the DSN Goldstone complex had the highest power operational coherent uplink for spacecraft-up to 400 kW Continuous Wave (CW) at S-band. During the mission, this was used with a margin of 5 dB. That was the highest EIRP communications transmission ever, about 200 GW.

The Voyager downlink EIRP of 1.32 MW from the Neptune distance of 4.42E9 km gives a power flux density of 5.38E-2 1 W/m2 at Earth receiving stations. At the data rate of 2 1,600 ds, this is an energy per bit flux density of 2.49E-25 (J/b)/(m2) at the receiving stations-far smaller than ever before used anywhere for operational radio or any other communication. Early in the mission, one of the Voyager 2 radio receivers failed completely. The other had a capacitor short circuit in the filter of the carrier phase-locked loop which very greatly reduced the lock-in frequency range. This greatly reduced lock-in range was much smaller than the loop oscillator’s drift due to such things as spacecraft temperature change. Yet it was possible to maintain the full command function of the impaired receiver by creating the first continuous frequency-programmable uplink, derived originally from DSN planetary radar. The programmed frequency was obtained from a model for the spacecraft frequency drift.

Coding

During the entire mission, the telemetry downlink channel code was the NASA Standard constraint-length 7, rate 1/2 convolutional code using a real-time hardware Viterbi decoder (first space-based short-constraint-length convolutional code Viterbi decoded) at each receiving station. For the Voyager Jupiter and Saturn encounters, uncompressed image data was sent directly over the convolutionally coded channel. This pro- [Annotation 10] vided the required bit error probably of 5E-3 at a zero-margin signal-to-noise ratio E,/N, of 2.34 dB, the lowest anywhere ever, as was hinted in the previous section. Other science data

September 1990 - IEEE Communications Magazine 23

#### Page 3

Scan Imaging (ISS), Narrow An

and Radiometer

Low-Energy Charged Particle

Hydrazine Thrusters (1 6) for Attitude Control and

(Not All Shown in This View)

High-Gain Antenna Trajectory Correction (HGA) (3 7 m DIA)

Shunt Radiator

Canopus Star Tracker (2) (Not Visible in This View)

Astronomy (PRA) and Plasma Wave (PWS)

Voyager Spacecraft (Note Shown Without Thermal

Blankets for Clarity)

Fig. 2. Voyager spacecraft. The subsystems are shown by callout. The 3.66 m diameter antenna is a high1.v visible feature.

Fig. 3. Dual X/Sspacecraft antenna with feeds. The feed on the tripod is the S-band.feed, while the dual-polarization X-band feed is located on the reflector itse& [Annotation 11]

Quasar

Spacecraft

Fig 4. Delta VLBI concept. For Voyager 2 on its way to Neptune, the tvpical angular distance between the quasar used and Voyager 2 was 15 degrees, providing 150 nrad spacecraft angular positron accuracy.

24 September 1990 - IEEE Communications Magazine

#### Page 4

Fig. 5. Interagency arraying. World map showing antenna facilities used to support Voyager 2 at Neptune. Insets show pictures of the antennas used, including the 27 VLA antennas in a Y-configuration. The VLA antennas are on rails: the closest configuration was used because the resolution of the VLA was not required. only the aperture, 27 x 2Sm antennas, equivalent in aperture to a single 130 in-diameter antenna.

at key times used a concatenated Golay (24,12) outer code (also a space first) to provide a bit error probability of 1 E-5, but at 3 dB higher signal-to-noise ratio per information bit. Beginning with the Uranus encounter, an outer Reed- Solomon code (see Figure 7) was applied to the X-band link, using the by now NASA Standard 16-symbol-error-correcting 8-bit (255,223) Reed-Solomon code with “interleaving depth 4” (a deep-space first), with a hardware encoder included in the spacecraft. The inner code remained the 7, 1/2 convolutional code. The Reed-Solomon encoder was originally included on the spacecraft for compatibility with image compression, which needs low error probability but efficient power use. The encoder was available at launch, but the corresponding ground decoder was available only later, in time for the 1986 Uranus encounter. This improved concatenated coding scheme provides a bit error probability of 1 E-6 with a theoretical signal-tonoise ratio E /No of 2.43 dB. The additional radio loss increased this kgure to somewhere between 2.5 and 3.0 dB depending on how well a station was tweeked up. Since the Shannon limit for unrestricted bandwidth is -1.59 dB, this performance is within 4.02 dB of the Shannon limit,* the closest anywhere for this low error probability.

The low error probability provided by the concatenated Reed-Solomon/convolutional coding enabled the use of a lossless image-compression algorithm (a deep-space firstabout a compression factor of 2.5) which was not available at

the beginning of the mission. One of the spacecraft backup computers was assigned to carry out the data compression algorithm via software which was uplinked to the spacecraft. This was a very important contribution to the high imaging rates achieved at Neptune. The algorithm was essentially a universal source code on the differences between successive pixels on a scan line.

Navigation

The navigation capability provided by the Voyager radio system also resulted in a number of firsts. The Neptune encounter was supported by the longest-distance ranging ever, doppler, and the first operational use of delta VLBI. The rang-

2The bandwidth expansion factor due only to the coding is 2 x 2551 223 = 2.29. For this, the Shannon limit is -0.21 dB. However, the convolutionally coded signal is modulated on a square-wave subcamer, containing at least the third harmonic, which is in turn phase modulated (with double sidebands) on the X-band carrier. These modulation processes increase the bandwidth expansion factor perhaps six times beyond that due to coding. The result is a Shannon limit only a little larger (0.2 dB) than that for unrestricted bandwidth. Also, the Shannon limit should be increased slightly for the nonzero error probability, which is why this is closer to its Shannon limit than the unconcatenated SE-3 transmission was (by 0.1 dB).

September 1990 - IEEE Communications Magazine 25

#### Page 5

Fig. 6. Real-time arraying. Artist’s sketch showing real-time telemetry arraying of the VU with Goldstone via satellite.

ing accuracy was about one m in 4.42E9 km-the most accurate space distance measurement (percentagewise) ever made. The doppler provided an accuracy of about one millimeter per second. The first operational delta VLBI provided an angular accuracy of 150 nanoradians. The Voyager mission used the first three-way ranging ~ystem,~ which was made necessary by round-trip light times too long for the pass over a single station.

This navigation accuracy allowed the closest encounter ever with a planet-within 3,000 km of Neptune’s sensible atmosphere, within 500 km of the burn-up danger zone. This permitted a 50-degree trajectory bend for the Triton encounter. Including the use of spacecraft-provided images, the overall navigation accuracy relative to Neptune was about 40 km. Voyager was also the first space project to make operational use of ground-based hydrogen masers for radio navigation, whose excruciating stability of 1 E- 14 over part of a day is necessary for two-way doppler and ranging at these long roundtrip light times. Also, for the Neptune encounter, the hydrogen

3The prior two-way ranging system measured the round-trip light time between an Earth station and the spacecraft by transmitting a signal to the spacecraft, which coherently shifts the frequency and transmits back to the Earth station, where the received signal is correlated with the signal being transmitted. This requires that the spacecraft be in good view of the Earth station for a significantly longer time than the round-trip light time-which becomes impossible near the limits of the solar system. The three-way ranging system transmits the signal from one Earth station and receives the transponded signal from the spacecraft at another Earth station which is next coming into view, typically some eight hours later. This received signal is stored for later correlation with the (stored) transmitted signal.

masers in the DSN were synchronized absolutely within 1 ps, an operational record.

Radio Science

In the radio science area, where the medium is the message (see Figure 8), the Voyager mission achieved a number of firsts. It was the first mission specifically designed to obtain radio-science data-by having very exacting requirements for radio system stability, both at Sand X-bands, and for frequency and timing system stability, both flight and ground.

At Neptune, Voyager carried out the longest-distance Radio Frequency (RF) probe of a medium and used the first array of ground antennas for radio science, Canberra and Usuda (Japanese Institute of Space and Astronautical Sciences, ISAS) at S-band (non-real-time). To meet the exacting radio science requirements for Voyager, the hydrogen masers in the DSN were modified to reduce their phase noise at X-band by 10 to 20 dB-to -54 dBc at 1 Hz and -60 dBc from IO to 10,000 Hz. Navigation requires good long-term timing-system stability (over several hours), expressed as an “Allan deviation” of 1 E- 14 in units of cycles/cycle. But radio-science probing of the me- [Annotation 12] dium also requires the very good short-term stability expressed above in terms of phase noise.

Epilogue

The really remarkable success of the Voyager mission, both from the system reliability and science data aspects, is firmly based on an absolutely outstanding systems design exploited to its utmost limits by truly dedicated operational and science teams supported over an extended period by NASA. The vari-

26 September I990 - IEEE Communications Magazine

#### Page 6

Fig. 7. Concatenated convolutional coding concept. The inner code, the constraint-length 7 rate 112 NASA Standard convolutional code, is the one encoded last on the spacecraft and decoded first (via Viterbi decoding using soft decisions) on the ground. The outer Reed-Solomon code encodes the entire data stream. which is then fed to the spacecraft convolutional encoder.

ous communication firsts and records described above are both a cause for and a natural product of this winning combination.

Acknowledgments

The Voyager project and the DSN are managed by JPL of the California Institute of Technology under contract with

\ \ \

K>- \ , -

, \

' \\

Neptune

11 Detect0

Signal

and Sampling

r Conditioning Recc, \

Fig. 8. Radio Science. Geometry of Voyager 2 at Neptunefor the Triton occultation. The radio wave traverses the atmosphere and ionosphere of Triton. From eflecls observable in the amplitude and phase as received b.v a dedicated open loop radio science receiver. finely detailed conclusions about Triton were drawn.

NASA. The Bendix Field Engineering Corporation operates the DSN Goldstone complex under contract to JPL. The Madrid Complex is operated by a Spanish government agency, Instituto Nacional de Technica Aerospacial (INTA), while the Canberra complex is operated by the Australian Space Office (ASO).

The authors would like to thank their JPL associates H. W. Baugh, J. S. Border, H. G. Cox, A. W. Kermode, P. F. Kuhnle, F. Pollara, L. Swanson, G. P. Textor, and J. A. Wackley for counsel on Voyager firsts and records.

References

[l] Edward C Posner and Robertson Stevens, "Deep Space

Communication-Past, Present, and Future," I€€€ Commun Mag , vol 22, no 5, pp 8-21, May 1984 "Voyager 2 at Neptune and Triton," editorial and twelve articles, SoenceMag .voI 246,no 4,936,~~ 1,369andpp 1,417-1,501,Dec 15, 1989

[2]

Biography

Edward C. Posner (F) is Chief Telecommunications and Data Acquisition Technologist at the California Institute of Technology's (Caltech's) JPL and Visiting Professor of Electrical Engineering at Caltech. He has been associated with deep space communication and the DSN since 1960, when he began consulting at JPL before accepting a position there, and before the DSN had its present name. This is his third article for /€€€Communications Magazine. In addition, Posner was Guest Editor of the November 1989 special issue on 'Neural Networks in Communication."

Lawrence L. Rauch (LF) is Senior Research Engineer (Retired) at Caltech's JPL as well as Professor Emeritus of Aerospace Engineering at the University of Michigan. In addition, he taught in Caltech's Electrical Engineering Department for eight years after retiring from Michigan, while he was Telecommunications Science and Engineering Division Technologist at JPL. Rauch is one of the founders of radio telemetry, his landmark book Radio Telemetry-coauthored with Myron Nichols-having appeared in 1952 and subsequently having been translated into Japanese and Russian. He maintains an active research interest in the phase tracking of weak radio signals and consults for JPL's Telecommunications and Data Acquisition Office.

Boyd D. Madsen is a 1960 graduate of Brigham Young University with a B.E.S. in electrical engineering. He joined the Voyager Project in 1974 after working on the Mariner Venus-Mercury mission. He has thus been involved with Voyager Telecommunications at JPL since three years before launch. He joined Galileo in 1979 and Magellan in 1986. He is currently the Technical Group Supervisor of the Voyager-Galileo-Magellan Telecommunications Systems Group in JPL's Telecommunication Science and Engineering Division. These are the three major JPL deep-space flight projects currently flying.

September 1990 - IEEE Communications Magazine 27

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/voyager-mission-telecommunication-firsts. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
