# Search for Artificial Stellar Sources of Infrared Radiation

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/search-for-artificial-stellar-sources-of-infrared-radiation

- **Authors:** Freeman Dyson
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1509775684211-unawp1xhw1e-2bd03c791d081ac8a0639cd115e44878%2Fdyson1960c.pdf
- **Pages:** 1
- **Annotations:** 15 comments in 9 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/search-for-artificial-stellar-sources-of-infrared-radiation

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “drive an intelligent species to adopt some such efficient exploitation of its available resources. One should expect that, within a few thousand years of its entering the stage of industrial development, any intelligent species should be found occupying an artificial biosphere which completely surrounds its parent …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2017-11-07):

> Interesting interview with Freeman Dyson. He originally used the name **"Artificial Biosphere"** to describe an inhabited alien region that would radiate in the infrared band but **science fiction writers started using the term "Dyson Sphere"** to describe this concept.
>
> [![](https://i.imgur.com/anC2Qdz.png)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GPB775_BZlw)

**Reply** by Gregor Gross (2019-10-28):

> ... but Dyson is not speaking of a sphere in a geometrical sense, he is speaking of a biosphere. He is asking us to look for Dyson artificial biospheres in the form of a ring, actually.

**Reply** by Mário João (2023-03-24):

> @Gregor Gross: Dyson specifically mentions on this paper a "spherical shell revolving around the sun". I believe the ring designs (and all others) came after this paper was published. As Dyson himself said on the video above: thinking big!

**Reply** by Gregor Gross (2023-03-24):

> I have to admit I was surprised when I heard of this different ways of understand a sphere as well. And I can't find the reference anymore, even as I collect these references quite strictly usually. If I remember correctly, it was mentioned in this regard that it's not so easy to build an entire sphere around a sun because of material stress by weight and heat radiation. Also, the material itself is really alot when it's a full sphere around a sun, whereas a ring around it is still colossal, but within realistic reach. And a ring around the sun already offers the space of 10,000 Earth or so?

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “events if these beings had originated in a solar system identical with ours. Taking our own solar system as the model, we shall reach at least a possible picture of what may be expected to happen elsewhere. I do not argue that this is what will happen in our system; I only say that this is what may have happened in …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-11-04):

> This paper constitutes the first attempt to formalize the concept of a Dyson Sphere. A Dyson Sphere is a hypothetical structure that an advanced civilization
> might build around a star to intercept all of the star’s light
> for its energy needs.
>
> ![](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/5/5f/Dyson_Sphere_Diagram-en.svg/900px-Dyson_Sphere_Diagram-en.svg.png)
>
> Freeman Dyson argues that a way to look for extraterrestrial life is to search for the presence of Dyson Spheres.
>
> The basic idea is that as a civilization evolves it will have increasingly energy requirements. Once all the resources of the home planet have been explored the next obvious step is to get energy from the closest star.
>
> According to the Kardashev scale there are 3 types of civilizations based on the amount of energy a civilization is able to use:
>
> - **Type I** - can use and store all of the energy which reaches its planet from its parent star.
> - **Type II** - can harness the total energy of its planet's parent star.
> - **Type III** - can control energy on the scale of its entire host galaxy.
>
> Humans are currently a Type 0 civilization and Michio Kaku predicts that we attain Type I status in 100–200 years, Type II status in a few thousand years, and Type III status in 100,000 to a million years.

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “events if these beings had originated in a solar system identical with ours. Taking our own solar system as the model, we shall reach at least a possible picture of what may be expected to happen elsewhere. I do not argue that this is what will happen in our system; I only say that this is what may have happened in …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-11-05):

> Even if the civilization living in the Dyson sphere did its best to store available energy, the sphere would eventually start increasing its temperature and radiating energy away until thermal equilibrium is reached.
>
> We can assume that the sphere is a black body (it absorbs all incident electromagnetic radiation from the star) and in thermal equilibrium it behaves according to the [Stefan–Boltzmann law](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan%E2%80%93Boltzmann_law):
>
> $$
> P=\sigma A T^4
> $$
>
> where $\sigma = 5.67 \times 10^{-8}\text{Wm$^{-2}$K$^{-4}$}$ is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant, A is the area of the body, P is the total power emitted by the body and T is the temperature of the body.
>
> For a Dyson sphere with the size of Earth's orbit (1AU = $1.5\times 10^{11}$m) the temperature of the sphere is just
>
> $$
> T = \sqrt[4]{\frac{3.8\times 10^{26}}{5.67 \times 10^{-8}4 \pi (1.5\times 10^{11})^2}} \approx 393 K (120^{\circ}C)
> $$
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/TCTTYjB.png)
>
> Note that P is just the power output of the Sun: $3.8\times 10^{26} W$.
> Although 393 K is still very hot for a Earthlike environment, there are still a few factors that we haven't considered and that might decrease the temperature such as rotation of the Dyson Sphere (Earth's rotation contributes to decrease the temperature at the surface of the planet, halving its energy flux).
>
> That's why Freeman Dyson concludes the temperature of the sphere falls in the interval 200 K - 300 K.
>
> Note that if someone wanted to design an invisible sphere - something that would radiate at the same temperature as the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (2.73 K) -  it would have a radius of 328 light years!

**Reply** by Graham Lau (2020-03-10):

> True, but Dyson in the paper suggests a radius of 2 AU ("...revolving around the sun at twice the Earth's distance..."), which would give about 277 K.
>
> Cool to think about the sphere size for only radiation at the CMB, though - thanks for that!

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “If the foregoing argument is accepted, then the search for extraterrestrial intelligent beings should not be confined to the neighborhood of visible stars. The most likely habitat for such beings would be a dark object, having a size comparable with the Earth's orbit, and a surface temperature of 2000 to 3000K. Such a …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-11-05):

> To determine the radiation emitted by the sphere we use Wien's Law - the black body radiation curve peaks at a wavelength inversely proportional to the temperature.
>
> $$
> \lambda_{max} = \frac{b}{T}
> $$
>
> where b is the Wien's displacement constant:  $2.898×10^{−3}mK$.
>
> For this Dyson Sphere, if we replace T with 300 K we get$\lambda_{max} \approx 10 $ microns.

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “events if these beings had originated in a solar system identical with ours. Taking our own solar system as the model, we shall reach at least a possible picture of what may be expected to happen elsewhere. I do not argue that this is what will happen in our system; I only say that this is what may have happened in …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-11-07):

> There's a problem in the argument of Cocconi and Morrison. They assume the extraterrestrial beings would be to some extent cooperative in the sense that they would use radio signals to communicate between them and possibly with us. Freeman's idea allows us to search for extraterrestrial life even if they are not cooperative.

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “events if these beings had originated in a solar system identical with ours. Taking our own solar system as the model, we shall reach at least a possible picture of what may be expected to happen elsewhere. I do not argue that this is what will happen in our system; I only say that this is what may have happened in …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-11-05):

> It's interesting because we can now test Freeman's assumption regarding the world's energy consumption.
>
> In 2013 the estimated world energy consumption was $1.8 \times 10^{20}$ erg per second. This means the average growth since 1960 was 1.1%! Freeman's prediction has been right for the past 57 years.
>
> ![](https://gailtheactuary.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/world-energy-consumption-by-source.png)

**Reply** by Mário João (2023-03-24):

> From 1960 to 2021 I got an annual compounded growth rate of around 2.4%, which, I believe is what Dyson meant with his "average growth rate of 1 percent" as compounded over 3000 iterations it arrives at a factor of 10^12. So we've actually been surpassing his prediction and should disassemble Jupiter within 1300 to 1500 years from now?

### Annotation 7 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “If the foregoing argument is accepted, then the search for extraterrestrial intelligent beings should not be confined to the neighborhood of visible stars. The most likely habitat for such beings would be a dark object, having a size comparable with the Earth's orbit, and a surface temperature of 2000 to 3000K. Such a …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-11-06):

> There are a few things extra things we can discuss about the Dyson Sphere:
>
> ### Can the Dyson Sphere break due to gravity?
>
> To calculate the stress on the sphere let's first consider a small section with angular radius $\theta << 1$.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/K8kt96H.png)
>
> The mass of the section is just $m=\pi (r\theta)^2d\rho$, where $\rho$ is the density of the material and d is its thickness. The stress will generate a force pointing outwards with magnitude $2\pi(r\theta)T\sin \theta$ (where T is the force per unit length) that will oppose the gravitational force of the star.
>
> $$
> 2\pi(r\theta)T\sin \theta = \frac{GM\pi r^2 \theta^2 d \rho}{r^2}
> $$
>
> Since $\theta << 1$, $\sin \theta \approx \theta$ and
>
> $$
> T = \frac{GM \rho}{2rd}
> $$
> The Pressure is just $P=Td=\frac{GM \rho}{2r}$, which for a our Dyson Sphere is around $2.4\times10^{12}$ N/m$^2$. Such material strength is very difficult to attain since a typical chemical bond can resist a force of the order of 1 eV/Å ≈ 10$^{−9}$ N. The unit area will have of the order of $10^{20}$ chemical bonds in the perpendicular direction, hence can support at most ∼ $10^{11}$ N, even if all the bonds are perfectly aligned without any imperfections in the molecular structure, and are able to share the load equally.
>
> ### Stability
>
> The way to look at the stability question is to analyze the force applied inside the sphere using Gauss's Law: the flux of the force field across an arbitrary closed surface is proportional to the amount of mass inside it.
>
> $$
> \int F dA \propto \rho
> $$
>
> Since there's no mass inside the closed surface the integral is zero, which means the force inside the Dyson Sphere is also zero.
>
> This might be dangerous because any force applied on the sphere (e.g meteor collision) will cause it to drift and eventually hit the star.
>
>
> ### It can convert energy from trash
>
> Any trash released from the sphere would immediately fall into the star turning into energy. There's a potential danger in dumping too much waste into the star as it might push it over the mass limit of instability setting off a Supernova.
>
> ### Other types of structures
>
> After this paper was published people came up with other hypothetical structures such as:
>
> - **RingWorlds** - Introduced by Larry Niven, a ringworld is band encircling a band encircling a star, rotating to create gravity and covered with an ecosphere.
> - **Submerged Dyson Spheres** - these structures were proposed by Nick Szabo and are spheres built considerably closer to the star. These spheres would solve the communication delay problem that occurs in a "normal" Dyson Sphere due to its size and would also be more suitable for advanced "solid state civilizations".

**Reply** by Viraj Shah (2018-02-01):

> Hi, I may be misinterpreting here but what is the solid angle/volume element you're considering when you talk about the section of mass?
>
> \begin{equation}
> dm = \rho *dV
> \end{equation}
> \begin{equation}
> dV = \pi (r \theta)^2d
> \end{equation}
> In other words, where is your $dV$ coming from?

### Annotation 8 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “events if these beings had originated in a solar system identical with ours. Taking our own solar system as the model, we shall reach at least a possible picture of what may be expected to happen elsewhere. I do not argue that this is what will happen in our system; I only say that this is what may have happened in …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-11-05):

> After Freeman Dyson published this paper [SETI](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Search_for_extraterrestrial_intelligence) started searching for "infrared heavy" spectra from solar analogs. As of 2005 Fermilab has an ongoing survey for such spectra by analyzing data from the Infrared Astronomical Satellite (IRAS). So far Fermilab discovered 17 potential "ambiguous" candidates, of which four have been named "amusing but still questionable".
>
> The last event was on August 25th 2016, when scientists observed dimmings of up to 65% in a young M-type pre-main-sequence star with a resolved disk. The researchers hypothesize that the irregular dimmings are caused by either a warped inner-disk edge or transiting cometary-like objects in either circular or eccentric orbits.

### Annotation 9 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “FREEMAN J. DYSON Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, New Jersey”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2017-11-04):

> Freeman Dyson is an English-born American theoretical physicist and mathematician. He is professor emeritus at the Institute for Advanced Study and worked on several areas including quantum electrodynamics, solid-state physics, astronomy and nuclear engineering. ![](http://www.irishtimes.com/polopoly_fs/1.1795447.1400081217!/image/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/box_620_330/image.jpg)

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

Reports

Search for Artificial Stellar

Sources of Infrared Radiation

A bstract. If extraterrestrial intelligent beings exist and have reached a high level of technical development, one by-product of their energy metabolism is likely to be the large-scale conversion of starlight into far-infrared radiation. It is proposed that a search for sources of infrared radiation should accompany the recently initiated search for interstellar radio communications.

Cocconi and Morrison (1) have called attention to the importance and feasibility of listening for radio signals transmitted by extraterrestrial intelligent beings. They propose that listening aerials be directed toward nearby stars which might be accompanied by planets carrying such beings. Their proposal is now being implemented (2). The purpose of this report is to point out other possibilities which ought to be considered in planning any serious search for evidence of extraterrestrial intelligent beings. We start from the notion that the time scale for industrial and technical development of these beings is likely to be very short in comparison with the time scale of stellar evolution. It is therefore overwhelmingly probable that any such beings observed by us will have been in existence for millions of years, and will have already reached a technological level surpassing ours by many orders of magnitude. It is then a reasonable working hypothesis that their habitat will have been expanded to the limits set by Malthusian principles. We have no direct knowledge of the material conditions which these beings would encounter in their search for lebensraum. We therefore consider what would be the likely course of

Instructions for preparing reports. Begin the report with an abstract of from 45 to 55 words. The abstract should not repeat phrases employed in the title. It should work with the title to give the reader a summary of the results presented in the report proper. Type manuscripts double-spaced and submit one ribbon copy and one carbon copy. Limit the report proper to the equivalent of 1200 words. This space includes that occupied by illustrative material as well as by the references and notes. Limit illustrative material to one 2-column figure (that is, a figure whose width equals two columns of text) or to one 2-column table or to two I-column illustrations, which may consist of two figures or two tables or one of each. For further details see "Suggestions to Contributors" [Science 125, 16 (1957)].

3 JUNE 1960

events if these beings had originated in a solar [Annotation 2] system identical with ours. Taking our own solar system as the model, we shall reach at least a possible [Annotation 3] picture of what may be expected to happen elsewhere. I do not argue that this is what will happen in our system; I only say that this is what may have happened in other systems. The material factors which ultimately limit the expansion of a technically advanced species are the supply of matter and the supply of energy. At present the material resources being exploited by the [Annotation 5] human species are roughly limited to the biosphere of the earth, a mass of the order of 5 X 10' grams. Our present energy supply may be generously estimated [Annotation 6] at 1 0' ergs per second. The quantities of matter and energy which might conceivably become accessible to us within the solar system are 2 x 1030 grams (the mass of Jupiter) and 4 X 1033 ergs per second (the total energy output of the sun). The reader may well ask in what sense can anyone speak of the mass of Jupiter or the total radiation from the sun as being accessible to exploitation. The following argument is intended to show that an exploitation of this magnitude is not absurd. First of all, the time required for an expansion of population and industry by a factor of 1012 is quite short, say 3000 years if an average growth rate of 1 percent per year is maintained. Second, the energy required to disassemble and rearrange a planet of the size of Jupiter is about 1044 ergs, equal to the energy radiated by the sun in 800 years. Third, the mass of Jupiter, if distributed in a spherical shell revolving around the [Annotation 8] sun at twice the Earth's distance from it, would have a thickness such that the mass is 200 grams per square centimeter of surface area (2 to 3 meters, depending on the density). A shell of this thickness could be made comfortably habitable, and could contain all the machinery required for exploiting the solar radiation falling onto it from the inside. It is remarkable that the time scale of industrial expansion, the mass of Jupiter, the energy output of the sun, and the thickness of a habitable biosphere all have consistent orders of magnitude. It seems, then, a reasonable expectation that, barring accidents, Malthusian pressures will ultimately

drive an intelligent species to adopt some such efficient exploitation of its available resources. One should expect that, within a few thousand years of its entering the stage of industrial development, any intelligent species should be found occupying an artificial biosphere which completely surrounds its parent star. [Annotation 1]

If the foregoing argument is accepted, then the search for extraterrestrial intelligent beings should not be confined to the neighborhood of visible stars. The most likely habitat for such beings would be a dark object, having a size comparable with the Earth's orbit, and a surface temperature of 2000 to 3000K. Such a dark object would be radiating as copiously as the star which is hidden inside it, but the radiation would be in the [Annotation 4] far infrared, around 10 microns wavelength. It happens that the earth's atmosphere is transparent to radiation with wavelength in the range from 8 to 12 microns. It is therefore feasible to search for "infrared stars" in this range of wavelengths, using existing telescopes on the earth's surface. Radiation in this range from Mars and Venus [Annotation 7] has not only been detected but has been spectroscopically analyzed in some detail (3). I propose, then, that a search for point sources of infrared radiation be attempted, either independently or in conjunction with the search for artificial radio emissions. A scan of the entire sky for objects down to the 5th or 6th magnitude would be desirable, but is probably beyond the capability of existing techniques of detection. If an undirected scan is impossible, it would be worthwhile as a preliminary measure to look for anomalously intense radiation in the 10-micron range associated with visible stars. Such radiation might be seen in the neighborhood of a visible star under either of two conditions. A race of intelligent beings might be unable to exploit fully the energy radiated by their star because of an insufficiency of accessible matter, or they might live in an artificial biosphere surrounding one star of a multiple system, in which one or more component stars are unsuitable for exploitation and would still be visible to us. It is impossible to guess the probability that either of these circumstances would arise for a particular race of extraterrestrial intelligent beings. But it is reasonable to begin the search for infrared radiation of artificial origin by looking in the direction of nearby visible stars, and especially in the direction of stars which are known to be binaries with invisible companions.

FREEMAN J. DYSON [Annotation 9] Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, New Jersey

1667

on September 19, 2012www.sciencemag.orgDownloaded from

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/search-for-artificial-stellar-sources-of-infrared-radiation. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
