# The mysterious balancing stones on frozen lakes

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-mysterious-balancing-stones-on-frozen-lakes

- **Authors:** Nicolas Taberlet
- **Published:** 2022
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1679172696536-p5sg1y5pis-ee8dc29524a2f981a0f17088ff40082e%2Fpt.3.5088.pdf
- **Pages:** 2
- **Annotations:** 8 comments in 8 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-mysterious-balancing-stones-on-frozen-lakes

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “During the cold, dry Siberian winter, one can occasionally spot stones perched on impossibly thin pedestals of ice. How do they get there?”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-03-18):

> ## TL;DR
> This article explains the formation of Zen stones, natural structures where a stone on an ice surface ends up balanced on a narrow ice pedestal. The article provides a physical explanation for their formation, showing that slow surface sublimation is responsible for the differential ablation, and that the stone acts as an umbrella that inhibits sublimation and protects the ice underneath. Laboratory experiments using metal disks ruled out thermal conduction as an influence on the process, and numerical simulations showed the influence of stone shape on the ice foot formation. The stone's far-infrared black-body irradiance leads to a depression surrounding the pedestal.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “But initial disappointment can turn to amazement: After a few weeks si ing on the surface, the stone ends up balancing on a thin pedestal of ice, while the surface around it gradually vanishes into thin air. The phenomenon is manifest in the formation of Zen stones, shown in the ﬁ gure, so- called because of their …”

**Annotation** by Dr Wolf von Klitzing (2023-03-31):

> The melting point goes down with pressure. Therefore, if the stone is leaning towards one side, the pressure there will increase and thus will the melting... IF this term dominates the stone would topple over.

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Sightings are rare, possibly because speciﬁ c meteorological conditions are required. Not only must the temperature remain below freezing but the ice surface must remain free of snow for several consecutive weeks. The climate at Lake Baikal meets both conditions: The air temperature is below freezing for an average of …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-03-18):

> As can be seen from this phase diagram of pure water, the conditions at Lake Baikal make it very difficult for the ice to melt, whereas sublimation is possible.
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/74UcBnj.png)

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The umbrella effect In the case of water, the direct phase transition between the solid state and a gas occurs at negative temperatures (in Celsius) and in a very dry atmosphere. What’s more, it’s a slow, endothermic surface process, which therefore requires a constant ﬂux of external energy. Sunlight does the job in …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-03-18):

> The ablation rate of an ice surface can be calculated by considering the energy balance at the surface. The primary energy source contributing to ice ablation is solar irradiance, which provides energy for melting and sublimation. The ablation rate can be estimated using the following formula:
> $$
> \text{Ablation rate (AR)} = \frac{(\text{Solar irradiance (SI)} \times \text{Absorbed fraction (AF)})}{(\text{Latent heat of sublimation (LHS)} \times \text{Ice density} (\rho))}
> $$
>
> Here,
>
> - AR: Ablation rate (in meters per second or similar units)
> - SI: Solar irradiance (in Watts per square meter, W/m²)
> - AF: Absorbed fraction (unitless) - it represents the fraction of incoming solar radiation that is absorbed by the ice surface. This depends on the albedo (reflectivity) of the ice surface. A typical value for ice is about 0.9, meaning 90% of the incoming solar radiation is absorbed.
> - LHS: Latent heat of sublimation (in Joules per kilogram, J/kg) - it is the amount of energy required to change a given mass of ice directly from solid to vapor without going through the liquid phase. The latent heat of sublimation for water is approximately 2.83 x $10^6$ J/kg.
> - ρ: Ice density (in kilograms per cubic meter, kg/m³) - the density of ice is about 900 to 920 kg/m³.
>
> This formula provides a simplified estimation of the ablation rate and doesn't account for all factors influencing the ice ablation process, such as air temperature, wind speed, or long wave radiation from the atmosphere.
>
> At the latitude of Lake Baikal, in February or March, the irradiance reaches from 400 to 500 W/$m^2$ for typically 6 to 8 h. Assuming an emissivity of 0.95, the ice itself (at 260 K) radiates 246 W/$m^2$ back into the atmosphere resulting in a net energy input of 60W/$m^2$ per day. Substituting for the values at Lake Baikal:
> $$
> AR = \frac{60}{2.83 \times 10^6 \times 900} = 2.355 \times 10^{-8} m/s = 2 \ mm/day
> $$

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “A pebble placed on the ice blocks that light, however, and its shade hinders the sublimation beneath it. The rate, nearly zero underneath, gradually increases with distance from the center. The stone therefore acts as an umbrella, which protects”

**Annotation** by Dr Wolf von Klitzing (2023-03-31):

> Just looking at the image of the natural stone below, one notices the the stone is much thicker on one side -- and thus much more heavy. Any umbrella effect would be nearly independent of the thickness of the stone.
>
> At the same time, the stem is so thin, that it cannot support any bending forces, with other words the stem must be exactly located under the center of mass of the stone.
>
> These two facts together mean that whatever causes the stem to form must cause the sublimation to go slower with the pressure applied.

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “ZEN STONES in nature and the lab. (a) On Lake Baikal a stone rests on a narrow ice pedestal. (b) In a laboratory, this 30 mm aluminum disk rests on a at ice surface after sitting in a lyophilizer for 40 hours. (Adapted from Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 118, e2109107118, 2021.)”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-03-18):

> This is an illustration of the experimental setup for the experiment: a metal disk (of radius 15 mm) representing the stone is placed at the surface of a block of ice sublimating in the chamber of a commercial lyophilizer (Materials and Methods). The external energy required to sublimate the ice originates from the IR black-body radiation of the outer walls of the vacuum chamber, which remains at room temperature. The ablation is then isotropic (in the absence of a stone) and mimics the relative isotropy of natural diffuse sunlight in overcast weather, with a sublimation rate of typically 8 to 10 mm/d.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/I42M8Uy.png)

### Annotation 7 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Glacier tables appear on temperate glaciers where the ice (remaining at 0 °C) simply melts because of the warm ambient conditions. Depending on its size and shape, a rock atop the ice can provide enough thermal insulation to either hinder the ice from melting (a process that leads to the formation of the ice pedestal) …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-03-18):

> Here's a photo of a Glacier Table
> ![](https://media.sciencephoto.com/image/c0020079/400wm)

### Annotation 8 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Dip around the pedestal One interesting diﬀerence exists between natural and laboratory- made Zen stones. In nature a dip always surrounds the ice foot. But that feature was never encountered in our lab experiments. Whereas the umbrella eﬀect is clearly responsible for the pedestal’s formation, a detailed energy …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-03-18):

> In Fig. a) we have an illustration of this process. If we look at the typical energy profiles of diffuse sunlight (blue) and of far-infrared radiation FIR (orange) we can see that the irradiance of the sun is 100 times larger than the black-body emission of the stone, but the values of the integrated energies are comparable (359 W/m2 for the solar energy vs. 259 W/m2 from the stone at 260 K).
>
>
> Additionally, there is a significant difference in the range of wavelengths between sunlight and FIR: 300 to 2,500 nm for sunlight compared to 5 to 50 μm for FIR. This distinction has critical consequences, as the extinction rate (i.e., the imaginary part of the refraction index) varies by 10 orders of magnitude (Figure d). Likewise, the ice absorption length is highly dependent on wavelength (Figure d), with 10 km for 400-nm radiation, which renders the ice layer almost transparent, in contrast to 10-5 m for 10-μm radiation, where energy is absorbed within a 10-μm-thick layer, promoting surface sublimation of the ice. It is important to note that the data in Figure d pertain to pure ice; while multiple scattering in white ice may alter the exact extinction rate values, the discrepancy remains vast, and the conclusions are still valid. This immense difference indicates that even if FIR irradiance is 100 times lower than diffuse sunlight, it can locally and significantly boost the ablation rate. This clarifies why the depression reflects the stone's shape (Figure e).
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/mjKrph8.jpg)

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

62 PHYSICS TODAY | SEPTEMBER 2022

QUICK STUDY

Nicolas Taberlet is an associate professor at the University of Lyon in France. His research specialties are the physics of granular materials and pattern formation in ice structures.

A

mong those who live in a cold enough climate, who has never thrown a large pebble onto the pristine surface of a frozen lake in the hope of breaking the ice? In the Siberian winter on Lake Baikal, any attempt is bound to fail, as the ice typically reaches up to 3 meters thick—enough to support the weight of an 18- wheeler.

But initial disappointment can turn to amazement: After a [Annotation 2] few weeks si ing on the surface, the stone ends up balancing on a thin pedestal of ice, while the surface around it gradually vanishes into thin air. The phenomenon is manifest in the formation of Zen stones, shown in the ﬁ gure, so- called because of their resemblance to stacks of rocks sometimes found balancing in Japanese Zen gardens.

Sightings are rare, possibly because speciﬁ c meteorological conditions are required. Not only must the temperature remain below freezing but the ice surface must remain free of snow for several consecutive weeks. The climate at Lake Baikal meets both conditions: The air temperature is below freezing for an average of ﬁ ve months per year, and precipitation is rare in winter. Thus, the melting of ice is virtually impossible, and the region’s exceptionally low humidity mainly causes the ice to sublimate. [Annotation 3]

I was struck at how li le explanation exists in the literature and set out to reproduce the eﬀ ect in the lab.

The umbrella effect In the case of water, the direct phase transition between the solid state and a gas occurs at negative temperatures (in Celsius) and in a very dry atmosphere. What’s more, it’s a slow, endothermic surface process, which therefore requires a constant ﬂux of external energy. Sunlight does the job in nature, either directly in clear weather or diﬀusely in overcast conditions. Sublimation causes the ice to vaporize at a rate set by the temperature, humidity, and amount of sunlight it receives. From the average winter solar irradiance at the lake and water’s latent heat of sublimation, I estimate the sublimation rate of an [Annotation 4] ice surface at about 2 mm per day.

A pebble placed on the ice blocks that light, however, and [Annotation 5] its shade hinders the sublimation beneath it. The rate, nearly zero underneath, gradually increases with distance from the center. The stone therefore acts as an umbrella, which protects

the ice from solar irradiance. Known as diﬀ erential ablation, the process forces the pebble to remain at a constant altitude on an increasingly taller and narrower foot of ice until it eventually falls oﬀ . Its lifetime atop the pedestal is roughly the half width of the stone divided by the ablation rate— about 40 days for the stone in panel a of the ﬁ gure.

Sublimation is not the only possible factor at play. The melting temperature of water decreases with applied pressure. And between 100 MPa and 1 GPa, ice can start melting at temperatures as low as −10 °C. The pressures that Zen stones exert on the ice remain far below that range, however, and any melting would only cause the pebble to sink into the ice. Moreover, ice is known to slowly deform over time— a phenomenon known as plastic creep— which explains why glaciers can ﬂ ow down mountains. But that too only causes the stone to sink.

As another possible factor, small wind- driven ice particles could potentially create mechanical wear. But the smooth surface of the ice pedestals shows no evidence of erosion. And the typical time required for that ablation process is far longer than the lifetime of a natural Zen stone.

Stones in the lab To convince my University of Lyon colleague, Nicolas Plihon, and myself of the simple sublimation hypothesis, we reproduced the phenomenon in a laboratory- scale experimental setup. We placed an aluminum disk— a proxy for the stone— on the surface of a block of ice within a commercial lyophilizer, a device whose temperature, pressure, and humidity favor sublimation. The external energy used to sublimate the ice came not from sunlight but from IR radiation of the walls of the vacuum chamber, which remained at room temperature.

In the absence of a stone, the ablation is nearly isotropic and mimics the relative isotropy of natural diﬀ use sunlight in overcast weather. And its considerably greater sublimation rate of typically 8– 10 mm per day allowed us to accelerate the physical mechanism. Indeed, obtaining Zen stones from actual pebbles and disks was straightforward.

The ﬁ gure's panel b shows the results we achieved using a 30 mm aluminum disk after 40 hours of sublimation. With the disk initially placed either on the ice surface or embedded inside the ice, the IR forced the ice to sublimate only partially— the disk’s shade prevented it from vanishing completely.

The mysterious balancing stones on frozen lakes

Nicolas Taberlet

During the cold, dry Siberian winter, one can occasionally spot stones perched on impossibly thin [Annotation 1] pedestals of ice. How do they get there?

#### Page 2

SEPTEMBER 2022 | PHYSICS TODAY 63

Among other results, our experiments conﬁ rmed that the disk’s thermal properties had li le eﬀ ect. (In some cases, we used copper disks, whose thermal conductivity and speciﬁ c heat greatly exceed those of aluminum disks we used in other cases.) They supported our conclusion that the umbrella eﬀ ect is the predominant mechanism.

Dip around the pedestal One interesting diﬀerence exists between natural and laboratory- made Zen stones. In nature a dip always surrounds the ice foot. But that feature was never encountered in our lab experiments. Whereas the umbrella eﬀect is clearly responsible for the pedestal’s formation, a detailed energy balance of the system reveals second- order phenomena. Like any other material, ice and stone emit blackbody IR radiation in a range whose intensities depend on the temperature and the material’s emissivity. [Annotation 8]

In nature, because of sunlight or ambient wind, the ice and stone are unlikely to remain at the same temperature throughout the day. And that, in turn, causes an imbalance between them. More speciﬁ cally, if the stone is a few degrees warmer than the ice, the IR it radiates into the ice (in addition to that from sunlight) can exceed that emi ed by the ice itself. The

eﬀ ect becomes important in the later stages of Zen- stone formation— when a stone sits on a tall and thin pedestal— as thermal contact is reduced.

Two competing eﬀ ects are therefore at play: the umbrella eﬀ ect, which protects the ice, and the excess energy from the stone, which instead accelerates the sublimation and carves out a cavity in the stone’s vicinity. While the former is responsible for the formation of the ice pedestal in the early life of a Zen stone, the la er is responsible for the dip forming around the ice foot in the later stages.

The excess energy is absent in our experiment because of three factors: The lyophilizer was operated in a high vacuum, metal was used for Zen stones, and such stones were smaller, all of which favor a good thermal equilibrium between the disk and the ice.

Glacier tables In addition to Zen stones, other intriguing formations consisting of a rock resting on a thin pedestal can be found in nature. In a hoodoo, for instance, a hard stone protects a tall column of fragile sandstone from rain and frost- driven erosion. And in a so- called glacier table, a large rock on a low- altitude glacier ends up on a tall foot of ice. The laer case is akin to the Zen stones of Lake Baikal because it involves diﬀerential ablation of an ice surface. But the glacier tables’ rock formation, shape, and dynamics are broadly diﬀerent.

Glacier tables appear on temperate glaciers where the ice (remaining at 0 °C) simply melts because of the warm ambient conditions. Depending on its size and shape, a rock atop the ice can provide enough thermal insulation to either hinder the ice from melting (a process that leads to the formation of the ice pedestal) [Annotation 7] or increase the ice's melting rate (a process that leads to the rock sinking into the ice). A recent study has shown that the diﬀ erential melting of ice for glacier tables is predominantly caused by heat exchange with the surrounding air.

The umbrella eﬀ ect, which controls the formation of Zen stones, is therefore only a secondary factor for glacier tables. Conversely, although a material’s thermal properties, such as conductivity and speciﬁ c heat, are crucial for glacier tables, they are insigniﬁ cant to the formation of Zen stones. Any opaque object left on a sublimating ice surface is likely to wind up atop a narrow foot. Indeed, far from the romantic image sometimes conjured by a Zen stone, the frozen bodies of deceased penguins in Antarctica can occasionally be found perched on top of narrow ice pedestals.

Additional resources ‣ N. Mangold, “Ice sublimation as a geomorphic process: A planetary perspective,” Geomorphology 126, 1 (2011). ‣ N. Taberlet, N. Plihon, “ Sublimation- driven morphogenesis of Zen stones on ice surfaces,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 118, e2109107118 (2021). ‣ M. Hénot, N. Plihon, N. Taberlet, “Onset of glacier tables,” Phys. Rev. Le . 127, 108501 (2021). PT

a

b

10 cm

20 mm

ZEN STONES in nature and the lab. (a) On Lake Baikal a stone rests on a [Annotation 6] narrow ice pedestal. (b) In a laboratory, this 30 mm aluminum disk rests on a at ice surface after sitting in a lyophilizer for 40 hours. (Adapted from Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 118, e2109107118, 2021.)

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-mysterious-balancing-stones-on-frozen-lakes. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
