# Feynman's proof of the Maxwell equations

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/temp-feynmans-proof-of-the-maxwell-equations

- **Authors:** Freeman Dyson
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1454185628942-tr8z5psuxc877gb9-3d4d1dc78bcd8155ec34ad1e13097b3a%2FDysonMaxwell041989.pdf
- **Pages:** 3
- **Annotations:** 9 comments in 9 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/temp-feynmans-proof-of-the-maxwell-equations

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-01-30):

> Freeman Dyson is an English-born American theoretical physicist and mathematician. He is professor emeritus at the Institute for Advanced Study and worked on several areas including quantum electrodynamics, solid-state physics, astronomy and nuclear engineering.
>
> ![](http://www.irishtimes.com/polopoly_fs/1.1795447.1400081217!/image/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/box_620_330/image.jpg)
>
> He met Richard Feynman at Cornell University in 1947 while he was working with Hans Bethe. You can see [here](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rlaPLvETBug&feature=youtu.be&t=77) Freeman Dyson talking about the first time he interacted with Richard Feynman.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-01-31):

> Deriving identity (3) in $t$
>
> $$m\frac{d[x_j,\dot x_{k}]}{dt}=m\frac{d(x_j\dot x_{k}-\dot x_{k}x_j)}{dt}= \\
> = m( \dot x_j\dot x_{k}+x_j\ddot x_{k}-\ddot x_{k}x_j-\dot x_{k} \dot x_j)= \\
> = m( x_j\ddot x_{k}-\ddot x_{k}x_j+\dot x_j\dot x_{k}-\dot x_{k} \dot x_j)=\\
> =[x_j,F_k]+m[\dot x_{j}, \dot x_k] = 0
> \\
> $$

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-01-31):

> $$
> [x_l,[\dot x_j,\dot x_k]]+[\dot x_l,[\dot x_j,x_k]]+[\dot x_l,[x_j,\dot x_k]]= \\
> = -\frac{1}{m}[x_l,[x_j,F_k]]+\underbrace{[\dot x_j,\delta_{kl}]}_\text{0}+\underbrace{[\dot x_k,\delta_{lj}]}_\text{0}=\\
> =[x_l,[x_j,F_k]]=0
> $$

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-01-31):

> $$
> -[x_k,F_j]=m[\dot x_k, \dot x_j]=-m[\dot x_j, \dot x_k]=[x_j,F_k]
> $$

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-02-07):

> To prove that $[x_j,F_k]=-\frac{i \hbar}{m}\epsilon_{jkl} H_l$ we first start by using expression (4)
>
> $$
> [x_j,F_k]= [x_j,E_k]+\epsilon_{kim}[x_j,\dot x_i H_m]
> $$
>
> Now, since $[x_j,F_k]=-[x_k,F_j]$ it means that $[x_j,F_k]$ is antisymmetric and so it has to be proportional to the Levi-Civita symbol (which is also antisymmetric). This means $[x_j,E_k]=0$ (E is a function of t and x only) and
>
> $$
> [x_j,F_k]= \epsilon_{kim}[x_j,\dot x_i H_m]
> $$
>
> To calculate $[x_j,\dot x_i H_m]$ we recall that for any 3 operators A,B and C: $[A,BC]=[A,B]C+B[A,C]$ and so
>
> $$
> [x_j,\dot x_i H_m]=[x_j,\dot x_i] H_m + \dot x_i[x_j, H_m]=\\
> =\frac{i \hbar}{m}\delta_{ji}H_m+\dot x_i[x_j, H_m]
> $$
>
>
> $$
> [x_j,F_k]=\frac{i \hbar}{m}\epsilon_{kjm}H_m+\epsilon_{kim}\dot x_i[x_j, H_m]=\\
> =-\frac{i \hbar}{m}\epsilon_{jkm}H_m+\epsilon_{kim}\dot x_i[x_j, H_m]
> $$
>
> Using property (11) we see that
>
> $$
> [x_l,[x_j,F_k]]= -\frac{i \hbar}{m}\epsilon_{jkm}[x_l,H_m]+\epsilon_{kim}[x_l,\dot x_i[x_j, H_m]]
> $$
> $$
> [x_l,\dot x_i[x_j, H_m]]=\frac{i\hbar}{m}\delta_{li}[x_j,H_m]+\dot x_i(x_l[x_j,H_m]-[x_j,H_m]x_l)
> $$
>
> The only way for $[x_l,[x_j,F_k]]$ to be $0$ is if $[x_j, H_m]=0$ which means that all terms will vanish. Again as with $E$, this means that $H$ is a function of time and x only.

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-02-07):

> $$
> [x_j,F_k]= -\frac{i\hbar}{m}\epsilon_{jkl}H_l \equiv\\
> -m[\dot x_j,\dot x_k]=-\frac{i\hbar}{m}\epsilon_{jkl}H_l
> $$
> Now if we multiply both sides by $\epsilon_{jki}$
> $$
> -m\epsilon_{jki}[\dot x_j,\dot x_k]=-\frac{i\hbar}{m}\underbrace{\epsilon_{jkl}\epsilon_{jki}}_{2\delta_{li}}H_l\equiv \\
> H_i=-\frac{im^2}{2\hbar}\epsilon_{jki}[\dot x_j,\dot x_k]
> $$

### Annotation 7 (page 2)

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-02-07):

> This expression means that $H_l$ is not a function of $x_l$, otherwise they would not commute because $[x_l,\dot x_l]= \frac{i \hbar}{m}$. Now if $H_l$ is independent of $x_l$ the divergence of $H$ is zero because $\frac{\partial H_l}{\partial x_l}=0$.
>
> $$\text{div} H = \sum_l \frac{\partial H_l}{\partial x_l}=0$$
>
> Which is one of Maxwell's equations.

### Annotation 8 (page 2)

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-02-08):

> $$
> -\frac{im}{\hbar}\epsilon_{jkl}[E_j+\epsilon_{jmn}\dot x_m H_n , \dot x_k]=\\
> =-\frac{im}{\hbar}(\epsilon_{jkl}[E_j,\dot x_k]+\underbrace{\epsilon_{jkl}\epsilon_{jmn}}_{\delta_{km}\delta_{ln}-\delta_{kn}\delta_{lm}}[\dot x_m H_n , \dot x_k])=\\
> =-\frac{im}{\hbar}(\epsilon_{jkl}[E_j,\dot x_k]+[\dot x_k H_l , \dot x_k]-[\dot x_l H_k , \dot x_k])
>
> $$

### Annotation 9 (page 2)

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-02-08):

> Since the space coordinate operators $x_1,x_2,x_3$ commute with each other $[x_j,x_k]=0$. To prove (22) we need to recall that the momentum operator in x-space is represented by $\dot x = p_x = \frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}$ and so:
>
> $$
> [x_j,p_k]\Psi(x,t) =x_jp_k\Psi(x,t)-p_kx_j\Psi(x,t)= \\
>
> =x_j\frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\partial}{\partial x_k}\Psi(x,t)-\frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\partial}{\partial x_k}x_j\Psi(x,t)=\\
> =x_j\frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\partial \Psi(x,t)}{\partial x_k}-\frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\partial x_j}{\partial x_k}\Psi(x,t)-x_j\frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\partial \Psi(x,t)}{\partial x_k}=\\
> =-\frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\partial x_j}{\partial x_k}\Psi(x,t)=- \frac{\hbar}{i}\delta_{jk}\Psi(x,t)=i \hbar  \delta_{jk}\Psi(x,t)
> $$
>
> Where $\delta_{jk}$ is the Kronecker delta:
> $$\delta_{jk} = \begin{cases}
> 0 &\text{if } j \neq k,   \\
> 1 &\text{if } j=k.   \end{cases}
> $$
>
> Note that since the coordinates are independent $\frac{\partial x_j}{\partial x_k}$ is not zero only when $x_j=x_k$.

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/temp-feynmans-proof-of-the-maxwell-equations. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
