# Man’s size in terms of fundamental constants

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/man-ssize-in-terms-of-fundamental-constants

- **Authors:** William H. Press
- **Published:** 1991
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1753022379466-bs17zyggddk-e330dbe079db544d20e709f7dc50653a%2F1980-press.pdf
- **Pages:** 2
- **Annotations:** 8 comments in 8 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/man-ssize-in-terms-of-fundamental-constants

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “William H. Press Department of Physics, Harvard University and Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138 (Received 26 September 1979; accepted 15 January 1980)”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-09-28):

> The author argues that intelligent life requires
> - (i) complex chemistry
> - (ii) substantial atmosphere
> - (iii) bodies strong enough to resist gravity.
>
> From these premises, he derives the density of life-forms, environmental temperature, planetary mass and radius, and finally the characteristic size and lifespan of intelligent beings. The only free parameter is the effective bond energy, ε ≈ 0.003 Ry (hydrogen bonds), with size depending weakly on ε (∝ ε^¼) and lifespan strongly (∝ ε$^{–2.75}$).
>
> His conclusion: intelligent creatures across the universe should be roughly Earth-sized and live on Earth-like planets, though their characteristic timescales may differ greatly with stellar environment.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “William H. Press Department of Physics, Harvard University and Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138 (Received 26 September 1979; accepted 15 January 1980)”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-09-28):

> William H. Press (b. 1948) is a physicist best known for work in astrophysics and computational science (co-author of the classic Numerical Recipes).
>
> He earned his PhD under Nobel laureate William Fowler at Caltech, later held professorships at Harvard and UT Austin, was deputy director of Los Alamos, and served on the U.S. President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology.
>
> ![](https://numerical.recipes/whp/WHPheadshot3.jpg)

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “where mp is the mass of a proton. The scale of energies for all molecular binding is set by the characteristic energy of the hydrogen atom,”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-09-28):

> The Rydberg energy is the binding energy of the electron in the hydrogen atom’s ground state

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “According to (i) above, man’s chemistry is complicated, so his binding energies are a small fraction, say ¢€, of a Rydberg. A reasonable value for € is 0.003; but we will see below that in fact Lj, depends on € only very weakly. We next observe that man must live in an environment whose temperature is given in order …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-09-28):

> In statistical physics, temperature corresponds to the average thermal energy per particle:
>
> $$
> K_B T \sim E
> $$
>
> So the temperature formula in the paper is just:
>
> $$
> T \sim \epsilon \, \frac{E_\text{Ry}}{k_B}
> $$

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Haldane’s essay “On Being the Right Size,” ! discusses qualitatively but elegantly some concepts of elementary physics which cause various animal species to be the sizes that they are: weight increasing as the cube of size, while structural strength increases as only the square; force required to escape from the …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-09-28):

> The anthropic principle is the idea that the universe’s laws and constants must allow for the existence of observers like us, otherwise we wouldn’t be here to notice them.
>
> There are a couple of standard formulations:
>
> - Weak anthropic principle (WAP):
> Our observations of the universe are necessarily biased by the fact that we exist. For example, we shouldn’t be surprised to find ourselves on a planet with liquid water, because only such planets can support beings asking the question.
>
> - Strong anthropic principle (SAP):
> The universe (or multiverse) must have properties that inevitably give rise to life and observers at some stage. This is more controversial, because it sounds like the universe is “designed” for life, though in physics it’s often interpreted in terms of selection effects across many possible universes.
>
> Physicists sometimes use the principle in a very practical sense: to explain why certain physical constants (like the strength of gravity or the fine-structure constant) take the values they do if they were even slightly different, stable stars, chemistry, or life might not exist.

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “GMo/Re ~ € Ry/mp, (3) where G is the gravitational constant, M@ and Rg are the mass and radius of the Earth. From Eq. (2) we have”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-09-28):

> We want to estimate the condition for a planet to retain a nontrivial atmosphere.
> Press first sets the ambient temperature by the chemistry scale:
>
> #### Thermal velocity
>
> \[
> k_B T \sim \epsilon \, E_{\rm Ry}
> \]
>
> For hydrogen atoms (mass $m_p$) in a gas at temperature $T$, the typical kinetic
> energy per particle is of order the thermal energy,
> \[
> E_{\rm kin} \sim E_{\rm thermal} \sim k_B T.
> \]
> Using $E_{\rm kin} \sim \tfrac{1}{2} m_p v_{\rm th}^2$, we get
> \[
> \tfrac{1}{2} m_p v_{\rm th}^2 \sim k_B T
> \quad \Rightarrow \quad
> v_{\rm th}^2 \sim \frac{2 k_B T}{m_p}.
> \]
> Since this is an order-of-magnitude argument, factors of order unity are dropped,
> so we write
> \[
> v_{\rm th}^2 \sim \frac{k_B T}{m_p}.
> \]
> Substituting,
> \[
> v_{\rm th}^2 \sim \frac{\epsilon \, E_{\rm Ry}}{m_p}.
> \]
>
> #### Escape velocity
>
> For a planet of mass $M_\oplus$ and radius $R_\oplus$, the surface escape speed is
> \[
> v_{\rm esc}^2 \sim \frac{G M_\oplus}{R_\oplus},
> \]
> again omitting the factor of 2 as we keep only leading scalings.
>
> #### Retention condition
>
> To avoid losing the atmosphere, we require $v_{\rm esc} \gtrsim v_{\rm th}$.
> Equating the scales gives
> \[
> \frac{G M_\oplus}{R_\oplus}
> \sim
> \frac{\epsilon \, E_{\rm Ry}}{m_p},
> \]
> which is Press’s Eq. (5).

### Annotation 7 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Haldane’s essay “On Being the Right Size,” ! discusses qualitatively but elegantly some concepts of elementary physics which cause various animal species to be the sizes that they are: weight increasing as the cube of size, while structural strength increases as only the square; force required to escape from the …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-09-28):

> The Bohr radius is a fundamental length scale in atomic physics, it’s the typical size of the hydrogen atom in its ground state, according to the Bohr model.

### Annotation 8 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Unfortunately, the strong dependence on € here allows us to put little credence in the numerical result. The universal constants seem to determine the scale of man’s size quite narrowly, but they seem to determine the scale of his time only very poorly. This result, if true, may be relevant to the problem of …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2025-09-28):

> Intelligent life elsewhere should be roughly our size (meters tall) and live on Earth-like planets (mass and radius close to Earth’s), since size of creatures depends weakly on 𝜖.
>
> Howver their characteristic timescales (metabolism, reaction speeds, lifespans) could differ drastically, since they depend sensitively on the fraction
> 𝜖 of the Rydberg that local chemistry actually uses.
>
> So aliens might be our size, but experience time very differently: “slow” or “fast” compared to us.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

Man’s size in terms of fundamental constants

William H. Press Department [Annotation 2] of Physics, Harvard University and Harvard-Smithsonian Center [Annotation 1] for Astrophysics, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138 (Received 26 September 1979; accepted 15 January 1980)

Why ate we the size we are, instead of some very different size? Simple physical scaling laws and three “requirements” dictate that our size be of order (# |m.e”)(e?/Gm, ”)'*. They also “predict” the mass and radius of the Earth. The three requirements are: (i) We are made of complicated molecules; (ii) we breathe an evolved planetary atmosphere; (iii) we are about as big as we can be without breaking.

Haldane’s essay “On Being the Right Size,” ! discusses qualitatively but elegantly some concepts of elementary physics which cause various animal species to be the sizes that they are: weight increasing as the cube of size, while structural strength increases as only the square; force required to escape from the surface tension of liquid water; oxygen diffusion resistance in organisms such as insects, lacking lungs; heat loss; eye resolution; limits to brain weight. Very recently there has been a flurry of interest?3.4 in astrophysical and cosmological circles on a problem of similar character there, namely to understand as many as possible of the basic features of “galaxies, stars, planets, and the everyday world” 3 in terms of a few microscopic physical constants (c, G, h, e, etc.) plus the constraint that these constants have values consistent with the possibility of intelligent life evolving so as to observe them. This additional constraint is usually called the “anthropic principle.” 2 A few years ago, in connection with an elementary physics course, I attempted to fuse Haldane’s general approach with the more quantitative astrophysical arguments, and to derive an order of magnitude expression for Lj, the size of man (the term used generically to include male as well as female) in terms of fundamental constants. Since the result of my calculation has now found its way into the literature [Annotation 5] on the anthropic principle (e.g., Ref. 3) and since the line of argument is suitable in level for use in an undergraduate general physics course, I sketch the calculation here. , Let us assume only that man satisfies three properties: (i) he is made of complicated molecules; (ii) he requires an atmosphere which is not (primordial, cosmological) hydrogen and helium; and (iii) he is as large as possible, to carry his huge brain, but he is liable to stumble and fall; and in so doing he should not break. These three properties do not differentiate between a man and, say, an elephant ofsize Lg; however Le ~ Ly to the accuracy of our calculation, and we should not expect to distinguish elephants from men by dimensional arguments. The characteristic atomic size of all matter is set by the Bohr [Annotation 7] radius

ao = h?/m.e2 = 0.53 X 1078 cm, (1)

where h is Planck’s constant, m, the mass of the electron, and e its charge. The characteristic density of all matter is therefore set by the density of one (or so) proton in a cubic Bohr diameter, so we can define a scale density

Po = mp/(2a0)3 = 1.4 g/cm, (2)

597 Am. J. Phys. 48(8), Aug. 1980 0002-9505 /80/080597-02$00.50

where mp is the mass of a proton. The scale of energies for all molecular binding is set by the characteristic energy of the [Annotation 3] hydrogen atom,

e?/2a9 = 1 Ry = 13.6 eV. (3)

According to (i) above, man’s chemistry is complicated, so his binding energies are a small fraction, say ¢€, of a Rydberg. A reasonable value for € is 0.003; but we will see below that in fact Lj, depends on € only very weakly. We next observe that man must live in an environment whose temperature [Annotation 4] is given in order of magnitude by

T ~ (e/k) Ry = 470(€/0.003) K (4)

(where & is Boltzmann’s constant). If the temperature were much larger, his chemistry would be disrupted; if it were much lower, his internal chemical processes would proceed at an exponentially smaller rate; thus he would be immobile and unlikely to stumble, violating assumption (iii) above. (Empirically, man does in fact live at close to the temperature of his chemical bond energy; this, incidentally, makes cooking practicable.) We now use property (ii). Since man’s atmosphere is not hydrogen, but is also not vacuum, the escape velocity from the surface of his planet (Earth) should be greater, but not too much greater, than the thermal velocity of hydrogen at his ambient temperature (€/k) Ry. This condition gives

GMo/Re ~ € Ry/mp, (3) where [Annotation 6] G is the gravitational constant, M@ and Rg are the mass and radius of the Earth. From Eq. (2) we have

M @/Ra ~ mp/(2a0)?. (6)

Equations (5) and (6) can be solved for M/@ and Re separately, giving

2 \1/2 « \i72 Re ~ €/2(2 = 6.5 X 108 @ €"(2a0) ea 0.003) “™

(7) 2 \3/2 e \3/2 Me ~ 2m, |— = 3.8 X 1026 even me es 0.003) ®

(8) which are to be compared with the actual values 6.4 X 108 cm and 5.9 X 1027 g. If man is of a size Ly, his mass is roughly

Mu ~ poLh. (9) When, according to property (iii), he stumbles and falls, the

© 1980 American Association of Physics Teachers 597

This article is copyrighted as indicated in the abstract. Reuse of AAPT content is subject to the terms at: http://scitation.aip.org/termsconditions. Downloaded to IP:

155.41.127.63 On: Tue, 29 Oct 2013 14:28:23

#### Page 2

energy of his fall is of order MyLy(GMo/R3), the last factor being the acceleration of gravity at planetary surface. The number of atoms that man contains is about My/mp. His breaking involves a disruption only on a two-dimensional surface which contains of order (Mj/m,)?/3 atoms, and each atom is bound with an energy € Ry, so the scale of man’s breaking energy is set by the combination ¢ Ry(Mx/m,)?/°. Property (iii) thus takes the form of an equation,

MyLy GMo@/R8 ~ € Ry(My/m,)?/3. (10)

Using Eqs. (2), (5), (7), and (9), this can be solved for Ly in terms of known quantities,

Ly ~ €4(2a0)(e?/Gm;) “4 = 26/42 0 V/2mz'mzG— UA

= 2.6(€/0.003)!/4 cm, Ql)

which is very insensitive to changes in the assumed value of €,

The observed value of L;, is, we note, about a factor 102 larger than that given by our dimensional calculation. This disagreement is not surprising, considering the crudeness of the estimate. Even so, it is not difficult (using, however, more information than the three properties originally assumed) to see where the disagreement arises: we have underestimated man’s breaking energy [right-hand side of Eq. (10)] by a factor of about 104-105, and this factor enters the estimate for Lj, as a square root. Equation (10) assumed implicitly that man was “brittle,” i.e., that the energy of a fall would be concentrated as stress along his weakest fault plane. If this were true, a 100-kg man would break under an energy of order 10° erg; in actuality his breaking energy is of order 3 X 10!9 erg (a 3-m fall). Probably the reason for this excess strength is that man’s molecular structure is polymeric rather than amorphous, so that stresses are distributed over a rather larger volume than that of a single monatomic fault plane. As a very crude model, one might take the fault to be about as wide as the length of a polymer, and therefore equate the excess breaking energy (104-105) to the number of atoms in a protein; this gives fairly good agreement with observation. We might turn now to different problem, that of estimating the characteristic human timescale (or lifespan). In this regard, we first notice that if the ambient temperature (e/k) Ry is to be maintained by solar radiation, then the scale of the solar constant is determined by the Stefan-Boltzmann law, namely,

598 Am. J. Phys., Vol. 48, No. 8, August 1980

J ~ a(e/k Ry)* = 2.9 X 10° (€/0.003)4 ergcm-?sec—!

(12)

(compared to a measured value 1.4 X 106 ergcm~?sec™'). Here a is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant which is defined from fundamental constants by

= 72k4/60 02h}, (13)

A natural characteristic time ty is obtained by equating the total energy of chemical bonds in man to t,, multiplied by the solar flux incident on man’s surface area L},. If man were a plant, this time would be a characteristic growth time, hence set the scale for his lifespan, but in fact we are not plants; we are at the end of a complicated food chain. Another possible interpretation is that the time ty is a “shelter-seeking” time, in which the solar flux is likely to be damaging to an unprotected man. In any case, the value obtained is

~ Ki po Ln @ m, (e Ry)? _ 120 = 2-75 6H 0-75 mo'm5G- V4 T

0.003 0.003

Unfortunately, the strong dependence on € here allows us to put little credence in the numerical result. The universal constants [Annotation 8] seem to determine the scale of man’s size quite narrowly, but they seem to determine the scale of his time only very poorly. This result, if true, may be relevant to the problem of interstellar communication, since we should probably not hope to establish communication with intelligences whose time scale is either very much shorter or very much longer than our own.

—2.75 —2.75 = 50x 104| é | seo~ 14 [-<] h. (14)

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

I am pleased to acknowledge interesting and helpful discussions on these matters with Douglas Eardley and V. F. Weisskopf.

'J. B. S. Haldane, in Possible Worlds (Harper, New York, 1928); reprinted in The World of Mathematics, edited by James R. Newman, (Simon and Schuster, New York, 1956), Vol. 2. 2B. Carter, in Confrontation of Cosmological Theories with Observation, edited by M. S. Longair (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1974), p. 291. 3B. J. Carr and M. J. Rees, Nature 278, 605 (1979). 4J, Barrow and F. Tipler (unpublished monograph).

William H. Press 598

This article is copyrighted as indicated in the abstract. Reuse of AAPT content is subject to the terms at: http://scitation.aip.org/termsconditions. Downloaded to IP:

155.41.127.63 On: Tue, 29 Oct 2013 14:28:23

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/man-ssize-in-terms-of-fundamental-constants. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
