# Gender stereotypes about intellectual ability emerge early and influence children’s interests

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/gender-stereotypes-about-intellectual-ability-emerge-early-and-influence-children-s-interests

- **Authors:** Lin Bian, Sarah-Jane Leslie, Andrei Cimpian
- **Published:** 2017
- **Topic:** Biology
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1579983432929-frv83p1ywic-2f3d0a12764567d372d7fa0839441373%2Fgender_stereotypes_bian2017.pdf
- **Pages:** 3
- **Annotations:** 7 comments in 7 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/gender-stereotypes-about-intellectual-ability-emerge-early-and-influence-children-s-interests

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “ability emerge early and influence”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-01-25):

> ### TL;DR
>
> The distribution of women and men across academic disciplines seems to be affected by ***perceptions of intellectual brilliance.*** In this paper the authors ran 4 different studies with young children in order to assess when the divergence in the perception of brilliance starts to emerge between the two genders.
>
> At age 5 boys and girls do not show any divergence in their perception of each gender's intellectual abilities. **By the age of 6 there is a significant drop in girls' perception of their own gender's intellectual abilities.**
>
> ***Children seem to assimilate brilliance as a male quality and this stereotype begins to shape their interests as soon as it is acquired*** - as can been seen in studies 3 and 4. Young children’s emerging notions about who is likely to be brilliant are one of the factors that guide their decisions about which activities to pursue and thus are likely to narrow the range of careers they will one day contemplate.
>
> It is important to investigate the acquisition of the “brilliance = males” stereotype in early childhood, as children enter school and begin to make choices that shape their future career paths.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The results suggest that children’sideasabout brilliance exhibit rapid changes over the period from ages 5 to 7. At 5, boys and girls associated brilliance with their own gender to a similar extent (Wald c 2 =0.02,P =0.89)(Fig.1Aandtable S2). The high scores are consistent with the overwhelming in-group positivity …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-01-25):

> > *"investigations of the “brilliance = males” stereotype that focus exclusively on participants of college age or older overlook a critical fact: Cultural messages about the presumed cognitive abilities of males and females are likely to be influential throughout development. If children absorb and act on these ideas, then many capable girls are likely to have already veered away from certain fields by the time they reach college."*

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “In study two, we replicated our initial findings with a larger sample (144 children; 48 per age group).Childreninthissampleratedbothadult and child targets. (Study one included only adult targets.) As before, there was no statistically significant difference in own-gender brilliance scores for 5-year-old boys and …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-01-25):

> **Description of Study 2:**
>
> Study 2 replicated study 1 but with a larger sample and in this study children had to rate both adult and child targets whereas study 1 one only included adult targets.
>
> Results:
> - there was no statistically significant difference in own-gender brilliance scores for 5-year-old boys and girls.
> - a significant difference started emerging at age 6 - as previously seen in study 1.
> - the pattern did not differ whether children rated adults or children targets.

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “he career aspirations of young men and women are shaped by societal stereotypes about gender (1, 2). For example, the stereotype that men are better than women at mathematics (3) impairs women’sperformance in this domain (4, 5) and undermines their interest in mathematics-intensive fields (6, 7). However, popular …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-01-25):

> **Description of Study 1:**
>
> Study 1 set out to asses children's support of the “brilliance = males” stereotype with three tasks:
>
> 1. children were told a brief story about a person who was “really, really smart.” and then were asked to guess which of four unfamiliar adults (2 women, 2 men) was the protagonist of the story.
>
> 2. children saw several pairs adults and were asked to guess which adult in each pair was “really, really smart.”
>
> 3. children guessed which objects or attributes best corresponded to pictures of unfamiliar men and women.
>
>
> Results:
> - children's ideas about brilliance exhibit rapid changes over the period from ages 5 to 7.
> - boys and girls aged 5 associated brilliance with their own gender.
> - girls aged 6 and 7 were significantly less likely than boys to associate brilliance with their own gender.

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “In study four, we compared 5- and 6-year-old boys’ and girls’ interest in novel games said to be “for children who are really, really smart” (96 children; 48 per age group; half boys, half girls). We predicted that 5-year-old boys ’ and girls’ interest in these games would not differ because their ideas about …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-01-26):

> **Description of Study 4:**
>
> Study 4 was designed to compare children's interest in games for children who were “really smart”. Two groups of 5 and 6-year-olds were assessed each with half girls and half boys.
>
> Results:
> - In the 5-year-old group there was no difference in interest in the game for smart children.
> - In the 6-year-old group girls showed less interest than boys in the in the game for smart children.

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “In study three, we investigated whether children’s gendered beliefs about brilliance shape their interests. Sixty-four children aged 6 and 7 (half boys, half girls) were introduced to two novel games, one said to be for “children who are really, really smart” and the other for “children who try really, really hard” …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-01-25):

> **Description of Study 3:**
>
> Study 3 set out to assess whether children's beliefs shape their interests. Here is how study 3 was run:
>
> 1. Children aged 6 and 7 were introduced to two games:
>   - one said to be for children who were “really smart”
>   - the other for children “who try really hard”
>
> 2. Children were then asked four questions to measure their interest in these games.
>
>
> Results:
> - Girls were less interested than boys in the game for smart children but not in the game for hard-working children.
> - Girls aged 6-7 had lower perception of own-gender brilliance than boys - this is similar to the findings of the first two studies for the 6-7 year-olds groups.

### Annotation 7 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “e0150194 (2016). 15. M. Meyer, A. Cimpian, S.-J. Leslie, Front. Psychol. 6, 235 (2015). 16. K. T. U. Emerson, M. C. Murphy, Pers. Soc. Psychol. Bull. 41,”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2020-01-26):

> > *"Many children assimilate the idea that brilliance is a male quality at a young age. This stereotype begins to shape children’s interests as soon as it is acquired and is thus likely to narrow the range of careers they will one day contemplate."*

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

REPORT

◥

PSYCHOLOGY

G ender stereotypes about intellectual

ability emerge early and influence [Annotation 1]

children’s interests

Lin Bian, 1,2 * Sarah-Jane Leslie, 3 Andrei Cimpian 1,2 *

Common stereotypes associate high-level intellectual ability (brilliance, genius, etc.) with men more than women. These stereotypes discourage women’s pursuit of many prestigious careers; that is, women are underrepresented in fields whose members cherish brilliance (such as physics and philosophy). Here we show that these stereotypes are endorsed by, and influence the interests of, children as young as 6. Specifically, 6-year-old girls are less likely than boys to believe that members of their gender are “really, really smart.” Also at age 6, girls begin to avoid activities said to be for children who are “really, really smart.” These findings suggest that gendered notions of brilliance are acquired early and have an immediate effect on children’s interests.

T

he career aspirations of young men and women are shaped by societal stereotypes about gender (1, 2). For example, the stereotype that men are better than women at mathematics (3) impairs women’sperformance in this domain (4, 5) and undermines their interest in mathematics-intensive fields (6, 7). However, popular beliefs about ability associate not only specific cognitive processes (e.g., mathematical reasoning) with a particular gender but also the overall amount of cognitive ability. It is commonly assumed that high-level cognitive ability (brilliance, genius, giftedness, etc.) is present more often in men than in women (8–11). This “brilliance = males” stereotype has been invoked to explain the gender gaps in many prestigious occupations ( 12–15). However, little is known about the acquisition of this stereotype. The earlier children acquire the notion that brilliance is a male quality, the stronger [Annotation 4] its influence may be on their aspirations. The four studies reported here (N = 400 children) show that, by the age of 6, girls are less likely than boys to believe that members of their gender are “really, really smart”—a child-friendly way of referring to brilliance. Also at age 6, the girls in these studies begin to shy away from novel activities said to be for children who are “really, really smart.” These studies speak to the early acquisition of cultural ideas about brilliance and gender, as well as to the immediate effect that these stereotyped notions have on children ’s interests.

The stereotypes associating men but not women with brilliance and genius (8–11) may

take a toll on women’s careers; fields whose members place a great deal of value on sheer brilliance (e.g., mathematics, physics, philosophy) have lower proportions of women earning bachelor’s and doctoral degrees (12–17). However , investigations of the “brilliance = males” stereotype that focus exclusively on participants of college age or older overlook a critical fact: Cultural messages about the presumed cognitive abilities of males and females are likely to be influential throughout development (18, 19). If children absorb and act on these ideas (3, 20, 21), then many capable girls are likely to have already veered away from certain fields by the time they reach college. Thus, it is important to investigate the acquisition of the “brilliance = males” stereotype in early childhood, as children enter school and begin to make choices that shape their future career paths.

Study one examined the developmental trajectory of this stereotype in 96 children aged 5, 6, and 7 (32 children per age group; half boys, half girls). Children came mostly from middleclass backgrounds, and 75% were white. (The supplementary materials contain additional demographic information. However , across studies, children’s race/ethnicity and socioeconomic status did not significantly moderate the results of interest.) We assessed children’s endorsement of the “brilliance = males” stereotype with three tasks, presented in counterbalanced order (see the supplementary materials). In task (i), children were told a brief story about a person who was “really, really smart.” No hints as to the protagonist’s gender were provided. Children were then asked to guess which of four unfamiliar adults (two men, two women) was the protagonist of the story. In task (ii), children saw several pairs of same- or different-gender adults and guessed which adult in each pair was “really, really smart.” In task (iii), children completed

three novel puzzles in which they had to guess which objects (e.g., a hammer) or attributes (e.g., smart) best corresponded to pictures of unfamiliar men and women.

Across tasks and studies, the pictures depicted males and females matched for attractiveness and professional dress (potential cues to intelligence). In each task, we recorded the proportion of relevant trials on which children linked intellectual abili ty with people of their own gender; these proportions were then averaged into an own-gender brilliance score. As a comparison, we also elicited children’s ideas about whether men versus women are “really, really nice.” These two traits are differentially linked to gender in common stereotypes (2). As the relevant cultural notions are being assimilated, children’sresponses should likewise differentiate between these traits.

The results suggest that children’sideasabout brilliance exhibit rapid changes over the period from ages 5 to 7. At 5, boys and girls associated brilliance with their own gender to a similar extent (Wald c 2 =0.02,P =0.89)(Fig.1Aandtable S2). The high scores are consistent with the overwhelming in-group positivity previously observed in boys and (especially) girls across early and middle childhood (22, 23). Despite this strong tendency to view one’s gender in a positive light, girls aged 6 and 7 were significantly less likely than boys to associate brilliance with their own gender (Wald c [Annotation 2] 2 =8.10,P = 0.004) (Fig. 1A). Thus, the “brilliance = males” stereotype may be familiar to, and endorsed by, children as young as 6. The stereotype associating females with being nice seems to follow a similar developmental trajectory (Fig. 1B).

In study two, we replicated our initial findings with a larger sample (144 children; 48 per age group).Childreninthissampleratedbothadult and child targets. (Study one included only adult targets.) As before, there was no statistically sig- [Annotation 3] nificant difference in own-gender brilliance scores for 5-year-old boys and girls (Wald c 2 =0.01,P = 0.94), but a significant difference emerged starting at age 6 (Wald c 2 =9.63,P = 0.002) (Fig. 1C and table S2). This pattern did not differ significantly by whether children rated adult versus child targets (Wald c 2 =1.42,P = 0.23). What might explain the drop in girls’ evaluation of their gender’s intellectual abilities? Although many factors are likely involved, in study two we tested whether this drop is associated with differences between younger (5-year-old) and older (6- and 7-year-old) girls in their perceptions of their school achievement—information that is, in principle, relevant to judging intelligence. These perceptions were measured with four questions similar to those we used to measure stereotypes (e.g., children had to guess which of four children, two boys and two girls, “gets the best grades in school”). In contrast with the drop in brilliance scores, there was no significant difference between younger and older girls in the likelihood of selectingothergirlsashaving top grades (t =0.22,P =0.83)(fig.S1).Oldergirls were actually more likely to select girls as having top grades than older boys were to select boys

Bian et al., Science 355 ,389–391 (2017) 27 January 2017 1of3

1 Department of Psychology, University of Illinois, Champaign, IL 61820, USA. 2 Department of Psychology, New York University, New York, NY 10003, USA. 3 Department of Philosophy, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA. *Corresponding author. Email: linbian2@illinois.edu (L.B.); andrei.cimpian@nyu.edu (A.C.)

RESEARCH

on January 26, 2017http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from

#### Page 2

(t = 4.41, P < 0.001), consistent with the reality that girls get better grades in school than boys at this age (24). Nevertheless, there was no significant correlation between girls’ perceptions of school achievement and their perceptions of brilliance (r =0.11,P =0.34;forboys:r =0.38,P = 0.001). Thus, girls’ ideas about who is brilliant are not rooted in their perceptions of who performs well in school. [However, other aspects of children’s experiences in school, such as teachers’ attitudes and biases (25, 26), may still be implicated in the development of this stereotype.]

In study three, we investigated whether chil- [Annotation 6] dren’s gendered beliefs about brilliance shape their interests. Sixty-four children aged 6 and 7 (half boys, half girls) were introduced to two novel games, one said to be for “children who are really, really smart” and the other for “children who try really, really hard” (counterbalanced;

see the supplementary materials). Children were then asked four questions to measure their interest in these games (e.g., “Do you like this game, or do you not like it?”). Girls were less interested than boys in the game for smart children (Wald c 2 =4.02,P =0.045)butnotin thegameforhard-workingchildren(Waldc 2 = 0.53, P =0.47)(Fig.2AandtableS3).

To test whether the gender differences in interest are related to children’s beliefs about brilliance, we measured these beliefs with two items adapted from study one. Indeed, as with the 6- and 7-year-olds from the first two studies, girls’ own-gender brilliance perceptions were lower than boys’ (t =2.40,P = 0.020). Moreover, these stereotyped beliefs mediated the relationship between children ’s gender and their interest in the game for brilliant (versus persistent) children: indirect effect = –0.11, 95% confidence

interval = [–0.33, –0.004] (fig. S2). Thus, young children’s emerging notions about who is likely to be brilliant are one of the factors that guide their decisions about which activities to pursue.

In study four, we compared 5- and 6-year-old boys’ and girls’ interest in novel games said to be “for children who are really, really smart” (96 children; 48 per age group; half boys, half girls). We predicted that 5-year-old boys ’ and girls’ interest in these games would not differ [Annotation 5] because their ideas about brilliance are not yet differentiated (Fig. 1, A and C). In contrast, 6-year-old girls’ interest was predicted to be lower than boys’, in line with the results of study three. We found no significant gender differences in interest among 5-year-olds (Wald c 2 =0.55,P = 0.46)andatrendinthepredicteddirection among 6-year-olds (Wald c 2 = 3.66, P =0.056) (Fig. 2B and table S3). Combining the samples of 6- and 7-year-olds from studies three an d four with a random-effects meta-analysis (27), we estimated the magnitude of the difference in boys’ versus girls’ interest toward the game for brilliant children to be d = 0.51, 95% confidence interval = [0.13, 0.88], P = 0.008.

We considered two possible alternative explanations for the results of studies one to four. First, because boys are sometimes held back from entering the formal schooling system (28), their understanding of int ellectual ability may be delayed relative to girls’ (29), which may inflate boys’ confidence ab out their brilliance (30). However, the boys and girls in our sample did not enter school at different ages (e.g., the average chronological age for first-grade boys and girls was 6.87 and 6.72 years, respectively; t =1.28,P = 0.20). Moreover, own-gender brilliance scores did not differ for boys who had already entered first grade versus those who had not (M before = 0.70 versus M after =0.67;t = 0.33, P =0.74),but these scores differed for girls (M before = 0.71 versus M after =0.56;t =2.16,P =0.037).Second,because women are subject to stronger modesty norms than men (31), perhaps 6- and 7-year-old girls’ lower interest in the games for brilliant children (studies three and four) was due to an increase in concerns about modest y. Contrary to this alternative, children in the age range we tested are notoriously boastful about their abilities (30). Moreover, the difference in boys’ versus girls’ interest in the brilliance games was specifically mediated by their perceptions about brilliance, pinpointing these stereotyped perceptions (rather than modesty) as the underlying mechanism. Notably, our measure of the “brilliance = males” stereotype is not susceptible to the modesty explanation: Modesty norms dictate that a woman should not boast about her own smarts (32, 33), whereas we asked children to judge whether other people were smart.

It will be important to test whether these findings extend beyond a middle-class, majority-white U.S. cultural context and to comprehensively investigate the sources of the “brilliance = males” stereotype in children’s environments. Nevertheless, the present results suggest a sobering conclusion: Many children assimilate the idea that

Bian et al., Science 355 ,389–391 (2017) 27 January 2017 2of3

Fig. 1. Results of studies one and two. Boys’ (blue) and girls’ (red ) stereot ype scores in study one (A and B) and study two (C and D), by age group (5- versus 6- versus 7-year-olds). Error bars represent ± 1 SE.

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0

56 7

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Own- Gender Brilliance

Score

Own- Gender Niceness

Score

Age (yrs)

567

Age (yrs)

Fig. 2. Results of studies three and four. Boys’ (blue) and girls’ (red) interest (average of standardized responses to four questions) in novel games in study three (A) and study four (B). The main independent variable for each study (task in study three, age in study four) is shown in bold. Error bars represent ± 1 SE.

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

0.0

-0.1

-0.2

-0.3

-0.4

Interest Score

TASK:

AGE:

Smart Game

Try-Hard

Game

Smart Game

Smart Game

6- and 7- year-olds

6- and 7- year-olds

5-year-olds 6-year-olds

RESEARCH | REPORT

on January 26, 2017http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from

#### Page 3

brilliance is a male quality at a young age. This stereotype begins to shape children’s interests as soon as it is acquired and is thus likely to narrow the range of careers they will one day contemplate.

REFERENCES AND NOTES 1. W. Wood, A. H. Eagly, Adv . Exp. Soc. Psychol. 46,55–123 (2012). 2. S. T. Fiske, A. J. C. Cuddy, P. Glick, J. Xu, J. Pers. Soc. Psychol.

82, 878–902 (2002). 3. D. Cvencek, A. N. Meltzoff, A. G. Greenwald, Child Dev. 82,

766–779 (2011). 4. S. J. Spencer, C. M. Steele, D. M. Quinn, J. Exp. Soc. Psychol.

35,4–28 (1999). 5. S. Galdi, M. Cadinu, C. Tomasetto, Child Dev. 85, 250–263

(2014). 6. P. G. Davies, S. J. Spencer, D. M. Quinn, R. Gerhardstein,

Pers. Soc. Psychol. Bull. 28, 1615–1628 (2002). 7. M. C. Murphy, C. M. Steele, J. J. Gross, Psychol. Sci. 18,

879–885 (2007). 8. S. Upson, L. F. Friedman, Sci. Am. Mind 23,63–65 (2012). 9. A. Furnham, E. Reeves, S. Budhani, J. Genet. Psychol. 163,

24–39 (2002). 10. B. Kirkcaldy, P. Noack, A. Furnham, G. Siefen, Eur. Psychol. 12,

173–180 (2007). 11. A. Lecklider, Inventing the Egghead: The Battle Over

Brainpower in American Culture (Univ. of Pennsylvania Press, 2013).

12. S.-J. Leslie, A. Cimpian, M. Meyer, E. Freeland, Science 347,

262–265 (2015). 13. A. Cimpian, S.-J. Leslie, Science 349, 391 (2015). 14. D. Storage, Z. Horne, A. Cimpian, S.-J. Leslie, PLOS ONE 11,

e0150194 (2016). 15. M. Meyer, A. Cimpian, S.-J. Leslie, Front. Psychol. 6, 235 (2015). 16. K. T. U. Emerson, M. C. Murphy, Pers. Soc. Psychol. Bull. 41, [Annotation 7]

295–307 (2015). 17. D. K. Ginther, S. Kahn, Science 349, 391 (2015). 18. K. Crowley, M. A. Callanan, H. R. Tenenbaum, E. Allen, Psychol.

Sci. 12, 258–261 (2001). 19. H. R. Tenenbaum, C. Leaper, Dev. Psychol. 39,34–47 (2003). 20. N. Ambady, M. Shih, A. Kim, T. L. Pittinsky, Psychol. Sci. 12,

385–390 (2001). 21. L. S. Liben, R. S. Bigler, H. R. Krogh, J. Exp. Child Psychol. 79,

346–363 (2001). 22. Y. Dunham, A. S. Baron, M. R. Banaji, Dev. Sci. 19, 781–789

(2015). 23. D. Cvencek, A. G. Greenwald, A. N. Meltzoff, J. Exp. Soc.

Psychol. 62,50–57 (2016). 24. D. Voyer, S. D. Voyer, Psychol. Bull. 140, 1174–1204 (2014). 25. S. L. Beilock, E. A. Gunderson, G. Ramirez, S. C. Levine,

Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S .A. 107, 1860– 1863 (2010). 26. J. P. Robinson-Cimpian, S. T. Lubienski, C. M. Ganley,

Y. Copur-Gencturk, Dev. Psychol. 50, 1262–1281 (2014). 27. G. Cumming, Psychol. Sci. 25,7– 29 (2014). 28. F. L. Huang, AERA Open 1,1–11 (2015). 29.J.Eccles,C.Midgley,T.F.Adler,inThe Development of

Achievement Motivation,J.G.Nicholls, Ed. (JAI Press, 19 84), pp. 282– 331.

30.R.Butler,inHandbook o f Competence and Motivation,

A. J. Elliott, C. S. Dweck, Eds. (Guilford Press, 2005), pp. 202–221. 31. L. A. Rudman, J. Pers. Soc. Psychol. 74, 629–645 (1998). 32. J. L. Smith, M. Huntoon, Psychol. Women Q. 38, 447–459

(2013). 33. J. Mazei et al., Psychol. Bull. 141,8 5–104 (2015).

AC KN OW LE D GM E NT S We are grateful to the families who participated and to the members of the Cognitive Development Lab at the University of Illinois for research assistance and helpful discussion. We also thank J. R. Cimpian for insightful feedback on previous drafts. This research was supported by a Graduate College Dissertation Completion Fellowship from the University of Illinois (L.B.) and NSF grant BCS-1530669 (A.C. and S.-J.L.). The supplementary materials contain additional data. The data for these studies are also available on Open Science Framework: https://osf.io/yund6/ ?view_only=9a8505d4e87b456a89f255b43e21234e.

SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS www.sciencemag.org/content/355/6323/389/suppl/DC1 Materials and Methods Supplementary Text Figs. S1 and S2 Tables S1 to S5 References (34, 35)

30 July 2016; accepted 9 December 2016 10.1126/science.aah6524

Bian et al., Science 355 ,389–391 (2017) 27 January 2017 3of3

RESEARCH | REPORT

on January 26, 2017http://science.sciencemag.org/Downloaded from

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/gender-stereotypes-about-intellectual-ability-emerge-early-and-influence-children-s-interests. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
