# Gabriel's Wedding Cake

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/gabriels-wedding-cake

- **Authors:** Julian F. Fleron
- **Published:** 1999
- **Topic:** Mathematics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1653854309621-og78hzqtjqp-69ca310f3991ff68fd8236eda7a7c9c1%2Fgabriels_wedding_cake.pdf
- **Pages:** 4
- **Annotations:** 7 comments in 7 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/gabriels-wedding-cake

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Julian Fleron (j_fleron@foma.wsc.mass.edu) has been Assistant Professor of Mathematics at Westfield State College since completing his Ph.D. in several complex variables at SUNY University at Albany in 1994. He has broad mathematical passions that he strives to share with all of his students, whether mathematics for …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2022-05-29):

> #### TL;DR
>
> Gabriel's wedding cake describes a geometric figure with a finite volume but infinite surface are. In the author's words imagine ***"a cake  you can eat, but cannot frost"***.
>
> A few interesting properties of this cake (see image below):
> - Gabriel's wedding cake describes a particular geometric figure which has **infinite surface area but finite volume**
> - the rotation of an infinitely large section of the $xy$ plane about the x axis generates an object of finite volume was considered a **paradox because the section lying in the $xy$ plane has an infinite area, any other section parallel to it has a finite area. **
>
> This paradox was first discovered in the 17th century and it originated a **dispute on the nature of infinity involving many of the key thinkers of the time, including Thomas Hobbes, John Wallis and Galileo Galilei.**
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/ZapbgL4.png)

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Figure 1. Gabriel's Horn.”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2022-05-29):

> Three-dimensional illustration of Gabriel’s Horn. This horn shape has an interesting, counterintuitive property: **a finite volume but an infinite surface area.**
> ![GH](http://67.media.tumblr.com/47e8ed75408372defa0ccdf3ce155147/tumblr_n7umskeuNz1tzs5dao3_1280.gif)
>
> Create your own Gabriel Horn with Mathematica:
> ```mathematica
> x[u_, v_] := u
> y[u_, v_] := Cos[v]/u
> z[u_, v_] := Sin[v]/u
> Manipulate[ParametricPlot3D[{{x[u, v], y[u, v], z[u, v]}},
>    {u, 1, umax}, {v, 0, 2*Pi},
>    PlotRange -> {{0, 20}, {-1, 1}, {-1, 1}},
>    Mesh -> {Floor[umax], 20}, Axes -> False, Boxed -> False],
>    {{umax, 20}, 1.1, 20}]
> ```
> Source: [Fouriest Seriess.](http://fouriestseries.tumblr.com/post/90296337418/gabriels-horn-and-the-painters-paradox)

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “This object and some of its remarkable properties were first discovered in 1641 by Evangelista Torricelli. At this time Torricelli was a little known mathematician and physicist who was the successor to Galileo at Florence. He would later go on to invent the barometer and make many other important contributions to …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2022-05-29):

> **Cavalieri's Principle:** states that if two objects are between two parallel planes and if every plane cross-section parallel to the given planes have equal areas then the two objects must have equal volume. Figure 1. below is a great illustration of different objects with matching cross-sectional areas. They all have the same volume.
> !["cvp1"](http://i.imgur.com/zl6t9kD.png)
> **Figure 1:** Simple illustration of different objects with the same volume.
>
> #### We will now use Cavalieri's principle and apply it to Gabriel's horn.
> Figure 2 shows shows the intersection of a cylinder with an hyperbola in the $xy$-plane at point $(x_0,y_0)$. We can easily compute the curved surface area of the cylinder:
> $$V_C = (2\pi y_0)x_0$$
> and we know that $y= \frac{1}{x}$ thus:
> $$V_C = 2\pi$$
>
> !["cvp2"](http://i.imgur.com/06NQP0o.png)
> **Figure 2:** Illustration of a horn with open lip (1,1) and it's intersection with a cylinder at point $(x_0,y_0)$.
>
> The area of the cylinder is constant as the point of contact varies. Now imagine that you can cut the cylinder along the $x$-axis and unravel it so that it becomes a horizontal rectangle at point $y_0$, see the left panel of Figure 3. We can construct a new object that has surface are $2\pi$ at point $y_0$, see right panel of Figure 3.
>
> !["cvp3"](http://i.imgur.com/0nJweyO.png)
> **Figure 3:** Applying Cavalieri's principle to Gabriel's horn.
>
> Using Cavalieri's principle we know that two objects between two parallel planes with the same matching cross-sectional areas have the same volume. We know that the cylinder that we just constructed is a succession of $2\pi$ planes from $y=0, y=1$. Thus the volume of the cylinder is $V_C = 2\pi*1 = 2\pi$. Now we can use Cavalieri's principle and infer the volume of Gabriel's horn $V_{GH}$.
> $$V_{GH} = V_C = 2\pi.$$ Thanks to Cavalieri's principle have shown that although the horn seems to have an infinite length it has a finite volume!

### Annotation 4 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “This last integral cannot be evaluated readily, although with the aid of a computer algebra system we find”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2022-05-29):

> Determining the surface of the horn is a slightly more complex than the volume.
>
> The area for a volume of revolution is given by:
> \begin{eqnarray}
> S &=& 2\pi \int_1^N  y \sqrt{1+ \left(\frac{dy}{dx} \right)^2} dx\\
> \end{eqnarray}
> In this scenario we know that $y = \frac{1}{x}$ and we can then write:
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> \frac{dy}{dx} &=& -\frac{1}{x^2}
> \end{eqnarray*}We can then rewrite (1):
> \begin{eqnarray}
> S &=& 2\pi \int_1^N  \frac{1}{x} \sqrt{1+ \frac{1}{x^4} } dx \nonumber  \\
> &=& 2\pi \int_1^N \frac{\sqrt{x^4+ 1}}{x^3} dx\\
> \end{eqnarray}using integration by parts we can rewrite the integra in equation (2) as:
> \begin{eqnarray}
> \int \frac{\sqrt{x^4+ 1}}{x^3} dx &=&- \frac{1}{2x^2}\sqrt{x^4+1} + \int \frac{x}{\sqrt{x^4+1}}dx
> \end{eqnarray}to compute the integral in the right side of equation (3) we perform the following substition:
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> u = x^2 ; \frac{du}{dx} = 2x
> \end{eqnarray*}we have then that:
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> \int \frac{x}{\sqrt{x^4+1}}dx &=& \frac{1}{2} \int \frac{1}{\sqrt{u^2+1}}du\\
>  &=& \frac{1}{2} \ln{\left(u + \sqrt{u^2+1}\right)}+k\\
> \end{eqnarray*}and re-doing the substition we finally have that:
> \begin{eqnarray}
> \int \frac{x}{\sqrt{x^4+1}}dx &=& \frac{1}{2} \ln{\left(x^2 + \sqrt{x^4+1}\right)}+k
> \end{eqnarray}Taking (3) and (4) into account we can rewritte the surface area (2):
> \begin{eqnarray}
> S &=& 2\pi \left[ - \frac{1}{2x^2}\sqrt{x^4+1} + \frac{1}{2} \ln{\left(x^2 + \sqrt{x^4+1}\right)}\right]_1^N \nonumber\\
> &=& \pi \left(- \frac{1}{N^2}\sqrt{N^4+1} + \ln{\left(N^2 + \sqrt{N^4+1}\right)} \nonumber \\
> +\sqrt{2}- \ln{ \left( 1+\sqrt{2}\right)} \right)
> \end{eqnarray}
> As $N \rightarrow \infty$ the dominent term is $\ln{\left(N^2 + \sqrt{N^4+1}\right)}$ and taking the properties of the logarithm into accoun we can then write that:
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> \lim_{x\to\infty} S &\simeq& \lim_{x\to\infty} \left(\pi \ln{N} \right)
> &=&  \infty
> \end{eqnarray*} Thus we determined with modern calculous that **Gabriel's horn has a finite Volume and an intfinite area!** Paradox!

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Hence, Gabriel's hom is an infinite solid with finite volume but infinite surface area! Although Gabriel's hom is an engaging and appropriate example for second semester calculus, analysis of its remarkable features is complicated by two factors. First, many of the new calculus curricula do not include areas of …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2022-05-29):

> You can learn more about Gabriel's Horn here:
> - [Fermat's Library - Gabriel's Horn](https://fermatslibrary.com/s/gabriels-horn)
> - [Wolfram - Gabriel's Horn](https://mathworld.wolfram.com/GabrielsHorn.html)

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “1 - for n x < n + 1 n”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2022-05-29):

> How to transform the the "continuous horn" into a "discrete cake".

### Annotation 7 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “Thus, this solid illustrates essentially the same paradox as Gabriel's hom: an infinite solid with finite volume and infinite surface area. In other words: a cake you can eat, but cannot frost. Regarding a name for this new solid, Gabriel's wedding cake seems appropriate for physical and genealogical reasons. In …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2022-05-29):

> Another similar object is the infinite Gift 🎁:
>
> The infinite gift is an interesting object where the side of the nth box is $\frac{1}{√n}$. As $n\rightarrow +∞$, the gift has infinite surface area and length but finite volume!
>
> - [Learn more here: Infinit Gift](https://twitter.com/fermatslibrary/status/1166324490760065024)
>
> !["infinite_giff"](https://i.imgur.com/s1tvfvS.jpg)

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

Gabriel's Wedding Cake Julian F. Fleron

Julian Fleron (j_fleron@foma.wsc.mass.edu) has been [Annotation 1] Assistant Professor of Mathematics at Westfield State College since completing his Ph.D. in several complex variables at SUNY University at Albany in 1994. He has broad mathematical passions that he strives to share with all of his students, whether mathematics for liberal arts students, pre-service teachers, or mathematics majors. Family hobbies include popular music, cooking, and restoring the family's Victorian house.

We obtain the solid which nowadays is commonly, although perhaps inappropriately, known as Gabriel's hom by revolving the hyperbola y = 1/x about the line y = 0, as shown in Fig. 1. (See, e.g., [2], [5].) This name comes from the archangel Gabriel who, the Bible tells us, used a hom to announce news that was sometimes heartening (e.g. the birth of Christ in Luke 1) and sometimes fatalistic (e.g. Armageddon in Revelation 8-11).

Figure 1. Gabriel's [Annotation 2] Horn.

This object and some of its remarkable properties were first discovered in 1641 by Evangelista Torricelli. At this time Torricelli was a little known mathematician and physicist who was the successor to Galileo at Florence. He would later go on to invent the barometer and make many other important contributions to mathematics and physics. Torricelli communicated his discovery to Bonaventura Cavalieri [Annotation 3] and showed how he had computed its volume using Cavalieri's principle for indivisibles. Remarkably, this volume is finite! This result propelled Torricelli into the mathematical spotlight, gave rise to many related paradoxes [3], and sparked an extensive philosophical controversy that included Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, Isaac Barrow and others [ 4].

VOL. 30, NO. 1, JANUARY 1999 35

#### Page 2

This solid is a favorite in many calculus classes because its volume can be readily computed via the method of disks:

co co 1 ( -1 In) V= 1 7T(f( x) ) 2

dx = 1 7T- 2 dx = lim 7r- = 7T. 1 1 X X 1

The seeming paradox of an infinite solid with a finite volume becomes even more striking when one considers its surface area. The standard method for computing areas of surfaces of revolution gives

This last integral cannot [Annotation 4] be evaluated readily, although with the aid of a computer algebra system we find

In lieu of this, typically we estimate ...J x 4 + 1 I x 3 0 I x 3 = 1 I x so

co ...J x 4 + 1 co dx n 5=1 27T 3 -=lim (lln{x)lt)=oo. 1 X 1 X

Hence, Gabriel's hom is an infinite solid with finite volume but infinite surface area! Although Gabriel's hom is an engaging and appropriate example for second semester calculus, analysis [Annotation 5] of its remarkable features is complicated by two factors. First, many of the new calculus curricula do not include areas of surfaces of revolution. Second, the beauty of the paradox is often obscured by an integral estimate that most students find spurious at best.

In an effort to alleviate these factors, as well as to find an example accessible to less advanced students, we can use a discrete analogue of Gabriel's hom to illustrate the same paradox. To construct it we can replace the function y = 11x with a step function. Let

f(x) =

1 for 1 2 1 - 2

1 [Annotation 6] - for n x < n + 1 n

Revolving the graph of f about the line y = 0 we obtain the solid of revolution shown in Fig. 2. Notice that, when stood on end, it appears to be a cake with infinitely many layers.

36 THE COLLEGE MATHEMATICS JOURNAL

#### Page 3

///// (1/////'A. \XXXXXX\\' N\ : 1 //////!' IV ,v,, ,:"\n ' •'\ II 1

\\\\\\

'11 l U/111! cxl/f 11

Figure 2. Gabriel's Wedding Cake.

As each layer is simply a cylinder, the volume and surface area of the solid can be readily computed. The nth layer has volume 1T(lln) 2 , so the total volume of the cake is

V= i: 1T(2_)

2

= 1T E \. n=I n n=I n

This series converges. Calculus students will recognize the series as a p-series with p = 2. Less advanced students can see that the series converges by comparison:

00 1 111111 "-=1+-+-+-+-+-+-+ ... n'":I nz 22 32 42 52 62 72

< 1 + 2.(2. + 2.) + 2.(2. +..:. +..:. + 2.) + ... -22 2 44 4 4 4

1 1 1 = 1 + 2 + 4 + ... = --1- = 2 · 1--

2

Using Euler's remarkable result that the sum of the series is E:= 1 (1ln 2 ) = 1r 2 16 [1], one can even obtain an exact result: V= 1r 3 16. The surface area is formed by the annular tops and the lateral sides of each layer. The surface area of the nth annular top is 7T(1 I n) 2 - 1T(l In + 1) 2 , so the total area of the annular tops is given by the telescoping series

Notice this result is obvious if one "collapses" the layers since the resulting top layer will be a complete disk of radius one. The surface area of the nth lateral side is 21T(lln)(l), so the total lateral surface area is

VOL. 30, NO. 1, JANUARY 1999 37

#### Page 4

This is the harmonic series, among the most important of all the infinite series, which diverges.

Thus, this solid illustrates essentially the same paradox as Gabriel's hom: an infinite solid with finite volume and infinite surface area. In other words: a cake you can eat, but cannot frost. Regarding a name for this new solid, Gabriel's wedding cake seems appropriate for physical [Annotation 7] and genealogical reasons. In aqdition, it seems a bit refreshing since weddings are so unabashedly joyous, and the connotations of the hom have often imposed a heavy burden on Gabriel.

References

1. William Dunham, journey Through Genius, John Wiley & Sons, 1990. 2. P. Gillett, Calculus and Analytic Geometry, 2nd ed., D. C. Heath, 1984. 3. Jan A. van Maanen, Alluvial deposits, conic sections, and improper glasses, or history of mathematics applied in the classroom, in F. Swetz,]. Fauvel, 0. Bekken, B. Johansson, and V. Katz, eds., Learn from the Masters, Mathematical Association of America, 1995. 4. Paolo Mancosu and Ezio Vailati, Torricelli's infinitely long solid and its philosophical reception in the seventeenth century, Isis, 82:311 (1991) 50-70. 5. D. W. Varberg and E.]. Purcell, Calculus, 7th ed., Prentice Hall, 1997.

38

---o---

Call for Referees

The jounzal is in constant need of people who will read and evaluate manuscripts, suggest how they could be improved, correct their grammatical errors (if any), and, in general, give them a thorough going-over.

This is voluntary, unpaid, and anonymous labor, but referees are vital for the jounzal, and for the profession. If you would be willing to take on this job-it is not too onerous, one or two manuscripts a year-please let me know (Underwood Dudley, Mathematics Department, DePauw University, Greencastle, Indiana 46135; dudley@depauw.edu) and, if you want to, indicate fields in which you would be especially interested

THE COLLEGE MATHEMATICS JOURNAL

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/gabriels-wedding-cake. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
