# Evidence for Oscillation of Atmospheric Neutrinos

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/oscillation-of-atmospheric-neutrinos

- **Authors:** Super-Kamiokande Collaboration
- **Published:** 1998
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** http://journals.aps.org/prl/pdf/10.1103/PhysRevLett.81.1562
- **Pages:** 6
- **Annotations:** 14 comments in 11 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/oscillation-of-atmospheric-neutrinos

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Evidence for Oscillation of Atmospheric Neutrinos”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> Curiosity: This paper is mentioned in two different Physics Nobel Prize ceremonies 2002 and 2015. See here: [Physical Review Letters.](http://journals.aps.org/prl/50years/milestones#1998)

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “rays with nuclei in the upper atmosphere. Production”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-12):

> Atmospheric neutrinos are produced in hadronic showers that result from the interaction of a cosmic ray at the top of the atmosphere. The cosmic rays start a cascade of reactions that produce pions that will decay and produce neutrinos.

**Reply** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-12):

> ![hadronic shower](http://www.mpi-hd.mpg.de/hfm/CosmicRay/shower.png "Hadronic Shower")

### Annotation 3 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “s; n m yn e d of the ﬂux of n m 1 n m to the ﬂux of n e 1 n e of about 2. The n m yn e ratio has been calculated in detail with an uncertainty of less than 5% over a broad range of energies from 0.1 to 10 GeV [1,2].”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-12):

> There are three flavours of neutrinos (electron, muon, tau):
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> e - \nu_e\\
> \mu - \nu_\mu\\
> \tau - \nu_\tau\\
> \end{eqnarray*}
> (and the corresponding antineutrinos)

**Reply** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> ![Leptons](http://thumbsnap.com/sc/7wsSurZQ.jpg "Leptons table")

### Annotation 4 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “The n m yn e ﬂux ratio is measured in deep underground experiments by observing ﬁnal state leptons produced via charged-current interactions of neutrinos on nuclei, n1 N!l1X. The ﬂavor of the ﬁnal state lepton is used to identify the ﬂavor of the incoming neutrino.”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-12):

> It is very hard to detect neutrinos. Neutrinos are electrically neutral, so they are not affected by Electromagnetism; they are leptons so they are not affected by the Strong force. So they are only affected by the Weak force (short range interaction) and Gravity (extremly weak at the subatomic scale). Neutrinos are detected indirectly via their weak interactions with matter where they produce the charged leptons associated with them.

**Reply** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> Picture of the first neutrino observation in a Bubble chamer (1970) via it's charged current interaction with a proton. Once can see that the neutrino detection is made indirectly by studying the paths of the particles produced when the neutrino interaction with matter occurred.
>
> ![first neutrino](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/57/FirstNeutrinoEventAnnotated.jpg)

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “where E n is the neutrino energy, u is the mixing angle between the ﬂavor eigenstates and the mass eigenstates, and Dm 2 is the mass squared difference of the neutrino mass eigenstates. For detectors near the surface of the Earth, the neutrino ﬂight distance, and thus the oscillation probability, is a function of the …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> Let us compute the oscillation probability. Consider a two Neutrino oscillation hypothesis from flavour a to flavour b, ($\nu_a\,,\nu_b$):
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> \left(\begin{array}{c}
> \nu_{a} \\
> \nu_{b} \\
> \end{array}\right) &=& \left(\begin{array}{cc}
> cos{\theta} & sin{\theta} \\
>  -sin{\theta} & cos{\theta} \\
> \end{array}\right)
> \left(\begin{array}{c}
> \nu_{1} \\
> \nu_{2} \\
> \end{array}\right)
> \end{eqnarray*}
> In bra-ket notation:
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> \newcommand{\ket}[1]{|#1\rangle}
> \newcommand{\bra}[1]{\langle #1|}
> \ket{\nu_a} &=& \cos\theta\ket{\nu_1} + \sin\theta\ket{\nu_2}\\
> \ket{\nu_b} &=& -\sin\theta\ket{\nu_1} + \cos\theta\ket{\nu_2}
> \end{eqnarray*}
> Using the Schrödinger equation one can write the mass eigenstates of a particle as:
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> \ket{\nu_1(t)} &=& e^{-iE_1t}\ket{\nu_1} = e^{-i\sqrt{m_1^2+p_1^2}\,t}\ket{\nu_1} \nonumber\\
> &\simeq& e^{-i(p+\frac{m_1^2}{2p})t}\ket{\nu_1}\\
> \ket{\nu_2(t)} &\simeq& e^{-i(p+\frac{m_2^2}{2p})t}\ket{\nu_2}
> \end{eqnarray*}
> In natural units the energy of any given mass eigenstate $i$ can be written as: $E_i=\sqrt{m_i^2+p^2}\simeq p+\frac{m_i^2}{2p}$ where we consider that  $m\ll p$. One can then rewrite the wave function for a flavour a neutrino ($\nu_a$) as:
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> \ket{\nu_a(t)} &=& c\ket{\nu_1(t)} + s\ket{\nu_2(t)}\\
> &\simeq& e^{-ip}\left( ce^{-i\frac{m_1^2}{2p}t}\ket{\nu_1} + se^{-i\frac{m_2^2}{2p}t}\ket{\nu_2} \right)
> \end{eqnarray*}
> where $c \equiv \cos\theta$ and $s\equiv \sin\theta$. We do the same for flavour b ($\nu_b$) and then compute the probability function for the oscillation from flavour $\ket{\nu_a}$ to flavout $\ket{\nu_b}$ as:
>  \begin{eqnarray*}
>
> P_{\nu_a\rightarrow \nu_b}(t) &=& \left| \left< \nu_b | \nu_a(t) \right> \right|^2 \nonumber \\
> &=& \left|  -sce^{-i\frac{m_1^2}{2p}t} + cse^{-i\frac{m_2^2}{2p}t} \right|^2 \nonumber \\
> &=& 2s^2c^2 \left(  1-\cos{\frac{m_1^2-m_2^2}{2p}t}  \right) \nonumber  \\
> &\simeq& \sin^2(2\theta)\sin^2(\delta_{12})
> \end{eqnarray*}
> where:\begin{eqnarray*}
> \delta_{ij} = \frac{c^3}{\hbar}\frac{\Delta m_{ij}^2}{4E} L \simeq \frac{\Delta m_{ij}^2}{2p} L  \simeq 1.27\, \frac {\Delta m_{ij}^2}{E} L
> \end{eqnarray*} with $\Delta m^2_{ij}=m^2_i-m^2_j$ and again we use natural units so that $t \simeq L$, $p \simeq E$, $L$ (km) is the distance travelled by the neutrino $E$ (GeV) the neutrino energy $\theta$ mixing angle. So finally one can write:
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> P_{\nu_a \rightarrow \nu_b} \left( L/E \right) &=& sin^2\left( 2\theta \right) \, sin^2\left( 1.27\,\Delta m^2 L/E \right).\\
> \end{eqnarray*}

### Annotation 6 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “exhibit no excess of e-like events close to the ﬁducial boundary [6,7].”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> Figure 1 (bottom) shows a strong asymmetry for $\mu$-like events detected by Super-Kamiokande. The hatched region shows the Monte Carlo results considering no neutrino oscillations. We see that the data (black dots) deviate from these predictions. The dashed line corresponds to $$\nu_\mu \leftrightarrow \nu_\tau$$ oscillations and seems to be fairly consistent with the observations.

### Annotation 7 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “We have examined the hypotheses of two-ﬂavor n m $ n e and n m $ n t oscillation models using a x 2 comparison of data and Monte Carlo, allowing all important Monte Carlo parameters to vary weighted by their expected uncertainties.”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> Curiosity: In Particle Physics, there is a convention of a **five-sigma effect (99.99994% confidence)** being required to qualify any detected event as a **"Discovery"**.

### Annotation 8 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “FIG. 2. The 68%, 90%, and 99% conﬁdence intervals are shown for sin 2 2u and Dm 2 for n m $ n t two-neutrino oscillations based on 33.0 kton yr of Super-Kamiokande data. The 90% conﬁdence interval obtained by the Kamiokande experiment is also shown.”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> Phase space *("allowed solutions")* for $\Delta m^{2}$ and $\sin^2(2\theta)$ for the results of the best fit to the data considering a two flavour oscillation scenarion from $\nu_\mu$ to $\nu_\tau$ for different confidence levels (68%, 90%, 99%). We see an overlap at the 90% confidence level between Super-Kamiokande and Kamiokande.

### Annotation 9 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “FIG. 3. Zenith angle distributions of m-like and e-like events for sub-GeV and multi-GeV data sets. Upward-going particles have cos Q,0and downward-going particles have cos Q.0. Sub-GeV data are shown separately for p , 400 MeVyc and p . 400 MeVyc. Multi-GeV e-like distributions are shown for p , 2.5 and p . 2.5 GeVyc …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> Zenith angle distributions for $e$-like and $\mu$-like events. The hatched region shows the Monte Carlo expectation in the case of no oscillations. The bold line corresponds to the best fit considering a $\nu_\mu \leftrightarrow \nu_\tau$ oscillation. We can see that the data (black dots) is consistent with an oscillation scenario for both types of events and various energy ranges.

### Annotation 10 (page 6)

Beside the passage: “FIG. 4. The ratio of the number of FC data events to FC Monte Carlo events versus reconstructed LyE n . The points show the ratio of observed data to MC expectation in the absence of oscillations. The dashed lines show the expected shape for n m $ n t at Dm 2  2.2 3 10 23 eV 2 and sin 2 2u  1. The slight LyE n …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> Figure 4 shows the ratio of data *"real"* events and Monte Carlo expected events in the absence of oscillations for various $L/E_\nu$. The dashed lines correspond to the predictions of the best fit considering a $\nu_\mu \leftrightarrow \nu_\tau$ oscillation. Once again we see a deficit of $\mu$-like events showing that the data collected by Super-Kamiokande is consistent with a  $\nu_\mu \leftrightarrow \nu_\tau$ oscillation scenario.

### Annotation 11 (page 6)

Beside the passage: “Both the zenith angle distribution of m-like events and the value of R observed in this experiment signiﬁcantly differ from the best predictions in the absence of neutrino oscillations. While uncertainties in the ﬂux prediction, cross sections, and experimental biases are ruled out as explanations of the observations, …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2015-10-13):

> The conclusion states that the observed events are consistent with a two flavour  $\nu_\mu \leftrightarrow \nu_\tau$ oscillation scenario a gives new limits for $\sin^2(2\theta)$ and $\Delta m^2$.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

VOLUME 81, NUMBER 8 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 24A UGUST 1998

Evidence for Oscillation of Atmospheric Neutrinos [Annotation 1]

Y. Fukuda,

1

T. Hayakawa,

1

E. Ichihara,

1

K. Inoue,

1

K. Ishihara,

1

H. Ishino,

1

Y. Itow,

1

T. Kajita,

1

J. Kameda,

1

S. Kasuga,

1

K. Kobayashi,

1

Y. Kobayashi,

1

Y. Koshio,

1

M. Miura,

1

M. Nakahata,

1

S. Nakayama,

1

A. Okada,

1

K. Okumura,

1

N. Sakurai,

1

M. Shiozawa,

1

Y. Suzuki,

1

Y. Takeuchi,

1

Y. Totsuka,

1

S. Yamada,

1

M. Earl,

2

A. Habig,

2

E. Kearns,

2

M. D. Messier,

2

K. Scholberg,

2

J. L. Stone,

2

L. R. Sulak,

2

C. W. Walter,

2

M. Goldhaber,

3

T. Barszczxak,

4

D. Casper,

4

W. Gajewski,

4

P. G. Halverson,

4,

* J. Hsu,

4

W. R. Kropp,

4

L. R. Price,

4

F. Reines,

4

M. Smy,

4

H. W. Sobel,

4

M. R. Vagins,

4

K. S. Ganezer,

5

W. E. Keig,

5

R. W. Ellsworth,

6

S. Tasaka,

7

J. W. Flanagan,

8, †

A. Kibayashi,

8

J. G. Learned,

8

S. Matsuno,

8

V. J. Stenger,

8

D. Takemori,

8

T. Ishii,

9

J. Kanzaki,

9

T. Kobayashi,

9

S. Mine,

9

K. Nakamura,

9

K. Nishikawa,

9

Y. Oyama,

9

A. Sakai,

9

M. Sakuda,

9

O. Sasaki,

9

S. Echigo,

10

M. Kohama,

10

A. T. Suzuki,

10

T.J. Haines,

11,4

E. Blaufuss,

12

B. K. Kim,

12

R. Sanford,

12

R. Svoboda,

12

M. L. Chen,

13

Z. Conner,

13, ‡

J. A. Goodman,

13

G. W. Sullivan,

13

J. Hill,

14

C. K. Jung,

14

K. Martens,

14

C. Mauger,

14

C. McGrew,

14

E. Sharkey,

14

B. Viren,

14

C. Yanagisawa,

14

W. Doki,

15

K. Miyano,

15

H. Okazawa,

15

C. Saji,

15

M. Takahata,

15

Y. Nagashima,

16

M. Takita,

16

T. Yamaguchi,

16

M. Yoshida,

16

S. B. Kim,

17

M. Etoh,

18

K. Fujita,

18

A. Hasegawa,

18

T. Hasegawa,

18

S. Hatakeyama,

18

T. Iwamoto,

18

M. Koga,

18

T. Maruyama,

18

H. Ogawa,

18

J. Shirai,

18

A. Suzuki,

18

F. Tsushima,

18

M. Koshiba,

19

M. Nemoto,

20

K. Nishijima,

20

T. Futagami,

21

Y. Hayato,

21, §

Y. Kanaya,

21

K. Kaneyuki,

21

Y. Watanabe,

21

D. Kielczewska,

22,4

R. A. Doyle,

23

J. S. George,

23

A. L. Stachyra,

23

L.L. Wai,

23,

R. J. Wilkes,

23

and K. K. Young

23

(Super-Kamiokande Collaboration)

1 Institute for Cosmic Ray Research, University of Tokyo, Tanashi, Tokyo, 188-8502, Japan

2 Department of Physics, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts 02215

3 Physics Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York 11973

4 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California at Irvine, Irvine, California 92697-4575

5 Department of Physics, California State University, Dominguez Hills, Carson, California 90747

6 Department of Physics, George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia 22030

7 Department of Physics, Gifu University, Gifu, Gifu 501-1193, Japan

8

Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Hawaii, Honolulu, Hawaii 96822

9

Institute of Particle and Nuclear Studies, High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (KEK),

Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-0801, Japan

10

Department of Physics, Kobe University, Kobe, Hyogo 657-8501, Japan

11

Physics Division, P-23, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico 87544

12

Department of Physics and Astronomy, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70803

13

Department of Physics, University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland 20742

14

Department of Physics and Astronomy, State University of New York, Stony Brook, New York 11794-3800

15

Department of Physics, Niigata University, Niigata, Niigata 950-2181, Japan

16

Department of Physics, Osaka University, Toyonaka, Osaka 560-0043, Japan

17

Department of Physics, Seoul National University, Seoul 151-742, Korea

18

Department of Physics, Tohoku University, Sendai, Miyagi 980-8578, Japan

19

The University of Tokyo, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan

20

Department of Physics, Tokai University, Hiratsuka, Kanagawa 259-1292, Japan

21

Department of Physics, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Meguro, Tokyo 152-8551, Japan

22

Institute of Experimental Physics, Warsaw University, 00-681 Warsaw, Poland

23

Department of Physics, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington 98195-1560

( Received 6 July 1998)

We present an analysis of atmospheric neutrino data from a 33.0 kton yr (535-day) exposure of the

Super-Kamiokande detector. The data exhibit a zenith angle dependent deﬁcit of muon neutrinos which

is inconsistent with expectations based on calculations of the atmospheric neutrino ﬂux. Experimental

biases and uncertainties in the prediction of neutrino ﬂuxes and cross sections are unable to explain our

observation. The data are consistent, however, with two-ﬂavor n m $ n t oscillations with sin

2

2u.

0.82 and 5 3 10

24

,Dm

2

,6310

23

eV

2

at 90% conﬁdence level. [S0031-9007(98)06975-0]

PACS numbers: 14.60.Pq, 96.40.Tv

Atmospheric neutrinos are produced as decay products

in hadronic showers resulting from collisions of cosmic

rays with nuclei in the upper atmosphere. Production [Annotation 2]

of electron and muon neutrinos is dominated by the pro-

cesses p

1

! m

1

1n m followed by m

1

! e

1

1 n m 1

n e (and their charge conjugates) giving an expected ratio

1562 0031-9007y98y81(8)y1562(6)$15.00 © 1998 The American Physical Society

#### Page 2

VOLUME 81, NUMBER 8 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 24A UGUST 1998

s; n m yn e d of the ﬂux of n [Annotation 3] m 1 n m to the ﬂux of n e 1 n e of about 2. The n m yn e ratio has been calculated in detail with an uncertainty of less than 5% over a broad range of energies from 0.1 to 10 GeV [1,2].

The n [Annotation 4] m yn e ﬂux ratio is measured in deep underground experiments by observing ﬁnal state leptons produced via charged-current interactions of neutrinos on nuclei, n1 N!l1X. The ﬂavor of the ﬁnal state lepton is used to identify the ﬂavor of the incoming neutrino.

The measurements are reported as R ;smyed DATA y smyed MC , where m and e are the number of muonlike sm-liked and electronlike se-liked events observed in the detector for both data and Monte Carlo simulations. This ratio largely cancels experimental and theoretical uncertainties, especially the uncertainty in the absolute ﬂux. R  1 is expected if the physics in the Monte Carlo simulation accurately models the data. Measurements of signiﬁcantly small values of R have been reported by the deep underground water Cherenkov detectors Kamiokande [3,4], IMB [5], and recently by Super-Kamiokande [6,7]. Although measurements of R by early iron-calorimeter experiments Fréjus [8] and NU- SEX [9] with smaller data samples were consistent with expectations, the Soudan-2 iron-calorimeter experiment has reported observation of a small value of R [10].

Neutrino oscillations have been suggested to explain measurements of small values of R. For a two-neutrino oscillation hypothesis, the probability for a neutrino produced in ﬂavor state a to be observed in ﬂavor state b after traveling a distance L through a vacuum is

P a!b  sin 2 2u sin 2

µ

1.27Dm 2 seV 2 dLskmd E n sGeVd

∂

, (1)

where E [Annotation 5] n is the neutrino energy, u is the mixing angle between the ﬂavor eigenstates and the mass eigenstates, and Dm 2 is the mass squared difference of the neutrino mass eigenstates. For detectors near the surface of the Earth, the neutrino ﬂight distance, and thus the oscillation probability, is a function of the zenith angle of the neutrino direction. Vertically downward-going neutrinos travel about 15 km, while vertically upward-going neutrinos travel about 13 000 km before interacting in the detector. The broad energy spectrum and this range of neutrino ﬂight distances make measurements of atmospheric neutrinos sensitive to neutrino oscillations with Dm 2 down to 10 24 eV 2 . The zenith angle dependence of R measured by the Kamiokande experiment at high energies has been cited as evidence for neutrino oscillations [4].

We present our analysis of 33.0 kton yr (535 days) of atmospheric neutrino data from Super-Kamiokande. In addition to measurements of small values of R both above and below ,1 GeV, we observed a signiﬁcant zenith angle dependent deﬁcit of m-like events. While no combination of known uncertainties in the experimental measurement or predictions of atmospheric neutrino ﬂuxes is able to explain our data, a two-neutrino oscillation model of

n m $ n x , where n x may be n t or a new, noninteracting “sterile” neutrino, is consistent with the observed ﬂavor ratios and zenith angle distributions over the entire energy region.

Super-Kamiokande is a 50 kton water Cherenkov detector instrumented with 11146 photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) facing an inner 22.5 kton ﬁducial volume of ultrapure water. Interaction kinematics are reconstructed using the time and charge of each PMT signal. The inner volume is surrounded by a ,2mthick outer detector instrumented with 1885 outward-facing PMTs. The outer detector is used to veto entering particles and to tag exiting tracks.

Super-Kamiokande has collected a total of 4353 fully contained (FC) events and 301 partially contained (PC) events in a 33.0 kton yr exposure. FC events deposit all of their Cherenkov light in the inner detector while PC events have exiting tracks which deposit some Cherenkov light in the outer detector. For this analysis, the neutrino interaction vertex was required to have been reconstructed within the 22.5 kton ﬁducial volume, deﬁned to be .2m from the PMT wall.

FC events were separated into those with a single visible Cherenkov ring and those with multiple Cherenkov rings. For the analysis of FC events, only single-ring events were used. Single-ring events were identiﬁed as c-like or m-like based on a likelihood analysis of light detected around the Cherenkov cone. The FC events were separated into “sub-GEV” sE vis , 1330 MeVd and “multi-GeV” sE vis . 1330 MeVd samples, where E vis is deﬁned to be the energy of an electron that would produce the observed amount of Cherenkov light. E vis  1330 MeV corresponds to p m , 1400 MeVyc. In a full-detector Monte Carlo simulation, 88% (96%) of the sub-GeV e-like sm-liked events were n e sn m d chargedcurrent interactions and 84% (99%) of the multi-GeV e-like sm-liked events were n e sn m d charged-current (CC) interactions. PC events were estimated to be 98% n m charged-current interactions; hence, all PC events were classiﬁed as m-like, and no single-ring requirement was made. Table I summarizes the number of observed events for both data and Monte Carlo as well as the R values for the sub-GeV and multi-GeV samples. Further details of the detector, data selection, and event reconstruction used in this analysis are given elsewhere [6,7].

We have measured signiﬁcantly small values of R in both the sub-GeV and multi-GeV samples. Several sources of systematic uncertainties in these measurements have been considered. Cosmic ray induced interactions in the rock surrounding the detector have been suggested as a source of e-like contamination from neutrons, which could produce small R values [11], but these backgrounds have been shown to be insigniﬁcant for large water Cherenkov detectors [12]. In particular, Super-Kamiokande has 4.7 m of water surrounding the ﬁducial volume; this distance corresponds to roughly 5 hadronic interaction lengths and 13 radiation lengths. Distributions of event vertices

1563

#### Page 3

VOLUME 81, NUMBER 8 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 24A UGUST 1998

TABLE I. Summary of the sub-GeV, multi-GeV, and PC event samples compared with the Monte Carlo prediction based on the neutrino ﬂux calculation of Ref. [2].

Data Monte Carlo Sub-GeV Single-ring 2389 2622.6 e-like 1231 1049.1 m-like 1158 1573.6 Multi-ring 911 980.7 Total 3300 3603.3

R  0.63 6 0.03 sstat.d 6 0.05 ssyst.d Multi-Gev Single-ring 520 531.7 e-like 290 236.0 m-like 230 295.7 Multi-ring 533 560.1 Total 1053 1091.8

Partially contained 301 371.6

R FC1PC  0.65 6 0.05 sstat.d 6 0.08 ssyst.d

exhibit no excess of e-like events close to the ﬁducial [Annotation 6] boundary [6,7].

The prediction of the ratio of the n m ﬂux to the n e ﬂux is dominated by the well-understood decay chain of mesons and contributes less than 5% of the uncertainty in R. Different neutrino ﬂux models vary by about 620% in the prediction of absolute rates, but the ratio is robust [13]. Uncertainties in R due to a difference in cross sections for n e and n m have been studied [14]; however, lepton universality prevents any signiﬁcant difference in cross sections at energies much above the muon mass and thus errors in cross sections could not produce a small value of R in the multi-GeV energy range. Particle identiﬁcation was estimated to be * 98% efﬁcient for both m-like and e-like events based on Monte Carlo studies. Particle identiﬁcation was also tested in Super-Kamiokande on Michel electrons and stopping cosmic-ray muons and the m-like and e-like events used in this analysis are clearly separated [6]. The particle identiﬁcation programs in use have also been tested using beams of electrons and muons incident on a water Cherenkov detector at KEK [15]. The data have been analyzed independently by two groups, making the possibility of signiﬁcant biases in data selection or event reconstruction algorithms remote [6,7]. Other explanations for the small value of R, such as contributions from nucleon decays [16], can be discounted as they would not contribute to the zenith angle effects described below.

We estimate the probability that the observed m ye ratios could be due to statistical ﬂuctuation is less than 0.001% for sub-GeV R and less than 1% for multi-GeV R.

The m-like data exhibit a strong asymmetry in zenith angle sQd while no signiﬁcant asymmetry is observed in the e-like data [7]. The asymmetry is deﬁned as A 

FIG. 1. The sU 2 DdysU 1 Dd asymmetry as a function of momentum for FC e-like and m-like events and PC events. While it is not possible to assign a momentum to a PC event, the PC sample is estimated to have a mean neutrino energy of 15 GeV. The Monte Carlo expectation without neutrino oscillations is shown in the hatched region with statistical and systematic errors added in quadrature. The dashed line for m-like is the expectation for n m $ n t oscillations with ssin 2 2u  1.0, Dm 2  2.2 3 10 23 eV 2 d.

sU 2 DdysU 1 Dd where U is the number of upwardgoing events s21 , cosQ,20.2d and D is the number of downward-going events s0.2 , cos Q,1d. The asymmetry is expected to be near zero independent of the ﬂux model for E n . 1 GeV, above which effects due to the Earth’s magnetic ﬁeld on cosmic rays are small. Based on a comparison of results from our full Monte Carlo simulation using different ﬂux models [1,2] as inputs, treatment of geomagnetic effects results in an uncertainty of roughly 60.02 in the expected asymmetry of e-like and m-like sub-GeV events and less than 60.01 for multi-GeV events. Studies of decay electrons from stopping muons show at most a 60.6% up-down difference in Cherenkov light detection [17].

Figure 1 shows A as a function of momentum for both e-like and m-like events. In the present data, the asymmetric as a function of momentum for e-like events is consistent with expectations, while the m-like asymmetry at low momentum is consistent with zero but signiﬁcantly deviates form expectations at higher momentum. The average angle between the ﬁnal state lepton direction and the incoming neutrino direction is 55 ± at p  400 MeVyc and 20 ± at 1.5 GeVyc. At the lower momenta in Fig. 1, the possible asymmetry of the neutrino ﬂux is largely washed out. We have found no detector bias differentiating e-like and m-like events that could explain an asymmetry in m-like events but not in e-like events [7].

1564

#### Page 4

VOLUME 81, NUMBER 8 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 24A UGUST 1998

Considering multi-GeV sFC 1 PCd muons alone, the measured asymmetry, A  20.296 6 0.048 6 0.01 deviates from zero by more than 6 standard deviations.

We have examined the hypotheses of two-ﬂavor n [Annotation 7] m $ n e and n m $ n t oscillation models using a x 2 comparison of data and Monte Carlo, allowing all important Monte Carlo parameters to vary weighted by their expected uncertainties.

The data were binned by particle type, momentum, and cos Q.Ax 2 is deﬁned as

x 2 

X

cos Q,p

sN DATA 2 N MC d 2 ys 2 1

X

j

e 2 j ys 2 j , (2)

where the sum is over ﬁve bins equally spaced in cos Q and seven momentum bins for both e-like events and m-like plus PC events (70 bins total). The statistical error, s, accounts for both data statistics and the weighted Monte Carlo statistics. N DATA is the measured number of events in each bin. N MC is the weighted sum of Monte Carlo events:

N MC  L DATA L MC

X

MC events

w . (3)

L DATA and L MC are the data and Monte Carlo live times. For each Monte Carlo event, the weight w is given by

w  s1 1adsE i n yE 0 d d s1 1h s,m cos Qd

3 f e,m sss sin 2 2u, Dm 2 , s1 1ldLyE n ddd

3

8 > > > > > > > <

\> > > > > > > :

s12b s y2d sub-GeV e-like , s1 1b s y2d sub-GeV m-like , s1 2b m y2d multi-GeV e-like ,

s1 1b m y2d

≥ 12 r 2

N PC N m

¥

multi-GeV m-like ,

s1 1b m y2d

≥ 11 r 2

¥

PC . (4)

E i n is the average neutrino energy in the ith momentum bin; E 0 is an arbitrary reference energy (taken to be 2 GeV); h s sh m d is the up-down uncertainty of the event rate in the sub-GeV (multi-GeV) energy range; N PC is the total number of Monte Carlo PC events; and N m is the total number of Monte Carlo FC multi-GeV muons. The factor f e,m weights an event accounting for the initial neutrino ﬂuxes (in the case of n m $ n e ), oscillation parameters, and LyE n . The meaning of the Monte Carlo ﬁt parameters, a and e j ;sb s ,b m ,d,r,l,h s ,h m dand their assigned uncertainties, s j , are summarized in Table II. The overall normalization, a, was allowed to vary freely. The uncertainty in the Monte Carlo LyE n ratio sld was conservatively estimated based on the uncertainty in an absolute energy scale, uncertainty in neutrino-lepton angular and energy correlations, and the uncertainty in production height. The oscillation simulations used proﬁles of neutrino production heights calculated in Ref. [18], which account for the competing factors of production, propagation, and decay of muons and mesons through the atmosphere.

TABLE II. Summary of Monte Carlo ﬁt parameters. Bestﬁt values for n m $ n t sDm 2  2.2 3 10 23 eV 2 , sin 2 2u  1.0d and estimated uncertainties are given. (*) The overall normalization sad was estimated to have a 25% uncertainty but was ﬁtted as a free parameter.

Monte Carlo ﬁt parameters Best ﬁt Uncertainty

a Overall normalization 15.8% (*) d E n spectral index 0.006 s d  0.05 b s Sub-GeV mye ratio 26.3% s s  8% b m Multi-GeV mye ratio 211.8% s m  12% r Relative norm. of PC to FC 21.8% s p  8% l LyE n 3.1% s l  15% h s Sub-GeV up-down 2.4% s s h  2.4% h m Multi-GeV up-down 20.09% s m h  2.7%

For n m $ n e , effects of matter on neutrino propagation through the Earth were included following Ref. [19,20]. Because of the small number of events expected from t production, the effects of t appearance and decay were neglected in simulations of n m $ n t . A global scan was made on a ssin 2 2u, log Dm 2 d grid minimizing x 2 with respect to a, b s , b m , d, r, l, h s , and h m at each point. The best ﬁt to n m $ n t oscillations, x 2 min  65.2y 67 DOF, was obtained at ssin 2 2u  1.0, Dm 2  2.2 3 10 23 eV 2 d inside the physical region s0 # sin 2 2u#1d. The best-ﬁt values of the Monte Carlo parameters (summarized in Table II) were all within their expected errors. The global minimum occurred slightly outside of the physical region at (sin 2 2u  1.05, Dm 2  2.2 3 10 23 eV 2 , x 2 min  64.8y67 DOF). The contours of the 68%, 90%, and 99% conﬁdence intervals are located at x 2 min 1 2.6, 5.0, and 9.6 based on the minimum inside the physical region [21]. Thee contours are shown in Fig. 2. The region near x 2 minimum is rather ﬂat and has many local minima so that inside the 68% interval the best-ﬁt Dm 2 is not well-constrained. Outside of the 99% allowed region the x 2 increases rapidly. We obtained x 2  135y69 DOF, when calculated at sin 2 2u  0, Dm 2  0 (i.e., assuming no oscillations).

For the test of n m $ n e oscillations, we obtained a relatively poor ﬁt; x 2 min  87.8y67 DOF, at ssin 2 2u  0.93, Dm 2  3.2 3 10 23 eV 2 d. The expected asymmetry of the multi-GeV e-like events for the best-ﬁt n m $ n e oscillation hypothesis, A  0.205, differs from the measured asymmetry, A  20.036 6 0.067 6 0.02,by 3.4 standard deviations. We conclude that the n m $ n e hypothesis is not favored.

The zenith angle distributions for the FC and PC samples are shown in Fig. 3. The data are compared to the Monte Carlo expectation (no oscillations, hatched region) and the best-ﬁt expectation for n m $ n t oscillations (bold line). We also estimated the oscillation parameters considering the R measurement and the zenith angle shape separately. The 90% conﬁdence level allowed regions for each

1565

#### Page 5

VOLUME 81, NUMBER 8 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 24A UGUST 1998

FIG. 2. The 68%, 90%, and 99% conﬁdence intervals are [Annotation 8] shown for sin 2 2u and Dm 2 for n m $ n t two-neutrino oscillations based on 33.0 kton yr of Super-Kamiokande data. The 90% conﬁdence interval obtained by the Kamiokande experiment is also shown.

case overlapped at 1 3 10 23 ,Dm 2 ,4310 23 eV 2 for sin 2 2u  1. As a cross-check of the above analyses, we have reconstructed the best estimate of the ratio LyE n for each event. The neutrino energy is estimated by applying a correction to the ﬁnal state lepton momentum. Typi-

cally, ﬁnal state leptons with p , 100 MeVyc carry 65% of the incoming neutrino energy increasing to ,85% at p  1 GeVyc. The neutrino ﬂight distance L is estimated following Ref. [18] using the estimated neutrino energy and the reconstructed lepton direction and ﬂavor. Figure 4 shows the ratio of FC data to Monte Carlo for e-like and m-like events with p . 400 MeV as a function of LyE n , compared to the expectation for n m $ n t oscillations with our best-ﬁt parameters. The e-like data show no signiﬁcant variation in LyE n , while the m-like events show a signiﬁcant deﬁcit at large LyE n . At large LyE n , the n m have presumably undergone numerous oscillations and have averaged out to roughly half the initial rate.

The asymmetry A of the e-like events in the present data is consistent with expectations without neutrino oscillations and two-ﬂavor n e $ n m oscillations are not favored. This is in agreement with recent results from the CHOOZ experiment [22]. The LSND experiment has reported the appearance of n e in a beam of n m produced by stopped pions [23]. The LSND results do not contradict the present results if they are observing small mixing angles. With the best-ﬁt parameters for n m $ n t oscillations, we expect a total of only 15–20 events from n t chargedcurrent interactions in the data sample. Using the current sample, oscillations between n m and n t are indistinguishable from oscillations between n m and a noninteracting sterile neutrino.

Figure 2 shows the Super-Kamiokande results overlaid with the allowed region obtained by the Kamiokande

FIG. 3. Zenith angle distributions of m-like and e-like events for sub-GeV and multi-GeV data sets. Upward-going particles have cos Q,0and downward-going particles have cos Q.0. Sub-GeV data are shown separately for p , 400 MeVyc and [Annotation 9] p . 400 MeVyc. Multi-GeV e-like distributions are shown for p , 2.5 and p . 2.5 GeVyc and the multi-GeV m-like are shown separately for FC and PC events. The hatched region shows the Monte Carlo expectation for no oscillations normalized to the data live time with statistical errors. The bold line is the best-ﬁt expectation for n m $ n t oscillations with the overall ﬂux normalization ﬁtted as a free parameter.

1566

#### Page 6

VOLUME 81, NUMBER 8 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 24A UGUST 1998

FIG. 4. The ratio of the number of FC data events to FC [Annotation 10] Monte Carlo events versus reconstructed LyE n . The points show the ratio of observed data to MC expectation in the absence of oscillations. The dashed lines show the expected shape for n m $ n t at Dm 2  2.2 3 10 23 eV 2 and sin 2 2u  1. The slight LyE n dependence for e-like events is due to contamination (2–7%) of n m CC interactions.

experiment [4]. The Super-Kamiokande region favors lower values of Dm 2 than allowed by the Kamiokande experiment; however the 90% contours from both experiments have a region of overlap. Preliminary studies of upward-going stopping and through-going muons in Super-Kamiokande [24] give allowed regions consistent with the FC and PC event analysis reported in this paper.

Both the zenith angle distribution of m-like events and the value of R observed in this experiment signiﬁcantly differ from the best predictions in the absence of neutrino oscillations. While uncertainties in the ﬂux prediction, cross sections, and experimental biases are ruled out as explanations of the observations, the present [Annotation 11] data are in good agreement with two-ﬂavor n m $ n t oscillations with sin 2 2u.0.82 and 5 3 10 24 ,Dm 2 , 6310 23 eV 2 at a 90% conﬁdence level. We conclude that the present data give evidence for neutrino oscillations.

We gratefully acknowledge the cooperation of the Kamioka Mining and Smelting Company. The Super- Kamiokande experiment was built and has been operated with funding from the Japanese Ministry of Education, Science, Sports and Culture, and the United States Department of Energy.

*Present address: NASA, JPL, Pasadena, CA 91109. † Present address: High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (KEK), Accelerator Laboratory, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-0801, Japan. ‡ Present address: University of Chicago, Enrico Fermi Institute, Chicago, IL 60637. § Present address: Institute of Particle and Nuclear Studies, High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (KEK), Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-0801, Japan. Present address: Stanford University, Department of Physics, Stanford, CA 94305. [1] G. Barr et al., Phys. Rev. D 39, 3532 (1998); V. Agrawal

et al., Phys. Ref. D 53, 1314 (1996); T.K. Gaisser and T. Stanev, in Proceedings of the International Cosmic Ray Conference, Rome, Italy, 1995 (Arti Graﬁche, Urbino, 1995), Vol. 1, p. 694. [2] M. Honda et al., Phys. Lett. B 248, 193 (1990); M. Honda

et al., Phys. Rev. D 52, 4985 (1995). [3] K. S. Hirata et al., Phys. Lett. B 205, 416 (1988); K.S.

Hirata et al., Phys. Lett. B 280, 146 (1992). [4] Y. Fukuda et al., Phys. Lett. B 335, 237 (1994). [5] D. Casper et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 66, 2561 (1991);

R. Becker-Szendy et al., Phys. Rev. D 46, 3720 (1992). [6] Super-Kamiokande Collaboration, Y. Fukuda et al., hep-

ex/9803006. [7] Super-Kamiokande Collaboration, Y. Fukuda, et al., hep-

ex/9805006. [8] K. Daum et al., Z. Phys. C 66, 417 (1995). [9] M. Aglietta et al., Europhys. Lett. 8, 611 (1989). [10] W. W. M. Allison et al., Phys. Lett. B 391, 491 (1997);

T. Kafka, inProceedings of the 5th International Workshop on Topics in Astroparticle and Underground Physics, Gran Sasso, Italy, 1997 (to be published). [11] O. G. Ryazhskaya, JETP Lett. 60, 617 (1994); JETP Lett.

61, 237 (1995). [12] Y. Fukuda et al., Phys. Lett. B 388, 397 (1996). [13] T. K. Gaisser et al., Phys. Rev. D 54, 5578 (1996). [14] J. Engel et al., Phys. Rev. D 48, 3048 (1993). [15] S. Kasuga et al., Phys. Lett. B 374, 238 (1996). [16] W. A. Mann, T. Kafka, and W. Leeson, Phys. Lett. B 291,

200 (1992). [17] This represents an improvement from Refs. [6,7] due to

improved calibration. [18] T. K. Gaisser and T. Stanev, Phys. Rev. D 57, 1977

(1998). [19] L. Wolfenstein, Phys. Rev. D 17, 2369 (1978). [20] S. P. Mikheyev and A. Y. Smirnov, Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 42,

1441 (1985); S.P. Mikheyev and A.Y. Smirnov, Nuovo Cimento Soc. Ital. Fis. 9C, 17 (1986); S.P. Mikheyev and A. Y. Smirnov, Sov. Phys.-Usp. 30, 759 (1987). [21] Based on a two-dimensional extension of the method from

the Particle Data Group, R. M. Barnett et al., Phys. Rev. D 54, 1 (1996); see sec. 28.6, p. 162. [22] M. Apollonio et al., Phys. Lett. B 420, 397 (1998). [23] C. Athanassopoulos et al., Phys. Rev. C 54, 2685 (1996);

Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3082 (1996). [24] T. Kajita, in Proceedings of the XVIIIth International Con-

ference on Neutrino Physics and Astrophysics, Takayama, Japan, 1998 (to be published).

1567

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/oscillation-of-atmospheric-neutrinos. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
