# On the rheology of cats

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/on-the-rheology-of-cats

- **Authors:** M.A. Fardin
- **Published:** 2017
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1762764639149-9f2uti2lild-c801b47fff3e96c109d60d4523098a2c%2FRheology-of-cats.pdf
- **Pages:** 3
- **Annotations:** 16 comments in 11 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/on-the-rheology-of-cats

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “On the rheology of cats”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-11-10):

> ### TL;DR:
>
> In this "satirical" yet technically rigorous paper, physicist Marc-Antoine Fardin applies the equations of rheology (the study of how materials deform and flow) to cats. Using the Deborah number (De = τ / T), he argues that whether a cat behaves like a solid or a liquid depends on the timescale of observation: a cat bouncing on a table (short T) acts like an elastic solid, but one melting into a container (long T) flows like a viscous fluid.
>
> The author extends the joke with real rheological terminology - yield stress, capillary number, Weissenberg effect - to “model” feline behavior as if it were a complex fluid :)
>
> The paper earned Fardin the 2017 Ig Nobel Prize in Physics.
>
> ![](https://themeta.news/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/fardin-vert-16-9-scaled.jpg)

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “M.A. Fardin 1, 2, 3, ∗ 1 Universit´e de Lyon, Laboratoire de Physique, ´ Ecole Normale Sup´erieure de Lyon, CNRS UMR 5672, 46 All´ee d’Italie, 69364 Lyon cedex 07, France.”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-11-10):

> The paper earned Fardin the 2017 Ig Nobel Prize in Physics, you can watch the ceremony and talk [here](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yNwLfRpNHhI).

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “παντα ρι! Everything ﬂows! This famous aphorism used to characterize Heraclitus’ thought is also the motto of rheology. “Everything ﬂows and nothing abides; everything gives way and nothing stays ﬁxed.” a recipe for insubordination actually from Simplicius and Plato. Everything ﬂows? Well, it depends on the deﬁnition …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-11-10):

> The expression πάντα ῥεῖ (panta rhei, literally “all things flow”) is attributed to the Greek philosopher Heraclitus of Ephesus (c. 535–475 BCE).
>
> Heraclitus’ central doctrine was that change is the fundamental nature of reality. He used vivid imagery especially the river analogy:
>
> "You cannot step twice into the same river, for fresh waters are ever flowing in upon you"

**Reply** by Bob  (2025-11-12):

> While Plato is well known and often studied, Simplicius may need an introduction. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/simplicius/

**Reply** by Bob  (2025-11-12):

> While Plato is well known and often studied, Simplicius may need an introduction. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/simplicius/

**Reply** by Bob  (2025-11-12):

> While Plato is well known and often studied, Simplicius may need an introduction. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/simplicius/

**Reply** by Bob  (2025-11-12):

> While Plato is well known and often studied, Simplicius may need an introduction. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/simplicius/

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “παντα ρι! Everything ﬂows! This famous aphorism used to characterize Heraclitus’ thought is also the motto of rheology. “Everything ﬂows and nothing abides; everything gives way and nothing stays ﬁxed.” a recipe for insubordination actually from Simplicius and Plato. Everything ﬂows? Well, it depends on the deﬁnition …”

**Annotation** by Bob  (2025-11-12):

> While Plato may not need an introduction, it may be helpful to provide Simplicius with an intro:
> https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/simplicius/

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Historically, the popular distinction between states of matter has been made based on qualitative diﬀerences in bulk prop erties. Solid is the state in which matter maintains a ﬁxed volume and shape; liquid is the state in which matter maintains a ﬁxed volume but adapts to the shape of its container; and gas is the …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-11-10):

> Rheology is the branch of physics that studies how materials deform and flow under applied forces.
>
> It connects the behavior of solids (which resist deformation) and fluids (which flow)

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “ﬂuids, the extensional viscosity can be or d ers of magnitude diﬀerent, usually larger than the shear viscosity for polymeric materials. For cats, the determination of the Trouton ratio is complicated but the situation seems opposite. In the absence of reliable extensional rheology data, we can only point to the fact …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-11-10):

> In rheology, the Trouton ratio (ηₑ/ηₛ) quantifies how much harder it is to stretch a fluid than to shear it (≈3 for simple liquids).
>
> Fardin humorously notes that for cats the opposite seems true: cats elongate effortlessly (low extensional resistance) but resist lateral motion, suggesting a Trouton ratio < 1.

**Reply** by Bob  (2025-11-12):

> While Plato may not need an introduction, it may be helpful to provide Simplicius with an intro:
> https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/simplicius/

### Annotation 7 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “The wetting and general tribology of cats has not progressed enough to give a deﬁnitive answer to the capillary dependence of the feline relaxation time. Fig. 2b gives an example of a lotus eﬀect of Felis catus, suggesti ng that the substrate is superfelidaphobic. This behavior is usually distinguished from the yield …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-11-10):

> Fardin invents the term “superfelidaphobic” by analogy with “superhydrophobic” surfaces that repel water (lotus effect). A superfelidaphobic surface would repel cats :)

### Annotation 8 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “In the ﬁrst part of this letter I wish to highlight the potential factors that have to be taken into account in computing the value of τ for cat s. Fig. 2a shows the capillary bridge formed during extensional rheometry of Felis catus. First, in the introduction, we assumed τ tobea scalar, but it can have a higher …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-11-10):

> In complex materials, the “viscosity” isn’t just a single number, it can depend on direction. That’s why the author says viscosity can be a tensor of rank 2 (i.e., a matrix relating stress and strain in different directions).
>
> For a simple, isotropic fluid, symmetry simplifies everything: it behaves the same in every direction, so viscosity (and τ) can be treated as a scalar (just one number).

### Annotation 9 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “The limit Rw  1 deﬁnes the laminar base ﬂow. Nontrivial secondary ﬂows will usually app ear around Rw ∼ 1. Finally, the ﬂow will b e turbul ent if Rw  1. For simple ﬂuids, the relaxation time is the viscous dissipation time, the driving force of instability is inertia and the dimensionless number is just the usual …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-11-10):

> When Fardin introduces the Reynolds–Weissenberg number (Rw = τγ̇), he’s mixing two classical instability criteria: the Reynolds number (inertial turbulence) and the Weissenberg number (elastic turbulence).
>
> In simple fluids, flow becomes turbulent only when inertia dominates; in complex fluids (or cats) turbulence can arise purely from elastic stresses.
>
> The humor here is that he’s treating the famous “cat zoomies” as non-linear flow instabilities. For low Rw (calm cat), flow is laminar; around Rw ≈ 1, small perturbations appear (tail twitches, rotational modes); at Rw ≫ 1, full elastic turbulence ensues!

### Annotation 10 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “In conclusion, much more work remains ahead, but cats are proving to be a rich model system for rheological research, both in the linear and nonlinear regimes. Standing questions include the potential implications of the rheology of cats on their righting reﬂex, and whether the nonlinear self-sustaining mechanism for …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-11-10):

> If you're curious, this is [what a Cat Cafe looks like in Japan](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zadxEvylsw8).

### Annotation 11 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Acknowledgments No animals were (h)armed in the making of this study. I thank L. and J.F. Berret for providing a reliable technique to load Felis catus in diﬀerent geometries: 1. Bring an empty b ox; 2. Wait. Illustrations of the protocol can be found on the web (weknowmemes.com/2012/11/how-to-catch-a-cat/, or …”

**Annotation** by Gerardo Lisboa (2025-11-12):

> The link in the article has been taken by spammers.
> Please refer to the archived version here: https://web.archive.org/web/20190720121721/weknowmemes.com/2012/11/how-to-catch-a-cat

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

16 Rheology Bulletin, 83(2) July 2014

On the rheology of cats [Annotation 1]

M.A. Fardin 1, 2, 3, ∗ 1 Universit´e de Lyon, Laboratoire de Physique, ´ Ecole Normale Sup´erieure de Lyon, [Annotation 2] CNRS UMR 5672, 46 All´ee d’Italie, 69364 Lyon cedex 07, France.

2 The Academy of Bradylogists. 3 Member of the Extended McKinley Family (EMF).

(Dated: July 9, 2014)

In this letter I highlight some of the recent developments around the rheology of Felis catu s, with p otential applications for other species of the felidae family. In the linear rheology regime many factors can enter the determination of the characteristic time of cats: from surface eﬀects to yield stress. In the nonlinear rheology regime ﬂow instabilities can emerge. Nonetheless, the ﬂow rate, which is the usual dimensional control parameter, can be hard to compute because cats are active rheological materials.

παντα ρι! Everything ﬂows! This famous aphorism [Annotation 3] used to characterize Heraclitus’ thought is also the motto of rheology. “Everything ﬂows and nothing abides; everything gives way and nothing stays ﬁxed.” a recipe for insubordination actually from Simplicius and Plato. Ev- [Annotation 4] erything ﬂows? Well, it depends on the deﬁnition of a ﬂow; if suﬃciently general, there is no doubt that there are no exceptions to the rule! What is a ﬂow? What is a ﬂuid? As pointed out from the start by Reiner, the essential value of rheology is to recognize that states of matter are a matter of time(s). The ﬁrst time, is a time of observation T . What is true today may not be true tomorrow. Time over time, one day 49, the next 50.

Historically, the popular distinction between states of matter has been made based on qualitative diﬀerences in bulk prop erties. Solid is the state in which matter maintains a ﬁxed volume and shape; liquid is the state in which matter maintains a ﬁxed volume but adapts to the shape of its container; and gas is the state in which matter expands to occupy whatever volume is available. Following these common sense deﬁnitions, a meta-study untitled “Cats are liquids” was recently published on boredpanda.com. I propose here to check if the panda’s claim that the cats are liquid is solid, by using the tools of modern rheology. [Annotation 5]

First of all, ‘maintains’, ‘adapts’ or ‘expands’ are verbs. They describe actions unfolding with a characteristic time scale τ , which we will call relaxation time. From T and τ we can deﬁne the Deborah number as:

De ≡ τ T (1)

Usually T is just the duration of the experiment, but for oscillatory ﬂows it is the inverse of the frequency (and thus De is analogous to a Strouhal number). The relaxation time τ can have a variety of origins. When one seeks the diﬀerence between gas and liquid, ‘relaxing’ will mean ‘expan di n g’ and so τ will be linked to the characteristic rate of expansion of the material. The expansion

∗ Corresponding author ; Electronic address: marcantoine.fardin@ ens-lyon.fr

FIG. 1: (a) A cat appears as a solid material with a consistent shape rotating and bouncing, like Silly Putty on short time scales. We have De  1 because the time of observation is under a second. (b) At longer time scales, a cat ﬂows and ﬁlls an empty wine glass. In this case we have De  1. In both cases, even if the samples are diﬀerent, we can estimate the relaxation time to be in the range τ = 1 s to 1 min. (c-d) For older cats, we can also introduce a characteristic time of expansion and distinguish between liquid (c) and gaseous (d) feline states. [(a) Courtesy of http://catb ounce.com, (b) http://www.dweebist.com/2009/07/kittenin-wine-glass/, (c) http://imgur.com/gallery/UuNSR, (d) http://imgur.com/s7JtV ]

is a type of ﬂow. In this case, we will say that we have a gas if De  1. When one seeks the diﬀerence between liquid and solid, ‘relaxing’ will mean ‘adapting’ and so τ will be linked to the characteristic rate of adaptation of the shape of the material to its container. The adaptation of the shape of the material is a type of ﬂow. In this case, we will say that we have a liquid if De  1. Solids ‘maintain’ their shape and volume, i.e. they do not ﬂow. But solids can be deformed under stress. Note ﬁnally that any ﬂow is intrinsically made of deformations.

As illustrated in Fig. 1a, for De  1 a cat appears

#### Page 2

17 Rheology Bulletin, 83 (2) July 2014

2

FIG. 2: (a) Extensional rheology of a cat before capillary break-up. (b) Cat on a superfelidaphobic substrate showing a high contact angle. (c) Tilted jar experiment showing the yield stress of a kitten. (d) Spreading of a cat on a very rough substrate. (e) Low aﬃnity between cats and water surfaces. (f) Sliding cat on smooth ﬂoor. (g) Adhesion of a cat on a vertical wall. [Courtesy of (a) facebook.com, (c) http://metro.co.uk/2011/02/18/ksyusha-the-kitten-is-cat-in-ajar-639735/ , (d) http://www.theyfailed.com/cats-sleep-anywhere/, (f) http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/youtubewatch-hilarious-viral-of-two-882779, (g) http://amazinghandpaintedmurals.com/picture gallery - page 3]

solid, whereas for De  1 it seems liquid. From these preliminary experiments, knowing T we can estimate the relaxation time to be in the range τ = 1 s to 1 min, for normal cases of Felis catus. Note that the samples used in Fig. 1a-b are relatively young. Older cats may have a shorter relaxation time, and thus become liquid more easily than agitated kittens, for which τ can reach values as high as a few hours. The assumption of incompressibility may also fail for older cats, which can acquire gaseous properties like in Fig. 1c-d. In this letter, we will tend to ignore this thixotropic behavior. There’s an old saying in investing: even a dead cat will bounce if it is dropped from high enough. Where, of course, the dead cat bounce refers to a short-term recovery in a declining trend.

Overall, the Deborah number is the dimensionless expression of the concept of linear viscoelasticity. The greater the Deborah number, the more elastic/solid the material; the smaller the Deborah number, the more viscous/ﬂuid it is. Thus, rheology suggests only two states of matter: solids that deform; and ﬂuids that ﬂow. Both gases and liquids ﬂow, they are ﬂuids, the ﬁrst compressible, the other incompressible. In general, both the ﬂuidlike and the solid-like properties of a material can be complex, in the sense that the solid part may not be purely elastic, and the ﬂuid part may not be purely viscous. For simple incompressible and athermal molecular ﬂuids, the relaxation time will simply be the viscous dissipation time τ = δ 2 /ν, where δ is the thickness of the momentum boundary layer and ν is the kinematic viscosity. For more complex ﬂuids, τ can have a large range of origins, which often require chemistry and/or biology to b e well understood.

In the ﬁrst part of this letter I wish to highlight the potential factors that have to be taken into account in computing the value of τ for cat s. Fig. 2a shows the capillary bridge formed during extensional rheometry of Felis catus. First, in the introduction, we assumed τ tobea scalar, but it can have a higher dimensionality. Usually the time scale is considered as a contribution to viscosity, which in the most general case is a tensor of rank 2. For simple incompressible ﬂuids symmetry considera- [Annotation 8] tions reduce this tensor to a scalar. The extensional viscosity is si mp l y 3 times the shear viscosity. For complex

ﬂuids, the extensional viscosity can be or d ers of magnitude diﬀerent, usually larger than the shear viscosity for polymeric materials. For cats, the determination of the Trouton ratio is complicated but the situation seems opposite. In the absence of reliable extensional rheol- [Annotation 6] ogy data, we can only point to the fact that when cats are deformed along their principal axis, they tend to relax more easily, suggesting that the extensional time is smaller than the shear time. Transient strain-hardening can nonetheless occur. Second, because, ﬂows of cats are usually free surface ﬂows, the surface tension between the cat and its surrounding medium can be important and even dominant in the rheology, especially in CATBER (Capillary thinning and breakup extensional rheometer) experiments. The catpillar y number becomes important τ = f(Ca), with Ca ≡ ηU/γ LV , where η is the shear viscosity, U is a characteristic ﬂow velo city and γ LV is the surface tension (not to be confused with the deformation). Let us recall that even water droplets bouncing on hydrophobic substrates can behave elastically, with a response time τ =



ρR 3 0 /γ, where ρ is the density and R 0 the size of the drops. When the ﬂuid is complex, the situation can be even more entangled.

The wetting and general tribology of cats has not progressed enough to give a deﬁnitive answer to the capillary dependence of the feline relaxation time. Fig. 2b gives an example of a lotus eﬀect of Felis catus, suggesti ng that the substrate is superfelidaphobic. This behavior is [Annotation 7] usually distinguished from the yield stress that cats can also display, as shown in Fig. 2c, where the kitten cannot ﬂow because it is b elow its yield stress, like ketchup in its bottle. It is still unclear what physical and chemical properties generate superfelidaphobicity, but a Cassie- Baxter-like model seems plausible. Here, the roughness of the cat’s fur would be as determinant as the roughness of the substrate, but probably with somewhat opposite eﬀects. Indeed, cats are oft en found to spread on rough substrates as seen in Fig. 2d, but they have low aﬃnity for substrates that smooth their fur, like water in Fig. 2e. Signiﬁcant wall slip and shear localizat i on can also be involved in some experiments, like shown in Fig. 2f, where there is a very signiﬁcant relative velocity b etween the substrate and the cat. Counter-intuitively, gravity seems

(continues page 30)

#### Page 3

30 Rheology Bulletin, 83(2) July 2014

3

FIG. 3: (a) A cat spontaneously rotates in a cylindrical jar. (b) Normal forces and Weissenberg eﬀect in a young sample of Felis catus. [Courtesy of (a) http://guremike.jp/, (b) http://buzzlamp.com/10-weird-places-cats-get-stuck-in/]

to enhance adhesiveness, as shown in Fig. 2g.

In the last part of this letter, I wish to discuss the possibility of ﬂow instabilities in Felis catus. Linear viscoelasticity conceptualizes the fact that if its Deborah number is small a material is ﬂowing. The physics of ﬂow instabilities warns us that, as the characteristic rate of deformation ˙γ increases, non trivial secondary ﬂows emerge and eventually become chaotic. Here, the important dimensionless number will be the Reynolds-Weissenberg number (a sort of P´eclet number):

Rw ≡ τ ˙γ (2)

The limit Rw  1 deﬁnes the laminar base ﬂow. Nontrivial secondary ﬂows will usually app ear around Rw ∼ 1. Finally, the ﬂow will b e turbul ent if Rw  1. For simple ﬂuids, the relaxation time is the viscous dissipation [Annotation 9] time, the driving force of instability is inertia and the dimensionless number is just the usual Reynolds number Rw = Re. For more complex ﬂuids in creeping ﬂow (Re = 0) recent progress on instabilities in viscoelastic polymers and micelles solutions suggests that the relevant dimensionless number is the Weissenberg number alone, i.e. Rw = Wi if Re = 0. In this case elastic turbulence can be achieved without inertia. We speak of visco elastic ﬂow instabilities.

When taken in its philosophical form, “panta rhei” is the theory of motion: the belief that everything is dynamic and that the state of rest is illusory. But for centuries, this ontology was superseded by Aristotle’s viewpoint. He posited that in the absence of an external motive power all objects would come to rest and that moving objects only continue to move so long as there is a power inducing them to do so. Modern physics started when Galileo and his followers put an end to Aristotle’s dogma by showing that, unless acted upon by a net unbalanced force, an object will maintain a constant velocity. This was key to the realization that motion is relative and preceded by the more fundamental concept of frame of reference, e.g. the train moves with respect to the frame of the platform, but the platform moves with respect to the frame of the train. Note that even if rheologists have taken Heraclitus’ doctrine as their motto, they depart from his thoughts by a paradoxical but useful conception

of motion or ﬂow, alternatively faithful to Aristotle or Galileo.

Simple ﬂuids like water are “passive”, they continue to move or deform so long as there is a power inducing them to do so. In this case, the typical ﬂow rate ˙γ is simply imposed by the operator and Rw is a natural control parameter. For cats, assuming we have a well-deﬁned relaxation time τ, computing Rw is still challenging because deﬁning ˙γ can be diﬃcult since cats are “active” materials. They have t h eir own motive power. Like other biologically active materials (acto-myosin gels, bacterial swimmers, epithelium, packs, ﬂocks, schools, etc.), they can exhibit spontaneous rotation as shown in Fig. 3a.

Despite these diﬃculties, the question remains: are cats prone to ﬂow instabilities when Rw increases? In a cylindrical ﬂow geometry, instabilities in the purely inertial case (i.e. Rw = Re) and in the purely elastic case (i.e. Rw = Wi) lead to vortex ﬂows. In the inertial case, the centrifugal force drives this instability and is also responsible for the deformation of the top free surface, which climbs up the outer walls of the cylinder. In the purely elastic case, the mechanism is opposite: centripetal n or mal forces (“ho op stresses”) drive the instability and are also responsible for the Weissenberg eﬀect, where the ﬂuid climbs at the center of the free surface. In general, both inertial and elastic eﬀects can occur. In ﬂows of Felis catus, signiﬁcant normal forces can occur and they seem to be able to drive a Weissenberg-type eﬀect, as shown in Fig. 3b.

In conclusion, much more work remains ahead, but cats are proving to be a rich model system for rheological research, both in the linear and nonlinear regimes. Standing questions include the potential implications of the rheology of cats on their righting reﬂex, and whether the nonlinear self-sustaining mechanism for turbulence in pipe is applicable to streaks of tigers. Very recent experiments from Japan also suggest that we should not see cats as isolat ed ﬂuid systems, bu t as able to transfer and absorb stresses from their environment. Indeed, in Japan, they have cat cafes, where stressed out customers [Annotation 10] can pet kitties and purr their worries away.

Acknowledgments No animals were (h)armed in the making of this study. I thank L. and J.F. Berret for providing a reliable technique to load Felis catus in diﬀerent geometries: 1. Bring an empty b ox; 2. Wait. Illustrations of the protocol can be found on the web [Annotation 11] (weknowmemes.com/2012/11/how-to-catch-a-cat/, or youtube.com/watch?v=pX4yK4yG3pE ). This paper was written in honor of Gareth’s 50th birthday and his Bingham award. Many members of the EMF helped motivating this study, all good things in it can be found in Gareth’s 200+ publications, and all mistakes are mine. Help and encouragements from A. Jaish ankar, S. Manneville, V. Sharma and N. Taberlet were particularly valuable.

(Cats, continued from page 17)

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/on-the-rheology-of-cats. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
