# The Earth as a Man-Controlled Space Ship

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-earth-as-a-man-controlled-space-ship

- **Authors:** Darol Froman
- **Published:** 1962
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1783291278726-5bgc1je0ztq-78867c217495e4b51348022ebf00fd82%2Ffroman1962+%282%29.pdf
- **Pages:** 5
- **Annotations:** 14 comments in 14 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-earth-as-a-man-controlled-space-ship

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “AM very happy to have the opportunity tonight to express the pleasure of the Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory in cosponsoring this meeting on Plasma Physics. The fine facilities and cooperation of the Air Force and the excellent accommodations in this hotel certainty constitute a fitting environment for the scholarly …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-05):

> **Darol K. Froman** (1906–1997) was a Canadian-born American nuclear physicist and longtime Los Alamos leader. After undergraduate and master’s degrees at the University of Alberta, he earned his Ph.D. under Arthur Compton at the University of Chicago in 1930. He joined the Manhattan Project early, worked on implosion diagnostics and the Trinity test, and later became Technical Associate Director (Deputy Director) of the Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory.
>
> He worked closely with Teller and Ulam on hydrogen-bomb design and was also involved in nuclear thermal rocket work (Project Rover). He retired in January 1962, shortly before this talk. This talk is essentially a valedictory: a weapons physicist, at the end of an 18-year career spent unlocking fusion energy in its explosive form, playfully asking what the ultimate peaceful application of that energy might be.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/ppJuq6w.jpeg)
> *Darol Froman*

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “AM very happy to have the opportunity tonight to express the pleasure of the Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory in cosponsoring this meeting on Plasma Physics. The fine facilities and cooperation of the Air Force and the excellent accommodations in this hotel certainty constitute a fitting environment for the scholarly …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-06):

> **MeV** stands for mega-electronvolt (10⁶ eV), the unit commonly used for nuclear reaction energies. One electronvolt is the energy gained by an electron accelerated through a potential difference of one volt.
>
> The **erg** is the unit of energy in the centimeter-gram-second (CGS) system. Its name derives from the Greek word *ergon* (ἔργον), meaning “work.” It is defined as the work done by a force of one dyne (1 g·cm/s²) acting over one centimeter, so 1 erg = 1 g·cm²/s². This equals 10⁻⁷ joules, a very small quantity that makes it convenient to express nuclear energies in microergs when working in CGS units.

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Now, let us invent a rocket engine which either squirts the products of the D-D and D-T reactions out the back end at their velocity of formation or allows the products to thermalize. If the reaction goes fast enough to burn essentially all the deuterium, there will not be much difference in the specific impulses in …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-07):

> ### Specific Impulse ($I_{sp}$) as a Measure of Rocket Efficiency
>
> **Specific impulse ($I_{sp}$)** is the primary metric used to measure the efficiency of a rocket engine. It defines how much thrust a rocket can produce per unit rate of propellant consumed.
>
> Mathematically, it represents the effective exhaust velocity of the propellant gases ($v_e$) divided by Earth's standard gravitational acceleration ($g$):
>
> $$
> I_{sp} = \frac{v_e}{g}
> $$
>
> Because thrust and the weight-flow rate of propellant share the same unit of force, they cancel out, leaving specific impulse with the dimension of **time (seconds)**.
>
> A useful physical reading of the seconds is this: an $I_{sp}$ of 450 seconds means that **1 kilogram of propellant can produce 1 kilogram-force ($1 \text{ kgf}$) of thrust for 450 seconds**. Equivalently, in idealized terms, that kilogram of propellant could support its own weight against Earth's gravity for 450 seconds.
>
> A higher $I_{sp}$ means the engine can extract more momentum from every kilogram of propellant ejected. For comparison, modern chemical rockets operate at an $I_{sp}$ of roughly 300 to 450 seconds.
>
> Froman calculates that a thermonuclear rocket directly venting D-D and D-T reaction products out the nozzle would achieve a staggering $I_{sp}$ of $2.2 \times 10^6$ seconds. At this extreme efficiency, the rocket requires very little propellant mass to achieve tremendous speeds, meaning a spacecraft requires an exceptionally low mass ratio to escape a gravitational field.

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Now, let us invent a rocket engine which either squirts the products of the D-D and D-T reactions out the back end at their velocity of formation or allows the products to thermalize. If the reaction goes fast enough to burn essentially all the deuterium, there will not be much difference in the specific impulses in …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-05):

> In 1962, controlled thermonuclear fusion research was still in its early experimental phase. Major programs in the U.S., Soviet Union, and Britain were exploring magnetic confinement approaches such as pinches, stellarators, and magnetic mirrors, but persistent plasma instabilities had prevented any device from approaching sustained energy breakeven. The field had been largely declassified at the 1958 Geneva Atoms for Peace conference, which increased both scientific collaboration and public speculation about future applications.
>
> Among plasma physicists, one of the most discussed long-term possibilities was fusion rocket propulsion: the very high exhaust velocities of fusion reaction products promised specific impulses of order $  10^6  $ seconds or more, far beyond chemical or fission systems, raising hopes for rapid interplanetary travel and, more speculatively, interstellar missions.

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Now, let us invent a rocket engine which either squirts the products of the D-D and D-T reactions out the back end at their velocity of formation or allows the products to thermalize. If the reaction goes fast enough to burn essentially all the deuterium, there will not be much difference in the specific impulses in …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-05):

> In a 1960 Brookhaven lecture, physicist Edward Purcell demonstrated that round-trip interstellar travel within a human lifetime is practically impossible due to the severe constraints of relativistic rocketry.
>
> To travel to a nearby star and return within a few decades, a spacecraft must accelerate to a significant fraction of the speed of light. Because a round trip requires four distinct phases of major acceleration and deceleration, the relativistic rocket equation dictates that the required initial fuel mass increases exponentially. Even using a theoretically perfect engine powered by matter-antimatter annihilation, the initial rocket would need to be impossibly massive just to carry its own propellant.
>
> Furthermore, traveling at these velocities turns ambient interstellar hydrogen into a lethal stream of high-energy, multi-GeV proton radiation, requiring heavy, impractical shielding to protect the crew.
>
> Froman takes this critique as his starting point and draws the opposite conclusion: if nothing can leave at high speed, take everything at low speed.

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “772o/rM{,* 200”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-05):

> ### Theoretical Engines vs. Practical Fusion
>
> Purcell analyzed two idealized propulsion systems that bracket the absolute limits of physics:
>
> * **Matter-Antimatter Annihilation:** The ultimate theoretical engine, which converts $100\%$ of its fuel mass to energy ($E=mc^2$). No higher efficiency is allowed by physical law.
> * **Proton-to-Alpha Conversion ($4p \rightarrow \text{He}^4$):** The net fusion process powering the Sun, which converts about $0.7\%$ of its mass to energy—the highest efficiency possible for any nuclear fuel. However, it is unusable in a reactor. Fusing bare protons requires a weak-interaction conversion ($p \rightarrow n$) at the exact millisecond of collision. This event is so improbable that an average proton in the Sun's core waits billions of years to fuse. The Sun compensates with sheer bulk; a rocket engine cannot.
>
> Because of these limitations, laboratory and practical fusion must rely on Deuterium-Tritium (D-T) and Deuterium-Deuterium (D-D) reactions, which proceed through the strong nuclear interaction alone. D-T yields $17.6\text{ MeV}$ and requires the lowest ignition temperature, making it the primary target for modern fusion programs, while D-D reactions tap into an inexhaustible fuel source found naturally in seawater. However, these reactions only convert roughly $0.1\%$ to $0.4\%$ of their mass into energy, falling far short of the performance offered by proton or antimatter systems.
>
> Froman’s “less than a million years” joke captures the 1962 mood: fusion was physically real, explosively proven, and theoretically promising, but controlled fusion was still an unsolved plasma-confinement problem.

### Annotation 7 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Propellant Solid Propellant LOX-kerosene LOX-H 2 H2 at 3000°K (nuclear heat) U 235 fission products D-D, T products 4H->He» Matter-antimatter”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-05):

> The reaction that fuses four protons into helium (the main energy source in stars like the Sun) has never been achieved in a sustained, controlled way in any laboratory. It proceeds through the weak interaction and has an extremely low probability at achievable temperatures and densities, making it impractical compared with the deuterium-based reactions used in experiments and weapons.
>
> Antimatter, by contrast, *has* been produced on Earth since the 1950s using high-energy particle accelerators (for example, antiprotons at the Bevatron and antihydrogen at CERN). However, the quantities remain extraordinarily small - on the order of nanograms or less in total across all experiments ever performed. Containing even these tiny amounts requires sophisticated magnetic traps and is possible only for seconds to minutes. Froman’s reference to “half a million pounds” of antimatter underscores just how far beyond current technology such a fuel source would be.

### Annotation 8 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Let's get a few basic numbers in hand. The oceans contain about one third of a billion cubic miles of water. The total deuterium content is about 5 X 10 13 tons. The total energy available in complete D-D and D-T”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-06):

> ### Deuterium Abundance
>
> Deuterium ($\text{D}$, or $^2\text{H}$) is a heavy isotope of hydrogen containing one proton and one neutron. In natural terrestrial water, deuterium has an abundance of approximately 1 atom for every 6,400 regular hydrogen atoms.
>
> Because water ($\text{H}_2\text{O}$) is mostly made of oxygen by mass, hydrogen accounts for about $11.2\%$ of water's total weight. Applying these ratios reveals the total scale of the resource:
>
> * **Total Hydrogen Mass:** $11.2\% \text{ of } 1.39 \times 10^{18}\text{ tons} \approx 1.56 \times 10^{17}\text{ tons}$
> * **Deuterium Fraction:** Because a deuterium atom is twice as heavy as a standard proton, its mass fraction relative to total hydrogen is roughly $2 \times (1 / 6400) \approx 3.125 \times 10^{-4}$.
>
> Multiplying the total hydrogen mass by this mass fraction yields:
>
> $$1.56 \times 10^{17}\text{ tons} \times 3.125 \times 10^{-4} \approx 4.88 \times 10^{13}\text{ tons}$$
>
> This calculation validates Froman's value of **$5 \times 10^{13}$ tons**. It highlights the core premise of his paper: the oceans contain an extraordinarily dense, incredibly abbundant supply of thermonuclear fuel.

### Annotation 9 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “well-known and ancient idea. The order of magnitude of the effort in accelerating and decelerating an asteroid might be like two earth-escape missions with it—i.e., m Q /m b — (1.0005) 2 = 1.001. So at the best, not counting getting our locomotive to the load and with a 100% efficient engine, we will need to burn …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-07):

> The estimate works like this: hauling an asteroid home means speeding it up out of its own orbit and slowing it down at Earth. Rather than compute the actual trajectory, Froman takes each maneuver to cost roughly one Earth-escape's worth of $\Delta v$ (11.2 km/s), a fair order-of-magnitude stand-in for a trip from the asteroid belt. Mass ratios in the rocket equation multiply when maneuvers add, so two escape-class burns give $(1.0005)^2 = 1.001$: the D-D engine from Table 1 must expel just 0.1% of the total mass as fusion exhaust. Hence 1 ton of deuterium burned per 1000 tons of asteroid delivered, with the caveats that the engine is perfectly efficient and that the tug travels to the asteroid for free.
>
> The idea of mining asteroids traces back at least to Konstantin Tsiolkovsky, the self-taught Russian schoolteacher regarded as the father of astronautics (and author of the rocket equation used above), who proposed exploiting asteroids in his 1903 treatise on spaceflight; by the 1920s the notion was a science-fiction staple.

### Annotation 10 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “well-known and ancient idea. The order of magnitude of the effort in accelerating and decelerating an asteroid might be like two earth-escape missions with it—i.e., m Q /m b — (1.0005) 2 = 1.001. So at the best, not counting getting our locomotive to the load and with a 100% efficient engine, we will need to burn …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-07):

> ### Composition of Asteroids in the Solar System
>
> When Froman wrote in 1962, the precise chemical makeup of asteroids was largely inferred from meteorites that fell to Earth. Today, thanks to advanced spectroscopy and direct robotic sample-return missions, we categorize asteroids into three primary composition classes:
>
> * **C-type (Carbonaceous):** The most common variety, making up about $75\%$ of known asteroids. They are ancient, dark, and rich in carbon compounds, rocks, and water bound up in clay minerals.
> * **S-type (Stony/Silicate):** Accounting for about $17\%$ of the population, these are composed mainly of iron- and magnesium-silicates mixed with nickel-iron metals.
> * **M-type (Metallic):** This class aligns closest to Froman’s speculation. They are dominated by pure nickel and iron.
>
> Perhaps the most famous M-type asteroid, **16 Psyche**, is believed to be the exposed iron-nickel core of a shattered protoplanet. Radar observations indicate that Psyche is a massive block of metal containing enough iron, nickel, and gold to theoretically collapse global commodity markets if brought to Earth, validating Froman's playful economic premise of immense celestial wealth.
>
> Modern asteroid-mining proposals mostly ignore nickel, targeting instead water (to be split into hydrogen and oxygen for in-space rocket propellant) and platinum-group metals, whose price per pound better survives the immense transportation costs Froman waves away.

### Annotation 11 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Now let's look at more distant horizons. I do not understand at all why would-be astronauts want to go tootling off into interstellar space. The quarters and food are likely to be miserable. To get anywhere and back in a lifetime, the speed will have to be very high so as to take advantage of the relativistic change …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-07):

> ### Relativistic Time Dilation in Interstellar Travel
>
> Froman is referencing **time dilation**, a consequence of Einstein's theory of special relativity. When an object travels through space at a significant fraction of the speed of light, time passes more slowly for that object relative to a stationary observer left behind.
>
> The relationship between the time elapsed on Earth ($\Delta t$) and the time experienced by the spaceship crew ($\Delta t_0$) is governed by the Lorentz factor:
>
> $$\Delta t = \frac{\Delta t_0}{\sqrt{1 - \frac{v^2}{c^2}}}$$
>
> **Taking Advantage of Clock Rates:** If a spacecraft accelerates to $99\%$ of the velocity of light ($v = 0.99c$), the Lorentz factor is roughly $7$. This means that a journey to a star 70 light-years away would take about 70 years from Earth's perspective, but only about 10 years for the astronauts on board.
>
> So distant destinations become reachable within a crew's lifetime, but at the price of enormous speed, and the catch is what Froman turns to next: at 0.99c, the thin interstellar hydrogen through which the ship flies becomes a relativistic proton beam.

### Annotation 12 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Now let's look at more distant horizons. I do not understand at all why would-be astronauts want to go tootling off into interstellar space. The quarters and food are likely to be miserable. To get anywhere and back in a lifetime, the speed will have to be very high so as to take advantage of the relativistic change …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-07):

> ### Calculating the Proton Beam: 5 mA and 6 BeV
>
> The specific values of $5\text{ mA}$ and $6\text{ BeV}$ are derived directly from the physics of driving a vehicle through the interstellar medium at $99\%$ the speed of light ($0.99c$).
>
> #### 1. Kinetic Energy (6 BeV)
>
> From the perspective of the spacecraft, stationary interstellar hydrogen atoms (which are single protons) approach the ship at $0.99c$. The relativistic kinetic energy ($K$) of an incoming proton is calculated using the Lorentz factor ($\gamma$):
>
> $$\gamma = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1 - \frac{v^2}{c^2}}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1 - 0.99^2}} \approx 7.09$$
>
> Subtracting the rest energy leaves the pure kinetic energy delivered by the impact:
>
> $$K = (\gamma - 1) m_p c^2$$
>
> $$K = (7.09 - 1) \times 938\text{ MeV} \approx 5.71\text{ BeV}$$
>
> Rounding this value yields the **$6\text{ BeV}$** baseline.
>
> #### 2. Electrical Current (5 mA)
>
> Because each colliding proton carries an elementary positive charge ($1.6 \times 10^{-19}\text{ C}$), a continuous stream of them creates an electrical current ($I = \text{charge} / \text{time}$). This current depends on the ambient hydrogen density ($n = 1\text{ cm}^{-3}$), the ship's velocity ($v = 0.99c$), and its forward cross-sectional area ($A$):
>
> $$I = A \cdot n \cdot v \cdot e$$
>
> Substituting Froman's **$5\text{ mA}$** figure ($0.005\text{ A}$) into this relation reverse-engineers the structural scale he had in mind:
>
> $$0.005\text{ A} = A \cdot (1) \cdot (2.97 \times 10^{10}) \cdot (1.6 \times 10^{-19})$$
>
> $$0.005\text{ A} = A \cdot (4.75 \times 10^{-9}) \implies A \approx 105\text{ m}^2$$
>
> This cross-sectional area corresponds to a circular rocket nose cone with a diameter of roughly **11.5 meters** (38 feet)—the typical size of a conceptual 1960s heavy-lift space vehicle. Flying a hull of this size through space at relativistic speeds physically sweeps up enough ambient ions to generate the stated $30\text{-MW}$ radiation environment.

### Annotation 13 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “not only for the poor astronaut in the picture whose troubles have been described in the doggerel verse you found on the table (see Appendix 1) but also for the stay-at-home folk who, if the sun runs true to form, will someday get fried to a crisp and the remains left out in the cold. According to Hoyle (Fred Hoyle, …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-07):

> Froman cites British astrophysicist Fred Hoyle. In the mid-20th century, Hoyle was a pioneer in stellar nucleosynthesis - the science of how stars burn nuclear fuel and change over time.
>
> As a main-sequence star like our Sun fuses hydrogen into helium in its core, the core becomes denser and hotter. This increases the rate of fusion, causing the Sun to grow gradually brighter and hotter over its lifetime. Hoyle's 1960s calculations estimated that this rising temperature would make Earth uninhabitable in about **two billion years**.
>
> Modern stellar astrophysics has refined this timeline, and the outlook for life is actually more compressed than Hoyle believed:
>
> * **In ~1 Billion Years:** The Sun’s luminosity will increase by about $10\%$. This seemingly small increase will trigger a moist greenhouse effect, causing Earth's oceans to evaporate into the stratosphere and escape into space, effectively ending complex multicellular life.
> * **In ~5 Billion Years:** The Sun will completely exhaust its core hydrogen fuel and exit the main sequence, expanding into a **Red Giant**. Its outer atmosphere will swell past the orbits of Mercury and Venus, likely engulfing or entirely melting the surface of the Earth.
>
> While Froman's exact two-billion-year figure has been adjusted downward for the survival of the biosphere, the core problem remains a driving premise of his essay: the solar system has a fixed expiration date, making long-term planetary relocation a ultimate physical necessity.

### Annotation 14 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “not only for the poor astronaut in the picture whose troubles have been described in the doggerel verse you found on the table (see Appendix 1) but also for the stay-at-home folk who, if the sun runs true to form, will someday get fried to a crisp and the remains left out in the cold. According to Hoyle (Fred Hoyle, …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2026-07-07):

> #### Calculating the Net Energy Barrier
>
> The minimum energy required to escape a gravitational source from a specific distance is governed by Newton's law of universal gravitation:
>
> $$E_{\text{escape}} = \frac{G \cdot M_{\odot} \cdot M_{\oplus}}{R}$$
>
> Where $G$ is the gravitational constant, $M_{\odot}$ is the mass of the Sun, $M_{\oplus}$ is the mass of the Earth, and $R$ is Earth's orbital radius (1 AU). This total potential energy barrier equals approximately $5.3 \times 10^{40}\text{ ergs}$.
>
> Froman states the required energy is **$2.4 \times 10^{40}\text{ ergs}$**. This lower figure accounts for the fact that the Earth is not stationary; its orbital velocity of $30\text{ km/s}$ provides an existing kinetic energy reservoir of roughly $2.7 \times 10^{40}\text{ ergs}$. Subtracting this current kinetic energy from the total potential energy barrier leaves the exact net deficit Froman cites:
>
> $$5.3 \times 10^{40}\text{ ergs} - 2.7 \times 10^{40}\text{ ergs} \approx 2.6 \times 10^{40}\text{ ergs}$$

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

19

THE EARTH

as a MAN-CONTROLLED

The folloiving is based on an after-dinner talk at the Colorado Springs meeting of the Division of Plasma Physics of the American Physical Society in November 1961. The author retired in January of this year from his post as Technical Associate Director of the Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory after having served as a member of the LASL staff for more than eighteen years.

SPACE SHIP

By Darol Froman

I

AM very happy to have the opportunity tonight to [Annotation 1] express the pleasure of the Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory in cosponsoring this meeting on Plasma [Annotation 2] Physics. The fine facilities and cooperation of the Air Force and the excellent accommodations in this hotel certainty constitute a fitting environment for the scholarly papers and discussion I heard today.

Now, I don't know much about plasma physics, so I'll talk about something else, but something which touches on plasma physics and fusion. I would like to make a few remarks about possible long-range applications and economics of fusion without much attention to some of the practical aspects. However, what I shall say is based upon such fundamental concepts as the conservation of energy and momentum.

We all know the interest of the Air Force in space and one can hardly study so potent a physical phenomenon as fusion without looking for its possibilities in space applications. To begin with I wish to remind you that it is essentially impossible to make a return space-ship trip to a near star and return in a human lifetime. Edward Purcell 1 pointed this out very clearly about a year ago. He considered two of the best imaginable engines: one which derived its power by conversion of protons to alpha particles and one in which matter and antimatter were annihilated. We can't approach such high performance with D-D and D-T reactions, but on the other hand, if I understand some of the plasma physicists correctly, there is some chance we may learn how to get such reactions in a controlled way very soon—perhaps even in less than a million years. We can, of course, get it explosively now. We are a long way from learning how to get four protons to combine and even further from making and containing half a million pounds of antimatter.

Let's get a few basic numbers in hand. The oceans contain about one third of a billion cubic miles of water. The total deuterium content is about 5 X 10 [Annotation 8] 13 tons. The total energy available in complete D-D and D-T

Edward Purcell, Brookhaven Lecture, November 1960.

combustion is about 5 MeV = 8 microergs per deuteron or 2.4 X 10 24 ergs/ton. Thus, the total energy available from all the deuterium in the oceans is about 10 38 ergs, an awesome number.

Now, let us invent a rocket engine which either squirts the products of the D-D and D-T reactions out the back end at their velocity of formation or allows the products to thermalize. If the reaction goes fast enough to burn essentially all the deuterium, there will not be much difference in the specific impulses in these cases. What kind of specific impulse would we have? A simple calculation shows it to be 2.2 X 10° sec. Perhaps I should remind you that specific impulse means [Annotation 3] the number of pounds of thrust exerted per second per pound of propellant ejected. In proper units it is equal to the exhaust velocity of the propellant gases measured relative to the vehicle, divided by g, the acceleration of gravity, and has the dimension of time. Table 1 gives other specific impulses for comparison. Our engine [Annotation 4] is not so bad when one considers that only the first three or four of those listed are in current practice or [Annotation 5] close to it.

Now with our rocket and D-D engine we can go out to capture asteroids and bring them home. This is a

Table 1. Specific Impulses

Propellant Solid Propellant LOX-kerosene LOX-H 2 H2 at 3000°K (nuclear heat) U 235 fission products [Annotation 7] D-D, T products 4H->He» Matter-antimatter

7 8p in sec 2.25 X10 2

2.75 X10 2

4X10 2

1x10* 1.3X10 6

2.2X10 6

3.7X10 6

3X10 7

772o/rM{,* [Annotation 6] 200

65 17 3.2 1.001 1.0005 1.0003 1.00003

* Mass ratio of single-stage vehicle for escape from earth's gravitational field.

JULY 1962

#### Page 2

20

well-known and ancient idea. The order of magnitude [Annotation 9] of the effort in accelerating and decelerating an asteroid might be like two earth-escape missions with it—i.e., m Q /m b — (1.0005) 2 = 1.001. So at the best, not counting getting our locomotive to the load and with a 100% efficient engine, we will need to burn about 1 ton of D 2 for each 1000 tons of asteroid we bring back. Now I don't know what asteroids are made of, but maybe they are half nickel. Nickel is worth about 50# a pound [Annotation 10] and Do about $100 a pound. So for $1 million we can buy 5 tons of D 2 and with it bring back 2500 tons of nickel worth $2.5 million. IVe been thinking of organizing the American Asteroidal Mining and Transportation Co. whose equipment is illustrated in Fig. 1. With a

A.A.M.& T CO.,;*

substantial subsidy from Uncle Sam to pay part of the development and operations costs, it might be a good thing. Anyone in the audience with a large bank account who wants in on the ground floor should see me after the meeting.

Now let's look at more distant horizons. I do not understand at all why would-be astronauts want to go tootling off into interstellar space. The quarters and food are likely to be miserable. To get anywhere and back in a lifetime, the speed will have to be very high so as to take advantage of the relativistic change in clock rates. Let's say the speed is to be 99% of the velocity of light. To attain this is not too hard on the [Annotation 11] pilot and crew. It takes only about a year at an acceleration of g to reach such a speed. There is, however, as Purcell pointed out, a little shielding problem because of the interstellar hydrogen. It is estimated that there is one atom of H per cubic centimeter in space. A fair-sized rocket traveling at 0.99c through this stuff would then receive about a 5-mA current of 6-BeV protons. This 30-MW beam would produce quite [Annotation 12] a radiation field. Some of the problems of such space travel are illustrated in Fig. 2. There should be some way to get around these troubles. I got to feeling sorry

Fig. 1. An American Asteroidal Mining and Transportation Company locomotive bringing home a cargo

Fig. 2. The mode of space travel in vogue in this century presents some difficulties

Pb

20^century

space TRAVEL

PHYSICS TODAY

#### Page 3

21

Fig. 3. Travel in comfort the American Earth Moving Co. way

not only for the poor astronaut in the picture whose troubles have been described in the doggerel verse you found on the table (see Appendix 1) but also for the stay-at-home folk who, if the sun runs true to form, will someday get fried to a crisp and the remains left out in the cold. According to Hoyle (Fred Hoyle, that is), it will become too hot on the earth for comfort, [Annotation 13] even for life, in about two billion years. This constitutes a real reason for going elsewhere and about the only compelling one I know. It occurred to me that for most of us the most comfortable space ship imaginable [Annotation 14] would be the earth itself. So if we don't like it here because the sun is dying or something, let's go elsewhere, earth and all. We will not have to worry about all the usual hardships of space travel. For example, the radiation problem will disappear because of the atmosphere and because we will be going at low speed. The ease and comfort of this mode of travel are shown in Fig. 3.

How are we equipped energy-wise to handle this job? First of all, what about heat and light? We will be a long time away from the sun or other near star. The power received from the sun and re-radiated from the earth to space is, as everyone knows, 1.9 cal/min/cm 2

normal to the sun's rays. Assuming an albedo of 0.5,

the total power received by the earth in this way is 10 17

watts. We saw that the oceans' deuterium content could supply 10 38 ergs. So this deuterium could supply our heat and light (away from the sun) for three million years. There is no problem here. Or maybe there is a little problem. At this rate we would use 3 X 10 10 lb of deuterium per year which, at $100 per lb, would cost about 100 times the current Air Force annual budget. Perhaps we could get it in quantity for wholesale prices.

But how about getting away from the sun? The energy required for the earth to escape from the sun's gravitational field is about 2.4 X 10 40 ergs. This is much more than all our deuterium can give us, so we shall have to seek some other energy source.

There is clearly no point in using antimatter for this purpose because, as we shall see, the specific impulse is much too high and the conversion of energy to enough antimatter would be difficult. It would take much too long to collect the energy from sunlight. If we collected all the sunshine falling on the earth it would take about fifteen times the estimated remaining life of the sun to accumulate sufficient energy to accomplish the escape of the earth from the solar system.

I believe we shall have to go to the 4p —> He 4 reaction. With this reaction, all the protons in all the oceans

JULY 1962

#### Page 4

22

can give us about 10* times as much energy as all the deuterium, i.e., about 10 42 ergs. This gives us forty times as much energy as we need to get away from the sun. To just get away we will need effectively to double the earth's kinetic energy which means adding an increment in velocity, Av — 1.25 X 10° cm/sec. Using the specific impulse given in Table 1 for the proton reaction we find that in the ordinary way of propelling rockets we would need to expel fifteen times the total mass of hydrogen available.

This presents us a case in propulsion we are not very used to. What we usually ask for is the highest possible 7 sp in order to minimize the amount of propellant. In this case, we wish to conserve our energy resources for a long flight and we search more for minimum energy than for minimum mass of propellant. On the other hand we don't wish to use up any large fraction of the mass of the earth as propellant. As a compromise, I suggest we allocate about 25% of the available energy to getting out of the solar system, save about 25% in case we may eventually want to get into another similar one and use the remaining 50% for heat, light, and interstellar propulsion. A little figuring suggests the following fuel and reaction for an engine with 50% efficiency:

Table 2. Earth escape possibilities with various

propellant mixtures

2 ELO + 1000 SiO 2 > He + 2002 O + 1000 Si + 26.7 MeV.

With equipartition of energy, this propellant has a specific impulse of 2.9 X 10 4 sec. To get out of the solar system with this propellant we will need to exhaust 4% of the earth's mass, but I guess we can afford it. We can get a quarter of it by using the moon which will be no good to us anyway away from the sun. We need to leave the solar system in a time short compared to our estimate of the stable life of the sun and also because we do not wish to use up too much of our available light and heat energy at low speeds not getting anywhere. I suggest 100 million years for this stage. This would require a mass flow rate of propellant (mostly sand) of 8.7 X 10* tons/sec.

Actually, this formula goes with using an engine efficiency of about 50%. By using a 100% efficient engine we can reduce the amount of sand and get by with expelling only 2% of the earth's mass. If we don't wish to save enough propellant capacity to get back into a similar orbit around some other sun, we can use only the mass in the moon and 40% of our available energy.

Table 2 illustrates what can be done by changing the ratio of sand to water in the propellant.

After this stage (i.e., getting out of the solar system), we will wish to use our hydrogen as propellant at the same rate we need to use it for heat and light in order to maximize the distance we can go. This results in a mass flow rate of only 300 lb/sec and an acceleration of about 8 X 10" 17 g which is certainly quite comfortable. We can then travel this way for 8 X 10 9 years which is at least four or five times longer than we are allowed if we stay here. In this time if, for example,

Propellant-ratio:

molecules SiO* 500 125 50 molecules H>O

/, p in sec. 2.9X10 1 5.7 X10 1 9.2 X10 1

50 100 100 Engine effi-

ciency, %

% of earth's 24 oceans required

% of earth 4 f+moon) expelled

25 40

1 (=moon)

we accelerate half the way and slow down the other half, we can go about 1300 light years. In this time and distance we should be able to figure out how to refuel (i.e., fill an ocean or two) from some handy planet and keep the earth operating indefinitely. With all our oceans we are not able to get going fast enough to collect enough hydrogen from interstellar space to make any appreciable contribution to our energy store even if we go through luminous nebulae, where the density of hydrogen is relatively high, perhaps 500 atoms per cubic centimeter.

In our interstellar travel it will take very little energy to guide us through space. We can literally "guide by the stars"—i.e., select, using only a little energy, the impact parameter for a star near our path and, thus, the appropriate hyperbolic trajectory to put us in the desired direction.

We had better begin to learn how to combine protons before long. Time is running out. We have already passed two thirds of the useful life of the sun. I predict a pleasant existence in space—we will get away from the daily grind. Perhaps we shall not wish to join another star—life in space may be more desirable. (I haven't yet figured out a good way to leave certain people behind. It has been suggested that we use them for propellant. The human body is not constituted with quite as good proportions of the elements for our propellant as is damp sand. Nevertheless, the proportions are not too bad and we can in this way take care of the problem of overpopulation.) The best groups in the world to undertake this project are assembled here tonight. There are really only two problems to solve. One is scientific, namely, learning how to make four protons combine into an alpha particle. The plasma physicists here can easily tackle this problem. The second problem is just engineering, although on a fantastically large scale. I am sure you will agree that the United States Air Force is the most experienced group in the world in letting and monitoring the development and manufacturing contracts for the engines, nozzles, and feed systems we shall need for propulsion of the earth.

PHYSICS TODAY

#### Page 5

23

Appendix 1

the last astronaut

Now a solar sail is of no avail In an astronaut's terrible plight In the all pervading night Of his intergalactic flight.

For the rare photon and bare proton, At a millimicro lux And with isotropic flux, Fail the problem's central crux.

Expired its guarantee for high I SP Is the nuclear engine's thrust, 'Cause the nozzle's all riddled with rust And the propellant tankage is bust.

The ion expulsion for better propulsion Was made by the AEC At NASA's requested eV For ARPA's requirement, you see.

But the ion gun had failed to run Since the cesium plasma fell Down temperatures open well In the thermoelectric cell.

The heat was supplied from the fission inside Which stopped when the fuel burned out; And the poisons, all gathered about, Had dealt k effective a clout.

The final injection for plasma ejection By the patented mirror machine Was made ere the coolant had been Spilled out through the holes we have seen.

And the magnetic bottle, in obeying the throttle To admix antimatter with real, Sprung a leak in its B-theta seal And squirted the coils a good deal.

Thus came the destruction of the superconduction Which kept the magnetic field high. This let all the antistuff fly Away to react in the sky.

The missile's main mission when powered by fission In the rocket motor's core Was to visit planets galore To expand the economy more.

And to find life space for the human race Whose reproductive yen Spewed forth so many men No room was left for a wren.

He had got off his course beyond gravity's force In the solar orbit desired. And the added speed he acquired 'Till all the engines expired.

Nearly stopped all his clocks and kept his brown locks From aging and turning to gray. While he frigged around for a day Earth's clocks ticked eons away.

Then he looked off afar and saw a bright star And thought of Orion's strong belt Whose impact had often been felt When a push to the platform was dealt.

So he unpacked a bomb and directed it from A gyro that stable had been Toward a signal he'd seen On his fluorescent screen.

The speed was decreased through momentum released By the unidirectional blast; But the rocket was going so fast He had to use all but the last.

Then about a year later (the time seemed much greater And it was on the Earth and the sun) He returned where the trip had begun And planned for his homecoming fun.

But the sun had grown dim, and way out on the rim Of the dead solar system he spied The Earth, where the people had tried To expand the space nature supplied.

And things were not nice on that spheroid of ice With its atmosphere turned into snow, And not even a creature below To start a new family to grow.

So he pulled out the string on that last man made thing, And he thought himself clever To have solved thus forever— —Boom—.

JULY 1962

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/the-earth-as-a-man-controlled-space-ship. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
