# I, Pencil

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/i-pencil

- **Authors:** Leonard E. Read
- **Published:** 1958
- **Topic:** Economics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1617595624501-x703fj8xg0b-edb42da982394a49e1513eaeaf4c05fa%2Fi-pencil.pdf
- **Pages:** 7
- **Annotations:** 15 comments in 14 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/i-pencil

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “I, Pencil My Family Tree as told to Leonard E. Read”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> #### TL;DR
>
> This essay - first published in 1958 - gives a wonderful description of the process behind the creation of what is seemingly a very simple object, a lead pencil. It beautifully describes the amount of human coordination that needs to happen for a simple pencil to be made.
>
> Main topics covered:
> - Leonard is considered to be largely responsible for the revival of the liberal tradition in post–World War II America.
> - In this essay he describes the incredible amount of coordination, cooperation and trade that needs to take place in the simple production of a pencil.
> - Guided by Adam Smith’s “invisible hand”  free people accomplish economic miracles.
> - In this essays he shows that the seemingly unrelated interests of countless individuals from around the world converge to produce pencils without a single “master mind”.
> - Leonard’s main point is that economies can hardly be “planned” when not one soul possesses all the know-how and skills to produce a simple pencil.
> - While “I, Pencil” shoots down the baseless expectations for central planning, it provides a supremely uplifting perspective of the individual.

**Reply** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> > *Here is an astounding fact: Neither the worker in the oil field nor the chemist nor the digger of graphite or clay nor any who mans or makes the ships or trains or trucks nor the one who runs the machine that does the knurling on my bit of metal nor the president of the company performs his singular task because he wants me. Each one wants me less, perhaps, than does a child in the first grade. Indeed, there are some among this vast multitude who never saw a pencil nor would they know how to use one. Their motivation is other than me. Perhaps it is something like this: Each of these millions sees that he can thus exchange his tiny know-how for the goods and services he needs or wants. I may or may not be among these items.
> *

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “I, Pencil My Family Tree as told to Leonard E. Read”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> Leonard Edward Read was the founder and President of the Foundation for Economic Education - one of the first modern libertarian institutions in the United States - he is considered to be largely responsible for the revival of the liberal tradition in post–World War II America. He was also an author - he wrote 29 books and numerous essays, including this well-known "I, Pencil" published in December of 1958.
>
> ![LER](https://cdn.mises.org/styles/slideshow/s3/static-page/img/Leonard%20Read.jpg?itok=K2DSYzj8)

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “I am a lead pencil—the ordinary wooden pencil familiar to all boys and girls and adults who can read and write. Writing is both my vocation and my avocation; that’s all I do. You may wonder why I should write a genealogy. Well, to begin with, my story is interesting. And, next, I am a mystery —more so than a tree or a …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> Here is a video of Nobel Laureate Milton Friedman talking about the complexity involved in making a lead pencil:
>
> Milton Friedman - I, Pencil:
>
> [![Milton Friedman](https://i.imgur.com/G5gu3jx.png)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67tHtpac5ws)

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “I am a lead pencil—the ordinary wooden pencil familiar to all boys and girls and adults who can read and write. Writing is both my vocation and my avocation; that’s all I do. You may wonder why I should write a genealogy. Well, to begin with, my story is interesting. And, next, I am a mystery —more so than a tree or a …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> The same argument could have been given by writing a different essay, say *"I, Car"* or *"I, Airplane"*. As a good educator Leonard E. Read chooses a more down-to-earth example - a simple pencil - to prove his point and make his argument stick with the reader.

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “I am a lead pencil—the ordinary wooden pencil familiar to all boys and girls and adults who can read and write. Writing is both my vocation and my avocation; that’s all I do. You may wonder why I should write a genealogy. Well, to begin with, my story is interesting. And, next, I am a mystery —more so than a tree or a …”

**Annotation** by R. Clayton (2021-04-13):

> "Make" isn't strong enough to carry this sentence; "manufacture" is probably the word he wanted, as in "manufacture me in large enough quantities to render me a commonplace."  It seems almost impossible that no one on earth back in 1950-whatever could make a pencil from scratch; it certainly isn't true now, as a quick search through YouTube shows.  The rest of the paragraph also argues for "manufacture," although I'm not sure that was the author's intention.

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “meets the eye—there’s some wood, lacquer, the printed labeling, graphite lead, a bit of metal, and an eraser.”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> > there’s some wood, lacquer, the printed labeling, graphite lead, a bit of metal, and an eraser.
>
>
>
> ![pencil](https://i.imgur.com/Br7Itnp.jpg)
>
> The materials that go into a pencil are:
> - cedar wood
> - graphite
> - metal
> - rubber
>
> Although this list seems short and trivial no one person could create these elements on their own.

### Annotation 7 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Just as you cannot trace your family tree back very far, so is it impossible for me to name and explain all my antecedents. But I would like to suggest enough of them to impress upon you the richness and complexity of my background. My family tree begins with what in fact is a tree, a cedar of straight grain that …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> > *Think of all the persons and the numberless skills that went into their fabrication: the mining of ore, the making of steel and its refinement into saws, axes, motors; the growing of hemp and bringing it through all the stages to heavy and strong rope; the logging camps with their beds and mess halls, the cookery and the raising of all the foods. Why, untold thousands of persons had a hand in every cup of coffee the loggers drink!
> The logs are shipped to a mill in San Leandro, California. Can you imagine the individuals who make !at cars and rails and railroad engines and who construct and install the communication systems incidental thereto? These legions are among my antecedents.*

### Annotation 8 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “company, who contributes more than a tiny, innitesimal bit of know-how. From the standpoint of know-how the only dierence between the miner of graphite in Ceylon and the logger in Oregon is in the type of know-how. Neither the miner nor the logger can be dispensed with, any more than can the chemist at the factory …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> The division of labor is the separation of complex production tasks into many simpler subtasks so that individuals may specialize. Specialized Individuals or organizations will trade to take advantage of the capabilities of others in addition to their own. The division of labor is the motive for trade and the source of economic interdependence. Its importance in economics lies in the fact that a given number of workers can produce far more output using division of labor compared to the same number of workers each working alone.
>
> Read on here: [Division of Labor by Michael Munger](https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/DivisionofLabor.html)
>
> > *From the standpoint of know-how the only dierence between the miner of graphite in Ceylon and the logger in Oregon is in the type of know-how. Neither the miner nor the logger can be dispensed with, any more than can the chemist at the factory or the worker in the oil field—paran being a by-product of petroleum.*

### Annotation 9 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “company, who contributes more than a tiny, innitesimal bit of know-how. From the standpoint of know-how the only dierence between the miner of graphite in Ceylon and the logger in Oregon is in the type of know-how. Neither the miner nor the logger can be dispensed with, any more than can the chemist at the factory …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> > *Here is an astounding fact: Neither the worker in the oil field nor the chemist nor the digger of graphite or clay nor any who mans or makes the ships or trains or trucks nor the one who runs the machine that does the knurling on my bit of metal nor the president of the company performs his singular task because he wants me. Each one wants me less, perhaps, than does a child in the first grade. Indeed, there are some among this vast multitude who never saw a pencil nor would they know how to use one. Their motivation is other than me. Perhaps it is something like this: Each of these millions sees that he can thus exchange his tiny know-how for the goods and services he needs or wants. I may or may not be among these items.
> *

### Annotation 10 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “There is a fact still more astounding: The absence of a master mind, of anyone dictating or forcibly directing these countless actions which bring me into being. No trace of such a person can be found. Instead, we nd the Invisible Hand at work. This is the mystery to which I earlier referred. It has been said that …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> The Invisible Hand is a metaphor describing the ***unintended greater benefits and public good brought about by individuals acting in their own self-interests.***  We approve and reward acts that benefit society, and disapprove and punish acts that harm it - this behavior promotes the continued existence of our species and our society. This economic concept that was first introduced by Adam Smith in The Theory of Moral Sentiments in 1759.

### Annotation 11 (page 6)

Beside the passage: “If I, Pencil, were the only item that could oer testimony on what men and women can accomplish when free to try, then those with lile faith would have a fair case. However, there is”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-06):

> A great video about "I, Pencil"
>
> [![](https://i.imgur.com/WSEMnDy.png)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IYO3tOqDISE)

### Annotation 12 (page 7)

Beside the passage: “testimony galore; it’s all about us and on every hand. Mail delivery is exceedingly simple when compared, for instance, to the making of an automobile or a calculating machine or a grain combine or a milling machine or to tens of thousands of other things. Delivery? Why, in this area where men have been le free to …”

**Annotation** by R. Clayton (2021-04-14):

> I'm not sure how this advances the author's point (I probably don't understand the author's point).  If we're supposed to go goggle-eyed over somebody making rope in the Philippines so I can have a pencil, we should be equally goggle-eyed over somebody in Virginia making chewing tobacco for the cowboys herding the livestock providing the leather for the mail pouches used by the letter carriers so I can get a letter.   Despite government monopoly, mail delivery seems to provide at least as much wonder as pencil manufacture.

### Annotation 13 (page 7)

Beside the passage: “the human voice around the world in less than one second; they deliver an event visually and in motion to any person’s home when it is happening; they deliver 150 passengers from Seale to Baltimore in less than four hours; they deliver gas from Texas to one’s range or furnace in New York at unbelievably low rates and …”

**Annotation** by R. Clayton (2021-04-14):

> Passing lightly over the (presumably non-trivial) equivalence between delivering natural gas from Texas to New York and delivering a letter across the street, it is an interesting exercise to apply the author's reasoning to the step before delivery: addressing.  How is it that "millions of tiny know-hows would naturally and miraculously form and cooperate" to create a practical trans-territorial addressing scheme?  There's hot-potato routing, but that's neither efficient, effective, nor cheap.  There's Milgram's small-world experiment, but that begs the question because it assumes USPS addressing.

### Annotation 14 (page 7)

Beside the passage: “the human voice around the world in less than one second; they deliver an event visually and in motion to any person’s home when it is happening; they deliver 150 passengers from Seale to Baltimore in less than four hours; they deliver gas from Texas to one’s range or furnace in New York at unbelievably low rates and …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2021-04-05):

> > *The lesson I have to teach is this: Leave all creative energies uninhibited. Merely organize society to act in harmony with this lesson. Let society’s legal apparatus remove all obstacles the best it can. Permit these creative know-hows freely to flow. Have faith that free men and women will respond to the Invisible Hand.*

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

I, Pencil [Annotation 1] My Family Tree as told to Leonard E. Read [Annotation 2]

I am a lead pencil—the ordinary wooden pencil familiar to all boys and girls and adults who can read and write. Writing is both my vocation and my avocation; that’s all I do. [Annotation 3] You may wonder why I should write a genealogy. Well, to begin with, my story is interesting. And, next, I am a mystery —more so than a tree or a sunset or even a ash of lightning. But, sadly, I am taken for granted by those who use me, as if I were a mere incident and without background. This supercilious aitude relegates me to the level of the commonplace. This is a species of the grievous error in which mankind cannot too long persist without peril. For, the wise G. K. Chesterton observed, “We are perishing for want of wonder, not for want of wonders.” I, Pencil, simple though I appear to be, merit your wonder and awe, a claim I shall aempt to prove. In fact, if you can understand me—no, that’s too much to ask of anyone—if you can become aware of the miraculousness which I symbolize, you can help save the freedom mankind is so unhappily losing. I have a profound lesson to teach. And I can teach this lesson beer than can an automobile or an airplane or a mechanical dishwasher [Annotation 4] because—well, because I am seemingly so simple. Simple? Yet, not a single person on the face of this [Annotation 5] earth knows how to make me. This sounds fantastic, doesn’t it? Especially when it is realized that there are about one and onehalf billion of my kind produced in the U.S.A. each year. Pick me up and look me over. What do you see? Not much

4

“

If you can become aware of the miraculousness

which I symbolize,

you can help save the freedome

mankind is so unhappily losing.

#### Page 2

meets the eye—there’s some wood, lacquer, the printed labeling, graphite lead, a bit of metal, and an eraser. [Annotation 6]

INNUMERABLE ANTECEDENTS

Just as you cannot trace your family tree back very far, so is it impossible for me to name and explain all my antecedents. But I would like to suggest enough of them to impress upon you the richness and complexity of my background. My family tree begins with what in fact is a tree, a cedar of straight grain that grows in Northern California and Oregon. Now contemplate all the saws and trucks and rope and the countless other gear used in harvesting and carting the cedar logs to the railroad siding. Think of all the persons and the numberless skills that went into their fabrication: the mining of ore, the making of steel and its renement into saws, axes, motors; the growing of hemp and bringing it through all the stages to heavy and strong rope; the logging camps with their beds and mess halls, the cookery and the raising of all the foods. Why, untold thousands of persons had a hand in every cup of coee the loggers drink! The logs are shipped to a mill in San Leandro, California. [Annotation 7] Can you imagine the individuals who make at cars and rails and railroad engines and who construct and install the communication systems incidental thereto? These legions are among my antecedents. Consider the millwork in San Leandro. The cedar logs are cut into small, pencil-length slats less than one-fourth of an inch in thickness. These are kiln dried and then tinted for the same reason women put rouge on their faces. People prefer that I look prey, not a pallid white. The slats are waxed and kiln dried again. How many skills went into the making of the tint and the kilns, into supplying the heat, the light and power, the belts, motors, and all the other things a mill requires? Sweepers in the mill among my ancestors? Yes, and included are the men who poured the concrete for the dam of a Pacic Gas & Electric Company hydroplant which supplies the mill’s power! Don’t overlook the ancestors present and distant who have a

5

#### Page 3

hand in transporting sixty carloads of slats across the nation. Once in the pencil factory—$4,000,000 in machinery and building, all capital accumulated by thriy and saving parents of mine—each slat is given eight grooves by a complex machine, aer which another machine lays leads in every other slat, applies glue, and places another slat atop—a lead sandwich, so to speak. Seven brothers and I are mechanically carved from this “woodclinched” sandwich. My “lead” itself—it contains no lead at all—is complex. The graphite is mined in Ceylon [Sri Lanka]. Consider these miners and those who make their many tools and the makers of the paper sacks in which the graphite is shipped and those who make the string that ties the sacks and those who put them aboard ships and those who make the ships. Even the lighthouse keepers along the way assisted in my birth—and the harbor pilots. The graphite is mixed with clay from Mississippi in which ammonium hydroxide is used in the rening process. Then weing agents are added such as sulfonated tallow—animal fats chemically reacted with sulfuric acid. Aer passing through numerous machines, the mixture nally appears as endless extrusions—as from a sausage grinder—cut to size, dried, and baked for several hours at 1,850 degrees Fahrenheit. To increase their strength and smoothness the leads are then treated with a hot mixture which includes candelilla wax from Mexico, paran wax, and hydrogenated natural fats. My cedar receives six coats of lacquer. Do you know all the ingredients of lacquer? Who would think that the growers of castor beans and the reners of castor oil are a part of it? They are. Observe the labeling. That’s a lm formed by applying heat

6

Why, even the processes by which the lacquer is made a beautiful yellow involve the skills of more persons than one can enumerate.

“

#### Page 4

to carbon black mixed with resins. How do you make resins and what, pray, is carbon black? Why, even the processes by which the lacquer is made a beautiful yellow involve the skills of more persons than one can enumerate! My bit of metal—the ferrule—is brass. Think of all the persons who mine zinc and copper and those who have the skills to make shiny sheet brass from these products of nature. Those black rings on my ferrule are black nickel. What is black nickel and how is it applied? The complete story of why the center of my ferrule has no black nickel on it would take pages to explain. Then there’s my crowning glory, inelegantly referred to in the trade as “the plug,” the part man uses to erase the errors he makes with me. An ingredient called “factice” is what does the erasing. It is a rubber-like product made by reacting rapeseed oil from the Dutch East Indies [Indonesia] with sulfur chloride. Rubber, contrary to the common notion, is only for binding purposes. Then, too, there are numerous vulcanizing and accelerating agents. The pumice comes from Italy; and the pigment which gives “the plug” its color is cadmium sulde.

NO ONE KNOWS

Does anyone wish to challenge my earlier assertion that no single person on the face of this earth knows how to make me? Actually, millions of human beings have had a hand in my creation, no one of whom even knows more than a very few of the others. Now, you may say that I go too far in relating the picker of a coee berry in far-o Brazil and food growers elsewhere to my creation; that this is an extreme position. I shall stand by my claim. There isn’t a single person in all these millions, including the president of the pencil

7

“

Actually, millions of human beings have had a hand in my creation,

no one of whom even knows more than a very few of

the others.

#### Page 5

company, who contributes more than a tiny, innitesimal bit of know-how. From the standpoint of know-how the only dierence between the miner of graphite in Ceylon and the logger in Oregon is in the type of know-how. Neither the miner nor the logger can be dispensed with, any more than can the chemist at the factory or the worker in the oil eld—paran being a by-product of petroleum. [Annotation 8] Here is an astounding fact: Neither the worker in the oil eld nor the chemist nor the digger of graphite or clay nor any who mans or makes the ships or trains or trucks nor the one who runs the machine that does the knurling on my bit of metal nor the president of the company performs his singular task because he wants me. Each one wants me less, perhaps, than does a child in the rst grade. Indeed, there are some among this vast multitude who never saw a pencil nor would they know how to use one. Their motivation is other than me. Perhaps it is something like this: Each of these millions sees that he can thus exchange his tiny know-how for the goods and services he needs or wants. I [Annotation 9] may or may not be among these items.

NO MASTER MIND

There is a fact still more astounding: The absence of a master mind, of anyone dictating or forcibly directing these countless actions which bring me into being. No trace of such a person can be found. Instead, we nd the Invisible Hand at work. This is the mystery to which I earlier referred. [Annotation 10] It has been said that “only God can make a tree.” Why do we agree with this? Isn’t it because we realize that we ourselves could not make one? Indeed, can we even describe a tree? We cannot, except in supercial terms. We can say, for instance, that a certain molecular conguration manifests itself as a tree. But what mind is there among men that could even record, let alone direct, the constant changes in molecules that transpire in the life span of a tree? Such a feat is uerly unthinkable! I, Pencil, am a complex combination of miracles: a tree, zinc, copper, graphite, and so on. But to these miracles which

8

#### Page 6

manifest themselves in Nature an even more extraordinary miracle has been added: the conguration of creative human energies—millions of tiny know-hows congurating naturally and spontaneously in response to human necessity and desire and in the absence of any human masterminding! Since only God can make a tree, I insist that only God could make me. Man can no more direct these millions of know-hows to bring me into being than he can put molecules together to create a tree. The above is what I meant when writing, “If you can become aware of the miraculousness which I symbolize, you can help save the freedom mankind is so unhappily losing.” For, if one is aware that these know-hows will naturally, yes, automatically, arrange themselves into creative and productive paerns in response to human necessity and demand— that is, in the absence of governmental or any other coercive master-minding—then one will possess an absolutely essential ingredient for freedom: a faith in free people. Freedom is impossible without this faith. Once government has had a monopoly of a creative activity such, for instance, as the delivery of the mails, most individuals will believe that the mails could not be eciently delivered by men acting freely. And here is the reason: Each one acknowledges that he himself doesn’t know how to do all the things incident to mail delivery. He also recognizes that no other individual could do it. These assumptions are correct. No individual possesses enough know-how to perform a nation’s mail delivery any more than any individual possesses enough know-how to make a pencil. Now, in the absence of faith in free people—in the unawareness that millions of tiny know-hows would naturally and miraculously form and cooperate to satisfy this necessity—the individual cannot help but reach the erroneous conclusion that mail can be delivered only by governmental “masterminding.”

TESTIMONY GALORE

If I, Pencil, were the only item that could oer testimony on what men and women can accomplish when free to try, then those with lile faith would have a fair case. However, there is [Annotation 11]

9

#### Page 7

testimony galore; it’s all about us and on every hand. Mail delivery is exceedingly simple when compared, for instance, to the making [Annotation 12] of an automobile or a calculating machine or a grain combine or a milling machine or to tens of thousands of other things. Delivery? Why, in this area where men have been le free to try, they deliver

the human voice around the world in less than one second; they deliver an event visually and in motion to any person’s home when it is happening; they deliver 150 passengers from Seale to Baltimore in less than four hours; they deliver gas from Texas to one’s range or furnace in New York at unbelievably low rates and without subsidy; they deliver each four pounds of oil from the Persian Gulf to our Eastern Seaboard—halfway around the world—for less money than the government charges for delivering a one- [Annotation 13] ounce leer across the street! The lesson I have to teach is this: Leave all creative energies uninhibited. Merely organize society to act in harmony with this lesson. Let society’s legal apparatus remove all obstacles the best it can. Permit these creative know-hows freely to ow. Have faith that free men and women will respond to the Invisible Hand. [Annotation 14] This faith will be conrmed. I, Pencil, seemingly simple though I am, oer the miracle of my creation as testimony that this is a practical faith, as practical as the sun, the rain, a cedar tree, the good earth.

10

“

The lesson I have to teach is this: Leave all creative energies uninhibited.

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/i-pencil. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
