# How to teach me physics: Tradition is not always a virtue

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/how-to-teach-me-physics-tradition-is-not-always-a-virtue

- **Authors:** Ricardo Heras
- **Published:** 2019
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1682291772506-fizom1tt6y8-c20aa505a3a9f40b196e2dedbf784083%2Fheras2017.pdf
- **Pages:** 2
- **Annotations:** 6 comments in 5 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/how-to-teach-me-physics-tradition-is-not-always-a-virtue

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The aspects of physics I have understood best so far are those I have studied for pleasure. I understood special relativity be#er when I derived the Lorentz transformations in a diﬀerent form. 3 This task was much more exciting than the usual assignment of calculating the length contraction of a rod. I understood …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-04-24):

> In "Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!" Feynman recounts how he enjoyed playing pranks on people during his college years. Many of these pranks aimed to highlight people's gullibility. For instance, in an MIT mechanical drawing class where students were taught to use a drawing tool called a French curve (a curved plastic piece for sketching smooth curves), Feynman told his classmates that "at the lowest point of each curve, the tangent remains horizontal regardless of the curve's orientation." The other students, intrigued by this revelation, began examining their French curves, rotating them in different ways to confirm that the tangent was always horizontal at the lowest point. Feynman found this amusing, as these students had already studied calculus and should have known that the derivative of any curve's minimum is zero.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “A person can do magniﬁcently on a test and understand very li#le. We’ve all had the experience of “acing a test” and forge#ing everything two weeks later....”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-04-24):

> The author is referring to the Forgetting Curve, or the Ebbinghaus Curve of Forgetting, which hypothesizes the decline of memory retention in time.
>
> This curve shows how information is lost over time when there is no attempt to retain it.
>
> In 1885, Hermann Ebbinghaus theorized that the rate at which we forget information is influenced by various factors, including the complexity of the material learned (such as its meaningfulness), its presentation, and physiological elements like stress and sleep. He also postulated that the fundamental forgetting rate is relatively consistent among individuals. Ebbinghaus concluded that differences in memory performance can be attributed to individuals' mnemonic representation skills.
>
> Furthermore, he suggested that basic instruction in mnemonic techniques could partially mitigate these disparities. Ebbinghaus maintained that the most effective strategies for enhancing memory retention are:
>
> 1. Improving memory representation (for example, using mnemonic techniques)
> 2. Employing repetition based on active recall (particularly spaced repetition).
>
> ![](https://images.prismic.io/edapp-website/ZTYzNGUzODAtZGUyNi00YjAyLWI5YTMtY2E2MmMxZWM0MDVk_ebbinghaus-forgetting-curve-graph-png_iaa?auto=compress,format&rect=0,0,600,504&w=600&h=504)

### Annotation 3 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Feynman stressed creativity— which to him meant working things out from the beginning. He urged each of us to create his or her own universe of ideas, so that our products, even if only answers to assigned classwork problems, would have their own original character. 6”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-04-24):

> Laurie Brown studied at Cornell University, where in 1951 he received his Ph.D. under Richard Feynman
>
>  ![](https://physics.northwestern.edu/images/people/brown-168x210.jpg)

### Annotation 4 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “LETTERS”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-04-24):

> In one interview Feynman described his method for reading scientific papers:
>
> 1. Read the abstract
> 2. Try to predict what are the results and conclusions of the paper.
> 3. Go to the “Conclusions” section — check whether your prediction stands.
> 4. If your prediction was successful don't bother reading the rest of the paper, go to the next one.
> 5. If the outcome surprised you, then read the whole paper and carefully study the methods.
>
> This method emphasizes Feynman's obsession to push himself to think creatively instead of merely following another person's line of reasoning.

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “The problem is, however, that as students we are o!en not given proper time to think! We are instead overwhelmed with solving problem sets, writing lab r e p o r t s , a n d w o r r y i n g a b o u t p a s s i n g exams. Remarkably, Feynman emphasized creativity in physics until his very last days. He wrote on his …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2023-04-24):

> Here's a photo of Feynman's last blackboard at Caltech
>
> ![](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Eh0t5tOXcAAzllH?format=jpg&name=small)

**Reply** by Luke Marren (2023-08-10):

> Thank you so much for these comments, Luis. They helped bring parts of this commentary alive!

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

10 PHYSICS TODAY | MARCH 2017

READERS’ FORUM

P

hysics is the most exciting endeavor I can imagine. That is why I want to become a physicist and join what Richard Feynman called “the greatest adventure that the human mind has ever begun.” 1 Now, a!er my second year of undergraduate studies in astrophysics at University College London (UCL), I want to comment on some of the vicissitudes I have experienced while being taught physics.

The basic courses of my ﬁrst two years were disappointing. They didn’t really give me the opportunity to join that greatest adventure. Most of my l e c t u r e r s f o l l o w e d t r a d i t i o n a l t e a c h i n g a p p r o a c h e s b a s e d h e a v i l y o n s o l v i n g standard problems and learning by rote, with no hint of free inquiry or discussion. They seemed to be convinced that we would understand physics through that method. I was not enthusiastic.

Traditional teaching My fellow students and I spent a lot of time and eﬀort solving textbook-style problems. But we didn’t really understand physics by doing that. In practice, we were mostly trained to use problemsolving techniques. Feynman touched on that failing when he said, “I don’t know what’s the ma#er with people: they don’t learn by understanding; they learn by some other way—by rote or something. Their knowledge is so fragile!” 2 I felt that fragility. The time crunch of a heavy course load forced me to memorize a lot of equations and mathematical procedures in order to pass my physics exams.

As time passed, I forgot many of the things I had studied. Noam Chomsky, i n t e r v i e w e d i n 2 0 1 2 f o r t h e L e a r n i n g Without Frontiers Conference, put it best when he said,

A person can do magniﬁcently on a test and understand very li#le. We’ve all had the experience of [Annotation 2] “acing a test” and forge#ing everything two weeks later....

Passing tests doesn’t begin to compare with inquiring, searching, pursuing topics that engage us and excite us. In fact, you will remember what you discover—if you pursue this kind of learning.

The aspects of physics I have under- [Annotation 1] stood best so far are those I have studied for pleasure. I understood special relativity be#er when I derived the Lorentz transformations in a diﬀerent form. 3 This task was much more exciting than the usual assignment of calculating the length contraction of a rod. I understood Maxwell’s equations be#er when I reviewed the Helmholtz theorem 4 and this task was far more thrilling than calculating the electric ﬁeld of a charged sphere.

Traditional teaching methods urge us to perform standard calculations that rarely spark our creativity. Being immersed in such teaching, I feel trapped in a labyrinth whose exit can only be found by solving a ton of mostly uninteresting textbook problems.

The idea that solving such problems is not the best way to understand physics was succinctly expressed by Dieter Nachtigall:

Pupils can o!en solve what textbook authors call “problems” without understanding the physics concepts involved in them. Such “problem solving” o!en exhibits nothing else than the ability to ﬁnd some appropriate equations, put them together, manipulate them algebraically, ﬁll in ﬁgures and ﬁnally come out with the “correct answer.” A student can be good with the formulae but may have understood nothing about the physics behind them. 5

Learning by creating A robust alternative to traditional teaching is one that prioritizes creative thinking. That is the approach that Feynman strongly emphasized. Laurie Brown, a former pupil of his, comments that

Commentary

How to teach me physics: Tradition is not always a virtue

Tradition, discipline,

and reverence are necessary to learn physics.

I agree, my students must solve tons

of problems to pass exams.

The traditional curriculum is ok

by definition.

Learning by creating? Free inquiry? Physics X?

Feynman is crazy!

TRADITIONAL PHYSICS TEACHERS teach us to swim on the surface but not in the deep, where, as Steven Weinberg says, “the unclear, uncharted areas of science can lead to creative work” (Nature 426, 389, 2003).

#### Page 2

MARCH 2017 | PHYSICS TODAY 11

Feynman stressed creativity— which to him meant working things out from the beginning. He [Annotation 3] urged each of us to create his or her own universe of ideas, so that our products, even if only answers to assigned classwork problems, would have their own original character. 6

Feynman’s way of teaching is perhaps best described in three words: learning by creating. As he said,

It’s the way I study—to understand something by trying to work it out or, in other words, to understand something by creating it. Not creating it one hundred percent, of course; but taking a hint as to which direction to go but not r e m e m b e r i n g t h e d e t a i l s . T h e s e you work out for yourself.

In a le#er to a student asking for advice, Feynman touched again on that point:

All you have to do is, from time to time—in spite of everything, just try to examine a problem in a novel way. You won’t “stiﬂe the creative process” if you remember to think from time to time. Don’t you have time to think? 7

The problem is, however, that as students we are o!en not given proper time to think! We are instead overwhelmed with solving problem sets, writing lab r e p o r t s , a n d w o r r y i n g a b o u t p a s s i n g exams. Remarkably, Feynman emphasized creativity in physics until his very last days. He wrote on his blackboard shortly before he died, “What I cannot create I do not understand.” [Annotation 5]

The Feynman Lectures on Physics clearly exhibit their author’s unconventional approach. David Goodstein (P HYSICS TODAY, February 1989, page 70) says of the lectures,

If his purpose in giving them was to prepare classes of adolescent boys to solve examination problems in physics, he may not have succeeded particularly well. . . . If, however, his purpose was to illustrate, by example, how to think and reason about physics, then, by all indications, he was brilliantly successful.

Feynman’s lectures successfully omitted proposed problems. His teaching style is also exempliﬁed in the noncredit, no-homework, no-registration, tuition-

free Physics X course he oﬀered at Caltech. Students met weekly, and the curriculum consisted of whatever they felt like discussing. The primary focus was to promote a culture of free inquiry and joy toward the subject. In the lectures I have a#ended so far at UCL, the idea of enjoying physics has not even been raised.

Feynman said,

The best teaching can be done only when there is a direct individual relationship between a student and a good teacher—a situation in which the student discusses the ideas, thinks about the things, and talks about the things. 1

Such teaching is mostly absent from my current physics education.

As a student, I have not yet been able to reconcile the traditional approach with my ﬁrm conviction that the best physics teaching puts a premium on creativity and free inquiry. Feynman has

shown that such creative teaching is possible.

References 1. R. P. Feynman, R. B. Leighton, M. Sands,

The Feynman Lectures on Physics, vol. 3, Addison-Wesley (1965). 2. R. P. Feynman, R. Leighton, “Surely You’re

Joking, Mr. Feynman!” Adventures of a Curious Character, E. Hutchings, ed., W. W. Norton (1985), p. 36. 3. R. Heras, Eur. J. Phys. 37, 025603 (2016);

Eur. J. Phys. 38, 019401 (2017). 4. R. Heras, Eur. J. Phys. 37, 065204 (2016). 5. D. K. Nachtigall, Eur. J. Phys. 11, 1 (1990). 6. L. M. Brown, “Most of the Good Stuff”:

Memories of Richard Feynman, L. M. Brown, J. S. Rigden, eds., American Institute of Physics (1993), p. 54. 7. R. P. Feynman, Perfectly Reasonable Devia-

tions from the Beaten Track: The Letters of R. P. Feynman, M. Feynman, ed., Basic Books (2005), p. 283.

Ricardo Heras (ricardo.heras.13@ucl.ac.uk) University College London

London, UK

Approaches to studying our history

LETTERS [Annotation 4]

I

share Ma# Stanley’s view that studying the history of our subject enriches our perspectives as practicing physicists (“Why should physicists study h i s t o r y ? , ” P HYSICS TODAY, July 2016, page 38). In my talks to the nontechnical public and in presentations of new results to colleagues, I try to emphasize the complex network of chance inﬂuences, mistakes, collaborations, and controversies that lie behind discoveries conventionally caricatured by a#ributing them to one person.

Stanley and I part company when he complains about those who interpret the science of the past in terms of what we know today: “the bugbear of . . . Whig history.” Of course, it is essential to study scientiﬁc advances in the social, economic, and cultural context of their times, as professional historians do. But Whig history is a complementary activity, justiﬁable on several grounds.

Our scientific predecessors are celebrated largely because of the science that their discoveries led to; that is why they are important, and why historians study them. And the signiﬁcance of their science changes with time, so it is inevitable that we regard it diﬀerently as we look back: With the discovery of the

Aharonov–Bohm eﬀect, the magnetic vector potential of James Clerk Maxwell and his Victorian contemporaries takes on a new meaning. In addition, many of our famous predecessors were cleverer and wiser than us; they le! “time bombs,” ignored for generations until, suddenly triggered by resonating with a contemporary preoccupation, they explode.

One such time bomb is Isaac Newton’s query 3, which he posed 1 a!er decades of struggling to accommodate Grimaldi’s observation of edge diﬀraction fringes in his ray theory of light: “Are not the Rays of Light, in passing by the edges and sides of Bodies, bent several times backwards and forwards, with a motion like that of an Eel? And do not the three Fringes of colour’d Light above-mention’d arise from three such bendings?” Now, three centuries later, and thanks to three insights, we can understand 2 that this apparently eccentric remark makes perfect sense.

The ﬁrst insight was Sommerfeld’s 1896 exact solution of Maxwell’s equations for light diﬀracted by a conducting half plane. 3 The second insight was Braunbek and Laukien’s 1952 calculation 4 exhibiting Newton’s eel-like undulations by plo#ing the trajectories of the Poynting

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/how-to-teach-me-physics-tradition-is-not-always-a-virtue. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
