# String Theory, 500 BCE

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/string-theory-500-bce

- **Authors:** Eli Maor
- **Published:** 2018
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1592596597355-em0x7k8ug3n-856e6bc2f33f83c672553c23ff8a8e80%2Feli_maor_music_by_the_numbers_string_theory.pdf
- **Pages:** 9
- **Annotations:** 15 comments in 13 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/string-theory-500-bce

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “CHAPTER 2”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-23):

> This is the 2nd chapter of the book
>
> ***"Music by the Numbers: From Pythagoras to Schoenberg"*** by **Eli Maor**
>
> [Google Books - Music by the Numbers: From Pythagoras to Schoenberg
> ](https://books.google.com/books?id=mh6vDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA13&lpg=PA13&dq=string+theory+500+bce&source=bl&ots=XrlTuoaPJj&sig=ACfU3U2fNxePkyH8ep_dG2zAoGi23zssCw&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj_j42j7ZjqAhV8ITQIHRncAPQQ6AEwBHoECAoQAQ#v=onepage&q=string%20theory%20500%20bce&f=false)

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “CHAPTER 2”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-19):

> ### TL;DR
>
> Pythagoras of Samos was intrigued by the sounds emitted by vibrating objects and set out to study them. He found mathematical order in sound. This conscious connection was the first time of a hidden pattern of Nature had been unveiled.
>
> Pythagoras found that there is an order in musical sounds and tried impose mathematical rules on the sounds emitted by vibrating objects. His work established the basis for all music theory and made possible the scales systems was we know them today (ex: minor and major scales).
>
> ***His experiments would end up altering music forever.***
>
> > ***It is a strange truism: the earliest experimental science to establish quantitative relations between observable entities was acoustics.***

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Not being satised with just a qualitative observation, Pythagoras went on to experiment with all kinds of vibrating bodies—taut strings, water- lled glasses, bells, and pipes (gure 2.1). He is said to have built a primitive musical instrument, the monochord—a single string attached to a sound board with a numerical …”

**Annotation** by Rui Diaz Pacheco (2022-02-18):

> A child today may notice a similar event while playing with a plastic ruler at the edge of a desk. While holding on end, they can pluck the hanging end and produce sound, and then notice how the pitch will vary with the length.

### Annotation 4 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “essentially identical, like walking down the hallway on different oors of a hotel. The octave, Pythagoras had found, corresponds to the ratio 1:2.”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-19):

> An Octave corresponds to the fundamenta interval between one musical pitch and another one which is double its frequency. This relationship is a natural phenomenon and was first identified by Pythagoras. The majority of musical scales begin and end on notes that are an octave apart.
>
> ![](https://cdn.britannica.com/92/145592-050-A9A21816/Notation-octave.jpg)
> *A perfect octave between two C's*

### Annotation 5 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “FIGURE 2.2. Monochord.”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-22):

> ### The Monochord
>
> The monochord is a musical instrument that is comprised of a single string stretched over a sound that includes box a movable bridge. The monochord was used in Greece by the 6th century BC as a scientific instrument for measuring musical intervals.
>
> 📹 Watch how the monochord works here:
> [![](https://i.imgur.com/TBlcj2L.png)](https://youtu.be/gYtSI4-ShLU?t=17)

### Annotation 6 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “rather large interval into smaller parts. He experimented with other ratios of string length, leading him to a discovery that left a deep impression on him: ratios of small numbers produced harmonious, pleasant combinations of sounds—consonances—whereas ratios of larger numbers produced dissonances. Foremost among the …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-22):

> Illustration of the Pythagorean intervals on the strings of a guitar.
>
> !["pythogaras guitar"](https://i.imgur.com/HbaQVVd.png)

### Annotation 7 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “We must digress here for a moment and mention that beginning around 1600, it became the practice to describe musical intervals in terms of their frequency ratios, rather than ratios of string length. For any given string, the frequency is inversely proportional to the string’s length, so the octave, the fth, and the …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-22):

> #### Physics of a vibrating string
>
> The wavelength of the fundamental vibrational mode of a stretched string is twice the length of the string.
>
> $$\lambda = 2L$$
>
> Taking into account the basic wave relationship $v=f\lambda$ one can write the frequency as follows:
>
> $$f = \frac{v}{2L}$$
>
> and since the wave velocity for a stretched string is given by:
>
> $$v = \sqrt{\frac{T}{m/L}}$$
>
> where $T$ is the tension of the string, $m$ the mass of the string and $L$ the length of the string.
>
> We can then write the frequency for a vibrating string as follows:
>
> $$f = \frac{\sqrt{\frac{TL}{m}}}{2L}$$

### Annotation 8 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “The three intervals just mentioned were to play a fundamental role in music. Pythagoras called them perfect consonances and used them to construct a musical scale— the rst known attempt to organize musical sounds into an orderly numerical system. He found that, starting with any note, going up a fth and then another …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-20):

> > Pythagoras called them perfect consonances and used them to construct a musical scale— the first known attempt to organize musical sounds into an orderly numerical system.

### Annotation 9 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “9”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-22):

> This sequence:
> $$\frac{9}{8},\frac{9}{8},\frac{256}{243},\frac{9}{8},\frac{9}{8},\frac{9}{8},\frac{256}{243}$$
>
> Which corresponds to:
>
> ***tone, tone, semi-tone, tone, tone, tone, semi-tone***
>
> is to this day the way the majority of scales are built.

### Annotation 10 (page 6)

Beside the passage: “Major Keys”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-22):

> Learn more about the circle of fifths and the geometry of music here:
> [![geometry of music](https://i.imgur.com/cJIrlLL.png)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZWzwb4BumIk)

### Annotation 11 (page 7)

Beside the passage: “this series can go on forever, producing an innite blend of ever higher notes. Usually, however, the amplitudes of these overtones, and therefore their intensities, quickly diminish as we go up the sequence, making them increasingly feeble and difcult to hear. Indeed, for nearly two thousand years they remained …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-22):

> Joseph Sauveur was a French mathematician and physicist and a member of the French Academy of Sciences.
>
> Sauveur drew a sharp divide between sound and music - he recognized the former as a physical phenomenon obeying mathematical principles and the latter as subjective and unquantifiable perception.
>
> He was one of the founding fathers of acoustics

### Annotation 12 (page 9)

Beside the passage: “FIGURE 2.5. Kepler’s planetary music. From Harmonices Mundi, Libri V (Linz: Jo Planck, 1619).”

**Annotation** by Samuel Rocha (2020-06-26):

> It would be nice to listen the music. A mp3 file, perharps?

**Reply** by Micael Oliveira (2020-06-26):

> This looks interesting 🎼: [Giovanni Keplero - Harmonices Mundi](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WihmsRinpQU)

**Reply** by Samuel Rocha (2020-06-30):

> Yes, indeed.

### Annotation 13 (page 9)

Beside the passage: “He believed that each planet, in its orbit around the Sun, plays a tune that our ears are unable to hear, being below the range of audible frequencies (not to mention that it was produced in the vacuum of outer space, where sound cannot propagate). He actually assigned a celestial melody, written down in musical …”

**Annotation** by Christian Luca (2020-06-23):

> How did Johannes Kepler come to his assignment of a celestial melody for the planets known in his time?  Did he use bass clef for the larger planets like Saturn and Jupiter because he expected them to produce lower frequency sounds based on their larger masses, whereas Mercury was assigned the alto clef, producing greater frequency sounds due to the smallest mass of the planets?
>
> Perhaps this is explained in the book, Harmonices Mundi, Libri V.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

CHAPTER 2 [Annotation 1] [Annotation 2]

String Theory,

500 BCE

IT IS A STRANGE TRUISM: the earliest experimental science to establish quantitative relations between observable entities was acoustics. Pythagoras of Samos (ca. 585–500 BCE), the legendary philosopher who will forever be associated with the right- triangle theorem named after him, began his scientic career by investigating the vibrations of sound- emitting objects. According to legend, while walking down a street one day he heard sonorous sounds coming from a blacksmith’s shop. Stopping by to investigate, he noticed that the sound had originated from the craftsman’s hammer hitting a metal sheet; the heavier the sheet, the lower the pitch of the sound it emitted.

Not being satised with just a qualitative observation, [Annotation 3] Pythagoras went on to experiment with all kinds of vibrating bodies—taut strings, water- lled glasses, bells, and pipes (gure 2.1). He is said to have built a primitive musical instrument, the monochord—a single string attached to a sound board with a numerical scale along it (gure 2.2). The string’s effective length could be varied by inserting a small bridge between the string and the board. Pythagoras found that, when the string was allowed to vibrate rst at its full length and then stopped at half its length, the two sounds bore a pleasant, harmonious afnity to one another: they were separated by an octave. A melody played in different octaves sounds

#### Page 2

14 CHAPTER 2

essentially identical, like walking down the hallway on different oors of a hotel. The octave, Pythagoras had found, corresponds to the ratio 1:2. [Annotation 4]

Having established the octave as a fundamental musical interval, Pythagoras next attempted to subdivide this

FIGURE 2.1. Pythagoras experimenting with sound-emitting objects. From Franchino Gaffurio, Theorica Musicae (Milan, 1492).

#### Page 3

STRING THEORY, 500 BCE 15

rather large interval into smaller parts. He experimented with other ratios of string length, leading him to a discovery that left a deep impression on him: ratios of small numbers produced harmonious, pleasant combinations of sounds—consonances—whereas ratios of larger numbers produced dissonances. Foremost among the former were the octave (1:2), the fth (2:3), and the fourth (3:4) (the names derive from the position of these intervals in the musical [Annotation 6] scale; see gure 2.3). Pythagoras saw in this a sign that nature itself—indeed, the entire universe—is governed by simple numerical ratios. Number rules the universe became the Pythagorean motto, and it would dominate scientic thought for the next two thousand years.

FIGURE 2.3. The octave, perfect fth, and perfect fourth.

FIGURE 2.2. Monochord. [Annotation 5]

#### Page 4

16 CHAPTER 2

𝄓

We must digress here for a moment and mention that beginning around 1600, it became the practice to describe musical intervals in terms of their frequency ratios, rather than ratios of string length. For any given string, the frequency is inversely proportional to the string’s length, so [Annotation 7] the octave, the fth, and the fourth correspond to the ratios 2:1, 3:2, and 4:3, respectively. We will adhere to this practice in what follows.

𝄓

The three intervals just mentioned were to play a fundamental role in music. Pythagoras called them perfect consonances and used them to construct a musical scale— the rst known attempt to organize musical sounds into [Annotation 8] an orderly numerical system. He found that, starting with any note, going up a fth and then another fourth brings us to a note exactly one octave above the starting note. Translated into ratios, the relation can be expressed as 2 3 3 4 1 2 # = . This is true in general: to add two intervals, multiply their frequency ratios. Unbeknownst to him, Pythagoras had discovered the rst logarithmic relation in history.

Next, he took each perfect consonance and raised its ratio to successive powers. Powers of 2:1 merely carry us to higher octaves, while powers of 4:3 result in inversions of 3:2 (an interval is said to be inverted if its lower note is moved up by one octave or its higher note down by one octave). This left him with powers of 3:2, starting with () 1 3 2 2 3 – = and leading to the following sequence:

1

. 2

3

3

2

2

3

2

3

2

3

2

3

4

9

2

3

8

27

2

3

16

81

2

3

32

243

1 012345–

=

a aaaaaa kkkkkkk

#### Page 5

STRING THEORY, 500 BCE 17

Of the seven ratios in this sequence, only the second and third lie within one octave. To bring the remaining ratios into the range of an octave, we multiply or divide them by powers of 2:

. 3

4 1 2

3

8

9

16

27

64

81

128

243

When this new sequence is arranged in ascending order and augmented by the ratio 2:1 to complete it to a full octave, we get the following array:

. 8

9

64

81

128

243 1 3

4

2

3

16

27

1

2

This sequence is known as a diatonic scale. It gives the ratio of each note to the fundamental (lowest) note. But in music, what matters most is the ratio between two notes, that is, the interval separating them. By taking the ratio of each note to the one preceding it, we get the sequence

, 8

9 [Annotation 9]

8

9

8

9

8

9

8

9 243

256

243

256

which represents the intervals of the Pythagorean diatonic scale. It consists of just two distinct intervals, a large one of 9:8 (= 1.125), called a whole tone, and a small one of 256:243 (~ 1.053), called a semitone or half tone.

𝄓

At rst thought, the Pythagorean scale seems like a great invention; it stands out for its simplicity, employing powers of just one ratio, 3:2. But this simplicity is deceiving, and for a number of reasons. First, as every music student learns early on, there is a scheme called a circle of fths: start with any note and go up in a succession of fths. After doing this twelve times (and in the process going through a series of sharps and ats, notes that are

#### Page 6

18 CHAPTER 2

a half tone above or below those of the diatonic scale), you should arrive back at the base note, albeit seven octaves higher (see gure 2.4). Alas, this is impossible to do with the Pythagorean scale: no positive integer values of m and n can ever satisfy the equation () 2 mn 2 3 = . 1 But even more troubling is the fact that the Pythagorean scale was out of tune with the natural sequence of harmonics, or overtones, generated by practically all musical instruments. When a string is vibrating, it emits a note with a denite pitch that can be placed on the musical staff, but there are also other, higher notes that come along with it. This mix of overtones gives the sound its characteristic color, or timbre—the quality that distinguishes the sound of a violin from that of a clarinet, even when they play the same note.

As we will see in the next chapter, the frequencies of these overtones are always whole multiples of the string’s lowest, fundamental frequency, so they follow the sequence 1, 2, 3, . . . (relative to the fundamental). In theory

FIGURE 2.4. The circle of fths.

C

A E D G

G

F

B

Major Keys [Annotation 10]

Minor Keys

G (1 sharp)(1 at) F

D (2 sharps)

E (4 sharps)

A (3 sharps)

B (5 sharps)

#### Page 7

STRING THEORY, 500 BCE 19

this series can go on forever, producing an innite blend of ever higher notes. Usually, however, the amplitudes of these overtones, and therefore their intensities, quickly diminish as we go up the sequence, making them increasingly feeble and difcult to hear. Indeed, for nearly two thousand years they remained hidden behind the fundamental tone, barely noticed until the eighteenth century, when a little- known French scientist by the name Joseph Sauveur conrmed their existence (see chapter 3). Never- [Annotation 11] theless, these harmonics play a crucial role in music, for they are the raw material from which the natural musical intervals are derived. The Pythagorean scale, being based solely on the ratio 3:2 while leaving out the remaining harmonics—including such important ratios as 5:4 and 6:5 (a major third and a minor third, respectively)— was therefore out of sync with the laws of acoustics; it was a purely mathematical creation, divorced from physical reality. This was the rst known attempt to impose mathematical rules on music, but it would not be the last.

𝄓

The Pythagorean scale was typical of the Pythagorean philosophy in general. Obsession with musical numerology led Pythagoras’s followers to believe that everything in the universe, from the laws of musical harmony to the motion of the celestial bodies, was governed by simple ratios of whole numbers. To understand this giant leap of faith, we must remember that in Greek tradition music ranked equal in status to arithmetic, geometry, and spherics (astronomy)—the quadrivium comprising the four disciplines every learned person was expected to master, the equivalent of the core curriculum of today’s university. 2 Signicantly, to the Pythagoreans the word “arithmetic” had a different meaning than it has today; it meant number theory, the study of the properties of integers,

#### Page 8

20 CHAPTER 2

rather than the practical skills needed to compute with them. Likewise, they regarded the music component of the quadrivium as referring to music theory, the study of scales and harmony, not the actual art of playing music. This was typical of the aloof attitude of the Pythagoreans to all things practical. Theirs was a perfect universe, governed by notions of beauty, symmetry, and harmony but removed from daily, mundane considerations. It may have been one reason why they kept all their discussions secret, fearing they would be ridiculed by their fellow citizens, the vast majority of whom had to toil daily to eke out a living. None of the Pythagorean writings—if they left any writings at all—survived. All that we know about them came from later writers, who lived hundreds of years after Pythagoras and often outdid each other in extolling the virtues of their revered master.

But if their writings did not survive, the Pythagorean legacy lasted well over two thousand years. Number rules the universe became a rallying motto to generations of scientists and philosophers, who sought to explain the mysteries of the cosmos on the basis of musical ratios or in terms of simple, elegant geometric shapes. The planets, for example, had to move around the Earth in perfect circular orbits; it was inconceivable that any shape other than the perfectly symmetric circle could rule the universe. Thus, by subjugating the laws of nature to their ideals of beauty, harmony, and symmetry, the Pythagoreans may have actually impeded the progress of science for the next two millennia.

One of the last Pythagoreans was the eminent German astronomer Johannes Kepler (1571–1630), considered the father of modern astronomy. Kepler, at once a devout mystic and an ardent believer in the Copernican heliocentric system, spent more than half his life trying to derive the laws of planetary orbits from those of musical harmony.

#### Page 9

STRING THEORY, 500 BCE 21

He believed that each planet, in its orbit around the Sun, plays a tune that our ears are unable to hear, being below the range of audible frequencies (not to mention that it was produced in the vacuum of outer space, where sound cannot propagate). He actually assigned a celestial melody, written down in musical notation, for each of the ve then- known planets (gure 2.5)—the celebrated music of the spheres. It was only after decades, during which he fol- [Annotation 13] lowed this blind path, that Kepler nally abandoned the Greek circular orbits in favor of ellipses, to which Newton, a generation later, would add the parabola and hyperbola.

NOTES 1. This can be seen by rewriting the equation as 3 m = 2 k , where k = m + n. Now the left side of this equation is a power of 3 and is therefore an odd integer, while the right side is a power of 2 and thus even. 2. The term quadrivium is attributed to Boethius (sixth century CE), but

the curriculum it embodied was already outlined in Plato’s The Republic. Together with the trivium (grammar, logic, and rhetoric), it comprised the seven liberal arts of medieval universities.

FIGURE 2.5. Kepler’s planetary music. From Harmonices Mundi, Libri V (Linz: Jo Planck, 1619). [Annotation 12]

Saturn Jupiter

Mars (approx.)

Mercury Here the moon also has a place

Earth Venus

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/string-theory-500-bce. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
