# The Standard Double Soap Bubble in ℝ² uniquely minimizes perimeter

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-standard-double-soap-bubble-in-R2-uniquely-minimizes-perimeter

- **Authors:** Joel Foisy et al
- **Topic:** Mathematics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1505714614303-p0vjtmkxfb-069447ce34308a4ed8630572ba6ae7cc%2Fpjm-v159-n1-p03-p+copy.pdf
- **Pages:** 13
- **Annotations:** 7 comments in 7 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-standard-double-soap-bubble-in-R2-uniquely-minimizes-perimeter

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “1. Introduction. Soap bubbles naturally tend to minimize surface area for given volumes. This paper considers the two-dimensional analog of soap bubbles, seeking the way to fence in prescribed areas using the least amount of perimeter. For one prescribed quantity of area, the answer is of course a circle. This paper …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-09-18):

> A double bubble is pair of bubbles which intersect and are separated by a membrane bounded by the intersection.
> The Double Bubble Conjecture states that the “standard” familiar double soap bubble provides the least-perimeter way to enclose and separate two given spaces. It was first conjectured in the 19th century by the Belgian physicist Joseph Plateau while observing the structure of soap films.
>
> ![](http://www.stephenherbert.co.uk/Plateau_Portrait.jpg)
>
> However it was only in 1993 that a group of undergraduate students from Williams College proved the conjecture was true for ℝ² and in 1995, Hass, Hutchings, and Schlafly announced a computer-assisted
> proof for the case of equal volumes in ℝ³.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “1. Introduction. Soap bubbles naturally tend to minimize surface area for given volumes. This paper considers the two-dimensional analog of soap bubbles, seeking the way to fence in prescribed areas using the least amount of perimeter. For one prescribed quantity of area, the answer is of course a circle. This paper …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-09-18):

> Here's an interesting way to prove the circle is the shape of maximal area in fixed perimeter (which is equivalent of saying that the circle minimizes the perimeter for a certain area) using some intuition about physics.
>
> Imagine a rope surrounding a 2D gas, with vacuum outside the rope. The gas will expand, pushing the rope to enclose a maximal area at equilibrium.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/AB4YJB9.png)
>
> When the system reaches equilibrium the net force applied on the rope is going to be zero in every direction, otherwise it would keep expanding. Thus, the pressure the gas exerts must be cancelled by the tension of the rope in every point. Drawing the force diagram for an infinitesimal piece of rope we have
>
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/3lJWoen.png)
>
> The force due to the gas is just the pressure times the length of the segment: $F_{GAS}=PL$. The force due to the tension is the projection along the direction of the gas expansion times 2 since the rope is under tension on both sides: $2T \sin(\frac{\theta}{2}) = 2T \sin (\frac{L}{2R})$.
>
> Since the pressure is the same everywhere, and the force from pressure must be canceled by the force from tension, the net tension force must be the same for any rope segment of the same length. That means the radius is the same everywhere, so the rope must be a circle.

### Annotation 3 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “For three or more areas, the question remains open (see Figure 1.0.3). In R 3 it is also an open question whether the standard double bubble is the least-area way to enclose and separate two prescribed volumes (see Figure 1.0.4).”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-09-18):

> The proof for ℝ³ was actually achieved 2 years later by [Joel Hass, Michael Hutchings and Roger Schlafly](https://www.emis.de/journals/ERA-AMS/1995-03-001/1995-03-001.html)

### Annotation 4 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “PROPOSITION 2.1. Let S be an edge of a perimeter minimizing bub ble cluster in R 2 . Define C to be the distance between the endpoints of S, with θ the angle between S and the line segment connecting its endpoints (see Figure 2.1.1). Then the radius of curvature R of S, the area A of the region between S and the line …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-09-18):

> To calculate R, A and L let's first draw the entire circumference.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/qAwf7Zj.png)
>
> It's not difficult to see that $\cos (90-\theta)=\frac{C/2}{R}$ and so $R=\frac{C}{2 \sin (\theta)}$.
>
> The length of the arc (L) is just the angle $2\theta$ times the radius of curvature R: $L=2\theta R$. Using the expression for R we get $L=\frac{C\theta }{\sin(\theta)}$
>
> Finally to calculate the area A we just need to compute the area of the semi-circle and subtract the sections A1 and A2.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/HhjE94r.png)
>
> $$
> A = A_{semi-circle} - 2A1-2A2 \\
> A = \theta R^2 - \frac{C^2 \cos (\theta)}{4 \sin (\theta)}\\
> A = \frac{\theta C^2 - \cos (\theta)\sin (\theta) C^2}{4 \sin^2(\theta)}
> $$

### Annotation 5 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “Proof. The wh o le cluster must be connected. Otherwise, sliding components together until their boundaries are t an gen t yields a con tradiction of the Regularity Theorem 1.3. In addition, Euler's formula concerning the vertices, edges, and faces of a planar graph gives V E + F = 1. Since each vertex has degree 3, …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-09-19):

> If the cluster is not connected as can be seen in the image on the left it is possible to slide the interior component so that the boundaries are tangent and so instead of having a group of 3 arcs meeting in point P we have 4 which contradicts Theorem 1.3!
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/vNEkcIG.png)

### Annotation 6 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “„ = 20(2 + cos(2fl)) 3(sin(2fl)) 1 ] 4sin 4 0”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-09-19):

> Here's a plot of A''(x)
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/VSAV95G.png)
>
> As can be seen A''(x)>0 on (0,$\pi$).

### Annotation 7 (page 9)

Beside the passage: “The perimeter of the standard double bubble with angle θ between the line segment connecting its vertices (distance 1 apart) and the arc separating its two bubbles is given by perim (θ) = L (θ) + L{(2π/ 3) + θ) + L ( ( 2π / 3) θ).”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-09-19):

> Here's an illustration of the calculation of the total perimeter for the standard double bubble.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/Chu5xXI.png)

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

PACIFIC JOURNAL OF MATHEMATICS

Vol. 159, No. 1, 1993

THE STANDARD DOUBLE SOAP BUBBLE IN R 2

UNIQUELY MINIMIZES PERIMETER

JOEL FOISY, MANUAL ALFARO, JEFFREY BROCK, NICKELOUS HODGES AND JASON ZIMBA

Of course the circle is the least-perimeter way to enclose a region of prescribed area in the plane. This paper proves that a certain standard "double bubble" i s the least-perimeter way to enclose and separate two regions of prescribed areas. The solution for three regions remains conjectural.

1. Introduction. Soap bubbles naturally tend to minimize surface [Annotation 1] area for given volumes. This paper considers the two-dimensional analog of soap bubbles, seeking the way to fence in prescribed areas using the least amount of perimeter. For one prescribed quantity [Annotation 2] of area, the answer is of course a circle. This paper shows that for two prescribed quantities of area, the unique answer is the "standard double bubble" of Figure 1.0.1, and not the non-standard competitors admitted by the general existence theory ([Al], [M]) with disconnected bubbles or exterior (see Figure 1.0.2).

FIGURE 1.0.1. The standard double-bubble is the unique least-perimeter way to enclose and separate two prescribed areas.

A B C FIGURE 1.0.2. Some non-standard double-bubbles. (A) has connected bubbles but the exterior is disconnected. (B) has a connected exterior, but its B\ bubble is disconnected. (C) has both disconnected bubbles and a disconnected exterior.

47

#### Page 2

48 J. FOISY, M. ALFARO, J. BROCK, N. HODGES AND J. ZIMBA

FIGURE 1.0.3. It is an open question whether the standard triple bubble is the least-perimeter way to enclose and separate three prescribed areas.

FIGURE 1.0.4. It is an open question whether the standard double bubble is the least-area way to enclose and separate two given volumes in R 3 .

For three or more areas, the question remains open (see Figure 1.0.3). In R [Annotation 3] 3 it is also an open question whether the standard double bubble is the least-area way to enclose and separate two prescribed volumes (see Figure 1.0.4).

Proofs 1.1. The proofs first treat the case when there are no bounded components of the exterior trapped inside the configuration (Lemma 2.4). In this case, the bubble must be a combinatorial tree. In a nonstandard double bubble, part of an extreme bubble can be reflected to contradict known regularity (cf. Figure 1.1.1).

The general case involves filling presumptive bounded components of the exterior to obtain a contradiction of certain monotonicity properties of the least-perimeter function.

Existence 1.2. F. J. Almgren [Al, Theorem VI.2] and [M] have established the existence of perimeter-minimizing bubble clusters in general

#### Page 3

DOUBLE BUBBLES 49

FIGURE 1.1.1. In the proof, presumptive extreme extra components can be reflected to contradict regularity. In the pictured reflection, there is a forbidden meeting of four arcs at the point t.

dimensions. Their results admit the possibility of disconnected bubbles and exterior. In the category of clusters with connected bubbles and connected exterior, existence remains open, although it is an easy mistake to think it obvious (cf. [B]).

The following regularity theorem, proved for R 3 by Jean Taylor ([Ta], [ATa]), appears in [M].

REGULARITY THEOREM 1.3. A perimeter-minimizing bubble cluster in R 2 consists of arcs of circles (or line segments) meeting in threes at angles of 120°.

DEFINITIONS 1.4. A cluster of bubbles (or bubble cluster) in R n is a collection of finitely many pairwise disjoint open sets, B\, 2?2 ? ^3 ? ? B k . Each open set B\, , B k is called a bubble. We do not require bubbles to be connected.

Call a cluster of exactly two bubbles a double bubble and a cluster of exactly three bubbles a triple bubble.

In R 2 , a standard double bubble has three circular arcs (in this paper, a line segment is a circular arc) meeting at two vertices at angles of 120°.

The perimeter of a cluster is given by the one-dimensional Hausdorff measure of the topological boundaries of the bubble:

Haus 1

A cluster is perimeter-minimizing if no other cluster enclosing the same areas has less perimeter.

#### Page 4

50 J. FOISY, M. ALFARO, J. BROCK, N. HODGES AND J. ZIMBA

Ac kno wle dgme nt s . This paper consists of some main results of the Geometry Group [A] of the Williams College SMALL Undergradu ate Research Project, summer 1990, a National Science Foundation site for Research Experiences for Undergraduates. Professor Frank Morgan advised the group. The work was further revised and devel oped in Joel Foisy's senior thesis [F] u n d e r advisor Dave Witte and by the SMALL 1991 Geometry Group, consisting of Thomas Colthurst, Chris Cox, Joel Foisy, Hugh Howards, Kathryn Kollett, Holly Lowy, and Steve Root. A very special thanks to Professors Morgan and Witte for all their help.

2. The double bubble in R 2 . Theorem 2.3 establishes the existence and uniqueness of the standard double bubble enclosing any two pre scribed quantities of area. Lemma 2.4 shows that, if the exterior is connected, a perimeter minimizing double bubble has connected bubbles. Proposition 2.8 shows that a perimeter minimizing double bubble must have a connected exterior. Finally, the Main Theorem 2.9 establishes the standard double bubble as the unique perimeter minimizing enclosure for two prescribed quantities of area.

We begin with some basic formulas and omit th e easy computations.

PROPOSITION 2.1. Let S be an edge of a perimeter minimizing bub ble [Annotation 4] cluster in R 2 . Define C to be the distance between the endpoints of S, with θ the angle between S and the line segment connecting its endpoints (see Figure 2.1.1). Then the radius of curvature R of S, the area A of the region between S and the line segment connecting its endpoints, and the length L of S are given by c AM r\ C 2 (θ sin(θ)cos(θ)) A{0C) = , ana , 2 4sur(0)

1

c ' FIGURE 2.1.1. The circular arc S has radius of curvature R, area A and length L.

#### Page 5

DOUBLE BUBBLES 51

PROPOSITION 2.2. I f a perimeter minimizing double bubble in R 2

has connected bubbles and a connected exterior, then it is a standard double bubble.

Proof. [Annotation 5] The wh o le cluster must be connected. Otherwise, sliding components together until their boundaries are t an gen t yields a con tradiction of the Regularity Theorem 1.3. In addition, Euler's formula concerning the vertices, edges, and faces of a planar graph gives V E + F = 1. Since each vertex has degree 3, 2E = 3V. We also know that F = 2. Solving these equations yields that V = 2 and E = 3 . By t h e R e g u l a r i t y Theorem 1.3, the cluster indeed consists of t h r ee circular arcs all m e e t i n g in two points at an gles of 120°.

THEOREM 2.3. For a n y t w o p r e s c r i b e d qu a nt ities of area, there exists a unique standard double bubble.

REMARK. The proof shows that given a family of standard double bubbles with vertices a fixed distance apart, increasing the cu r vat ure on the separator arc decreases the area enclosed by t h e smaller bubble and increases the a r e a enclosed by t h e l a r g e r bubble.

Proof. We will show that given any λ with 0 < λ < 1, there exists, up to c o n gr u e n c e, a un ique standard double bubble B\, Bι such that the ratio (area(J?i))/area(2?2)) of the two a r e a s it encloses is λ. Consider a standard double bubble with the d ist a n ce between its two vertices fixed to b e 1. Note that its edges are c ir c u lar arcs that meet at these two vertices. For t h e area underneath an arc o f o u r enclosure, Proposition 2.1 yields

A straightforward calculation shows that

„ = 20(2 + cos(2fl)) 3(sin(2fl)) 1 ] 4sin 4 [Annotation 6] 0

It can be ro u t in ely shown that A"(θ) > 0 on (0, π) . For any θ e [0, π / 3 ) , an angle formed by a circular arc a n d the line segment of distance 1 t h a t joins its en dpoin ts, one c a n construct a standard double bubble (see F i g u r e 2.3.1).

#### Page 6

52 J. FOISY, M. ALFARO, J. BROCK, N . H OD G ES AND J. ZIMBA

FIGURE 2.3.1. For any θ, one can construct a stan dard double bubble.

The enclosed areas satisfy

(1)

area B x = A((2π/ 3) θ) + A(θ), area B 2 = A((2π/ 3) + θ) A(θ).

For θ e[0, π/3), any ratio of A\ to A 2 will be uniquely represented. Indeed, let F{θ) = (area(5!))/(area(5 2 )). Since A"(θ) > 0 for θ in (0, π), in (0, π/3), area ^i = A((2π/ 3) θ) + A(θ) is strictly decreasing and area B 2 = A((2π/3) + θ) A(θ) is strictly increasing. In general, increasing θ will decrease the area enclosed by the smaller

FIGURE 2.3.2. As θ varies, a unique standard double bubble represents every possible ratio of area(2?i) to area(i? 2 ).

#### Page 7

DOUBLE BUBBLES 53

bubble and increase the area enclosed by the larger bubble. Thus F(θ) is strictly decreasing on the interval [0, π/ 3). In addition, F(0) = 1 and F(θ) > 0 as θ > π/ 3. Thus F: [0, π/3) + ( 0, 1] is bijective (see Figure 2.3.2). Since F is bijective, a standard double bubble enclosing any two prescribed quantities of area uniquely exists for every value of θ e [0, π / 3).

We now have to show that any double bubble that contains bo u n d ed components of the exterior or disconnected bubbles is not perimeter minimizing.

LEMMA 2.4. A perimeter minimizing double bubble whose exterior is connected must be standard.

Proof. Let U be a perimeter minimizing double bubble with con nected exterior. If U is not standard, by Proposition 2.2, U has a dis connected bubble. We will show that U is not perimeter minimizing. Consider a graph formed by placing a vertex inside each bubble component of U, with an edge between vertices of adjacent compo nents. For any U with a connected exterior, the corresponding graph has no cycles. Thus there will be a component of U that lies at an endpoint of the corresponding graph. It must have exactly two edges and exactly two vertices (see Figure 2.4.1).

FIGURE 2.4.1. Since the exterior is assumed to be connected as in A, the associated graph has an endpoint in a component with two edges and two vertices. If the exterior were disconnected, then a cycle as in B could result.

#### Page 8

54 J. FOISY, M. ALFARO, J. BROCK, N. HODGES AND J . ZIMBA \

FIGURE 2.4.2. An extreme component F bounded by only two edges.

Let F be a component of U that has exactly two edges and exactly two vertices, r and q. Let t be a vertex of U that is adjacent to r but is not a vertex of F (see Figure 2.4.2). Let S be the edge connecting r and t. Let p = r and define a new bubble cluster, U p , by replacing the component F by its reflection across the perpendicular bisector of the line segment qp (= qr). If we let the point p move continuously along arc S from point r to point t and reflect component F and arc rp across the perpendicular bisector of line qp, the bubble cluster changes, but initially the perimeter and enclosed quantities of area remain constant.

FIGURE 2.4.3. The reflected component F may touch another component, contradicting regularity.

#### Page 9

DOUBLE BUBBLES 55

FIGURE 2.4.4. Otherwise the reflected component F eventually touches t, also contradicting regular ity.

As p varies continuously from r to t, two things could happen: either there will be a point p for which the reflection will result in the touching of another bubble component and the creation of a new vertex with four edges leading to it (see Figure 2.4.3), or p will even tually coincide with point t , and there will be an instance of four edges meeting at a vertex (see Figure 2.4.4).

This operation creates a new bubble cluster of the same perime ter, enclosing the same prescribed quantities of area, that contradicts regularity. Therefore, the original bubble itself must not be perimeter minimizing.

We will soon show that a perimeter minimizing double bubble must have a connected exterior.

LEMMA 2.5. Increasing the larger o f the two prescribed a r e a s enclosed by a standard double bubble will increase total perimeter.

Proof. F r o m Proposition 2.1, the length function for a circular arc with endpoints distance 1 apart and with θ, the angle between the segment connecting the endpoints and the arc, is

The perimeter of the standard double bubble with angle θ between the line segment connecting its vertices (distance 1 apart) and the arc separating its two bubbles is given by perim (θ) = L (θ) + L{(2π/ 3) + θ) + L ( ( 2π / 3) θ). [Annotation 7]

#### Page 10

56 J. F OI SY, M. ALF AR O, J. BR OC K, N. H OD G E S AND J . Z I M B A

A routine c a lcu la t io n sh ows that , sin0 0cos0 L

W =

sm z 0 sin 2 0 + 2 0 c o s 2 0 sin 2(9 ΓTί sπ r 0 It can easily be shown that L'(θ) > 0 on (0, π ) , and t h u s L(θ) is increasing on [0, π / 3 ) . In ad d ition , Z/'(0) > 0 on (0, π ) ; thus o n [0, π/3), L((2π/3) + 0 ) 4 L ( ( 2 π / 3 ) 0) is increasing. This implies that perim(0) is increasing on [0, π / 3 ) . Thus increasing 0 will increase the t o t a l perimeter. In a d d i t i o n , it follows from Theorem 2.3 ( c f . R e m a r k ) that increasin g 0 will decrease the area enclosed by t h e smaller bubble and increase the area enclosed by the larger bubble. By sc a l i n g up t h e double bubble until the smaller bubble contains its original area, only the a r e a enclosed by the la r ge r bubble will increase. In t h e p r o c e s s , total perimeter also increases.

DEFINITION 2.6. For two prescribed quantities of area, A\ and A 2 ? let P(Aχ, A 2 ) be t h e p e r i m e t e r of the least perimeter double bubble enclosing areas A\ and A 2 . Let P§(A\, A 2 ) be t h e p e r i m e t e r of the standard double bubble enclosing areas of size A\ and A 2 .

LEMMA 2.7. For a n y fixed A\ , A 2 > 0, the function P(A, A 2 ) has a minimum for A e [A\, oo).

Proof. By the isoperimetric inequality, P(A y A 2 ) > perim(Z)), where D is a disk of area A. Hence P(A, A 2 ) —• oo as A —• oo. Since P is continuous, P has a minimum for A e [Aι, oo).

PROPOSITION 2.8. The exterior of a perimeter minimizing double bubble must be connected.

Proof. G iven two quan tities of area, A\ and A 2 , without loss of generality assume A\ > A 2 . Suppose that the e x t e r i o r of a p er im e t er minimizing double bubble B\, B 2 enclosing A\ and A 2 is discon nected. By Le m m a 2.7, w e c an c h o o s e some A\ e [A\, oo) that min imizes P(A\, A 2 ). In p a r t i c u l a r , P(A\, A 2 ) < P(A { , A 2 ). We now show that if B[, B 2 is t h e perimeter minimizing enclosure of the quantities of area A[ and A 2 , respectively, then the ext erio r of B[, B 2 is connected. Suppose, to o b t a in a contradiction, t h at t h e exterior is disconnected. By incorporating the b o u n d e d components

#### Page 11

DOUBLE BUBBLES 5 7

of the exterior into the bubble B[ and then removing the edges that were separating the bounded components of the exterior from B[, a new double bubble, B", B 2 , with less perimeter than B[, B 2 is formed. This contradicts the choice of A\.

Thus B[ Φ B x and hence A λ < A\. By Lemma 2.5, P 0 (Aι, A 2 ) < P 0 (A[, A 2 ). By Lemma 2.4, P 0 (A[, A 2 ) = P(A\, A 2 ). By definition, P(A\, A 2 ) < PQ(A\ , A 2 ). In summary:

P{A X , ^ 2 ) < Po(A x , ^ 2 ) < P o ( 4 , A 2 ) = P ( 4 , ^ 2 ) < ^ ( ^i, ^2) This is a contradiction. We conclude that the exterior must be con nected.

MAIN THEOREM 2.9. For any two prescribed quantities of area, the standard double bubble is the unique perimeter minimizing enclosure of the prescribed quantities of area, {See Figure 2.9.1.)

FIGURE 2.9.1. Theorem 2.9 shows that a perimeter minimizing double bubble must look like the first one, not the second two, which have disconnected bubbles or exteriors.

Proof. By Theorem 1.6, we know that a perimeter minimizing dou ble bubble exists. By Proposition 2.8, the exterior of this double bub ble must be connected. Then, by Lemma 2.4, the bubble cluster must be standard. Therefore, only a standard double bubble is perimeter minimizing. By Theorem 2.3, it exists uniquely for any two prescribed quantities of area.

Lemma 2.5 showed that increasing the larger quantity of area en closed by a standard double bubble increases perimeter. It follows from our main theorem that increasing either quantity of area en closed by a standard double bubble increases perimeter.

COROLLARY 2.10. Increasing either given area A\, A 2 increases the perimeter of the perimeter minimizing double bubble.

#### Page 12

58 J. FOISY, M. ALFARO, J. BROCK, N. HODGES AND J. ZIMBA

FIGURE 2.10.1. After we shorten an outside arc, the resulting double bubble has less perimeter, and 2?i has less area.

Proof. If not, for some A\, A2 some slight increase in, say, A\ decreases the least perimeter of the minimizing double bubble. Now A\ can be decreased back to its original value by shortening an outside arc, as in Figure 2.10.1, and further decreasing perimeter, contradicting the minimizing property of the original double bubble.

Added in proof. There has been recent progress on the existence of connected bubbles [M] and on the triple bubble: Chris Cox, Lisa Harrison, Michael Hutchings, Susan Kim, Janette Light, Andrew Mauer, Meg T i l t o n , The shortest enclosure of three connected areas in R 2 , NSF SMALL undergraduate research Geometry Group, Williams College, 1992. Also see the survey: Frank Morgan, Mathematicians, including undergraduates, look at soap bubbles, Amer. Math. Monthly, (1993), in press.

REFERENCES

[A] Manuel Alfaro, Jeffrey Brock, Joel Foisy, Nickelous Hodges, and Jason Zimba, Compound soap bubbles in the plane, SMALL undergraduate research project, Williams College, 1990. [Al] F. J. Almgren, Jr., Existence and regularity almost everywhere of solutions to elliptic variational problems with constraints, Mem. Amer. Math. Soc, 35 (1976). [ATa] F. J. Almgren, Jr. and J. E. Taylor, The geometry of soap films and soap bubbles, Scientific American, July 1976, 82-9 3 . [B] Michael H. Bleicher, Isoperimetric division into a finite number of cells in the plane, Studia Sci. Math. Hung., 22 (1987), 123-137. [F] Joel Foisy, Soap Bubble Clusters in R 2 and R 3 , Senior Honors Thesis, Williams College, 1991.

#### Page 13

DOUBLE BUBBLES 59

[M] Frank Morgan, Soap bubbles in R 2 and in surfaces, preprint (1992). [Ta] Jean Taylor, The structure of singularities in soap-bubble-like and soap-film-like

minimal surfaces, Annals of Math., 103 (1976), 489-539.

Received August 12, 1991. Thi s research was partially supported by the National Science Foundation Research Experiences for Undergraduates Program, the Ford Foundation, the New England Consortium for Undergraduate Science Education, the Shell Foundation, G.T.E., and the Bronfman Science Center at Williams College.

c/o FRANK MORGAN WILLIAMS COLLEGE WILLIAMSTOWN, MA 01267 E-mail address: Frank.Morgan@williams.edu

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-standard-double-soap-bubble-in-R2-uniquely-minimizes-perimeter. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
