# Neutron Production and Absorption in Uranium

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/neutron-production-and-absorption-in-uranium

- **Authors:** H. L. Anderson, E. Fermi, and Leo Szilard
- **Published:** 1939
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1615058245366-94m71ersxv-02745a2cc742d637c733064045c624d0%2Fneutron_production_absorption_szilard.pdf
- **Pages:** 3
- **Annotations:** 8 comments in 8 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/neutron-production-and-absorption-in-uranium

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Neutron Production and Absorption in Uranium*”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-03-09):

> Leo Szilard was a Hungarian-American physicist and inventor. He conceived the nuclear chain reaction in 1933, patented the idea of a nuclear fission reactor in 1934.
>
> Szilard feared the implication that nuclear chain reaction could have for the development of nuclear weapons for national defense. He shared his fears with Einstein in the summer of 1939 and he wrote the now-famous Einstein Letter which was delivered to President Franklin D. Roosevelt in October of 1939. This letter resulted in the creation of the Manhattan Project that built the atomic bomb.
>
> Learn more about Szilard here: [American Heritage Foundation - Leo Szilard](https://www.atomicheritage.org/profile/leo-szilard)
>
> ![szilard](https://i.imgur.com/vMrgVmS.jpg)

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “H. L. ANDERSON, E. FER.liH AND LEo SziLARD Columbia University, New York, New York (Received Jul y 3 , 1939 )”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-03-06):

> ### TL;DR
>
> This seemingly short and simple paper describes an experiment made by Szilard, Fermi and and Anderson. They were interested in studying the fission of Uranium and it's associated neutron absorption and production. They were interested in Uranium's potential for self-perpetuating nuclear reactions.
>
> Szilard was convinced of the viability of a nuclear chain reaction and became concerned about the possibility of German scientists working under the Nazi regime might attempt to exploit nuclear fission for bomb-making purposes.
>
> He shared his fears with Einstein in the summer of 1939 and he wrote the now-famous Einstein Letter which was delivered to President Franklin D. Roosevelt in October of 1939. This letter resulted in the creation of the Manhattan Project that built the atomic bomb.
>
> You can find the famous Einstein-Szilard Letter here: [Atomic Heritage Foundation - Einstein-Szilard Letter](https://www.atomicheritage.org/key-documents/einstein-szilard-letter)

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “H. L. ANDERSON, E. FER.liH AND LEo SziLARD Columbia University, New York, New York (Received Jul y 3 , 1939 )”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-03-09):

> H. L. Anderson was an American nuclear physicist who was Professor of Physics at the University of Chicago. He was a member of the team which made the first demonstration of nuclear fission in the United States. He contributed to the Manhattan Project and participated in the first atomic bomb test.
>
> Learn more about Anderson here: [America Heritage Foundation - Herbert L. Anderson](https://www.atomicheritage.org/profile/herbert-l-anderson)
>
> ![Anderson](https://www.atomicheritage.org/sites/default/files/Herb%20Anderson%2C%201950s%2C%20photo%20from%20U%20of%20Chicago%20and%20David%20Wargowski.jpg)

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “H. L. ANDERSON, E. FER.liH AND LEo SziLARD Columbia University, New York, New York (Received Jul y 3 , 1939 )”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-03-09):

> Enrico Fermi was an Italian physicist and Nobel Prize winner. He emigrated to the United States where he worked on the Manhattan Project during World War II. Fermi led the team that designed and built Chicago Pile-1, which in 1942 demonstrated the first artificial self-sustaining nuclear chain reaction.
>
> Fermi was one of the few physicists to excel both theoretically and experimentally and was known for his ability to make good approximate calculations with little or no actual data.
> ![fermi](http://www.atomicheritage.org/sites/default/files/Enrico%20Fermi%20chalkboard_0.jpg)
>
> You can find more papers authored by Fermi on Fermat's Library:
> - [My observations during the explosion at Trinity](https://fermatslibrary.com/s/my-observations-during-the-explosion-at-trinity)

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “T has been found 1 - 3 that there is an abundant emission of neutrons from uranium under the action . of slow neutrons, and it is of interest to asce rt ain whet h er and to what extent the number of neutrons e mitted exceeds the number absorbed. This question can be investi ga ted by placing a photo-neutron source in …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-03-06):

> This research lead to the design of the first nuclear reactor capable of maintain a self-sustaining nuclear chain reaction the Chicago Pile 1.
>
> ![chicagopile1](https://i.imgur.com/QXfM94k.jpg)
> *The Chicago Pile 1 reactor consisted of uranium and uranium oxide lumps spaced in a cubic lattice embedded in graphite. On December 2, 1942 it achieved the first self-sustaining chain reaction and thereby initiated the controlled release of nuclear energy.*

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “T has been found 1 - 3 that there is an abundant emission of neutrons from uranium under the action . of slow neutrons, and it is of interest to asce rt ain whet h er and to what extent the number of neutrons e mitted exceeds the number absorbed. This question can be investi ga ted by placing a photo-neutron source in …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-03-09):

> **Thermal Neutron**
>
> Thermal neutrons **are free neutrons, they are not bound within an atomic nucleus.** They have a kinetic energy of about 0.025 eV - corresponding to the average energy of the particles of the ambient materials. Relatively slow and of low energy, thermal neutrons exhibit properties, such as large cross sections in fission, that make them desirable in certain chain-reaction applications.
>
> They are produced by slowing down more energetic neutrons in a substance called a moderator after they have been ejected from atomic nuclei during nuclear reactions such as fission.

### Annotation 7 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “section for ne u tron production and neutron absorption in uranium is greater t h an one, and probably abo u t 1.5. \ Nhat fraction of the neutrons will reach t h e rmal energ i es w i t h o ut being absorb ed will, h oweve r, depend on the ratio of the average concent ra t ions of h yd rogen and ur ani um . Since …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-03-09):

> A nuclear chain reaction occurs when one single nuclear reaction causes an average of one or more subsequent nuclear reactions. Isotopes of Uranium (ex: uranium-235) were selected by scientists because they readily undergo fission. Fission occurs when a neutron strikes the nucleus of an isotope and splits it into fragments thus releasing an enormous amount of energy. The **fission process becomes self-sustaining as neutrons produced by the splitting of atom strike nearby nuclei and produce more fission. This is known as a chain reaction and is what causes an atomic explosion.** A nuclear chain reaction releases several million times more energy per reaction than any chemical reaction.
>
> ![nuclear_chain_reaction](https://i.imgur.com/ky387D3.png)

### Annotation 8 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “section for ne u tron production and neutron absorption in uranium is greater t h an one, and probably abo u t 1.5. \ Nhat fraction of the neutrons will reach t h e rmal energ i es w i t h o ut being absorb ed will, h oweve r, depend on the ratio of the average concent ra t ions of h yd rogen and ur ani um . Since …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-03-09):

> > "From this result we may conclude that a nuclear chain reaction could be maintained in a
> system in which neutrons are slowed down without much absorption until they reach thermal
> energies and are then mostly absorbed by uranium rather than by another element."

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

AUGUST 1, 1939 PHYSICAL REVIEW Printed in U. S. A.

VOLUME 56

Neutron Production and Absorption [Annotation 1] in Uranium*

H. L. ANDERSON, [Annotation 2] E. FER.liH AND [Annotation 3] LEo SziLARD Columbia University, New York, [Annotation 4] New York (Received Jul y 3 , 1939 )

I

T has been found 1 - 3 that there is an abundant emission of neutrons from uranium under the action . of slow neutrons, and it is of interest to asce rt ain [Annotation 5] whet h er and to what extent the number of neutrons e mitted exceeds the number absorbed. This question can be investi ga ted by placing a photo-neutron source in the center of a large water tank and comparin g, with and without uranium in the water, the number of thermal neutrons present in the water. In the previous experiments of this type 1 • 3 it was attempted to have as closely as possible a spherically symmetrical distribution of neutrons. The number of thermal neutrons present in the water was determined [Annotation 6] by measurin g along one radius the neutron density p as a function of the distance r from the center, and then calculating fr 2 pdr. A difference in favor of uranium of abo ut five percent was reported by von Halb an, Joliot and Kovarski. 4 Since one has to measure a small difference, s li ght deviations from a sp h er ically symmetrical distribution might g iv e misleading results. The present experiments which are based on the same ge neral principle do not require such symmetry. In order to measure the number of therma l neutrons in the water we filled the tank with a ten-percent solution of MnS04. The activity induced in manganese is proportional to the number of thermal neutrons present. A physical averaging was performed by stirring the solut i on before m eas urin g the activity of a sample with an ionization chamber. To obtain an effect of sufficient magnitude, about 200 kg of U30s was used. Th e expe rim enta l arrangement is shown in . Fig. 1. A photo-neutron so urc e, consist in g of about 2 g of radium and 250 g of beryllium was

*Pub li cation assisted by the Erne s t Kempton Adams Fund for Physical Rese a rch of Co lumbi a U niversity. tv. Halban, J o li ot and Kovarski, Natur e 143, 470 (1939).

2 L. Szilard and W. H. Zinn, Ph ys . R ev . 55 , 799 ( 1939 ) . a And er so n, F ermi and Han ste in, Phy s. R e v. 55, 797 (1939) . 4 v. Halban, Joliot and Kovar ski, Nature 143, 680 (1939).

pla ced in the center of the tank. The geo metry was such that practically all neutr ons emitted by the source and by the ur a nium oxide were s l owed down a nd absorbed within the tank. Each irr a diation exten d ed over several half-life periods of radioman ga nese and the observed activity of the solution was about four times the background of the ionizati o n chamber. Alt e rnatin g measurement s were taken with the cans filled with uranium oxide, and with e mpty cans of the same dimen s i o ns. The activity pr ove d to be about ten perce nt hi g h er with uranium oxide than without it. Thi s r es ult s hows that in our ar r angement mor e n e utron s are emitted by ur anium than are absorbed by uranium. In order to find the average number of fast neutrons emitted by uranium for each thermal neutron absorbed by u rani um , we have to d e - termine what fraction of the total number of neutrons emitted by the photo-n e utron so urce is, in o ur exper im ent, absorbed in the thermal re g ion by uranium. The number of photo-neutrons

0000 000000 00000000

0 0 0 0 -s oooo oooo 00000000

000000

0000

IOcm

FIG. 1. Horizonta l sect i o n through center of cylindrical tank which is fill ed with 540 li ters o f 10-p er cent MnSO, solution. A Photo-n e utr o n so ur ce composed of 2.3 grams of r ad ium 250 gram s of beryllium. B, One of 52 cylindrical cans 5 em in diamet er and 60 em in height, which are either empty or fill ed with uranium oxide. 284

#### Page 2

285 NEUTRON PRODUCTION AND ABSORPTIO

emitted by the source is indicated by the activity of the solution in the tank when the irradiation is carried out with e m pty cans s urr o undin g the source. Vve a m easure of th i s numb er by taking into acco un t that in our sol ution abo u t 20 percent of the ne u trons are capt ur ed by manganese and the rest by hydrogen. In order to obta in , in the same units , a measure of the number of neutrons absorbed by uranium we proceeded in the followin g way: A mixture of sand and manganese powder, having the sa m e thermal ne u tron absorption as uranium oxide replaced the u ranium oxide in t of the cans which were distributed uniformly among the other uranium ox id e-filled cans. After irradiation, all this powder was mixed toget h er, a ten-pe r cent MnS04 solut i on was prepared from a samp l e, and i ts activity was m easured w i th o ur ionization cha mb er. In this way we found that abo u t SO percent of t h e neutr ons e mitt e d by the so urc e are absorbed as t hermal n e utrons by uranium in our arrangement. I t follows that, if ur an ium absorbed only the rm al neutrons, the observed ten-percent inc rea se in activity obtaine d with ur a nium present would correspond to an average emission of a bout 1.2 neutrons per thermal neutron absorbed by uranium. Thi s number should be increased , to perhaps 1.5, by tak in g int o account the neutrons wh ich , in our p art i c ular a rran ge ment , are absorbed at r eso nanc e in t h e nonthermal region by uranium , without ca u s in g neutr on e mi ssiOn. From this result we m ay conclude that a nuclear cha in r eact ion could be maintained in a syste m in which neu t rons are slowed down w i tho u t mu c h absorption until t hey re ac h thermal e ner gies a nd are then mo st ly absorbed by uranium rather than by another el e m e n t. I t remain s a n open question, however, whet h er this holds for a syste m in w hi ch hydrogen is u se d for s lowing d ow n the neutrons. In s uch a syste m the abso rp t ion of n e utron s ta k es place in th r ee diff erent ways: Th e neutrons are absorb ed at ther m a l energ i es, both by hydrogen and ur ani um , and they a re also absorbed by uranium at re so nance b efore they are slowed down to thermal ener g ies. Our result is independent of the ratio of the concentrations of hydro gen and uranium , in sofar as it shows that, for thermal neutrons, the ratio of the cross

section for ne u tron production and neutron absorption in uranium is greater t h an one, and probably abo u t 1.5. \ Nhat fraction of the neutrons will reach t h e rmal energ i es w i t h o ut being absorb ed will, h oweve r, depend on the ratio of the average concent ra t ions of h yd rogen and ur ani um . Since there is an apprec i ab l e absorption even far from the center of the resonance band, it follows that the fraction of neutrons abso rb ed by uranium at resonance will increase with d ecreasi ng hydrogen concentrat ion. This has to be ta k e n into account in discussing t h e possibility of a nuclear chain reaction in a syste m composed essent i a ll y of ur a nium and hydrogen. A chain reaction wou ld require [Annotation 7] that more neutrons be produced by uranium than absorbed by uranium and hydro gen together. In our exper iment the ratio of the average concentration of h y dro ge n to ur a nium atoms was 17 to 1 , and in the experiment of von Halban, Joliot and Kovarski this r at io was 70 to 1. At such conce ntr at i ons the absorption o f hydro gen in the t h e rmal region will prevent a chain reaction. By reducing the concentration of hydro gen one would obtain the followin g e ffect: On the one h a nd a lar ger fraction of those neutrons which reach thermal energies will be absorbed by uranium; on the other hand fewer neutrons reach t h e thermal r eg ion du e to an incr ease d absorption by uranium at re sonance. Of t h ese two counteracting factors the first is more importan t for hig h h y dro gen co ncentrations [Annotation 8] and the second is mor e important for lo w hydro gen concentrations. Starting with high hydrogen co n ce ntrations , the ratio of neutron produ ct ion to t ota l neutr on absorption will thus fir st rise , pass through a maximum, and, as the hydro gen concentration is d ec rea se d, thereafter decrea se. We attempted to es timate the quantities involv e d from the information available about resonanc e absorption in uranium •- 7 and from the observed net ga in of 0.2 in the number of neutrons in our experiment. The effect of the absorption at resonance t urn s out to be so

5 Meitner, Hahn a nd Strassman, Z eits. f. Physik 106, 2 49 ( 1937 ). s v. Hal ban, Kovar s ki and Savitch, Compt es rend u s 208, 1396 (1939).

7 H . L. Anderson and E. F ermi, Ph ys. Rev. 55, 1106 (1939).

#### Page 3

ANDERSON, FERMI AND SZILARD 286

large that even at the optimum concentration of hydrogen it is at present quite uncertain whether neutron production will exceed the total neutron absorpt-ion. More information concerning the resonance absorption of uranium as well as more accurate measurement of some of the values which enter into our calculation are required before we can conclude whether a chain reaction is possible in mi.xtures of uranium and water.

We wish to thank Dr. D . W. Stewart, of the Department of Chemistry, and [r. S . E. Krewer, for advice and assistance in carrying out some of these experiments. We are much indebted to the Eldorado Radium Corporation for enabling us to work with large quantities of uranium oxide in our experiments, and to the Association for Scientific Collaboration for the use of the photoneutron source and other facilities.

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/neutron-production-and-absorption-in-uranium. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
