# The experience of mathematical beauty and its neural correlates

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-experience-of-mathematical-beauty-and-its-neural-correlates

- **Authors:** Zeki S, Romaya JP, Benincasa DMT and Atiyah MF
- **Published:** 2014
- **Topic:** Biology
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1711230106256-p9ahy3r6vv-271d7245be49676ceaafde2cc9dcec4e%2Fmathematical_beauty_fnhum-08-00068.pdf
- **Pages:** 12
- **Annotations:** 8 comments in 8 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-experience-of-mathematical-beauty-and-its-neural-correlates

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Edited by: Josef Parvizi, Stanford University, USA Reviewed by: Miriam Rosenberg-Lee, Stanford University, USA Marie Arsalidou, The Hospital for Sick Children, Canada *Correspondence: Semir Zeki, Wellcome Department of Neurobiology, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, UK e-mail: s.zeki@ucl.ac.uk”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2024-03-23):

> ### TL;DR
>
> This paper explores the fascinating connection between the experience of beauty in mathematics and art, and how the brain processes these abstract emotional experiences. The authors used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to identify the brain regions activated when mathematicians experience mathematical beauty.
>
> The researchers discovered that:
> - The experience of mathematical beauty correlates with activity in the same brain area as the experience of beauty derived from other sources, such as art or music.
> - The experience of mathematical beauty is related to activity in brain areas associated with reward, emotion, and cognition, suggesting a complex interplay between these processes.
> - Mathematical beauty is a combination of the understanding of mathematical concepts and the emotional response they evoke.
> - There seems to exist a strong link between mathematical and artistic beauty.
>
> Understanding the neural basis of mathematical beauty may help educators design teaching methods that foster a deeper appreciation for the subject.
>
> > ***"Art and mathematics are, to most, at polar opposites; the former
> has a more “sensible” source and is accessible to many while the
> latter has a high cognitive, intellectual, source and is accessible to
> few."***

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The beauty of mathematical formulations lies in abstracting, in simple equations, truths that have universal validity. Many— among them the mathematicians Bertrand Russell (1919) and Hermann Weyl (Dyson, 1956; Atiyah, 2002), the physicist Paul Dirac (1939) and the art critic Clive Bell (1914)—have written of the …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2024-03-23):

> > ***"The beauty of mathematical formulations lies in abstracting, in
> simple equations, truths that have universal validity.
> [...]  the experience of mathematical beauty has much in common
> with that derived from other sources, even though mathematical
> beauty has a much deeper intellectual source than visual or musical beauty, which are more “sensible” and perceptually based."***

### Annotation 3 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “the experience of visual and musical beaut y (Kawabata and Zeki, 2004; Ishizu and Zeki, 2011), we used similar experimental procedures to these previous studies. About 2–3 weeks before the scanning experiment, each subject was given 60 mathematical formulae (Data Sheet 1: EquationsForm.pdf) to study at leisure and …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2024-03-23):

> You can find the Data Sheet with all of the 60 mathematical equations here: [The Beauty of Mathematics - Equations](https://fermatslibrary.com/p/413aae33)

### Annotation 4 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “1 + e iπ = 0”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2024-03-23):

> $$1+e^{i\pi}=0$$
>
> Euler's Identity is a special case of Euler's Formula that establishes the fundamental relationship between the trigonometric functions and the complex exponential function.

### Annotation 5 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “The frequency distribution of post-scan understanding ratings is given in Figure 2D, which shows that more of the equations were well understood, as would be expected from a group of expert mathematicians. Figure 2E shows that there was a highly signiﬁcant positive correlation (Pearson’s r = 0.413 for 898 values, p < …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2024-03-23):

> The results show a strong positive correlation between the level of understanding and scan-time beauty ratings, indicating that well-understood equations were generally perceived as more beautiful.
>
>
> The relationship was not perfect, allowing the researchers to separate the effects of beauty from those of understanding. Authors note that for ideal analysis they would prefer equal ratios of the four understanding categories in each scanning session.

### Annotation 6 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “Post-scan questionnaires regarding subjective (emotional) experiences Mathematical subjects were as well given four questions to answer, post-scan. One subject did not respond to this part of the questionnaire, leaving us with 14 subjects. To the question: “When you consider a particularly beautiful equation, do you …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2024-03-23):

> Expert mathematicians had an emotional response described as an "aesthetic emotion" when viewing equations they rated as beautiful. This emotional experience was also characterized as satisfying or pleasurable.
>
> The subjects demonstrated a deep understanding and appreciation of mathematics by identifying specific equations they found particularly beautiful, and expressing regret when some of their favorite equations were not included in the list.

### Annotation 7 (page 8)

Beside the passage: “DISCUSSION Art and mathematics are, to most, at polar opposites; the former has a more “sensible” source and is accessible to many while the latter has a high cognitive, intellectual, source and is accessible to few. Yet both can provoke the aesthetic emotion and arouse an experience of beauty, although neither all …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2024-03-25):

> Art and mathematics are sometimes perceived as polar opposites. They can both provoke aesthetic emotions and arouse an experience of beauty. Despite its abstract nature, there is a strong relation between mathematical and artistic beauty, as both mathematicians and art appreciators feel a similar sense of delight and exaltation. Plato considered mathematical beauty to be the highest form of beauty.

### Annotation 8 (page 10)

Beside the passage: “BEAUTY AND UNDERSTANDING Perhaps one of the most awkward, and at the same time challenging, aspects of this work was trying to separate out beauty and understanding. Because the correlation between the two, though signiﬁcant, was also imperfect, we were able to do so for mathematicians. T his of course leaves the …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2024-03-25):

> > ***"Perhaps one of the most awkward, and at the same time challenging, aspects of this work was trying to separate out beauty and understanding. Because the correlation between the two, though significant, was also imperfect, we were able to do so for mathematicians. This of course leaves the question of whether non-mathematicians, with no understanding whatsoever of the equations, would also find the equations beautiful."***

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

ORIGINAL RESEARCH ARTICLE

published: 13 February 2014 doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2014.00068

The experience of mathematical beauty and its neural

correlates

Semir Zeki 1 * , John Paul Romaya 1 , Dionigi M. T. Benincasa 2 and Michael F. Atiyah 3

1 Wellcome Laboratory of Neurobiology, University College London, London, UK 2 Department of Physics, Imperial College London, London, UK 3 School of Mathematics, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK

Edited by: Josef Parvizi, Stanford University, USA [Annotation 1] Reviewed by: Miriam Rosenberg-Lee, Stanford University, USA Marie Arsalidou, The Hospital for Sick Children, Canada *Correspondence: Semir Zeki, Wellcome Department of Neurobiology, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, UK e-mail: s.zeki@ucl.ac.uk

Many have written of the experience of mathematical beauty as being comparable to that derived from the greatest art. This makes it interesting to learn whether the experience of beauty derived from such a highly intellectual and abstract source as mathematics correlates with activity in the same part of the emotional brain as that derived from more sensory, perceptually based, sources. To determine this, we used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to image the activity in the brains of 15 mathematicians when they viewed mathematical formulae which they had individually rated as beautiful, indifferent or ugly. Results showed that the experience of mathematical beauty correlates parametrically with activity in the same part of the emotional brain, namely ﬁeld A1 of the medial orbito-frontal cortex (mOFC), as the experience of beauty derived from other sources.

Keywords: mathematics, neuroesthetics, fMRI, beauty, mofc

INTRODUCTION

“Mathematics, rightly viewed, possesses not only truth, but supreme beauty”

Bertrand Russell, Mysticism and Logic (1919).

The beauty of mathematical formulations lies in abstracting, in simple equations, truths that have universal validity. Many— among them the mathematicians Bertrand Russell (1919) and Hermann Weyl (Dyson, 1956; Atiyah, 2002), the physicist Paul Dirac (1939) and the art critic Clive Bell (1914)—have written of the importance of beauty in mathematical formulations and have compared the experience of mathematical beauty to that derived [Annotation 2] from the greatest art (Atiyah, 1973). Their descriptions suggest that the experience of mathematical beauty has much in common with that derived from other sources, even though mathematical beauty has a much deeper intellectual source than visual or musical beauty, which are more “sensible” and perceptually based. Past brain imaging studies exploring the neurobiology of beauty have shown that the experience of visual (Kawabata and Zeki, 2004), musical (Blood et al., 1999; Ishizu and Zeki, 2011), and moral (Tsukiura and Cabeza, 2011) beauty all correlate with activity in a speciﬁc part of the emotional brain, ﬁeld A1 of the medial orbitofrontal cortex, which probably includes segments of Brodmann Areas (BA) 10, 12 and 32 (see Ishizu and Zeki, 2011 for a review). Our hypothesis in this study was that the experience of beauty derived from so abstract an intellectual source as mathematics will correlate with activity in the same part of the emotional brain as that of beauty derived from other sources.

Plato (1929) thought that “nothing without understanding would ever be more beauteous than with understanding,” making mathematical beauty, for him, the highest form of beauty. The premium thus placed on the faculty of understanding when

experiencing beauty creates both a problem and an opportunity for studying the neurobiology of beauty. Unlike our previous studies of the neurobiology of musical or visual beauty, in which participating subjects were neither experts nor trained in these domains, in the present study we had, of necessity, to recruit subjects with a fairly advanced knowledge of mathematics and a comprehension of the formulae that they viewed and rated. It is relatively easy to separ ate out the faculty of understanding from the experience of beauty in mathematics, but much more difﬁcult to do so for the experience of visual or musical beauty; hence a study of the neurobiology of mathematical beauty carried with it the promise of addressing a broader issue with implications for future studies of the neurobiology of beauty, namely the extent to which the experience of beauty is bound to that of “understanding.”

MATERIALS AND METHODS Sixteen mathematicians (3 females, age range = 22–32 years, 1 left-handed) at postgraduate or postdoctoral level, all recruited from colleges in London, took part in the study. All gave written informed consent and the study was approved by the Ethics Committee of University College London. All had normal or corrected to normal vision. One subject was eliminated from the study after it transpired that he suffered from attention deﬁcit hyperactivity disorder and had been on medication, although his exclusion did not affect the overall results. We also recruited 12 non-mathematicians who completed the questionnaires described below but were not scanned, for reasons explained below.

EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE To allow a direct comparison between this study and previous ones in which we explored brain activity that correlates with

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 1

HUMAN NEUROSCIENCE

#### Page 2

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

the experience of visual and musical beaut y (Kawabata and Zeki, 2004; Ishizu and Zeki, 2011), we used similar experimental procedures to these previous studies. About 2–3 weeks before the scanning experiment, each subject was given 60 mathematical formulae (Data Sheet 1: EquationsForm.pdf) to study at leisure [Annotation 3] and rate on a scale of −5 (ugly) to +5 (beautiful) according to how beautiful they experienced them to be. Two weeks later, they participated in a brain scanning experiment, using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), during which they were asked to re-rate the same equations while viewing them in a Siemens scanner, on an abridged scale of ugly—neutral— beautiful. The pre-scan ratings were used to balance the sequence of stimuli for each subject to achieve an even distribution of preferred and non-preferred equations throughout the experiment. A few days after scanning, each subject received a questionnaire (Data Sheet 2: UnderstandingForm.pdf) asking them to (a) report their level of understanding of each equation on a numerical scale, from 0 (no understanding) to 3 (profound understanding) and (b) to report their subjective feelings (including emotional reaction) when viewing the equations. The data from these questionnaires (pre-scan beauty ratings, scan-time beauty ratings, and post-scan understanding ratings) is given in Data Sheet 3: BehavioralData.xls.

STIMULI Stimuli consisting of equations were generated using Cogent 2000 (http://www.vislab.ucl.ac.uk/Cogent2000) and displayed by an Epson EH-TW5910 LCD projector at a resolution of 1600 × 1200 with a refresh rate of 60 Hz. The display was back-projected onto a translucent screen (290 × 180 mm, 27.2 ◦ × 18.1 ◦ visual angle), which was viewed by subjects using an angled mirror.

SCANNING Subjects viewed the formulae during four functional scanning sessions, with breaks between sessions which gave them an opportunity to take a rest if required and us to correct any anomalies, for example to correct rare omissions in rating a stimulus. Scans were acquired using a 3-T Siemens Magnetom Trio MRI scanner ﬁtted with a 32-channel head volume coil (Siemens, Erlangen, Germany). A B0 ﬁeldmap was acquired using a doubleecho FLASH (GRE) sequence (duration 2  14  ). An echo-planar imaging (EPI) sequence was applied for functional scans, measuring BOLD (Blood Oxygen Level Dependent) signals (echo time TE = 30 ms, TR = 68 ms, volume time = 3.264 s). Each brain image was acquired in an ascending sequence comprising 48 axial slices, each 2 mm thick, with an interstitial gap of 1 mm and a voxel resolution of 3 × 3 × 3 mm, covering nearly the whole brain. After functional scanning had been completed a T1 MDEFT (modiﬁed driven equilibrium fourier transform) anatomical scan was a cquired in the saggital plane to obtain high resolution structural images (176 slices per volume, constant isotropic resolution 1 mm, TE = 2.48 ms, TR = 7.92 ms).

Fifteen equations were displayed during each session (Figure 1A), so that each of the 60 equations appeared once over the four sessions. Each session started with a blank gray screen for 19.5 s, followed by 15 trials, each of 16 s, interspersed with four blanks, each of 16–17 s, to acquire baseline signal. A plain

gray blank screen was used, of an equivalent overall brightness to the equation screens. Pre-scan beauty ratings were used to divide the 60 equations into three groups; 20 “low” rated, 20 “medium” rated, and 20 “high” rated equations. The sequence of equations viewed by each subject in the scanner was then organized so that 5 low-, 5 medium- and 5 highly-rated equations appeared in each session and the pseudo-randomized sequence was organized so that a low-rated equation was never followed by another low-rated equation and the same held for medium and highly rated equations. The session ended with a blank screen of duration 30 s.

Each trial (Figure 1B) began w ith an equation which was displayed for 16 s followed by a blank lasting 1 s. The response screen appeared for 3 s, during which the subject selected interactively a scan-time beauty rating (Beautiful, Neutral, or Ugly) for each equation by pressing keypad buttons. A second blank lasting 1–2 s ended each trial. Equations were all drawn in the same sized font in white (CIE 1931 XYZ: 755, 761, 637) and the same gr ay background was used throughout (CIE 1931 XYZ: 236, 228, 200). The overall screen brightness varied between 280 and 324 cd m −2 ;the width of equations varied from 4 ◦ to 24 ◦ visual angle and the height varied between 1 ◦ and 5 ◦ .

ANALYSIS SPM8 (Statistical Parametric Mapping, Friston et al., 2006)was used to analyze the results, as in our previous studies (Zeki and Romaya, 2010; Ishizu and Zeki, 2011). At the single-subject level the understanding rating (0–3) and the scan-time beauty rating (coded as −1 for “Ugly,” 0 for “Neutral,” and 1 for “Beautiful”) for each equation were included as ﬁrst and second parametric modulators, respectively, of a boxcar function which modeled the appearance of each equation [in fact, the beauty and understanding ratings correlated but imperfectly (see behavioral data below)]. There were fewer “Ugly” rated equations than “Neutral” or “Beautiful” (see behavioral data below). Indeed, in 2 of the 60 functional sessions there was no “Ugly” rating. This imbalance does not bias the estimation of, or inference about, the effects of beauty—it only reduces the efﬁciency with which the effects can be estimated (Friston et al., 2000). Happily, this reduction was not severe, because we were able to identify signiﬁcant effects. As a result of SPM orthogonalization, the beauty rating parametric modulator can only capture variance that cannot be explained by the understanding rating, thus allowing us to distinguish activations that correlate with beauty alone. Contrast images for each of the 15 subjects for the parametric beauty rating and for All equations vs. Baseline were taken to a 2nd-level (random effects) analysis. We used a conjunction-null analysis (Nichols et al., 2005), to determine whether there was an overlap, within mOFC, in regions of parametric activation with beauty and the general de-activation produced by viewing mathematical formulae. In order to examine the activity of Ugly, Neutral, and Beautiful stimuli relative to baseline at locations identiﬁed in the parametric beauty analysis we also carried out a categorical analysis of the beauty rating alone, by coding contrasts for Ugly, Neutral, and Beautiful stimuli vs. Baseline for each subject at the ﬁrst level and taking these to a 2nd level, random effects, analysis as before.

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 2

#### Page 3

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

FIGURE 1 | Experimental paradigm and stimulus presentation. There were four functional scanning sessions, with a break between sessions. (A) 15 equations were displayed during each session, with each of the 60 equations appearing only once over the four sessions. The pre-scan beauty ratings were used to sequence the equations for each subject so that 5 low-rated (L), 5 medium-rated (M), and 5 highly-rated equations (H) appeared in each session and their sequence within a session organized so that a low-rated equation was never followed by another low-rated equation (similarly for medium and highly-rated equations). During each session four blank periods, each varying in duration from 16 to 17 s, were inserted to collect baseline signal. Each session commenced with a 19.5 s

blank period to allow T1 equilibration effects to subside and ended with a 30 s blank period, giving a tot al duration of about 7 min 20 s per functional session. (B) Each equation trial began with an equation displayed for 16 s, followed by a response period during which subjects indicated their scan-time beauty rating by pressing one of three keypad buttons. This started with a 1 s blank period (B1) followed by 3 s during which subjects pressed keypad buttons and their selection (either “Ugly,” “Neutral,” or “Beautiful”) was interactively displayed to them. The response was followed by an inter-trial interval which was randomly varied between 1 and 2 s during which a blank screen appeared (B2). Blank periods displayed a uniform mid-gray background.

In a similar way, we undertook another parametric analysis with the scan-time beauty rating as the ﬁrst parametric modulator and the understanding rating as the second one. This time the understanding modulator can only capture variance that cannot be explained by the beauty rating, thus allowing us to distinguish activations that are accounted for by understanding alone. Contrast images for the 15 subjects were taken to the second level, as before. To supplement this we also undertook a categorical analysis of the four understanding categories (0–3) in order to obtain parameter estimates for the four understanding categories at locations identiﬁed as signiﬁcant in the parametric understanding analysis (see Figure 5B).

A categorical analysis differs from the corresponding parametric analysis in two respects: ﬁrst, the parametric analysis looks for a relationship between BOLD signal and differences in the rated quantity (beauty or understanding) on an individual session basis, while a categorical analysis will average the BOLD

signal for each category of the rated quantity over all sessions and subjects; second, when using two parametric modulators we can isolate beauty effects from understanding and vice versa by using orthogonalization, but this is not available in a categorical analysis. When we use orthogonalization of two parametric regressors to partition the variance in the BOLD signal into a “beauty only” and an “understanding only” component, there remains a common portion which cannot be directly attributed to either component.

For the main contrasts of interest, parametric, and categorical beauty, we report activation at cluster-level signiﬁcance (P Clust -FWE < 0.05) with familywise error correction over the whole br ain volume as reported by SPM8 based on random ﬁeld theory (Friston et al., 1994). A statistical threshold of P unc. < 0.001 and an extent threshold of 10 voxels was used to deﬁne clusters. There were also some activations which did not reach signiﬁcance (clearly noted) which we nevertheless report since they

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 3

#### Page 4

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

suggest areas which may be contributing to the main activation. Whether they actually do will be left to future studies.

For other contrasts vs. baseline which are not of principal interest to this study we report activations that survive a peak voxel threshold of P FWE < 0.05, with familywise error correction over the whole brain volume.

Co-ordinates in millimeters are given in Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI) space (Evans et al., 1993).

RESULTS BEHAVIORAL DATA Beauty ratings The formula most consistently rated as beautiful (average rating of 0.8667), both before and during the scans, was Leonhard Euler’s identity

1 + e [Annotation 4] iπ = 0

which links 5 fundamental mathematical constants with three basic arithmetic operations, each occurring once; the one most consistently rated as ugly (average rating of −0.7333) was Srinivasa Ramanujan’s inﬁnite s eries for 1/π,

1 π = 2

√

2 9801

∞ 

k =0

( 4k ) ! ( 1103 + 26390k ) ( k! ) 4 396 4k

which expresses the reciprocal of π as an inﬁnite sum.

Other highly rated equations included the Pythagorean identity, the identity between exponential and trigonometric functions derivable from Euler’s formula for complex analysis, and the Cauchy-Riemann equations (Data Sheet 1: EquationsForm.pdf— Equations2,5,and54).Formulaecommonlyratedasneutral included Euler’s formula for polyhedral triangulation, the Gauss Bonnet theorem and a formulation of the Spectral theorem (Data Sheet 1: EquationsForm.pdf—Equations 3, 4, and 52). Low rated equations included Riemann’s functional equation, the smallest number expressible as the sum of two cubes in two different ways,andanexampleofanexactsequencewheretheimage of one morphism equals the kernel of the next (Data Sheet 1: EquationsForm.pdf—Equations 15, 45, and 59).

Pre-, post-, and scan-time ratings In pre-scan beauty ratings, each subject rated each of the 60 equations according to beauty on a scale of −5(Ugly)through0 (Neutral) to +5 (Beautiful) while during scan time ratings, subjects rated each equation into the three categories of Ugly, Neutral or Beautiful.

Post-scan understanding ratings. After scanning, subjects rated each equation according to their comprehension of the equation, from 0 (no comprehension whatsoever) to 3 (Profound understanding).

An excel ﬁle containing raw behavioral data is provided as Data Sheet 3: B ehavioralData.xlsx., which gives the following eight tables:

Table 1: Pre-scan beauty ratings for each equation by subject

Table 2: Scan-time equation numbers by subject, session and trial Table 3: Scan-time beauty ratings for each equation by subject Table 4: Scan-time beauty rating s by subject, session, and trial Table 5: Scan-time beauty ratings by subject—Session and experiment totals Table 6: Post-scan understanding ratings by subject Table 7: Post-scan understanding ratings by subject, session, and trial Table 8: Post-scan understanding ratings by subject—Session and experiment totals.

The pre-scan beauty ratings were used to assemble the equations into three groups, one containing 20 low-rated, another 20 medium-rated, and a third 20 high-rated equations, individually for each subject. These three allocations were used to organize the sequence of equations viewed during each of the four scanning sessions so that each session contained 5 lowrated, 5 medium-rated, and 5 high-rated equations. Each subject then re-rated the equations during the scan as Ugly, Neutral, or Beautiful. In an ideal case, each subject would identify 5 Ugly, 5 Neutral, and 5 Beautiful equations in each session. In fact, this did not happen. Figure 2A shows the frequency distribution of pre-scan beauty ratings for all 15 subjects; it is positively skewed, indicating that more equations were rated as beautiful than ugly. This is reﬂected in the frequency distr ibution of the scan-time beauty ratings (Figure 2B)which,again, shows a bias for beautiful equations. Figure 2C shows the relationship between pre-scan and scan-time beauty ratings. There was a highly signiﬁcant positive correlation (Pearson’s r = 0.612 for 898 values, p < 0.001) but there were departures; for example, one equation received a pre-scan rating of −4butwas classed as Beautiful at scan-time and three equations with a pre-scan rating of 5 were subsequently classed as Ugly. These infrequent departures are not of great concern providing there was still a reasonable ratio of Ugly: Neutral: Beautiful scan-time designations for each session, which was the case. Ideally this ratio would always be 5:5:5 but, due to the predominance of Beautiful over Ugly scan-time ratings, we twice recorded 0:7:8 and 1:5:9 for particular sessions (see Table 5 in Data Sheet 3: BehavioralData.xlsx). Other sessions in general showed more equable ratios and, even with an extreme ratio such as 0:7:8, a relationship between Neutral and B eautiful equations could still be established.

The frequency distribution of post-scan understanding ratings is given in Figure 2D, which shows that more of the equations were well understood, as would be expected from a group of expert mathematicians. Figure 2E shows that there was a highly signiﬁcant positive correlation (Pearson’s r = 0.413 for 898 val- [Annotation 5] ues, p < 0.001) between understanding and scan-time beauty ratings. In this case, departures from a fully correlated relationship allow us to separate out effects of beauty from those of understanding, so that, for example, i n the well understood categor y (3) the ratio of Ugly: Neutral: Beautiful is 31:97:205. In order to analyze scanning data with regard to understanding ratings we would ideally have equal ratios of the four understanding ratios (0, 1, 2, and 3) in each scanning session. These ratios are recorded

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 4

#### Page 5

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

FIGURE 2 | Summary of Behavioral data. Behavioral data scores summated over all 15 subjects. (A) Frequency distribution of pre-scan beauty ratings. (B) Frequency distribution of scan-time beauty ratings. (C) Pre-scan beauty ratings plotted against scan-time beauty ratings.

(D) Frequency distribution of post-scan understanding ratings. (E) Post-scan understanding ratings plotted against scan-time beauty ratings. Numbers in brackets give the count for each group. Area of each circle is proportional to the count for that group.

in Table 8 in Data Sheet 3: BehavioralData.xlsx. We occasionally ﬁnd missing categories in some sessions (such as 0:2:4:9) but we could still establish a relationship w hen one category is missing in a particular session.

Post-scan questionnaires regarding subjective (emotional) experiences Mathematical subjects were as well given four questions to answer, post-scan. One subject did not respond to this part of the questionnaire, leaving us with 14 subjects. To the question: “When you consider a particularly beautiful equation, do you experience an emotional response?,”9gaveanunqualiﬁed“Yes,”1reported a “shiver of appreciation,” 1 reported being “ a bit excited,” 1 reported “The same kind of response as when hearing a beautiful piece of music, or seeing a particularly appealing painting,” 1 reported that “the feeling is visceral” and 1 was “unsure” To the question: “Do you derive pleasure, happiness or satisfact ion from a beautiful equation?” 14 subjects answered afﬁrmatively; all 14 [Annotation 6] also gave a positive response to the question: “Is there any mathematical equation which, in the past, you have found particularly

beautiful and, if so, was it among the list of equations which we gave you?” but some regretted that variations of the equations were not on the list [e.g., the Einstein ﬁeld equations, related to equation 60 (contracted Bianchi identity), and Cauchy’s integral formula for the special case where n = 1 (Equation 29)]; three regretted that the following equations were not on the list: the analytical solution of the Abel integral equation, Noether’s theorem, the Euler- Lagrange and the Liouville, Navier-Stokes and Hamilton equations, Newton’s Second Law (F = ma), and the relativistic Dirac equation. Finally, variable answers were given to the question:“Do you experience a heightened state of consciousness when you contemplate a beautiful equation?” In summary, our subjects had an emotional experience when viewing equations which they had rated as beautiful (the “aesthetic emotion”), and which they also qualiﬁed as satisfying or pleasurable. They also showed a very sophisticated knowledge of mathematics, by specifying equations that they considered particularly beautiful (which the y had known), as well as by the regret expressed at not ﬁnding, in our list, equations that they consider especially beautiful.

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 5

#### Page 6

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

Non-mathematical subjects We also tried to gauge the reaction of 12 non-mathematical subjects to viewing the same equations. This was, generally, an unsatisfactory exercise because many had had some, usually elementary, mathematical experience [up to GCSE (General Certiﬁcate of Secondary Education) level, commonly taken at ages 14–16]. Reﬂecting this, the majority indicated that they had no understanding of what the equations signiﬁed, rating them 0, although some gave positive beauty ratings to a minority of the equations. Overall, of the 720 equations distributed over 12 non-mathematical subjects, 645 (89.6%) were given a 0 rating (no understanding), 49 (6.8%) were given a rating of 1 (vague understanding) and the remainder were rated as 2 (good understanding) or 3 (profound comprehension). To the question “When you consider a particularly beautiful equation, do you experience an emotional response?,” the majority (9 out of 12) gave a negative response. Given this, we hypothesized that, when such non-mathematical subjects gave a positive beauty rating to the equations, they were doing so on a formal basis, that is to say on how attractive the form of the equations was to them. This hypothesis receives support from the contrast to reveal the parametric relationship between brain activity and understanding in mathematicians (see Results).

BRAIN ACTIVATIONS Parametrically related activity in mOFC with beauty ratings, independently of understanding Results should that activity that was parametrically related to the declared intensity of the experience of mathematical beauty was conﬁned to ﬁeld A1 of mOFC (Ishizu and Zeki, 2011), where

there was a signiﬁcant difference in the BOLD signal when viewing equations rated as beautiful on the one hand and as neutral and ugly on the other (Figure 3). Even though our subjects were experts, with an understanding of the truths that the equations depict, we had nevertheless asked them to rate, post-scan, how well they had understood the formulae, on a scale of 0 (no comprehension) to 3 (profound understanding) (Data Sheet 2: UnderstandingForm.pdf), as a way of dissociating understanding from the experience of beauty. There was a good but imperfect correlation between their understanding and the beauty ratings given, in that some formulae that had been understood were not rated as beautiful (Pearson’s correlation coefﬁcient ranging from −0.0362 to 0.6826). As described above, separate parametric modulators were used for understanding and beauty ratings in the SPM analysis. This allowed us to model both understanding and beauty effects and examine responses to one that could not be explained by the other, thus separating out the two faculties in neural terms. Hence, cr ucially, the parametri cally related activity in mOFC (Figure 3) was speciﬁcally driven by beauty ratings, after accounting for the effects of understanding.

The mOFC was the only brain region that showed a BOLD signal that was parametrically related to beauty ratings, signiﬁcant at cluster level (see Tabl e 1A and Figure 3). Previous studies have nevertheless shown a number of areas that are active when subjects undertake mathematical tasks (see Arsalidou and Taylor, 2011 for a meta-analysis) and we observed some activity (which did not reach signiﬁcance) in three regions which previous studies of mathematical cognition had reported to be active (see Ta ble 1 B). One of these is located in the left angulargyrus,oneinthemiddletemporalgyrusandoneinthe

FIGURE 3 | Parametric “Activations” with Beauty. (A) Second level parametric analysis derived from 15 subjects, to show parametric modulation by scan-time beauty rating (after orthogonalization to understanding rating). One-sample t-test (df = 14) thresholded at P unc < 0.001 with an extent threshold of 10 voxels, revealed a cluster of 95 voxels in medial orbito-frontal cortex (mOFC) with hot-spots at (−6, 56, −2) and (0, 35, −14), signiﬁcant at cluster level, with familywise error correction over the whole brain volume. The location and extent of the cluster is indicated by sections along the three principal axes through the

two hot-spots, pinpointed with blue crosshairs and superimposed on an anatomical image which was averaged over all 15 subjects. (Note: “activation” in this case relates to a positive parametric relationship; i.e., an increase in activity with an increase in scan-time beauty rating. Overall, as can be seen in (B), these locations were deactivated relative to baseline, i.e., there was a relative activation in a deactivated region. (B) A separate categorical analysis, based on scan-time beauty ratings alone, was used to generate contrast estimates for the three categories Ugly, Neutral, and Beautiful vs. Baseline at each of the locations in (A).

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 6

#### Page 7

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

Table 1 | Activation for the contrast parametric beauty.

Location xyzk E P Clust-FEW T 14 P FWE

(A) ACTIVATIONS—PARAMETRIC BEAUTY —SIGNIFICANT AT CLUSTER LEVEL mOFC −656−2 95 0.047 5.14 0.619

mOFC 0 35 −14 4.90 0.733 (B) ACTIVATIONS—PARAMETRIC BEAUTY —NOT REACHING CLUSTER LEVEL SIGNIFICANCE R caudate 12 8 19 17 0.703 5.72 0.369 L angular gyrus −36 −55 22 28 0.489 4.96 0.705 L middle temporal gyrus

−63 −4 −17 16 0.725 4.48 0.895

SPM 2nd level analysis (15 subjects). One sample t-test (df = 14). (A) Cluster level signiﬁcant activation with familywise error correction over the whole brain volume (P Clust-FWE < 0.05, background threshold P unc. < 0.001, extent threshold 10 voxels). Co-ordinates of the two hotspots in the cluster are given in MNI space. (B) In addition to the signiﬁcant cluster activation shown in Figure 3 and tabulated above in (A) there were some clusters which failed to reach signiﬁcance but which are listed here as possible contributors to the main cluster of activation. For completeness we also give the peak signiﬁcance at each location, P FWE , with familywise error correction over the whole brain volume. The peak activation in each cluster is shown in bold with up to two other peaks in the same cluster listed below.

caudate nucleus. Although they did not attain signiﬁcance, we nevertheless document them here and leave it to future studies to ascertain their possible role in the experience of mathematical beauty.

Beauty—categorical analyses A categorical analysis of Beauty ratings vs. Baseline is less sophisticated than a parametric analysis in two respects, for reasons given in the methods section. Nevertheless, we thought it useful to employ such an analysis to examine the parameter estimates for Ugly, Neutral and Beautiful vs. Baseline at the locations in mOFC identiﬁed as signiﬁcant in the parametric study. Figure 3B shows the parameter estimates for the three beauty categories vs. baseline at the two locations in mOFC identiﬁed in the parametric analysis: at (−6, 56, −2) and (0, 35, −14). It is evident that, at both, overall activit y within this area of deactivation was greater for Beautiful than for Neutral or Ugly stimuli. In neither case is a linear relationship particularly evident, probably due to the inferior sensitivity of the categorical analysis, for the reasons given above.

Tab le 2 tabulates the categorical contrast Beauty > Neutral. There are cluster-level signiﬁcant activations in mOFC, the left angular gyrus and the left superior temporal sulcus. The relative activation within mOFC occurs within a region of de-activation relative to baseline (see section Cortical de-activations when viewing mathematical formulae). As with the previous study of Kawabata and Zeki (2004), parameter estimates show that it is a change in relative activity within a de-activated mOFC that correlates with the experience of mathematical beauty. Data Sheet 4: BeauNeutUglyBase.pdf tabulates activations and deactivations of the Beautiful, Neutral, and Ugly categories relative to baseline.

Table 2 | Activations for the categorical contrast beautiful > neutral.

Location xyz k E P Clust-FWE T 14 P FWE

ACTIVATIONS—BEAUTIFUL > NEUTRAL L angular gyrus −48 −67 22 143 0.015 6.32 0.180 mOFC −12 53 4 285 <0.001 5.52 0.416

mOFC −950−5 5.16 0.576 mOFC −938−5 4.70 0.790 L superior temporal gyrus −12 29 61 122 0.026 4.98 0.633

L superior temporal gyrus −3 17 67 4.65 0.809 L superior temporal gyrus −18 38 46 4.52 0.858

SPM 2nd level analysis (15 subjects). One sample t-test (df = 14). Cluster level signiﬁcant activations corrected for familywise error over the whole brain volume (P Clust-FWE < 0.05, background threshold P unc. < 0.001, extent threshold 10 voxels). Co-ordinates of hotspots within each cluster are given in MNI space. For completeness we also give the peak signiﬁcance at each location, P FWE ,with familywise error correction over the whole brain volume. The peak activation in each cluster is shown in bold with up to two other peaks in the same cluster listed below.

Activity unrelated to beauty ratings While the experience of mathematical beauty correlated parametrically with activity in mOFC, the contrast All equations > Baseline showed that many sites were generally active when subjects viewed the equations (Tabl e 3). These included sites implicated in a variety of relatively simple arithmetic calculations and problem solving (Dehaene et al., 1999; Fias et al., 2003; Anderson et al., 2011; Arsalidou and Taylor, 2011; Wintermute et al., 2012 for a meta-analysis), and symbol processing (Price and Ansar i, 2011) as well as activity in three sites in the cerebellum, generally ignored in past studies of the mathematical brain: one of these cerebellar sites, located in Crus I, may be involved in working memory (Stoodley, 2012), another one, also located in Crus I, in grouping according to numbers (Zeki and Stutters, 2013) and the processing of abstract information (Balsters and Ramnani, 2008) while the third one, located in the para-ﬂocculus, is involved in smooth pursuit eye movements (Ilg and Their, 2008). That these areas should have been active when subjects view more complex formulae suggests that they are also recruited in tasks that go beyond relatively simple arithmetic calculations and involve more complex mathematical formulations.

Cortical de-activations when viewing mathematical formulae As well, the contrast All equations < Baseline revealed widespread cortical de-activations (Ta bl e 3 ), many in areas not speciﬁcally related to mathematical tasks or aesthetic ratings; their distribution corresponds closely to areas active in the resting state and de-activated during complex cognitive tasks (Shulman et al., 1997; Binder et al., 1999), including arithmetic ones (Feng et al., 2007). The most interesting of these is in mOFC. A Conjunction- Null analysis (Nichols et al., 2005) of the contrasts “Paramet ric beauty rating” and “De-activations with Equations,” both thresholded at P unc < 0.001, showed that this de-activation overlaps the mOFC activation which correlates parametrically with the experience of mathematical beauty (Figure 4); unlike other areas of

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 7

#### Page 8

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

Table 3 | Activations and de-activations for the contrast all equations vs. baseline.

Location xyzk E T 14 P FWE

ACTIVATIONS—ALL EQUATIONS > BASELINE L fusiform gyrus −33 −82 −8 188 15.20 <0.001

L fusiform gyrus −30 −91 −514.96 <0.001 R fusiform gyrus 42 −79 −11 377 14.98 <0.001

R cerebellum Crus I 48 −70 −29 13.02 <0.001 R fusiform gyrus 39 −58 −11 10.58 0.001 L inferior temporal gyrus −48 50 4 77 13.40 <0.001 L inferior temporal gyrus −48 −61 −11 79 11.80 <0.001 L intraparietal sulcus −30 −67 46 88 10.29 0.002

L lingual/fusiform gyrus −30 −49 49 9.53 0.005 R cerebellum lobule VIII/crus I 6 −79 −29 45 10.10 0.002 R cerebellum dorsal paraﬂocculus 30 −70 −50 13 10.04 0.003 L inferior frontal gyrus −48 14 25 24 9.35 0.006 R intraparietal sulcus 30 −58 43 19 8.80 0.013 DE-ACTIVATIONS—ALL EQUATIONS < BASELINE L precuneus −12 −46 43 1188 18.22 <0.001

R precuneus 15 −40 43 16.63 <0.001 L precuneus −15 −40 52 14.73 <0.001 R fusifom gyrus 60 −52 16 179 15.39 <0.001 Fusiform gyrus 63 −34 16 10.87 <0.001 Fusiform gyrus 63 −22 16 8.25 0.027 R medial orbito-frontal cortex 332−5 459 14.91 <0.001

L medial orbito-frontal cortex −623−814.25 <0.001 R medial orbito-frontal cortex 12 53 −213.37 <0.0 01 R superior temporal gyrus 57 −16 −5 256 14.53 <0.001

R superior temporal gyrus 63 2 −23 14.39 <0.001 R superior temporal gyrus 45 −13 −811.05 <0.001 L lingual gyrus −12 −70 −22111.81<0.001 L middle temporal gyrus −60 −4 −17 44 11.75 <0.001 L superior medial gyrus (anterior paracingulate)

0 53 22 33 10.76 0.001

L middle frontal gyrus −24 26 40 16 10.46 0.002 R superior frontal gyrus (anterior paracingulate)

18 50 19 12 10.38 0.002

L lingual gyrus −24 −46 −2 11 9.41 0.006 R cuneus 12 −88 16 11 8.98 0.010

SPM 2nd level analysis (15 subjects). One sample t-test (df = 14). All loci, in Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI) space, are signiﬁcant, thresholded at P FWE < 0.05 with familywise error correction over the whole brain volume and with an extent threshold of 10 voxels. The peak activation in each cluster is shown in bold with the cluster size in voxels (k E ) with up to two other peaks in the same cluster listed below.

de-activation, the mOFC de-activation has been posited to be related to task-unrelated conceptual processing (Shulman et al., 1997). The overlap between the activation and de-activation suggests that there may be separate compartments or sub-systems within ﬁeld A1 of mOFC whose activities correlate with general cognitive tasks on the one hand and the more speciﬁc experience of beauty on the other.

Parametric “de-activations” with understanding ratings independent of beauty As described in the methods, we undertook a second parametric analysis, with Beauty rating and Understanding rating as ﬁrst and second parametric modulators, respectively, to isolate activations due to understanding alone. The result, shown in Figure 5,is that a large extent of the occipital visual cortex, comprising many of its subdivisions, was less active for well-understood equations (or, put another way, more active for less understood equations). The signiﬁcance of this is discussed below (under Beauty and Understanding).

DISCUSSION Art and mathematics are, to most, at polar opposites; the former has a more “sensible” source and is accessible to many while the latter has a high cognitive, intellectual, source and is accessible to few. Yet both can provoke the aesthetic emotion and arouse an experience of beauty, although neither all great ar t nor all great mathematical formulations do so. The experience of mathematical beauty, considered by Plato (1961a,b) to constitute the highest [Annotation 7] form of beauty, since it is derived from the intellect alone and is concerned with eternal and immutable truths, is also one of the most abstract emotional experiences. In spite of its abstract nature, there was, for Clive B ell (1914), a strong relation between mathematical and artistic beauty because the mathematician feels an emotion for his speculations which “springs... from the heart of an abstract science. I wonder, sometimes, whether the appreciators of art and of mathematical solutions are not even more closely allied,” while for Bertrand Russell (1919) “The true spirit of delight, the exaltation, the sense of being more than Man, which is the touchstone of the highest excellence, is to be found in mathematics as surely as poetry.” Given this, we hypothesized that it would be likely that the experience of beauty derived from mathematics would correlate with activity in the same par t of the emotional brain as that derived from other, more sensible and perceptually based, sources. Although we approached the experiment with difﬁdence, given the profoundly different sources for these different experiences, we were not surprised to ﬁnd, because of similarities in the experience of beauty provoked by the different sources alluded to above, that the experience of mathematical beauty correlates with activity in the same brain area(s), principally ﬁeld A1 of mOFC, that are active during the experience of visual, musical, and moral beauty. That the activity there is parametrically related to the declared intensity of the experience of beauty, whatever its source, answers afﬁrmatively a critical question in the philosophy of aesthetics, namely whether aesthetic experiences can be quantiﬁed (Gordon, 2005).

Mathematical and artistic beauty have been written of in the same breath by mathematicians and humanists alike, as arousing the “aesthetic emotion.” This implies that there is a common and abstract nature to the experience of beauty derived from very different sources. Viewed in that light, the activity in a common area of the emotional brain that correlates with the experience of beauty derived from different sources merely mirrors neurobiologically the s ame powerful and emotional experience of beauty that mathematicians and artists alike have spoken of.

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 8

#### Page 9

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

FIGURE 4 | Conjunction of activations with beauty rating and de-activations with equations. Conjunction-Null of two contrasts, “Parametric beauty rating” and “De-activations with Equations,” both

thresholded at P unc < 0.001. De-activations are shown in red, overlapping the area revealed by the parametric rating, shown in yellow. Numerals refer to MNI co-ordinates.

FIGURE 5 | Parametric “De-activations” with Understanding. (A) Second level parametric analysis derived from 15 subjects, to show parametric modulation by understanding rating (after orthogonalization to scan-time beauty rating). One-sample t-test (df = 14) thresholded at P unc < 0.001 with an extent threshold of 10 voxels, revealed two peak “de-activations” signiﬁcant (P FWE < 0.05) with familywise error correction over the whole brain volume, at (39, −52, −8) (T 14 = 9.01, P FWE = 0.010) and at (30, −91, 19) (T 14 = 8.05, P FWE = 0.032). A third peak at (−27, −85, 7) (T 14 = 7.65, P FWE = 0.050) was just above threshold. The location of each peak is

indicated by sections along the three principal axes, pinpointed with blue crosshairs and superimposed on an anatomical image which was averaged over all 15 subjects. (Note: A “de-activation” in this case relates to a negative parametric relationship; i.e., activity decreased as understanding rating increased. Overall, as can be seen in (B), these locations were signiﬁcantly active above baseline). (B) A separate categorical analysis based on understanding ratings alone was used to generate contrast estimates for the four understanding categories U0, U1, U2, and U3 vs. baseline at each of the peak locations in (A).

mOFC AND THE EXPERIENCE OF BEAUTY, PREFERENCE, PLEASURE AND REWARD The mOFC is active in a variety of conditions, of which experiences relating to pleasure, reward and hedonic states are the most interesting in our context. The relationship of the experience of beauty to that of pleasure and reward has been commonly discussed in the philosophy of aesthetics, without a clear conclusion (Gordon, 2005). This is perhaps not surprising , because the three merge into one another, without clear boundaries between them;

neurologically, activity in mOFC correlates with all three experiences thus reﬂecting, perhaps, the difﬁculty of separating these experiences subjectively. The imperfect distinction between the three is also reﬂected in the positive post-scan answers given by the mathematical subjects to the question whether they experienced pleasure, satisfaction or happiness when viewing equations that they had rated as beautiful. Whether one can ever experience beauty without at the same time experiencing a sense of pleasure and/or reward is doubtful. The converse is not true, in

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 9

#### Page 10

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

that something can be experienced as being pleasurable, rewarding, or preferred without it being also experienced as beautiful or arousing the “aesthetic emotion.” Neurobiologically, the issue resolves itself around the question of whether a ctivity in the same or different parts of the mOFC correlates with these different experiences. The mOFC is a relatively large expanse of cortex with several cytocrachitectonic subdivisions, including BA 10, 11, 12, and 32 (see Kringelbach, 2005 for a review) as well as BA 24 (which may more properly be considered as part of the rostral anterior cingulate cortex) and BA 25. Brodmann maps are useful general anatomical guides but do not delimit functional areas and major functional subidvisions can be found within single cytoarchitectonic ﬁelds such as, for example, BA 18 (see Zeki, 1979). It is possible that, as with lateral orbitofrontal cortex, future studies may subdivide mOFC into further subdivisions based on resting-state connectivity or other criteria (Kahnt et al., 2012). Hence any reference to Brodmann maps is no more than a rough guide and must be tentative. Our delineation (Ishizu and Zeki, 2011) of a ﬁeld within mOFC, ﬁeld A1, has the virtue of delimiting a speciﬁc cortical zone with relatively precise co-ordinates and dimensions, whose activity correlates with the “aesthetic emotion” and to which other functional parcellations, both past and future, can be referred with relative precision. Field A1 of mOFC has MNI co-ordinates of (−3, 41, −8) and a diameter of between 15 and 17 mm (see Ishizu and Zeki, 2011). This falls in the middle of the active region of mOFC in the present study, and hence must be located within what we deﬁned as ﬁeld A1.Infact,ifoneweretotaketheaverageofthetwohotspots in the mOFC cluster of the parametric beauty contrast of this study (namely −3, 45, −8), it will be found to be located 4 mm fromthecenteroftheﬁeldA1at(−3, 41, −8). A survey of the published evidence shows that functional parcellations cannot be restricted to single cytoarchitectonic subdivisions comprising the medial orbital wall of the frontal cortex. Not all rewarding and pleasurable experiences activate ﬁeld A1 of mOFC, which occupies mainly BA 32 but probably extends to BA 12 inferiorly and BA 25 anteriorly. While preference for drinks (McClure et al., 2004), abstract and predictive rewards and kinetic patterns do (O’Doherty et al., 2001; Gottfried et al., 2003; Zeki and Stutters, 2011), the hedonic experience of food appears to correlate with a morelateralpartofmOFCthanﬁeldA1ofmOFC(Kringelbach et al., 2003) while the experience of erotic pleasure appears to correlate with a region dorsal to it (Sescousse et al., 2010) (see also Berridge and Kringelbach, 2013) for a review. These are approximations that do not allow more deﬁnitive conclusions at present, even with meta-analyses such as the ones provided by Peters and Büchel (2010) or Kühn and Gallinat (2012). The latter help locate the general brain regions active with speciﬁc experiences but are not presently capable of pinpointing whether the identical regions are active, which would require far more detailed conjunction analyses in studies employing several different categories of hedonic experience. This is even true of the experience of visual and musical beauty. Though a conjunction analysis reveals that there is a common part of A1 of mOFC that correlates with both experiences (Ishizu and Zeki, 2011), the overlap is not perfect and it is possible that different subdivisions, or perhaps different groupings of cells within the same general subdivision, are recruited

during different experiences (see Figure 1 of Ishizu and Zeki, 2011). The same is true of the present results in relation to previous activations of mOFC that correlate with the experience of visual and musical beauty. Very close correspondence in the active regions for all three experiences does not preclude that there may yet be different distributions or subdivisions within ﬁeld A1 of mOFC. It is also useful to emphasize here, as we have done in the past, that the localization of activity in mOFC that correlates with the experience of mathematical beauty does not imply that this area alone is responsible for, or underlies, the experience. As we have shown here and elsewhere, the viewing of mathematical equations also results in activity in cortical areas that are distinct from the areas engaged w hen viewing paintings which, in turn, differ from those active when listening to musical excerpts. ThecommonfactorisactivityinmOFCwhenbeautyinthese domains is experienced, but mOFC cannot act alone; rather it is active in concert with other areas which, we suppose, collectively correlate with the experience of beauty derived from different sources.

BEAUTY AND UNDERSTANDING Perhaps one of the most awkward, and at the same time challenging, aspects of this work was trying to separate out beauty [Annotation 8] and understanding. Because the correlation between the two, though signiﬁcant, was also imperfect, we were able to do so for mathematicians. T his of course leaves the question of whether non-mathematicians, with no understanding whatsoever of the equations, would also ﬁnd the equations beautiful. Ideally, one would want to have subjects who are mathematically totally illiterate, a search that proved difﬁcult. We relied, instead, on a different approach. Most of our “non-mathematician” subjects had a very imperfect understanding of the equations, even though they had rated some of them as beautiful; we supposed that they did so on the basis of the formal qualities of the equations—the forms displayed, their symmetrical distribution, etc. We surmised that we could demonstrate this indirectly, by showing that less well understood equations in our mathematical subjects will, when viewed, lead to more intense activity in the visual areas. This is what we found (see Figure 5), and it implies that some combinations of form are more aesthetically pleasing than others, even if they are not “understood” cognitively (see also quote from Dirac, given below). What these formal qualities may be requires a s eparate and detailed study of the beauty of forms, well beyond the scope of this study. But a parallel may be found in our earlier study, which shows that there are some conﬁgurations of kinetic stimuli which activate the motion areas of the visual brain more intensely (Zeki and Stutters, 2011).

IMPLICATIONS FOR FUTURE WORK The experience of beauty derived from mathematical formulations represents the most extreme case of the experience of beauty that is dependent on learning and culture. The fact that the experience of mathematical beauty, like the experience of musical and visualbeauty,correlateswithactivityinA1ofmOFCsuggests that there is, neurobiologically, an abstract quality to beauty that is independent of c ulture and learning. But that there was an imperfect correlation between understanding and the experience

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 10

#### Page 11

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

of beauty and that activity in the mOFC cannot be accounted for by understanding but by the experience of beauty alone, raises issues of profound interest for the future. It leads to the capital question of whether beauty, even in so abstract an area as mathematics, is a pointer to what is true in nature, both within our natureandintheworldinwhichwehaveevolved.Paul Dirac (1939) put it like this: “There is no logical reason why the (method of mathematical reasoning should make progress in the study of natural phenomena) but one has found in practice that it does work and meets with reasonable success. This must be ascribed to some mathematical quality in Nature, a qualit y which the casual observer of Nature would not suspect, but which neverthelessplaysanimportantroleinNature’sscheme...Whatmakes the theory of relativity so acceptable to physicists in spite of its going against the principle of simplicity is its great mathematical beauty. This is a quality which cannot be deﬁned, any more than beauty in art can be deﬁned, but which people who study mathematics usually have no difﬁculty in appreciating. The theory of relativity introduced mathematical beauty to an unprecedented extent into the description of Nature...We now see that we have to change the principle of simplicity into a principle of mathematical beauty. The research worker, in his efforts to express the fundamental laws of Nature in mathematical form, should strive mainly for mathematical beauty. He should still take simplicity into consideration in a subordinate way to beauty. It often happens that the requirements of simplicity and of beauty are the same, but where the y clash the latter must take precedence” (ellipses added). In similar vein, Hermann Weyl is recorded as having said, “My work always tried to unite the true with the beautiful; but when I had to choose one or the other, I usually chose the beautiful” (Dyson, 1956). Relevant here is the story of Weyl’s mathematical formulations, which tried to reconcile electromagnetism with relativity. Rejected at ﬁrst (by Einstein) because it was thought to conﬂict with experimental evidence, it came subsequently to be accepted but only after the advent of quantum mechanics, which led to a new interpretation of Weyl’s equations. Hence the perceived beauty of his mathematical formulations ultimately predicted truths even before the full facts were known.

If the experience of mathematical beauty is not strictly related to understanding (of the equations), what can the source of mathematical beauty be? That is perhaps more difﬁcult to account for in mathematics than in visual art or music. Whereas the source for the latter can be accounted for, at least theoretically, by preferred harmonies in nature or preferred distribution of forms or colors (see Bell, 1914; Zeki and Stutters, 2011; Zeki, 2013), it is more difﬁcult to make such a correspondence in mathematics. The Platonic t radition would emphasize that mathematical formulations are experienced as beautiful because they give insights into the fundamental structure of the universe (see Breitenbach, 2013). For Immanuel Kant, by contrast, the aesthetic experience is as well grounded in our own nature because, for him, “Aesthetic judgments may thus be regarded as expressions of our feeling that something makes sense to us” (Breitenbach, 2013). We believe that what “makes sense” to us is grounded in the workings of our brain, which has evolved within our physical environment. Dirac (1939) wrote: “the mathematician plays a game in which

he himself invents the rules while the physicist plays a game in which the rules are provided by Nature, but as time goes on it becomes increasingly evident that the rules which the mathematician ﬁnds interesting are the same as those which Nature has chosen” and therefore that in the choice of new branches of mathematics, “One should be inﬂuenced very much... by considerations of mathematical beauty” (ellipsis added). Hence the work we report here, as well as our previous work, highlights further the extent to which even future mathematical formulations may, by being based on beauty, reveal something about our brain on the one hand, and about the extent to which our brain organization reveals something about our universe on the other.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work was supported by the Wellcome Trust London, Strategic Award “Neuroesthetics” 083149/Z/07/Z. We are ver y grateful to Karl Friston for his many good suggestions during the course of this work.

SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: http://www.frontiersin.org/journal/10.3389/fnhum. 2014.00068/abstract

We include four datasheets containing experimental details which are not essential for general understanding of the article:

Data Sheet 1: EquationsForm.pdf—The equation beauty-rating questionnaire. Data Sheet 2: UnderstandingForm.pdf—The equation understanding questionnaire. Data Sheet 3: BehavioralData.xlsx—Tables of behavioral data. Data Sheet 4: BeauNeutUglyBase.pdf—Tables of categorical beauty activations vs. baseline.

REFERENCES Anderson, J. R., Betts, S., Ferris, J. L., and Fincham, J. (2011). Cognitive and

metacognitive activity in mathematical problem solving: prefrontal and parietal patterns. Cogn. Affect. Behav. Neurosci. 11, 52–67. doi: 10.3758/s13415-010- 0011-0 Arsalidou, M., and Taylor, M. J. (2011). Is 2+2=4? Metanalysis of brain

areas needed for numbers and calculation. Neuroimage 54, 2382–2393. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2010.10.009 Atiyah, M. (1973). Mathematics: art and science. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 43, 87–88.

doi: 10.1090/S0273-0979-05-01095-5 Atiyah, M. (2002). Hermann Weyl: 1885-1955, biographical memoirs. Natl. Acad.

Sci. 82, 1–17. Balsters, J. H., and Ramnani, N. (2008). Symbolic representations of action in the

human cerebellum. Neuroimage 43, 388–398. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2008. 07.010 Bell, C. (1914). Art. London: Chatto and Windus. Berridge, K. C., and Kringelbach, M. L. (2013). Neuroscience of affect: brain mech-

anisms of pleasure and displeasure. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 23, 294–303. doi: 10.1016/j.conb.2013.01.017 Binder,J.R.,Frost,J.A.,Hammeke,T.A.,Bellgowan,R.S.F.,Rao,S.M.,and

Cox, R. W. (1999). Conceptual processing during the conscious resting state: a functional MRI study. J. Cogn. Neurosci. 11, 80–93. doi: 10.1162/0898929995 63265 Blood, A. J., Zatorre, R. J., Bermudez, P., and Evans, A. C. (1999). Emotional

responses to pleasant and unpleasant music correlate with activity in paralimbic brain regions. Nat. Neurosci. 2, 382–387. doi: 10.1038/7299

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 11

#### Page 12

Zeki et al. Neural correlates of mathematical beauty

Breitenbach, A. (2013). Beauty in proofs: kant on aesthetics in mathematics. Eur. J.

Philos. 21, 1–23. doi: 10.1111/ejop.12021 Dehaene, S., Spelke, E., Pinel, P., Stanescu, R., and Tsivki, S. (1999). Sources of

mathematical thinking: behavioral and brain-imaging evidence. Science 284, 970–974. doi: 10.1126/science.284.5416.970 Dirac, P. (1939). The relation between mathematics and physics. Proc. R. Soc. Edin.

59, 122–129. Dyson, F. (1956). Obituary of Hermann Weyl. Nature 177, 457–458. Evans, A. C., Collins, D. L., Mills, S. R., Brown, E. D., Kelly, R. L., and Peters,

T. M. (1993). 3D statistical neuroanatomical models from 305 MRI volumes, in Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference, 1993., 1993 IEEE Conference Record, Vol. 3 (San Francisco, CA), 1813–1817. doi: 10.1109/NSSMIC.1993.373602 Feng, H., Zhang, Y., Tang, Y., Jin, J., Dong, F., Feng, S., et al. (2007). Deactivations

during the numerical processing. Chinese Sci. Bull. 52, 1807–1812. doi: 10.1007/s11434-007-0256-3 Fias, W., Lammertyn, J., Reynovet, B., Dupony, P., and Orban, G. A. (2003). Parietal

representation of symbolic and nonsymbolic magnitude. J. Cogn. Neurosci. 15, 47–56. doi: 10.1162/089892903321107819 Friston,K.,Asburner,T.,Kiebel,S.J.,Nichols,T.E.,andPenny,W.D.(eds.).

(2006). Statistical Parametric Mapping: The Analysis of Functional Brain Images. Amsterdam and London: Academic Press. Friston, K. J., Josephs, O., Zar ahn, E., Holmes, A. P., Rouquette, S., and Poline, J.-B.

(2000). To smooth or not to smooth? Bias and efﬁciency in fMRI time-series analysis. Neuroimage 12, 196–208. doi: 10.1006/nimg.2000.060 Friston,K.J.,Worsley,K.J.,Frackowiak,R.S.J.,Mazziotta,J.C.,andEvans,A.C.

(1994). Assessing the signiﬁcance of focal activations using their spatial extent. Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 210–220. doi: 10.1002/hbm.460010306 Gordon, G. (2005). Philosophy of The Arts. 3rd Edn. Oxford: Routledge. Gottfried, J. A., O’Doherty, J., and Dolan, R. J. (2003). Encoding predictive reward

value in human amygdala and orbitofrontal cortex. Science 301, 1104–1107. doi: 10.1126/science.1087919 9.10 Ilg, U. J., and Their, P. (2008). The neural basis of smooth pursuit eye

movements in the rhesus monkey brain. Brain Cogn. 68, 229–240. doi: 10.1016/j.bandc.2008.08.014 Ishizu, T., and Zeki, S. (2011). Toward a brain-based theory of beauty. PLoS ONE

6:e21852. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0021852 Kahnt, T., Chang, L. J., Park, S. Q., Heinzle, J., and Haynes, J.-D. (2012).

Connectivity-based parcellation of the human orbitofrontal cortex. J. Neurosci. 32, 6240–6250. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0257-12.2012 Kawabata, H., and Zeki, S. (2004). Neural correlates of beauty. J. Neurophysiol. 91,

1699–2004. doi: 10.1152/jn.00696.2003 Kringelbach, M. H., O’Doher ty, J., Rolls, E. T., and Andrews, C. (2003). Activation

of the human orbitofrontal cortex to a liquid food stimulus is correlated with its subjective pleasantness. Cereb. Cortex 13, 1064–1071. doi: 10.1093/cercor/13.10.1064 Kringelbach, M. L. (2005). The human orbitofrontal cortex: linking reward to

hedonic experience. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 6, 691–702. doi: 10.1038/nrn1747 Kühn, S., and Gallinat, J. (2012). The neural correlates of subjective pleasantness.

Neuroimage 61, 289–294. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.02.065 McClure, S. M., Li, J., Tomlin, D., Cypert, K. S., Montague, L. M., and Montague,

P. R. (2004). Neural correlates of behavioral preference for culturally familiar drinks. Neuron 44, 379–387. doi: 10.1016/j.neuron.2004.09.019 Nichols, T., Brett, M., Andersson, J., Wager, T., and Poline, J.-B. (2005). Valid con-

junction inference with the minimum statistic. Neuroimage 25, 653–660. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2004.12.005 O’Doherty, J., Kringelbach, M. L., Rolls, E. T., Hornak, J., and Andrews, C. (2001).

Abstract reward and punishment representations in the human orbitofrontal cortex. Nat. Neurosci. 4, 95–102. doi: 10.1038/82959

Peters, J., and Büchel, C. (2010). Neural representations of subjective reward value.

Behav. Brain Res. 213, 135–141. doi: 10.1016/j.bbr.2010.04.031 Plato. (1929). Timaeus and Critias, 30b AE Taylor (trans). London: Methuen. Plato. (1961a). Timaeus, (54a), from: Plato: The Collected Dialogues, Bollingen Series

LXXI, Trans eds E. Hamilton and H. Cairns. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Plato. (1961b). Timaeus, (29a,b), from: Plato: The Collected Dialogues, Bollingen

Series LXXI, Trans eds E. Hamilton and H. Cairns. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Price, G. R., and Ansari, D. (2011). Symbol processing in the left angular gyrus:

evidence from passive perception of digits. Neuroimage 57, 1205–1211. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.05.035 Russell, B. (1919). Mysticism and Logic and Other Essays. London: Allen and

Unwin. Sescousse, G., Redouté, J., and Dreher, J.-C. (2010). The architecture of reward

value coding in the human orbitofrontal cortex. J. Neurosci. 30, 13095–13104. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3501-10.2010 Shulman, G. L., Fiez, J. A., Corbetta, M., Buchner, R. L., Miezin, F. M., Raichle, M.

E., et al. (1997). Common blood ﬂow changes across visual tasks: II. Decreases in cerebral cortex. J. Cogn. Neurosci. 9, 648–663. doi: 10.1162/jocn.1997. 9.5.648 Stoodley, C. J. (2012). The cerebellum and cognition: evidence from functional

imaging studies. Cerebellum 11, 352–365. doi: 10.1007/s12311-011-0260-7 Tsukiura, T., and Cabeza, R. (2011). Shared brain activity for aesthetic and moral

judgments: implications for the Beauty-is-Good stereotype. Soc. Cogn. Affect. Neurosci. 6, 138–148. doi: 10.1093/scan/nsq025 Wintermute, S., Betts, S., Ferris, J. L., Fincham, J. M., and Anderson, J. R. (2012).

Brain networks supporting execution of mathematical skills versus acquisition of new mathematical competence. PLoS ONE 7:e50154. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0050154 Zeki, S. (2013). Clive bell’s signiﬁcant form and the neurobiology of aesthetics.

Front. Hum. Neurosci. 7:730. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2013.00730 Zeki, S., and Romaya, J. P. (2010). The brain reaction to viewing faces of opposite-

and same-sex romantic partners. PLoS ONE 5:15802. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0015802 Zeki, S., and Stutters, J. (2011). A brain-derived metric for preferred kinetic stimuli.

Open Biol. 2, 1–8. doi: 10.1098/rsob.120001 Zeki, S., and Stutters, J. (2013). Functional specialization and generalization for

grouping of stimuli based on colour and motion. Neuroimage 73, 156–166. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.02.001 Zeki, S. M. (1979). Zu Brodmanns area 18 und 19. Exp. Brain Res. 36, 195–197.

doi: 10.1007/BF00238478

Conﬂict of Interest Statement: The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or ﬁnancial relationships that could be construed as a potential conﬂict of interest.

Received: 11 November 2013; accepted: 28 January 2014; published online: 13 February 2014. Citation: Zeki S, Romaya JP, Benincasa DMT and Atiyah MF (2014) The experience of mathematical beauty and its neural correlates. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 8:68. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2014.00068 This article was submitted to the journal Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. Copyright © 2014 Zeki, Romaya, Benincasa and Atiyah. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) or licensor are credited and that the original publicat ion in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience www.frontiersin.org February 2014 | Volume 8 | Article 68 | 12

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-experience-of-mathematical-beauty-and-its-neural-correlates. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
