# Many lives in many worlds

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/many-lives-in-many-worlds

- **Authors:** Max Tegmark
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1459040693394-sihydd9rxvt96oqj-3010f86c4d15fbe60d50fc9138bb3c3c%2F0707.2593v1.pdf
- **Pages:** 3
- **Annotations:** 17 comments in 14 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/many-lives-in-many-worlds

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Max Tegmark (In this universe:) Dept. of Physics & MIT Kavli Institute, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-04):

> This paper is about Everett's theory that Schrodinger's equation applies at all times, therefore the wavefunction never collapses. The author takes Everett's theory and discusses the implications associated with the non-collapse of the wavefunction (i.e. parallel worlds). This paper is important because it discusses the probability of multiple universes, a theory that (so far) is beyond our limits of observation.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Almost all of my colleagues have an opinion about it, but almost none of them have read it. The ﬁrst draft of Hugh Everett’s PhD thesis, the shortened oﬃcial version of which celebrates its 50th birthday this year, is buried in the out-of-pr int book The Many-Worlds Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics [1]. I remember …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-03-30):

> Everett’s thesis discussed the possibility that Schrodinger’s cat is both dead and alive, because the universe splits into two. In one universe, the cat is dead; in another, the cat is alive. Everett postulated that at each quantum juncture the universe splits in half, in an incessant sequence of splitting universes. Here is an example of Everett’s theory https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNwKPfOKipk

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The sticky part is how to connect this wavefunction w ith what we observe. Many legitimate wavefunctions correspond to counterintuitive situations, such as Schr¨odinger’s cat being dead-and-alive at the same time in a “superpo sition” of states. In the 1920s, physicists explained away this weirdness by postulating …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-03-30):

> Schrodinger's cat - Imagine a cat enclosed in a box with a radioactive source. If a single atom of the radioactive source decays, a mechanism would trip a hammer, which would in turn, break the vial containing the radioactive source, and kill the cat.
>  Until the source emits radiation, the cat would be considered (according to quantum mechanics) to be simultaneously both dead and alive, until the box is open, and the cat is observed. When the box is open, the “wavelength” collapses, and the cat can either be one of these two things: dead OR alive.
> Here is a brief video demonstrating Schrodinger’s cat and the implications behind observation
> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IOYyCHGWJq4

**Reply** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-03):

> The theory itself was incomplete because there is no mathematical way of calculating an observation, and without math to support it, a theory is merely a postulation. Scientists could not use observations as part of this theory, there was no way to accurately test an observation without mathematics behind it, thus rendering this theory incomplete.

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Quantum mechanics speciﬁes the state of the univer se not in classical terms, such as the positions and velocities of all particles, but in terms of a mathematical object called a wavefunction. According to the Schr¨odinger equation, this wavefunction evolves over time in a de-”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-03-30):

> The wave function is the mathematical formula we use to describe quantum objects. It is a wavering quantity that mathematically describes the wave characteristics of a particle. The value of the wave function of a particular particle at a given point of space/time is related to the probability of the particles being there at that time.
> Here is more information on wave functions https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aowYf44gDRY

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Everett’s theory is simple to state but has complicated implications, including par allel universes. The theory can be summed up by saying that the Schr¨odinger equation applies at all times; in other words, that the wavefunction never collapses. That’s it – no mention of parallel universes or splitting worlds, which …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-03-30):

> Schrodinger’s equation is the basic equation for describing quantum behavior, and is constantly used in quantum mechanics. Also known as the Schrodinger wave equation, it is a partial differential equation that describes how the wavefunctions of a physical system change over time.  In the past, observation of Schrodinger’s cat was said to “collapse” the wavefunction, thus leaving only one outcome (a dead or alive cat), however, Everett’s theory postulates that the wavelength never truly collapses, instead, the wavelength transforms into a parallel universe. In this case, if we were to open Schrodinger's box and find a dead cat, a parallel universe would be created where we open the box and find an alive cat.

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “FIG. 1: Is it only in ﬁction that we can experience parallel lives? If atoms can be in two places at once, so can you.”

**Annotation** by Imran Qureshi (2019-08-01):

> Funny

### Annotation 7 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “The breakthrough came in 1970 with a seminal paper by H. Dieter Zeh, who showed that the Schr¨odinger equation itself gives rise to a type of censorship. This eﬀect became known as “decoherence ”, and was worked out in great detail by Wojciech Zurek, Zeh and others over the following decades. Quantum superpositions …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-03):

> Decoherence was Zeh's theory involving Schrodinger's cat. Zeh noticed that in the real world you could not separate the cat from the environment (air molecules, the box, cosmic rays passing through the experiment). Zeh claimed that these interactions, no matter how small, can radically affect the wave function. If the wave function is disturbed in the slightest way, then the wave function will suddenly split into two distinct wave functions of the dead cat or the live cat (which no longer interact). Zeh showed that  a collision with a single air molecule was enough to collapse the wavefunction, forcing the permanent separation of the dead cat and the live cat, which no longer interact, In other words, before you even open the box, the cat has been in contact with the air molecules and hence is already dead or alive.

**Reply** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-03):

> Here is a video going more in depth about wave functions and decoherance https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zbe6ov22Nok

### Annotation 8 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Science of philosophy? The main motivation for introducing the no tion of random wavefunction collapse into quantum physics had been to e xplain why we perceive probabilities and not strange macroscopic superpositions . After Everett had shown that things wo uld appear rando m anyway (Figure 2) and decoherence had b e …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-03):

> The wavefunction never collapses in Everett's view, they just continue to evolve, forever splitting into other wave functions in a never-ending tree, with each branch representing an entire universe. However, in our universe, we perceive the wavefunction as "collapsing" because decoherence only gives us one outcome. If in this universe the outcome is "a", we perceive the wavefunction as collapsing to "a", however, there is another universe where the wavefunction collapses to "b" and the people living in that universe perceive the wavefunction collapsing to "b". Thus, decoherence appears as if it produces an effect like a collapse separately in each parallel universe, however, on a large scale, the wavefunction never collapses.

### Annotation 9 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “FIG. 2: According to quantum theory, a card perfectly b alanced on its edge will fall down in what is known as a “superposition” — the card really is in two places at once. If a gambler bets money on the queen landing face up, her own state changes to become a superposition of two possible outcomes — winning or losing …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-04):

> This example is supposed to prove that nothing is truly "random" when it comes to probability, even if it appears so. The underlying physics proves the card falling is not random, 16 parallel worlds would exist in which this card has every possible outcome

### Annotation 10 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Because Einstein’s theory of General Relativity has successfully predicted many things that we can observe, we also take s eriously its predictions for things we cannot, like the internal structure of black holes. Analogously, successful pre dictio ns by unitary quantum mechanics have made scientists take more …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-04):

> If we can use Einstein's theory of General Relativity to predict the physics surrounding certain objects we can not observe (internal structure of black holes for example) then we should be able to use theories of quantum mechanics to predict items we cannot see as well (such as parallel universes).

### Annotation 11 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “For example, if these parallel universes exist, then why don’t we perceive them? Quantum superpositions can-”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-03):

> Everett's theory claims that decoherence explains why we don't perceive parallel universes. He claimed that perhaps the cat is dead and alive at the same time, but in different universes. The cat is both dead and alive because the universe has split into two. In one universe, the cat is dead, and in another universe, the cat is alive. If this interpretation is correct, then at this very moment, your body coexists with wave functions of dinosaurs, wave functions where the Germans won world war one, where aliens roam, where you were never born, etc. The catch is we can no longer interact with these wave functions, because they have decohered from us (the waves are no longer in phase with one another). This means the slightest contamination with the environment will prevent the various wave functions from interacting with one another, thus we are unable to perceive these parallel universes.

### Annotation 12 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Indeed, collapse-free superpositions have been demonstrated in, for example, carbon-60 molecules. Several groups are now attempting to create quantum super positions of objects involving 10 1 7 ato ms or more, tantalizingly close to o ur human macroscopic s cale. There is also a g lobal eﬀort to build quantum …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-04):

> Everett's theory claimed that regardless of the size of the system, scientists will not observe a wavefunction collapsing, however, this theory will be disproven by future lab experiments.  Decoherence is due to constant interactions with the environment, which are impossible to avoid. This explains that what we think of as an observation doesn’t require a human; simply interacting with the environment counts. This explains why bringing large objects into superpositions of two states is extremely difficult and the superposition fades rapidly. The heaviest object so fat that has been brought into a superposition of locations is a carbon-60 molecule. More ambitious scientists have proposed to do this experiment to viruses or even heavier creatures, such as bacteria. Thus, the paradox that Schrodinger’s cat once raised, (the transfer of a quantum superposition, the decaying atom, to a large object, the cat) has been resolved. Scientists now understand that while small things (atoms, quarks, ect) can exist in superpositions for extended amounts of time, a large object will settle extremely quickly in one particular state. That is why we never see cats that are both dead and alive.

### Annotation 13 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Indeed, collapse-free superpositions have been demonstrated in, for example, carbon-60 molecules. Several groups are now attempting to create quantum super positions of objects involving 10 1 7 ato ms or more, tantalizingly close to o ur human macroscopic s cale. There is also a g lobal eﬀort to build quantum …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-04):

> A quantum computer can solve problems that no classical computer would be able to solve within a reasonable amount of time. They would be able to decrypt the majority of the cryptographic systems in use today. Currently, Google and NASA are working on building a quantum computer, here is a video explaining more about quantum computers as a whole, and google and nasa's involvement. http://mashable.com/2013/10/13/google-quantum-computing-video/#KW2dQZTqnsq3

**Reply** by Ted Sanders (2016-04-13):

> I don't think that's true. In a practical sense, classical computers are still faster than quantum computers. In a theoretical sense, it hasn't been proven impossible for a classical computer to factor a number in polynomial time.

### Annotation 14 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Everett asked us to acknowledge that our physical world is grander than we had imagined, a humble suggestion that is probably easier to accept after the recent breakthroughs in cosmology than it was 50 years ago. I think Everett’s only mistake was to be born ahead of his time. In another 50 years, I believe we will be …”

**Annotation** by Chelsie Steele (2016-04-04):

> If you would like to learn more about parallel worlds and the science behind it, here is a short article/video http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2816039/Parallel-universes-exist-Multiple-versions-living-alternate-worlds-interact-theory-claims.html

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

arXiv:0707.2593v1 [quant-ph] 18 Jul 2007

Many lives in many worlds

Max Tegmark [Annotation 1] (In this universe:) Dept. of Physics & MIT Kavli Institute, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA

(Dated: Published in Nature, 448, 23, July 2007)

I argue that accepting quantum mechanics to be universally tru e means that you should also believe in parallel universes. I give my assessment of Everett’s th eory as it celebrates its 50th anniversary.

Almost all of my colleagues have an opinion about it, but almost none of them have read it. The ﬁrst draft of [Annotation 2] Hugh Everett’s PhD thesis, the shortened oﬃcial version of which celebrates its 50th birthday this year, is buried in the out-of-pr int book The Many-Worlds Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics [1]. I remember my excitement on ﬁnding it in a small Be rkeley book store back in grad school, and still view it as one of the most brilliant texts I’ve ever read.

By the time Everett started his graduate work with John Archibald Wheeler at Princeton University, q uantum mechanics had chalked up stunning successes in explaining the atomic realm, yet a debate raged on as to what its mathematical formalism really meant. I was fortunate to get to discuss q uantum mechanics with Wheeler during my postdoctorate years in Princeton, but never had the chance to meet Everett.

Quantum mechanics speciﬁes the state of the univer se not in classical terms, such as the positions and velocities of all particles, but in terms of a mathematical object called a wavefunction. According to the Schr¨odinger [Annotation 4] equation, this wavefunction evolves over time in a de-

FIG. 1: Is it only in ﬁction that we can experience parallel lives? If atoms can be in two places at once, so can you. [Annotation 6]

terministic fashion that mathematicians term “unitary ”. Although quantum mechanics is often described as inherently random and uncertain, there is nothing random or uncertain abo ut the way the wavefunction evolves.

The sticky part is how to connect this wavefunction w ith what we observe. Many legitimate wavefunc- [Annotation 3] tions correspond to counterintuitive situations, such as Schr¨odinger’s cat being dead-and-alive at the same time in a “superpo sition” of states. In the 1920s, physicists explained away this weirdness by postulating that the wavefunction “collapsed” into some random but deﬁnite classical outcome whenever s omeone made an obs e rvation. This add-on had the virtue of explaining observations, but rendered the theor y incomplete, be c ause there was no mathematics specifying what constituted an observation – that is, when the wavefunction was supposed to collapse.

Everett’s theory is simple to state but has complicated implications, including par allel universes. The theory can be summed up by saying that the Schr¨odinger equation applies at all times; in other words, that the wavefunction never collapses. That’s it – no mention of parallel universes or splitting worlds, which are implications of the [Annotation 5] theory rather than po stulates. His brilliant insight was that this collapse- free quantum theory is, in fact, consistent with observation. Although it predicts that a wavefunction describing one classical reality gradually evolves into a wavefunction des cribing a superposition of ma ny such realities – the many worlds – observers subjectively exp erience this splitting merely as a slig ht randomness (see Figure 2), w ith probabilities consistent with those calculated using the wavefunction-collapse recipe.

Gaining acceptance It is often said that important scientiﬁc discoveries go though three phases: ﬁrst they are completely ignored, then they are violently attacked, a nd ﬁnally they are brushed aside as well-known. Everett’s discovery was no exception: it took over a decade until it started getting noticed. But it was too late for Everett who left academia disillusioned [2].

Everett’s no-collapse idea is not yet at stage three, but after being widely dismissed as too crazy during the 1970s and 1980s, it ha s gradually gained more acceptance. At an informal poll taken at a conference on the foundations of quantum theory in 1999 physicists rated the idea more highly than the alternatives, although there were still

#### Page 2

2

100%0% 25% 50% 75% Fraction of queens face up

FIG. 2: According to quantum theory, a card perfectly b alanced on its edge will fall down in what is known as a “superposition” — the card really is in two places at once. If a gambler bets money on the queen landing face up, her own state changes to become a superposition of two possible outcomes — winning or losing the bet. In either of these parallel worlds, the gambler is unaware of the other outcome and feels as if the card fell randomly. If the gambler repeats this game four times in a row, there will be 16 (2 × 2 × 2 × 2) possible outcomes, or parallel worlds. In most of these worlds, it will seem that q ueens occur randomly, with about 50% probabil- [Annotation 9] ity. Only in two worlds will all four cards land the same way up. If the game is continued many more times, almost every gambler in each of the worlds will conclude that the laws of probability apply even though th e underlying physics is not random and, as Einstein would have put it, “God does not play dice”.

many more ”undecided” [3]. I believe the upwards trend is clear.

Why the change? I think there are several reasons. Predictions of other types of para llel universes from co smological inﬂation and string theory have increased tolerance for weird-sounding ideas. New experiments have demonstrated quantum weirdness in ever larg er systems. Finally, the discovery of a process known as decoherence has a nswered crucial questions that Everett’s work had left dang ling.

For example, if these parallel universes exist, then why don’t we perceive them? Quantum superpositions can- [Annotation 11]

not be conﬁned – as most quantum experiments are – to the microworld. Beca use you are made o f atoms , then if atoms can be in two places at once in superposition, so can you (Figure 1).

The breakthrough came in 1970 with a seminal paper by H. Dieter Zeh, who showed that the Schr¨odinger equation itself gives rise to a type of censorship. This eﬀect became known as “decoherence ”, and was worked out in great detail by Wojciech Zurek, Zeh and others over the [Annotation 7] following decades. Quantum superpositions were found to remain observable only as long as they were kept secret from the rest of the world. The quantum card in Figure 2 is constantly bumping into air molecules, photons, and so on, which thereby ﬁnd out whether it has fallen to the left or to the right, destroying the coherence of the supe rp osition and making it unobservable. Decoherence also explains why states resembling classical physics have sp e c ial status: they are the most robust to decoherence.

Science of philosophy? The main motivation for introducing the no tion of random wavefunction collapse into quantum physics had been to e xplain why we perceive probabilities and not strange macroscopic superpositions . After Everett had shown that things wo uld appear rando m anyway (Figure 2) and decoherence had b e en found to explain why we never perceived anything strange, much of this motivation was gone. Even though the wavefunction technically never collapses in the Everett view, it is generally agreed that decoherence produces an eﬀect that looks like a co llapse and smells like a collapse . [Annotation 8]

In my opinion, it is time to update the many quantum textbooks that introduce wavefunction collapse as a fundamental postulate of quantum mechanics. The notion of collapse still has utility as a calculational recipe, but students should be told that it is probably not a fundamental proces s violating the Schr¨odinge r equation so as to avoid any subsequent confusion. If you are considering a quantum textbook that does not mention “Everett” and “decoherence” in the index, I recommend buying a more modern one.

After 50 years we can c e le brate the fact that Everett’s interpretation is still consistent with quantum observations, but we face another pressing question: is it science or mere philosophy? The key point is that parallel universes are not a theory in themselves, but a prediction of certain theories. For a theory to be falsiﬁable, we need not observe and test all its predictions – one will do.

Because Einstein’s theory of General Relativity has [Annotation 10] successfully predicted many things that we can observe, we also take s eriously its predictions for things we cannot, like the internal structure of black holes. Analogously, successful pre dictio ns by unitary quantum mechanics have made scientists take more seriously its other predictions, including parallel universes

Moreover, Everett’s theory is falsiﬁable by future lab exp eriments: no matter how large a system they probe, it s ays, they will not observe the wavefunction collapsing.

#### Page 3

3

Indeed, collapse-free superpositions have been demon- [Annotation 12] strated in, for example, carbon-60 molecules. Several groups are now attempting to create quantum super positions of objects involving 10 1 7 ato ms or more, tantalizingly close to o ur human macroscopic s cale. There is also a g lobal eﬀort to build quantum computers which, [Annotation 13] if successful, will be able to factor numbers exponentially faster than classical computers, eﬀectively perfor ming parallel computations in Everett’s parallel worlds.

The bird perspective So Everett’s theory is testable and so far ag rees with observation. But should you really believe it? When thinking about the ultimate nature of reality, I ﬁnd it useful to distinguish between two ways of viewing a physical theory: the outside view of a physicist studying its mathematical equations, like a bird surveying a landscape from high above, and the ins ide view of an observer living in the world described by the equations, like a frog being watched by the bird.

From the bird perspec tive, Everett’s multiverse is simple. There is only one wavefunction, and it evolves smoothly and deterministically over time without a ny kind of splitting or parallelism. The abs tract quantum world des c rib e d by this evolving wavefunction contains within it a vast number of class ic al parallel storylines (“worlds”), continuously splitting and merging, as well as a number of quantum phenomena that lack a classical description. From their frog perspective, observers perceive only a tiny fraction of this full rea lity, and they perceive the splitting of classical storylines as quantum randomness.

What is more fundamental – the frog pers pective or the bird perspective? In other words, what is more basic to you: human languag e or mathematical la nguage? If you opt for the former, you would pro bably prefer a “many words” interpretation of quantum mechanics,

where mathematical simplicity is sacriﬁced to collapse the wavefunction and eliminate parallel universes.

But if you pre fer a simple and purely ma thematical theory, then you – like me – are stuck with the many worlds interpretation. If you struggle with this you are in good company: in general, it has proven extremely diﬃcult to formulate a mathematical theory that predicts everything we can observe and nothing else – and not just for quantum physics.

Moreover, we should expect quantum mechanics to feel counterintuitive because evolution endowed us with intuition only for thos e aspects of physics that had survival value for our distant ancestors, such as the trajectories of ﬂying rocks.

The choice is yours. But I worry that if we dismiss theories like Everett’s b ecause we can’t observe everything or because they seem weird, we risk missing true breakthroughs, perpetuating our instinctive reluctance to expand our horizons. To modern ears the Shapley- Curtis debate of 1920 about whether there were really a multitude of galaxies (parallel universes by the standards of the time) sounds positively quaint.

Everett asked us to acknowledge that our physical world is grander than we had imagined, a humble suggestion that is probably easier to accept after the recent breakthroughs in cosmology than it was 50 years ago. I think Everett’s only mistake was to be born ahead of his time. In another 50 years, I believe we will be more [Annotation 14] used to the weird ways of o ur cosmos, and even ﬁnd its strangeness to be part of its charm.

Acknowledgments: This work was supported by NASA grant and NNG06GC55G, NSF grants AST- 0134999 and 0607597, the Kavli Foundation, and fellowships from the David and Lucile Packard Foundation and the Research Corporation.

[1] H. Everett, in “The Many-Worlds Interpretation of Quan-

tum Mechanics”, B. S. DeWitt & N. Graham (eds.), Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton (1973) [2] E. Shikhovtsev, “Biography of Hugh Everett, III”,

http://space.mit.edu/home/tegmark/everett/

[3] M. Tegmark & J. A. Wheeler, “100 Years of the

Quantum”, Scientiﬁc American, Feb. 2001, 68-75, http://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/0101077

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/many-lives-in-many-worlds. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
