# Shut Up and Calculate

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/shut-up-and-calculate

- **Authors:** Max Tegmark
- **Published:** 2007
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1510213343117-t6x5pye9cj8-10babf649c9d9e9e8b6aa959be356fbc%2F0709.4024+%281%29.pdf
- **Pages:** 3
- **Annotations:** 15 comments in 13 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/shut-up-and-calculate

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Shut up and calculate ∗”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> ‘Shut up and calculate!’ – is a very popular phrase in the quantum theory community to express the attitude of the typical working quantum physicist confronting people who express
> doubts or anxiety over what quantum theory really means. The phrase originated in an article by the physicist David Mermin, which appeared in the journal Physics Today, in 1989. "If I were forced to sum up in one sentence what the Copenhagen interpretation says to me, it would be “Shut up and calculate!”" For more about the history of "Shut up and calculate", see: http://www.physicsandmore.net/resources/Shutupandcalculate.pdf

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The foundation of my argument is the a ssumption that there exists an external physical reality indepe ndent of us humans. T his is not too controversial: I would guess that the majority of physicists favour this lo ng-standing idea, though it is still debated. Metaphysical solipsists reject it ﬂat out, and supporters …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> Max Erik Tegmark is a Swedish-American cosmologist. Tegmark is a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the scientific director of the Foundational Questions Institute. He is also a co-founder of the Future of Life Institute, and has accepted donations from Elon Musk to investigate existential risk from advanced artificial intelligence. His early research focused on cosmology, while his current focus is on artificial intelligence. In August of 2017, he published the book "Life 3.0: Being Human in the Age of Artificial Intelligence".

**Reply** by Conner Downey (2017-12-19):

> Might be worth mentioning his book The Mathematical Universe here too!

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The foundation of my argument is the a ssumption that there exists an external physical reality indepe ndent of us humans. T his is not too controversial: I would guess that the majority of physicists favour this lo ng-standing idea, though it is still debated. Metaphysical solipsists reject it ﬂat out, and supporters …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> Metaphysical solipsism is the variety of idealism which asserts that nothing exists externally to this one mind, and since this mind is the whole of reality then the "external world" was never anything more than an idea: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metaphysical_solipsism

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The foundation of my argument is the a ssumption that there exists an external physical reality indepe ndent of us humans. T his is not too controversial: I would guess that the majority of physicists favour this lo ng-standing idea, though it is still debated. Metaphysical solipsists reject it ﬂat out, and supporters …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> The Copenhagen interpretation was largely devised in the years 1925 to 1927 by Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg. According to the Copenhagen interpretation, physical systems generally do not have definite properties prior to being measured, and quantum mechanics can only predict the probabilities that measurements will produce certain results. The act of measurement affects the system, causing the set of probabilities to reduce to only one of the possible values immediately after the measurement. This feature is known as wave function collapse.
>
> There have been many objections to the Copenhagen interpretation over the years. These include: discontinuous jumps when there is an observation, the probabilistic element introduced upon observation, the subjectiveness of requiring an observer, the difficulty of defining a measuring device, and to the necessity of invoking classical physics to describe the "laboratory" in which the results are measured.
>
> Alternatives to the Copenhagen interpretation include the many-worlds interpretation, the De Broglie–Bohm (pilot-wave) interpretation, and quantum decoherence theories. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copenhagen_interpretation

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The foundation of my argument is the a ssumption that there exists an external physical reality indepe ndent of us humans. T his is not too controversial: I would guess that the majority of physicists favour this lo ng-standing idea, though it is still debated. Metaphysical solipsists reject it ﬂat out, and supporters …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> A theory of everything (ToE), final theory, ultimate theory, or master theory is a hypothetical single, all-encompassing, coherent theoretical framework of physics that fully explains and links together all physical aspects of the universe. Finding a ToE is one of the major unsolved problems in physics. Over the past few centuries, two theoretical frameworks have been developed that, as a whole, most closely resemble a ToE. These two theories upon which all modern physics rests are general relativity and quantum field theory. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_everything

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Mathematics has played a striking role in these successes. The idea that our universe is in some s e nse mathematical goes back at le ast to the Pythagoreans of ancient Gree c e, and has s pawned centuries of discussion among physicists and philosophers. In the 17th century, Galileo fa mously stated that the universe …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> Pythagoras interpreted the Pythagoras theorem and it's universal mathematical truth as divine and it lead him and his followers to believe that numbers and mathematical relations could explain the universe. The Pythagorans believed that before the universe there existed infinity with no limits or structure and that God would have then created a limit upon all things so that infinity would be able to take on an actual size. The Pythagorans were a community of 300 that lived in Croton, southern Italy and lived by structured rules and standards. They worshipped numbers and believed in the divinity of mathematics. No one knows for sure if Pythagoras actually existed or if his theorem is attributable to him or people in the community of Pythagorans. Many believe he is a mythical figure. To read more about Pythagoras and Pythagorans: http://classicalwisdom.com/pythagoras-and-the-revolution-of-mathematics/

### Annotation 7 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Mathematics has played a striking role in these successes. The idea that our universe is in some s e nse mathematical goes back at le ast to the Pythagoreans of ancient Gree c e, and has s pawned centuries of discussion among physicists and philosophers. In the 17th century, Galileo fa mously stated that the universe …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> Galileo famously stated in Il Saggiatore in 1623: "Philosophy is written in this grand book, which stands continually open before our eyes (I say the 'Universe'), but can not be understood without first learning to comprehend the language and know the characters as it is written. It is written in mathematical language, and its characters are triangles, circles and other geometric figures, without which it is impossible to humanly understand a word; without these one is wandering in a dark labyrinth."
> ![Imgur](https://i.imgur.com/qOHs3kZ.png)

### Annotation 8 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Mathematics has played a striking role in these successes. The idea that our universe is in some s e nse mathematical goes back at le ast to the Pythagoreans of ancient Gree c e, and has s pawned centuries of discussion among physicists and philosophers. In the 17th century, Galileo fa mously stated that the universe …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> The conclusion of "The unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics": "Let me end on a more cheerful note. The miracle of the appropriateness of the language of mathematics for the formulation of the laws of physics is a wonderful gift which we neither understand nor deserve. We should be grateful for it and hope that it will remain valid in future research and that it will extend, for better or for worse, to our pleasure, even though perhaps also to our bafflement, to wide branches of learning."
>
>
> Eugene Wigner was a was a Hungarian-American theoretical physicist, engineer and mathematician. He received half of the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1963 "for his contributions to the theory of the atomic nucleus and the elementary particles, particularly through the discovery and application of fundamental symmetry principles." To read the full document: http://www.dartmouth.edu/~matc/MathDrama/reading/Wigner.html

### Annotation 9 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “In contrast, all physics theories that I have bee n taught have two components: mathematical equations, and words that explain how the equations are connected to what we observe and intuitively understand. When we derive the consequences o f a theory, we introduce new concepts — protons, molecules, stars — because …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> This reminds me of Alpha Go Zero, Google DeepMind's neural network that learns to become the best GO player in the world in 1.5 days from scratch, learning in an unsupervised manner. Similarly, perhaps supercomputers could learn in an unsupervised manner and calculate over time how the universe evolves. It could also develop concepts (or not) that are relatable to human terms.

**Reply** by Constantine Black (2019-09-29):

> This brings to my mind philosophical trends where the ontological claims about the world, and the epistemological methods that are valid for acquiring "knowledge" about the world(merely: correlated data under a certain network of interpretations) are in their sense or nature, relational.
> It also brings forth several approaches to quantum mechanics- with the Relational Interpretation of Rovelli Carlo as the most intense- that are pointing out how an objectification of the observational action can't but fail on a conceptual level, hitherto leading to the minimalist approach( or apophatic) of the Copenhagen school(which is not so much on a disagreement with the above, but just admits it's inability to  offer an ontological explanation).
> It finally seems to me, that the name of the paper and the relational approaches( even QFT is based on the notion of interaction more than that of entities) is connected intimately with the modern understanding of correlation- be it  QFT, Statistical Mechanics, Renormalization, Chaotic systems).

### Annotation 10 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “That’s not all, however. The hypothesis also makes a more dramatic prediction: the existence of parallel universes. Many types of “multiverse” have been proposed over the years, and it is use ful to classify them into a fourlevel hierarchy. The ﬁrst three levels corre spond to noncommunicating parallel worlds within …”

**Annotation** by Antonio Guilherme Ferreira Viggiano (2017-11-14):

> [This youtube video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qd28YfV5ZAY) with Neil deGrasse Tyson and Princeton theoretical physicist Paul Steinhardt explains some nice philosophical implications of one of the multiverse theories.

### Annotation 11 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “If that is true, then the theory of everything must be purely abstract and mathematical. Although we do not yet know what the theory would look like, particle physics and cosmology have rea ched a point where all measurements ever made can be explained, at least in principle, with equations that ﬁt on a few pages and …”

**Annotation** by Yasir Suhail (2018-07-10):

> This is a big leap of faith. One could make the fairly un-controversial statement that our physical reality *has* a mathematical structure. Prof. Tegmark says that reality *is* a mathematical structure, and one could interpret it a few different ways. But how does it necessarily follow that everything is *purely* mathematical? One would have to show matter, energy, the fundamental particles and quantum mechanics arising out of some axiomatic basis.

### Annotation 12 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “If that is true, then the theory of everything must be purely abstract and mathematical. Although we do not yet know what the theory would look like, particle physics and cosmology have rea ched a point where all measurements ever made can be explained, at least in principle, with equations that ﬁt on a few pages and …”

**Annotation** by Tymor Hamamsy (2017-11-11):

> In fact, this is already done on a number of [Fermat's library T-shirts](https://teespring.com/stores/fermats-library?aid=marketplace&tsmac=marketplace&tsmic=campaign) ;)

### Annotation 13 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Today’s best estimates suggest that we need a huge amount o f information, perhaps a Googol (10 100 ) bits, to fully describ e our frog’s view of the observable universe, down to the positions of every star and g rain of sand. Most physicists hope for a theory of everything that is much s impler than this and can be …”

**Annotation** by Yasir Suhail (2018-07-10):

> If the multiverse is a *purely* mathematical object, and if we have a theory of *everything*, it should occupy exactly 0 bits of information. Or perhaps a mysterious one bit : that the multiverse exists.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

arXiv:0709.4024v1 [physics.pop-ph] 25 Sep 2007

Shut up and calculate ∗ [Annotation 1]

Max Tegmark Dept. of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139

I advocate an extreme “shut-up-and-calculate” approach to physics, where our external physical reality is assumed to be purely mathematical. This brief essay motivates this “it’s all just equations” assumption and discusses its implications.

What is the meaning of life, the universe and everything? In the sci-ﬁ spoof The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, the answer was found to be 42; the hardest part turned out to be ﬁnding the real question. Indeed, although our inquisitive ancestors undoubtedly asked such big questions, their search for a “theory of everything” evolved as their knowledge gre w . As the ancient Greeks replaced myth-based explanations with mechanistic models of the solar s ystem, their emphasis shifted from asking “why” to asking “how”.

Since then, the scop e of our questioning has dwindled in some areas and mushroomed in others. Some questions were abandoned as naive or misguided, such as explaining the sizes of planetary orbits from ﬁrst principles, which was popular during the Rena issance. The same may happen to currently trendy pursuits like predicting the amount of dark energy in the cosmos, if it turns out that the amount in our neighbourhood is a histo rical accident. Yet our ability to answer other questions has surpassed earlier generations’ wildest expectations: Newton would have been amazed to know that we would one day measure the age of our universe to an accuracy of 1 per cent, and comprehend the microworld well enough to make an iPhone.

Mathematics has played a striking role in these successes. The idea that our universe is in some s e nse math- [Annotation 6] ematical goes back at le ast to the Pythagoreans of ancient Gree c e, and has s pawned centuries of discussion among physicists and philosophers. In the 17th century, Galileo fa mously stated that the universe is a “grand book” written in the language of mathematics. More [Annotation 7] recently, the physics Nobel laureate Eugene Wigner argued in the 196 0s that “the unre asonable eﬀectiveness of [Annotation 8] mathematics in the natural sc ience s” demanded an explanation.

Here, I will push this idea to its extreme and argue that our universe is not just described by mathematics — it is mathematics. While this hypothesis might sound rather abstract and far-fetched, it makes startling predictions about the structure of the universe that could be testable by observations. It should also be useful in narrowing down what an ultimate theo ry of everything can loo k like.

∗ This is the “director’s cut” version of the September 15 2007 New Scientist cover story. The “full strength” version is the much longer article [1], which includes references.

The foundation of my argument is the a ssumption that [Annotation 2] there exists an external physical reality indepe ndent of us humans. T his is not too controversial: I would guess that the majority of physicists favour this lo ng-standing idea, [Annotation 3] though it is still debated. Metaphysical solipsists reject it ﬂat out, and supporters of the so-called Copenhagen interpre tation of quantum mechanics may reject it on the grounds that there is no reality without observation (New [Annotation 4] Scientist, 23 June, p 30). Assuming an external reality exists, physics theories aim to describe how it works. O ur most successful theo ries, such as general relativity and quantum mechanics, describe o nly parts of this rea lity: gravity, for instance, or the behaviour of subatomic particles. In contrast, the holy g rail of theoretical physics is a theory of everything — a complete description of reality. [Annotation 5]

My personal quest for this theory begins with a n extreme argument about what it is a llowed to look like. If we as sume that reality exists independently o f humans, then for a description to be complete, it must also be well-deﬁned according to non-human entities — aliens or supe rcomputers, say — that lack any understanding of human concepts. Put diﬀerently, such a description must be expressible in a form that is devoid of any human baggage like “particle”, “observation” or other English words.

In contrast, all physics theories that I have bee n taught have two components: mathematical equations, and words that explain how the equations are connected to what we observe and intuitively understand. When we derive the consequences o f a theory, we introduce new concepts — protons, molecules, stars — because they are convenient. It is important to remember, however, that it is we humans w ho create these concepts; in principle, everything c ould be c alculated without this baggage. For example, a suﬃciently powerful supercomputer could calculate how the state of the universe evolves over time without interpre ting what is happening in human terms. [Annotation 9]

All of this raises the question: is it possible to ﬁnd a description of externa l reality that involves no baggage? If so, such a description of objects in this external reality and the relations between them would have to be completely abstract, forcing any words or symbols to be mere labels with no preconceived meanings whatsoever. Instead, the only properties of these entities would be those embodied by the rela tions between them.

This is where mathematics comes in. To a modern logician, a mathematical structure is precisely this: a set of abstract entities with relations between them. Take the integers, for instance, or ge ometric objects like the do-

#### Page 2

2

decahedron, a favourite of the Pythagorea ns. This is in stark contrast to the way most of us ﬁrst perceive mathematics — either as a sadistic form of punishment, or as a bag of tricks for manipulating numbers. Like physics, mathematics has evolved to as k broader questions.

Modern mathematics is the formal study of structures that can be deﬁned in a purely abstract way. Think of mathematical symbols as mere labels without intrinsic meaning. It doesn’t ma tter whether you write “two plus two equals four”, “2 + 2 = 4” or “dos mas dos igual a cuatro”. The notation used to denote the entities and the relations is irrelevant; the only properties of integers are those embodied by the relations between them. That is , we don’t invent mathematical structures — we discover them, and invent only the notation for describing them.

So here is the crux of my arg ument. If you believe in an external r e ality independent of humans, then you must also believe in what I call the mathematical universe hypothesis: that our physical reality is a mathematical structure. In other words, we all live in a g igantic mathematical object — one that is more elaborate than a dodecahedron, and probably also more complex than objects with intimidating names like Calabi-Yau manifolds, tensor bundles and Hilbert spaces , which appea r in today’s most advanced theories . Everything in our world is purely mathematical — including you.

If that is true, then the theory of everything must be purely abstract and mathematical. Although we do not yet know what the theory would look like, particle physics [Annotation 11] and cosmology have rea ched a point where all measurements ever made can be explained, at least in principle, with equations that ﬁt on a few pages and involve merely 32 unexplained numerical constants (Physical Review D, vol 73, 023505). So it seems possible that the cor rect theory of everything could even turn out to be simple [Annotation 12] enough to describe with equations that ﬁt on a T-shirt.

Before discussing whether the mathematical universe hypothesis is correct, however, there is a more urgent question: what does it actually mean? To understand this, it helps to distinguish between two ways of viewing our external physical re ality. One is the outside overview of a physicist studying its mathematical str ucture, like a bird surveying a landsc ape from high above; the o ther is the inside view of an obse rver living in the world described by the structure, like a frog liv ing in the landscape s urveyed by the bird.

One issue in relating these two perspectives involves time. A mathematical structure is by deﬁnition an abstract, immutable entity ex isting outside of space and time. If the history of our universe were a movie, the structure would corres po nd not to a single frame but to the entire DVD. So from the bird’s perspective, trajectories of objects moving in four-dimensional space-time resemble a ta ngle of spaghetti. Where the frog sees something moving with constant velocity, the bird sees a straight strand of uncooked spaghetti. Where the frog sees the moon orbit the Earth, the bird sees two intertwined spa ghetti strands. To the frog, the world is de-

scribed by Newton’s laws of motion and gravitation. To the bird, the world is the geometry of the pasta.

A further subtlety in relating the two perspectives involves explaining how an observer could be purely mathematical. In this example, the frog itself must consist of a thick bundle o f pa sta whose highly complex structure corresponds to particles that store and process information in a way that gives rise to the familiar sensation of self-awareness.

Fine, so how do we test the mathematical universe hypothesis? For a start, it predicts that further mathematical r egularities remain to be discovered in nature. Ever since Galileo promulgated the idea of a mathematical cosmos, there has been a steady progression of discoveries in that vein, including the standard mo del of particle physics, which captures striking mathematical order in the microcosm of elementary particles and the macrocosm of the early universe.

That’s not all, however. The hypothesis also makes a more dramatic prediction: the existence of parallel universes. Many types of “multiverse” have been proposed [Annotation 10] over the years, and it is use ful to classify them into a fourlevel hierarchy. The ﬁrst three levels corre spond to noncommunicating parallel worlds within the same mathematical structure: level I simply means distant regions from which light has not yet had time to reach us; level II covers regions that are fore ver unr eachable because of the cosmologic al inﬂation of intervening space; and le vel III, often called “many worlds”, involves non-communicating parts of the so-called Hilbert space of quantum mechanics into which the universe can “split” during certa in quantum events. Level IV refers to parallel worlds in distinct mathematical structures, which may have fundamentally diﬀerent laws of physics.

Today’s best estimates suggest that we need a huge amount o f information, perhaps a Googol (10 100 ) bits, to fully describ e our frog’s view of the observable universe, down to the positions of every star and g rain of sand. Most physicists hope for a theory of everything that is much s impler than this and can be speciﬁed in few enough bits to ﬁt in a book, if not on a T-shirt. The mathematical universe hypothesis implies that such a s imple theory must predict a multiverse. Why? Because this theory is by deﬁnition a complete description of reality: if it lacks enough bits to completely specify our universe, then it must instead describe a ll possible combinations of stars, sand grains and such — so that the extra bits that des c ribe our universe simply encode which [Annotation 13] universe we are in, like a multiversal telephone number. In this way, describing a multiverse can be simpler than describing a single universe.

Pushed to its extreme, the mathematical universe hypothesis implies the level-IV multiverse, which includes all the other levels within it. If there is a par ticula r mathematical structure that is our universe, and its properties correspond to our physical laws, then each mathematical structure with diﬀerent properties is its own universe with diﬀerent laws. Indeed, the level-IV multiverse is

#### Page 3

3

compulsory, since mathematical str uctures are not “created” and don’t exist “somewhere” — they just exist. Stephen Hawking o nce asked, “What is it that breathes ﬁre into the equations and makes a universe for them to describe?” In the case of the mathematical cosmos, there is no ﬁre-breathing required, since the point is not that a mathematical structure describes a universe, but that it is a universe.

The existence of the level-IV multiverse also answers a confounding questio n emphasised by the physicist John Wheeler: even if we found equations that describe our universe perfectly, then why these particular equations, not others? The answer is that the other equations govern parallel universes, and that our universe has these particular equations becaus e they are sta tistica lly likely, given the distribution of mathematical structures that can s upport observers like us.

It is crucia l to ask whether para llel universes are within the purview of science, or are merely speculation. Parallel universes are not a theory in themselves, but rather a prediction made by certain theories. For a theory to be falsiﬁable, we need not be able to observe and test all its predictions, merely at least one of them. General re lativity, for instance, has successfully predicted many things that we can observe, such as gravitational lensing, so we also take seriously its predictions for things we cannot, like the internal structure of black holes.

So here’s a testable prediction of the mathematical universe hypothesis: if we exist in many parallel universes, then we sho uld expect to ﬁnd ourselves in a typical one. Suppose we succeed in computing the probability distribution for some quantity, say the dark energy density or the dimensionality of space, mea sured by a typical observer in the part of the multiverse where this quantity is deﬁned. If we ﬁnd that this distribution makes the value measured in our own universe highly atypical, it would rule out the multiverse, and hence the mathematical universe hypothesis. Although we are still far from understanding the requirements for life, we could start testing the multiverse prediction by assessing how typical our universe is as regards dark matter, dark energy and neutrinos, because these substances aﬀect only better understood pr ocesses like galax y formation. This prediction has passed the ﬁrst of such tests, bec ause the abundance

of these substances has been measur e d to be rather typical of what you might measure from a ra ndom galaxy in a multiverse. However, more accur ate calculations and measurements mig ht still rule out such a multiverse.

Ultimately, why should we believe the mathematical universe hypothesis? Perhaps the most compelling objection is that it feels counter-intuitive and disturbing. I personally dismiss this as a failure to a ppreciate Darwinian evolution. Evolution endowed us with intuition only for those aspects of physics that had survival value for our distant ancestors, such as the parabolic trajectories of ﬂying rocks. Darwin’s theory thus makes the testable prediction that whenever we look beyond the human scale, our evolved intuition should break down.

We have repeatedly tested this prediction, and the re - sults overwhelmingly support it: our intuition breaks down at high speeds, where time slows down; on small scales, where particles can be in two places at once; and at high temperatures, where colliding particles change identity. To me, an electron colliding with a positron and turning into a Z-boson feels about as intuitive as two colliding car s turning into a cruise ship. The point is that if we dismiss s e e mingly weird theories out of hand, we risk dismissing the corre c t theory of e verything, whatever it may turn out to be.

If the mathematica l universe hypothesis is true, then it is grea t news for science, a llowing the p ossibility that an elegant uniﬁcation of physics and mathematics will one day allow us to understand reality more deeply than most dreamed possible. Indeed, I think the mathematical cosmos with its multiverse is the best theor y of everything that we could hope for, because it would mean that no aspect of r e ality is oﬀ-limits from our scientiﬁc quest to uncover reg ularities and make quantitative predictions.

However, it would also s hift the ultimate question about the universe once again. We would abandon as misguided the question of which particular mathematical equations describe all of r e ality, and instead ask how to compute the frog’s view of the universe — o ur observations — fro m the bird’s view. That would determine whether we have uncovered the true structure of our universe, and help us ﬁgur e out which corner of the mathematical cosmos is our home.

[1] M Tegmark 2007, “The Mathematical Universe”, arXiv

0704.0646 [gr-qc], submitted to Foundations of Physics

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/shut-up-and-calculate. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
