# Venus is not Earth’s closest neighbor

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/venus-is-not-earth-s-closest-neighbor

- **Authors:** Tom Stockman, Gabriel Monroe, and Samuel Cordner
- **Published:** 2019
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1684690472451-owdo7mdhq1-3053888850bb549ea36328e6a70eaa06%2Fpaper+%282%29.pdf
- **Pages:** 5
- **Annotations:** 9 comments in 9 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/venus-is-not-earth-s-closest-neighbor

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Abstract Calculations and simulations conﬁrm that on average, Mercury is the nearest planet to Earth—and to every other planet in the solar system.”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-05-21):

> ## TL;DR
>
> Contrary to popular belief, Venus is not Earth's closest neighbor on average. This misunderstanding stems from a common but flawed assumption about the average distance between planets. Averaged over time, Mercury is actually the closest planet to Earth — and to every other planet in the solar system. This new approach can potentially improve our understanding of orbital dynamics and could be useful in estimating satellite communication relays.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Which planet is closest to Earth? Ask an astronomer or a search engine, and you’ll probably hear that though the situation changes frequently, Venus is the closest when averaged over time. Several educational websites, such as The Planets and Space Dictionary, publish the distance between each pair of planets, and …”

**Annotation** by Amir Panahi (2024-10-14):

> Q: Am I missing something here? What is the situation in question and why does it change frequently?

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Which planet is closest to Earth? Ask an astronomer or a search engine, and you’ll probably hear that though the situation changes frequently, Venus is the closest when averaged over time. Several educational websites, such as The Planets and Space Dictionary, publish the distance between each pair of planets, and …”

**Annotation** by Amir Panahi (2024-10-14):

> Q: What does it mean by closest approach to Earth? This may be a determining piece of knowledge

### Annotation 4 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Figure 2: (a) The uniform probabilistic distribution of two circularly orbiting bodies, with orbital radii r 1 and r 2 . (b) Radial symmetry is used to simplify the average distance between the distributions.”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-05-21):

> CGP Grey did an [interesting video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SumDHcnCRuU) on this topic.

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “¯ d = 2 π (r 1 + r 2 )E”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-05-21):

> ![](https://i.imgur.com/UxUaFj9.png)
> This diagram illustrates the terms used in the point-circle problem.
> The equation for distance in a radial coordinate system is
> $$
> \text {d}=\sqrt{r_1^2+r_2^2+r_1 r_2 \cos (\theta)}
> $$
> The equation for finding the average value of a function is
> $$
> \text { Average Value }=\frac{1}{b-a} \int_a^b f(x) d x
> $$
> Substituting $f(x)$ with Distance $(\theta)$ from the previous equation and integrating from 0 to $2 \pi$ yields
> $$
> \text { Average Distance }=\frac{1}{2 \pi} \int_0^{2 \pi} \sqrt{\left(r_1^2+r_2^2+r_1 r_2 \cos (\theta)\right.} d \theta
> $$
> which can be simplified using a complete elliptic integral of the second kind.
> $$
> \text { Average Distance }=\frac{2}{\pi}\left(r_1+r_2\right) E\left(\frac{2 \sqrt{r_1 r_2}}{r_1+r_2}\right)
> $$
> where $E()$ is an elliptic integral of the second kind. The use of this last equation for calculating the average distance between 2 orbiting bodies will hence be referred to as the Point-Circle Method (PCM).
>
>
> The average distances between pairs of planets determined by the PCM are shown as part of Figure 6.
> The Whirly Dirly Corollary
> Plotting the last equation reveals an interesting behavior. The distance between two orbiting bodies is at a minimum when the inner orbit is at a minimum. This observation results in the Whirly Dirly Corollary (WDC): for two bodies with roughly concentric circular orbits around a common center, the average distance between the two bodies decreases as the radius of the inner orbit decreases. From this corollary it is observed that Mercury (average orbital distance of 0.39 AU), not Venus (average orbital distance of $0.72 \mathrm{AU}$ ), is the closest planet to Earth on average.

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “where E(x) is an elliptic integral of the second kind. The average distances between pairs of planets determined by the PCM are included in the table. Venus is on average 1.14 AU from Earth, but Mercury is a much closer 1.04 AU.”

**Annotation** by Christian Luca (2023-05-24):

> Could you provide a link to elliptical integrals, generally, and one for elliptic integrals of the second kind, so that we could learn how equation (1) was obtained.  Thank you.

### Annotation 7 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Figure 3: A simulation of an Earth year’s worth of orbits by the terrestrial planets begins to reveal that Mercury (gray in orbital animation) has the smallest average distance from Earth (blue) and is most frequently Earth’s nearest neighbor. A longer run of the simulation can be seen on YouTube. In addition, …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-05-21):

> ![](https://www.flother.is/processed_images/ee27b186415fe87e00.png)
>
> You can actually use this [python script](https://github.com/flother/nearest-planet) by Matt Rigott to calculate which planet will be our nearest neighbour over the coming months and years!

### Annotation 8 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Figure 3: A simulation of an Earth year’s worth of orbits by the terrestrial planets begins to reveal that Mercury (gray in orbital animation) has the smallest average distance from Earth (blue) and is most frequently Earth’s nearest neighbor. A longer run of the simulation can be seen on YouTube. In addition, …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-05-21):

> Here's the link to the BBC episode of [More or Less](https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0001y9p).

### Annotation 9 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “In the table we list the average measured distances over the 10 millennia and compare them with the results from the PCM and the traditional method. The simulation results diﬀer from the ﬂawed numbers by up to 300 %, but they deviate from the PCM ﬁgures by less than 1 %. Figure 3 compares the results from both methods …”

**Annotation** by Christian Luca (2023-05-24):

> It should say Figure 4 instead of Figure 3 in comparing the results from both methods with the simulation of the average distance between Neptune and the seven other planets.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

Venus is not Earth’s closest neighbor

Tom Stockman, Gabriel Monroe, and Samuel Cordner

12 March 2019

Abstract Calculations and simulations conﬁrm that on average, Mercury is the nearest planet to Earth—and to every other planet in the solar system. [Annotation 1]

Figure 1: An illustration of the solar system. Credit: NASA

1 Introduction

Which planet is closest to Earth? Ask an astronomer or a search engine, and you’ll probably hear that though the situation changes frequently, Venus is [Annotation 2] the closest when averaged over time. Several educational websites, such as The Planets and Space Dictionary, publish the distance between each pair of planets, and they all show that Venus is nearest to Earth on average. They’re all wrong. NASA literature even tells us Venus is “our closest planetary neighbor,” which is true if we are talking about which planet has the closest approach to Earth but not if we want to know which planet is closest on average. [Annotation 3]

As it turns out, by some phenomenon of carelessness, ambiguity, or groupthink, science popularizers have disseminated information based on a ﬂawed assumption about the average distance between planets. Using a mathematical method that we devised, we determine that when averaged over time, Earth’s nearest neighbor is in fact Mercury.

1

#### Page 2

2 Simple but wrong

To calculate the average distance between two planets, The Planets and other websites assume the orbits are coplanar and subtract the average radius of the inner orbit, r 1 , from the average radius of the outer orbit, r 2 . The distance between Earth (1 astronomical unit from the Sun) and Venus (0.72 AU) comes out to 0.28 AU.

Although it feels intuitive that the average distance between every point on two concentric ellipses would be the diﬀerence in their radii, in reality that diﬀerence determines only the average distance of the ellipses’ closest points.

3 A better approach

To more accurately capture the average distance between planets, we devised the point-circle method (PCM). The PCM treats the orbits of two objects as circular, concentric, and coplanar. An object in a circular orbit maintains constant velocity, which means that over a suﬃciently long period, it is equally likely to be in any position in that orbit.

Figure 2: (a) The uniform probabilistic distribution of two circularly orbiting [Annotation 4] bodies, with orbital radii r 1 and r 2 . (b) Radial symmetry is used to simplify the average distance between the distributions.

It can be determined by integrating the point-to-point distance around c 1 , as simpliﬁed in the following equation, which deﬁnes the PCM:

¯ [Annotation 5] d = 2 π (r 1 + r 2 )E



2 √

r 1 r 2 r 1 + r 2



(1)

where E(x) is an elliptic integral of the second kind. The average distances [Annotation 6] between pairs of planets determined by the PCM are included in the table. Venus is on average 1.14 AU from Earth, but Mercury is a much closer 1.04 AU.

From the PCM, we noticed that the distance between two orbiting bodies is at a minimum when the inner orbit is at a minimum. That observation results in

2

#### Page 3

Figure 3: A simulation of an Earth year’s worth of orbits by the terrestrial [Annotation 7] planets begins to reveal that Mercury (gray in orbital animation) has the smallest average distance from Earth (blue) and is most frequently Earth’s nearest neighbor. A longer run of the simulation can be seen on YouTube. In addition, planetary geoscientist David Rothery ran a solar system simulation for the BBC radio program More or Less and came up with similar results. [Annotation 8]

what we call the whirly-dirly corollary (named after an episode of the cartoon Rick and Morty): For two bodies with roughly coplanar, concentric, circular orbits, the average distance between the two bodies decreases as the radius of the inner orbit decreases. It’s clear from this corollary, and from the table, that Mercury (average orbital radius of 0.39 AU), not Venus (average radius of 0.72 AU), is the closest planet to Earth on average. In fact, Mercury is even the closest planet to Neptune. (And yes, to Pluto too: Though the corollary doesn’t work as well for the dwarf planet, with its orbital inclination of 17° and eccentricity of 0.25, its nearest neighbor is also Mercury.)

4 Simulation validation

We ran a simulation to conﬁrm the whirly-dirly corollary, using a Python library called PyEphem to chart the positions of all eight planets in the solar system for 10 000 years. An animation illustrating the simulation is shown in ﬁgure 2. After each 24 hours of simulated time, the program records the distances between each pair of planets.

In the table we list the average measured distances over the 10 millennia and compare them with the results from the PCM and the traditional method. The simulation results diﬀer from the ﬂawed numbers by up to 300 %, but they deviate from the PCM ﬁgures by less than 1 %. Figure 3 compares the [Annotation 9] results from both methods with the simulation of the average distance between Neptune and the seven other planets.

3

#### Page 4

Figure 4: The point-circle method (blue points) calculates the average distance from Neptune to the other seven planets far more accurately than the method used by websites such as The Planets (yellow). The values are compared with those obtained from the 10000-year solar system simulation. Credit: Greg Stasiewicz and Flourish

5 Conclusion

As best we can tell, no one has come up with a concept like PCM to compare orbits. With the right assumptions, PCM could possibly be used to get a quick estimate of the average distance between any set of orbiting bodies. Perhaps it can be useful for quickly estimating satellite communication relays, for which signal strength falls oﬀ with the square of distance. In any case, at least we know now that Venus is not our closest neighbor—and that Mercury is everybody’s.

4

#### Page 5

Figure 5: A comparison of the average distances (in astronomical units) between planets, as obtained via simulation, the point-circle method, and the common method used by various educational websites. The PCM results are far closer to those from the simulation, correctly demonstrating that Mercury is every other planet’s closest neighbor.

5

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/venus-is-not-earth-s-closest-neighbor. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
