# Does Being Bored Make Us More Creative?

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/does-being-bored-make-us-more-creative

- **Authors:** Sandi Mann & Rebekah Cadman
- **Published:** 2014
- **Topic:** Economics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1539454788271-x75v288yo8-bd83f914ad4c49b1520e1fbcae39a635%2Fbeing_bored_mann2014.pdf
- **Pages:** 9
- **Annotations:** 11 comments in 11 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/does-being-bored-make-us-more-creative

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Does Being Bored Make Us More Creative?”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2018-10-13):

> ### TL;DR
> Boredom is often associated with negative connotations but recent studies show that being bored might actually be beneficial. This paper **discusses the main benefits of boredom and studies the impact of boredom on creativity and problem-solving capacity**.
>
> Some of the benefits of boredom include:
> - More altruistic thought and developed empathy.
> - Boredom induces daydreaming which leads to increased creativity and problem-solving.
> - When we are bored we are stimulated to introspect and think about thus helping us with goal setting.
>
> The main findings of this paper are:
> - Being bored seems to induce daydreaming and spark creativity and improve our problem-solving capacity.
> - Being bored and daydreaming seem to have a greater impact on creative problem-solving tasks in which there are finite solutions to be found than in more imaginative creative tasks where there are infinite possible outcomes.
>
> >***"it might be a worthwhile enterprise to allow or even embrace boredom in work, education, and leisure. On an individual basis, if one is trying to solve a problem or come up with creative solutions, the findings from our studies suggest that undertaking a boring task (especially a reading task) might help with coming up with a more creative outcome."***

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “in search of variety—failure to satisfy this leads to the experience of boredom. Many argue that boredom is a distinct emotional state, leading Fisher, one of the forerunners in boredom research, to deﬁne boredom as ‘‘an unpleasant, transient affective state in which the individual feels a pervasive lack of interest …”

**Annotation** by Jason Sun (2018-10-17):

> I think the method is a bit flawed: Both are boring-followed-by-creative task and then "creativity" was measured; yet there isn't a reverse direction. I.e. creative-followed-by-boring task and then "creativity" measured.
>
> Or alternatively, some tasks may be boring to the mind but require intense concentration. These may not reach the same conclusion.

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Contrary to popular wisdom, boredom is not the result of having nothing to do. It is very hard to co me up with a situation where a person’s options are so limited that he or she literally can do nothing. Rather, boredom stems from a situation where none of the possible things that a person can realistically do appeal …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2018-10-14):

> Here is a great video **The Scientific Benefits of Boredom** by Veritasium about the benefits of being bored:
>
> [![veritasium](https://i.imgur.com/0F42BDJ.jpg)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LKPwKFigF8U)

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Some researchers have attempted to deﬁne boredom although there is no real consensus. What is agreed about boredom is that it is a ‘‘complex phenomenon’’ (Martin et al., 2006, p. 196). Hebb (1996) deﬁned it as a ‘‘state in which the level of stimulation is perceived as unsatisfactorily low’’ (in Drory, 1982, p. 141). …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2018-10-14):

> #### What is boredom?
>
> - "state in which the level of stimulation is perceived as unsatisfactorily low"
> - "an unpleasant, transient affective state in which the individual feels a pervasive lack of interest in and dif- ficulty concentrating on the current activity"
> - "feeling stressed, agitated, yet at the same time lethargic"

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “In education, boredom has been linked with diminished academic achievement and school dissatisfaction (e.g., Maroldo, 1986). For example, students who rated themselves as often bored had generally lower scores on academic tests than those who were sometimes bored (Mikulas & Vodanovich, 1993). Stu dent boredom has also …”

**Annotation** by Joe Previti (2018-11-13):

> Do these studies also take into account the number of genius level students who are bored by subject matter that is too easy? Or is that proportion negligible with respect to these studies?

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “As the previous review suggests, resear ch shows that being bored is generally a negative experience. Yet boredom, like most emotions, has a purpose and, despite widely held views about its negative connotations, it is speculated that there are potentially many beneﬁts to being bored. These include that of …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2018-10-14):

> Recent studies have shown that being bored is not all that negative. As a matter of fact being bored could have a positive impact on:
>
> - **Empathy:** Being bored induces us to think about others in an altruistic way. Studies designed to induce boredom have shown that bored participants were more likely to donate to charity, or give blood.
> - **Creativity:** Boredom induces daydreaming which leads to a creative problem-solving and is related with higher creativity. Recent studies have shown that people tend to be more creative after being bored for a short amount of time (several minutes).
> - **Productivity:** Boredom acts like a warning that the task at hand is not stimulating enough. It will push us to act in order to get out of the current unpleasant situation.
> - **Goal setting:** When we are bored we are stimulated to think about our life and what we want to do in the future thus helping us set meaningful goals.

### Annotation 7 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Like most emotions, boredom is likely to have had evolutionary value; as a stimulus proves itself neither dangerous nor reinforcing, people would simply lose interest in it and turn attention to other stimuli. If humans did not bore of things, it would be impos sible to habituate to the continued minutiae of life and …”

**Annotation** by Michal Osiak (2018-10-17):

> I wonder whether there are any examples of what appears to be boredom within primates or other animal species.

### Annotation 8 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “The participants were from an opportunity sample from a community church local to one of the researchers. No ages were recorded; however, all participants were over 18. There were 80 participants (40 control condition and 40 boredom condition) with an even split of gender for each condition. Two raters were used to …”

**Annotation** by Joe Previti (2018-11-13):

> Only 2??

### Annotation 9 (page 6)

Beside the passage: “The aim of the two studies reported here was to examine the effects of boredom on creative potential. Two different methods of inducing boredom were used (written task in Study 1 and both reading and writing tasks in Study 2) and creative potential was measured with a range of different tasks.”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2018-10-14):

> #### Study 1:
> 1. There were 40 participants in the control group and 40 participants in the "boring-writing" group.
> 2. Participants were asked to do a boring writing task.
> 3. After the boring task, they were asked to come up with creative ideas (no right or wrong answers).
>
> **The boring group managed to produce more ideas/answers than the control group.** The creativity of ideas did not differ much which could be related to the fact that writing inhibits daydreaming and thus inhibits creativity.
>
> #### Study 2:
> 1. There were 30 participants in the control group, 30 participants in the "boring-writing" group and 30 participants in the "boring-reading" group.
> 2. Participants were asked to do respectively a boring writing or reading task.
> 3. After the boring task, they were asked to come up with creative ideas for 3 different tasks.
> 4. The last task (task 3) is a different type of task, **only right or wrong answers**.
>
> **The boring reading and writing groups produced more ideas/answers than the control group.** The "boring-reading" group managed to produce more ideas than the two other groups. The creativity of their ideas differed significantly between the "boring" groups and the control group. Boring reading tasks seem to facilitate more daydreaming than boring writing tasks. The boring reading group outperformed both other groups thus indicating that **being bored might be useful in creative problem-solving tasks in which there are finite solutions.**

### Annotation 10 (page 7)

Beside the passage: “can sometimes be a force for good. This means that it might be a worthwhile enterprise to allow or even embrace boredom in work, education, and leisure. On an individual basis, if one is trying to solve a problem or come up with creat ive solutions, the ﬁndings from our studies suggest that undertaking a boring task …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2018-10-14):

> >***"it might be a worthwhile enterprise to allow or even embrace boredom in work, education, and leisure. On an individual basis, if one is trying to solve a problem or come up with creative solutions, the findings from our studies suggest that undertaking a boring task (especially a reading task) might help with coming up with a more creative outcome."***

### Annotation 11 (page 7)

Beside the passage: “Task 3 was a totally different type of creative task that could produce only right or wrong answers (a convergent task). Here, only the reading boring task, and not the written boring task, led to a signiﬁcant increase the number of correct responses. This again lends further support to the hypothesis that writing …”

**Annotation** by Micael Oliveira (2018-10-14):

> >***"It could be that daydreaming is more significant a factor in the stimulation of creative thoughts with convergent creative tasks than with the divergent tasks; daydreaming might be more useful in creative problem-solving tasks in which there are finite solutions to be found, than in more imaginative creative tasks where there are infinite possible outcomes."***

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

Does Being Bored Make Us More Creative? [Annotation 1]

Sandi Mann and Rebekah Cadman University of Central Lancashire, United Kingdom

Boredom has traditionally been associated with a range of negative outcomes, both within the workplace and outside it. More recently, however, it has been suggested that boredom can have positive outcomes, one of which might be increased creativity. This study addressed this proposition by examining the relationship between boredom and creative potential on a range of tasks. Two studies were carried out; the ﬁrst involved 80 participants taking part in either a boring writing activity or not (control group) followed by a creative task. The second study involved a further 90 participants who varied in the type of boring activity they undertook (either a boring written activity, a boring reading activity, or a control) and the type of creative task that followed. Results suggested that boring activities resulted in increased creativity and that boring reading activities lead to more creativity in some circumstances (such as convergent tasks) than boring written activities. The role of daydreaming as a mediator between boredom and creativity is discussed and implications are outlined.

Contrary to popular wisdom, boredom is not the result of having nothing to do. It is very hard to co me up with [Annotation 3] a situation where a person’s options are so limited that he or she literally can do nothing. Rather, boredom stems from a situation where none of the possible things that a person can realistically do appeal to the person in question. This renders the person inactive, and generally unhappy. Thus, boredom is the result of having nothing to do that one likes, rather than nothing to do per se. For most people, boredom is a negative experience; even described in one study as ‘‘an extremely unpleasant and distressing experience’’ (Martin, Sadlo, & Stew, 2006, p. 193 ).

Some researchers have attempted to deﬁne boredom [Annotation 4] although there is no real consensus. What is agreed about boredom is that it is a ‘‘complex phenomenon’’ (Martin et al., 2006, p. 196). Hebb (1996) deﬁned it as a ‘‘state in which the level of stimulation is perceived as unsatisfactorily low’’ (in Drory, 1982, p. 141). Lack of external stimulation leads to increased neural arousal

in search of variety—failure to satisfy this leads to the [Annotation 2] experience of boredom. Many argue that boredom is a distinct emotional state, leading Fisher, one of the forerunners in boredom research, to deﬁne boredom as ‘‘an unpleasant, transient affective state in which the individual feels a pervasive lack of interest in and difﬁculty concentrating on the current activity ...[such that] it takes conscious effort to maintain or return attention to that activity’’ (Fisher, 1993, p. 396).

Despite the variations in deﬁnitions, there is surprising consensus in laypeople’s descriptions of the experience of boredom. A qualitative study by Martin et al. (2006) reported that all respondents described boredom as ‘‘feeling stressed, agitated, yet at the same time lethargic’’ (p. 208). This concurs with a study of teachers in which respondents described being bored as tiring, miserable, and frustrating (Mann and Robinson, 2009). Indeed, boredom has been associated with a range of negative outcomes both at work and beyond. Negative consequences at work include: poor work performance (Vodanovich, 2003), correlations with anger (Vodanovich, 2003), accidents (Brant on, 1970; Drory, 1982), absenteeism (Brisset & Snow, 1993), more errors (Cox, 1980; Drory, 1982; O’Hanlon, 1981), stress, increased risk taking=thrill seeking (e.g., Hamilton, 1983), sleepiness (Grose, 1989), stress-related

Parts of this article were presented at the British Psychological Society’s Division of Occupational Psychology Annual Conference, January 13th, 2013.

Correspondence should be sent to Sandi Mann, Senior Lecturer in Occupational Psychology, Department of Psychology, University of Central Lancashire, Preston PR1 2HE. E-mail: smann@uclan.ac.uk

CREATIVITY RESEARCH JOURNAL, 26(2), 165–173, 2014 Copyright # Taylor & Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 1040-0419 print=1532-6934 online DOI: 10.1080/10400419.2014.901073

#### Page 2

health problems, e.g., heart attacks (e.g., Alfredsson, Karasek, & Theorell, 1982), job dissa tisfaction (Caplan, Cobb, French, van Harrison, & Pinneau, 1975), and property damage (Drory, 1982). Some of these consequences are clearly symptoms of the boredom experience; accidents, mistakes, sleepiness, etc. are all the result of being unable to sustain attention. Other consequences are a result of the ways that individuals try to cope with their boredom by either refocusing atte ntion on the task or seeking additional sti mulation.

In education, boredom has been linked with diminished academic achievement and school dissatisfaction (e.g., Maroldo, 1986). For example, students who rated themselves as often bored had generally lower scores on academic tests than those who were sometimes bored (Mikulas & Vodanovich, 1993). Stu dent boredom has also been shown to be a contributor to truancy (e.g., [Annotation 5] Watt & Vodanovich, 1992). For example, boredom is one of the most frequently identiﬁed causes for students leaving school temporarily (e.g., skipping classes, feigning illness) or permanently (Farmer & Sundberg, 1986; Larson & Richards, 1991). Students who do not miss classes have been shown to have higher performance scores (e.g., Farmer & Sundberg, 1986; Grabe, 2005; Handelsman, Briggs, Sullivan, & Towler, 2005; Maroldo, 1986; Mikulas & Vodanovich, 1993).

IS BOREDOM ALW AYS BAD?

As the previous review suggests, resear ch shows that being bored is generally a negative experience. Yet bore- [Annotation 6] dom, like most emotions, has a purpose and, despite widely held views about its negative connotations, it is speculated that there are potentially many beneﬁts to being bored. These include that of communicating to others interests, values, and beliefs, and for communicating lack of presence—that the bored person does not want to be here, functioning as an excuse or justiﬁcation (Scott & Lyman, 1968) for noninvolvement or respite. Boredom might also communicate a desire to be stimulated by others, as well as providing an adaptive mechanism against societal noise or information overload (Klapp, 1986). Boredom might also be a ‘‘shield against self-confrontation’’ (Hoover, 1986, p. 43); a means to avoid discomfort or new knowledge (Dehlinger, 1975).

Like most emotions, boredom is likely to have had evolutionary value; as a stimulus proves itself neither dangerous nor reinforcing, people would simply lose [Annotation 7] interest in it and turn attention to other stimuli. If humans did not bore of things, it would be impos sible to habituate to the continued minutiae of life and everyone would be constantly preoccupied with every minor

stimulus to such an extent that they might not attend to real threats.

A ﬁnal function or beneﬁt of bor edom is that it might stimulate the ‘‘production of fantasies, awakening creativeness’’ (Brisset & Snow, 1993, p. 243). Boredom is, paradoxically, a motivating force=catalyst for action: ‘‘Boredom ...is an alerting phenomenon that all is not well and something must be done’’ (Gaylin, 1979, p. 129). Boredom might stimulate the need to redecorate, take up a new hobby, or look for a new job. The feeling, then, can induce challenge-seeking behavior, and therein lies the paradox that boredom, associated by many with lethargy, can actually be energising, inspiring a search for ‘‘change and va riety’’ (Harris, 2000, p. 578).

BOREDOM, CREATIVITY AND

DAYDREAMING

This idea that boredom can lead to a search for variety was taken up by Bell (2011), who suggested that boredom may well boost creativity. When individ uals are bored, they ﬁnd it difﬁcult to focus their attention on the task, and thought processes shift to other areas that can provide more stimulation. When the bored individual cannot physically escape the task to undertake a more engaging one, this attention shift is often from an external focus on the task, to a more interna l focus on inner thoughts, feelings, and experiences. This inner focus allows a way of gaining the stimulation that is being craved and that is missing from the boring task. This internal focus could involve a search for new ways to carry out the boring task to make it more engaging (Toohey, 2011) or could involve thinking about unrelated problems or ideas the consideration of which is more appealing than the boring task at hand. It is this attention-shifting that is termed daydreaming, and is thus a common by-product of boredom (Smallwood & Schooler, 2006). Indeed, previous research has shown that individuals use daydreaming to regulate boredominduced tension (Tushup & Zuckerman, 1977), thus suggesting that daydreaming is used as a coping strategy for dealing with the unpleasant state of boredom (Smith, 1981).

In concordance with this, Singer (1975) described daydreaming as shifting attention from the external situation or problem to the internal representation of situations, memories, pictures, unresolved things, scenarios, or future goals. Smallwood (2011) more recently explained the process of daydreaming as ‘‘a state of decoupled processing in which attention to ongoing perceptual information is reduced often in favor of the active consideration of internally generated thoughts and feeling’’ (p. 63). Schank (1982) proposed that daydreaming is a part of dynamic memory. Dynamic

166 MANN AND CADMAN

#### Page 3

memory is the ability to reevaluate information and possible solutions with the reexamining of a problem or unresolved scenario (Schank, 1999). The act of daydreaming can thus provide individuals with the opportunity to reexamine a prob lem or situation that is preoccupying their minds as many times as they wish, in varied ways and each time incorporating new information and possible solutions. The beneﬁt of daydreaming, then, is that seemingly illogical ideas can be explored in ways that may not be practically feasible and through this exploration a new or more suitable solution to problems or unresolved situations may be found. This, then, can lead to creative problem-solving (Singer, 1981) and suggests a link between daydreaming and creativity (Singer, 1975). This theme was taken up more recently, in an article in Newsweek (Begley, Bailey, Sone, & Interlandi, 2009) which described daydreaming as a ‘‘propitious mental state for creativity, insight and problem solving’’ (Begley et al., 2009, p. 36) in which ‘‘truly novel solutions and ideas emerge’’ due to the daydreaming brain being able to bring togeth er unrelated facts and thoughts.

THE PRESENT STUDIES

Our studies explored the hypothesis that boring activities lead to increased creativity. The ﬁrst study used a boring writing task to induce boredom and a divergent thinking task to measure creative potential. Divergent tasks are where there are no set answers to creative problems, but divergent thinkers can come up with a range of novel answers; these are among the most common means of assessing creative potential. Divergent thinking tasks require the individual to think creatively by using lateral thinking to produce various solutions to a given problem (Plucker & Renzulli, 1999) and lend themselves to boredom research given the daydreaming element of boredom (Smallwood et al., 2006).

The writing task might hinder the daydreaming thought to be necessary for creativity to be enhanced, due to it interfering with the propensity for attention to wander. This was suggested by previous research; for example, doodling when bored improved cognitive performance for students and it is thought this was due to it interfering with daydreaming (Andrade, 2010). Thus, the second study introduced a boring reading task in addition to the writing task.

Divergent thinking is not the only form of assessment in creativity, however, and has not been without its critiques (Weisberg, 2006). Part of the criticism of divergent thinking as a measure of creative potential has been in the scoring of divergent thinking tasks, in particular with the commonly used method of frequency and uniqueness scoring, which simply looks at the number

and rarity of the answers—rather than taking into consideration how useful or creative the answers are (Silvia et al., 2008). This can lead to confounding results, as with more answers there is a higher prob ability of there being unique answers (Silvia et al., 2008). To address this limitation, both frequency (number of answers) and creative usefulness (in terms of the range of creative uses of the responses that were generated), were assessed independently by two raters, as suggested by Silvia et al. (2008), in these studies. The use of more than one creative divergent thinking task also address ed the concerns that Silvia et al. (2008) had in relation to the problems of reliability in using only one task. In addition, Study 2 also introduced a convergent creative task (where there are deﬁnite answers to a problem) to further address any possible limitations.

STUDY 1

This study investigated the impact of undertaking a boring writing activity (copying telephone numbers from a phone directory) on subsequent levels of creativity shown in a divergent thinking task (to come up with as many uses for a pair of polystyrene cups as possible). The independent variable (IV) was the precreativity activity—either a boring task or not. The dependent variables (DVs) were the number of answers produced in the creative potential task and the degree of creative usefulness of those answers.

The participants were from an opportunity sample from a community church local to one of the researchers. No ages were recorded; however, all participants were over 18. There were 80 participants (40 control condition and 40 boredom condition) with an even split of gender for each condition. Two raters were used to assess the [Annotation 8] level of useful creativity (i.e., the degree of creativity in coming up with different uses of the objects) of the answers provided. These raters were colleagu es of one of the authors, but blind to the hypotheses of the study.

Materials/Apparatus

The participants in the boredom condition recei ved an information brieﬁng sheet, pages from a telephone book, and a recording sheet on which to write down the telephone numbers. After this, participants in both the boredom and the control conditions underwent the same creative task. Both sets of participants received the same instruction sheet for this task, two polystyrene cups, the recording sheet to write down their list of different uses for the cups, and a postprocedure information sheet containing the researcher’s contact information.

The boredom task was created especially for this study; howeve r, the creative uses task was an adapted

DOES BEING BORED MAKE US MORE CREATIVE? 167

#### Page 4

version of Guilford’s Alternative Uses Brick Task (1967, cited in Silvia et al., 2008), which has been widely used and has become an accepted measure of divergent thinking.

The raters were provided with the instruction sheets brieﬂy explaining the study and the criteria, the participants answer sheets from the creative task, and a recording sheet to record the scores.

Procedure

The participants in the boredom condition were asked to write down telephone numbers from a phone book for 15 min. Once the time had elapsed, they were asked to rate how boring they found the activit y as a manipulation check, on a 5-point Likert scale (1 ¼ not boring, 5 ¼ extremely boring) and participants with scores below 4 did not continue with the study, to ensure that the participants were experiencing a boring task.

Participants were also asked to state if they noticed that they daydreamed at any point during the boring task. Only those who admitted to daydreaming continued on to the creative task.

The creative potential task consisted of the participants being given 3 min to list as many different uses for the two polystyrene cups they were provided with. Once the 3 min had elapsed, the participants were asked to circle their two most creative uses of the cups. The participants were then fully debriefed. All the answers were compiled and given to two raters to assess the two most creative answers.

The experimenter was on hand at all times to answer any queries. The rater began by eliminating any duplicate answers from the list and then rated the two most creative answers on a 5-point Likert scale (1 ¼ no creativity,5¼ high creativity). They wer e assessing the answers for both quality (jn terms of how useful the suggestions were) and how unusual the answers were. They then recorded the average score for the two most creative answers and recorded it on the sheet provided.

Results

The mean Kappa coefﬁcient (0.82) revealed a high reliability (Kappa result ov er 0.70), so no alterations were made to the rater procedures. The rater scores were averaged and an overall score was assigned to each participant.

The mean frequency and standard deviation were obtained for the number of answers provided (Table 1).

An independent t-test was used to investigate the mean frequency of the number of answers provided. The results revealed that there was a signiﬁcant difference between scores for the two conditions (t ¼ "4.316, df ¼ 78, p < 0.0005), indicating that the number

of answers were higher for participants who completed a boredom task followed by the creative task than for participants who completed the creative task alone (control condition). This is also conﬁrmed by the mean scores (see Table 2). An independent t-test was used to investigate the mean creativity of answers provided. The results revealed that there was a nonsigniﬁcant difference between scores for the two conditions (t ¼"4. df ¼ 78, p > 0.05).

Results from Study 1 suggested then that the boring writing task did increase the number of responses produced, which is one measure of creative potential; however, being bored did not appear to lead to more creative answers. These results led to the adaption of new techniques for Study 2.

STUDY 2

The second study atte mpted to investigate further the hypothesis that boredom leads to enhanced creativity by making changes to the design of Study 1. In Study 2, a second boredom task was introduced (a boring reading task), as well as two extra creative potential tasks (one of whic h was a convergent task). The extra creative potential tasks were added as a way of ensuri ng generalizability of ﬁndings. It was further predicted that participants’ creativity would be higher following the reading boredom task than following the written boring task an d the control, because of the greater opportunities for daydreaming afforded by reading over writing (Andrade, 2010).

Participants

Participants were recruited on an opportunistic basis at the same venue as Study 1, but individuals who had

TABLE 1 Mean Frequency and Standard Deviation Scores for the Number of Answers Provided After Completing a Creative

Task Across a Control and Boredom Condition

Mean SD

Control 7.33 2.01 Boredom 10.63 4.4

TABLE 2 Mean Frequency and Standard Deviation Scores for the

Level of Creativity of the Two Most Creative Answers Provided After Completing a Creative Task Across a

Control and Boredom Condition

Mean SD

Control 3.58 0.68 Boredom 3.65 0.98

168 MANN AND CADMAN

#### Page 5

taken part in Study 1 were excluded. They were randomly assigned to the various conditions by selecting a time slot. Again, no ages were recorded but all participants were over 18. There were 90 participants for Study 2: 30 in the control condition, 30 in the written boredom condition, and 30 in the reading boredom condition, with an even split of gender for each condition.

Materials/Apparatus

The participants in the two boredom conditions (written or reading ) received an information sheet and pages from a telephone book. Participants in the written boredom condition also received a recording sheet to write down the telephone numbers.

All conditions received an instruction sheet for Creative Potential Task 1 (which was the same task as in Study 1), two polystyrene cups, and the recording sheet to write down their list of different uses for the cups. Once Creative Potential Task 1 was completed, they underwent Creative Potential Task 2 and received an instruction sheet and recording sheet to write a list of different consequences to global narcolepsy (a chronic sleep disorder that can include excessive sleepiness and sleep attacks).

Once Creative Potential Task 2 was completed, they moved onto the last task. They received an instruction sheet and recording sheet for Creative Potential Task 3, which consisted of a series of word problems. After all the tasks were completed, the participants were given a postprocedure information sheet containing the researcher’s contact information.

The boredom tasks were created especially for this study; however, the creative uses task was an adaptation from other research. Creative Potential Task 2 was adapted from Christ ensen, Merriﬁeld, and Guilford’s Consequences Task (1953, cited in Furnham, Crump, Batey, & Chamorro-Premuzic, 2009); Creative Potential Task 3, a convergent creative task, was created for this study and adapted from Mednick and Mednick Remote Associations Test (1962, 1967, cited in Isen, Daubman, & Nowicki, 1987) and involved completing as many answers as possible (in 3 min) to a series of 40 word problems. Participants were permitted to answer them in any order. They consisted of three stimulus words and were asked to generate the fourth word that combined with each of the stimulus words . They could combine to form a compound word=phrase, a shared meaning word or a shared relationship. For example the answer to the three stimulus words MEASURE, WORM, and VIDEO would be TAPE (tape measure, tape worm, and video tape).

These methods of assessing creative thinking have been widely used as a measure of creativity (Furnham et al., 2009; Isen et al., 1987; Silvia et al., 2008) and by

using more than one creative task, it increases the reliability of the results (Silvia et al., 2008).

The raters were provided with the instruction sheets that were used in the pilot study, the participants answ er sheets and three copies of the reco rding sheets.

Procedure

The tasks were conducted in the same mann er as in Study 1. The participant s in the written boredom condition were asked to write down telephone numbers from a phone book for 15 min, and in the reading boredom condition were asked to read the telephone numbers for 15 min. Once the time had elapsed, they were asked to rate the boredom activity on a 5-point Likert scale (1 ¼ not boring,5¼ extremely boring) and participants with scores below 4 did not continue with the study. Those who rated the task as boring and indicated that they daydreamed continued on to do the three creative potential tasks. Participants in the control condition undertook the three creative potential tasks without either of the telephone numbers tasks.

Before beginning, each creative potential task the participants received an instruction sheet. The experimenter was on hand to answer any queries. Each task was 3 min long and, once the time had elapsed, participants were asked to circle their two most creative answers. Once this was completed, they moved on to the next task.

Once all the tasks were completed, all the answers were compiled and given to two raters to assess the two most creative answers. This followed the same procedure as Study 1.

Results

The mean boredom score (for how boring they found the boredom task) for those that took part in the written boredom task condition was 4.3 and the mean score for those taking part in the reading boredom task was 4.5.

The mean frequency and standard deviation were obtained for the number of answers provided for each of the ﬁrst two tasks of creative potential and for the number of correct answers in the third creative task (Table 3).

A one-way between-subjects analysis of varianc e was (ANOVA) conducted for Task 1 to see if the mean number of answers on this task differed for each of the three conditions. The results revealed a signiﬁcant effect of condition, F(2, 87) ¼ 14.45, p ¼ 0.000, g 2 ¼ 0.25. Post hoc Bonferroni paired comparisons tests suggested that the written and reading conditions did not differ signiﬁcantly from each other (p ¼ 0.062), but written differed signiﬁcantly from the control condition (p ¼ 0.01) and

DOES BEING BORED MAKE US MORE CREATIVE? 169

#### Page 6

the reading different signiﬁcantly from the control condition (p ¼ 0.000).

A one-way between-subjects ANOVA was conducted for Task 2 to see if the mean number of answers on this task differed for each of the three conditions. The results revealed a signiﬁcant effect of condition, F(2, 87) ¼ 36.098, p ¼ 0.000, g 2 ¼ 0.45. Post hoc Bonferroni paired comparisons tests suggested that the reading and writing conditions differed signiﬁcantly (p ¼ 0.000) from each other, the reading and control differed signiﬁcantly (p ¼ 0.000) and that the writing and control differed signiﬁcantly (p ¼ 0.003).

A one-way between-subjects ANOVA was conducted for Task 3 to see if the mean number of correct answers on this task differed for each of the three conditions. The results revealed a signiﬁcant effect of condition, F(2, 87) ¼ 4.334, p ¼ 0.016, g 2 ¼ 0.09. Post hoc Bonferroni paired comparisons tests sugg ested that the only signiﬁcant differences lay between the reading and control conditions (p ¼ 0.019).

The level of creativity of answers given in the creative tasks 1 and 2 was examined next (but not for Task 3, which involved only supplying right or wrong answers); see Table 4.

Two one-way ANOVAs were performed to investigate the differences between scores for each task across the three conditions.

The Task 1 ANOVA revealed that there was a signiﬁcant effect of the condition, F(2, 87) ¼ 7.574, p ¼ 0.001, g 2 ¼ 0.15. Post hoc Bonferroni paired comparisons tests suggested that the control group differed signiﬁcantl y from the written condition (p ¼ 0.043) and the reading condition (p ¼ 0.001) but that the written and reading conditions did not differ signiﬁcantly from each other (p ¼ 0.56).

The Task 2 ANOVA revealed that there was a signiﬁcant effect of the condition, F(2, 87) ¼ 11.67, p ¼ 0.000, g 2 ¼ 0.2. Post hoc Bonferroni paired comparisons tests suggested that the control group differed signiﬁcantl y from the written condition (p ¼ 0.002) and the reading condition (p ¼ 0.000), but that the writt en and reading conditions did not differ signiﬁcantly from each other (p ¼ 0.98).

DISCUSSION

The aim of the two studies reported here was to examine the effects of boredom on creative potential. Two different methods of inducing boredom were used (written [Annotation 9] task in Study 1 and both reading and writing tasks in Study 2) and creative potential was measured with a range of different tasks.

Study 1 revealed that participants came up with signiﬁcantly more answers to a creative task following a written boredom task than without such a task. However, although more answers were produced following the boring task, these were not judged to actually be more creative. This suggests that being bored can lead to increased creativity in terms of quantity, but not necessarily in terms of quality. This dichotomy could be due to the writing task interfering with the ability to daydream, because the active act of writing is likely to have the role of refocusing attention on the task (and thus inhibiting daydreaming) in accordance with Andrade’s (2010) ﬁnding that doodling inhibi ted daydreaming.

Study 2 thus introduced a reading boring task in addition to the written boring task, but the results suggested that the number of creative answers and their level of creativity in Task 1, although higher for the reading condition, were not signiﬁcantly higher. This suggests that boring reading tasks do not lead to signiﬁcantly more creativity (at least for this type of task) than boring writing tasks do and thus suggests that either the written task did not inhibit daydreaming enough for it to effect creativity or that daydreaming is a not as important a moderator of the boredom-creativity link as hypothesised.

However, the boring tasks, whether written or read, did lead to an increase in both the number of creative answers produced in Task 1, as well as their level of

TABLE 3 Mean Frequency and Standard Deviation Scores for the Number of Answers Provided After Completing a Series of

Creative Tasks (1, 2 and 3) Across a Control, Written

Boredom and Reading Boredom Condition

Task Group

Creative Task

Row Mean

Task 1 Task 2 Task 3

Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD

Control 8.03 2.83 6.73 1.95 6.47 0.82 7.08 Written boredom 10.03 2.09 8.70 1.95 6.97 0.81 8.57 Reading boredom 11.60 2.74 11.60 2.71 7.10 1.00 10.10 Column mean 9.89 2.94 9.01 2.99 6.84 0.91

TABLE 4 Mean Frequency and Standard Deviation Scores for the Level of Creativity of the Two Most Creative Answers Provided After Completing a Series of Creative Tasks (1 and 2) Across a

Control, Written Boredom and Reading Boredom Condition

Task 1 Task 2

Mean SD Mean SD

Control 2.67 0.66 2.73 0.83 Written boredom 3.17 0.79 3.47 0.86 Reading boredom 3.43 0.86 3.67 0.66 Column mean 3.09 0.83 3.29 0.88

170 MANN AND CADMAN

#### Page 7

creativity (in terms of how useful they were), when compared to the control (nonboring) condition. These ﬁndings contradict those of Study 1, which found that level of creativity did not signiﬁcantly increase after the reading boring task and demonstrates the need for more research in the area.

Study 2 also introduced two new creative potential tasks to investigate whether the type of creative task makes a difference. In Task 2, the number of answers (but not their level of creativity) did differ signiﬁcantly between the reading and writing conditions such that more answers were produced in the reading condition. This supports the idea that ﬂuency (or number of ideas) does not necessarily equate to originality and creativity of those ideas because previous researchers (e.g., A. Snyder, Mitchell, Bossamaier, & Pallier, 2004) have suggested that adding more ideas within the same category, is not necessarily as creative as add ing new categories. It also lends some support to the hypothesis that boring reading tasks facilitate more daydreaming than boring written tasks—and it is this daydreaming that leads to an increase in creativity. Both conditions also produced signiﬁcantly more answers than in the control group. Like in Task 1, these answers were signiﬁcantly more creative in the two boring conditions than in the control group. The use of Task 2 then, like Task 1, clearly showed a link between boredom and creativity; Tasks 1 and 2, which were both creative uses or divergent tasks, showed similar ﬁndings in that preceding them with a boring task increased both the number of creative answers and the level of creativity of those answers.

Task 3 was a totally different type of creative task that could produce only right or wrong answers (a convergent task). Here, only the reading boring task, and not the written boring task, led to a signiﬁcant increase the number of correct responses. This again lends further support to the hypothesis that writing inhibits daydreaming (Smallwood et al., 2006) and that daydreaming is a mediator of boredom and creativity (e.g., Klinger 1987). It could be that daydreaming is more signiﬁcant a factor in the stimulation of creative thoughts with convergent creative tasks than with the [Annotation 11] divergent tasks; daydreaming might be more useful in creative problem-solving tasks in which there are ﬁnite solutions to be found, than in more imaginative creative tasks where there are inﬁnite possible outcomes.

Implications of Study

The ﬁndings have implications for the way that boredom is viewed both by society at large and by communities, such as within the work or education spheres. Until recently, boredom has been viewed as a negative emotion with only negative outcomes, but these studies add weight to the evidence that suggests that boredom

can sometimes be a force for good. This means that it might be a worthwhile enterprise to allow or even [Annotation 10] embrace boredom in work, education, and leisure. On an individual basis, if one is trying to solve a problem or come up with creat ive solutions, the ﬁndings from our studies suggest that undertaking a boring task (especially a reading task) might help with coming up with a more creative outcome.

Limitations and Implications for Future Research

Within the two studies, there was one contradictory ﬁnding; in Study 1, the level of creativity in the an swers given did not increase (when compared with the control group) following the writing boredom task, but they did when using the same task in Study 2. This suggests the need for further replication using much larger numbers of participants. It would also be useful to explore the role of daydreaming as a mediator of the proposed boredom-creativity link further by more in-depth measurement of daydreaming during boring tasks followed by regression techniques.

It should also be considered that the method of asking respondents to select their own most creative answers might be ﬂawed in that previous research has suggested that individuals are poor at doing this; asking independent raters to do this might have produced more clarity in the results (Runco & Smith, 1992). There may also have be en some confusion as how respon dents selected their two responses reﬂecting the most creative use of the cups and how these were subsequently rated by the raters. Previous studies ha ve simp ly used usefulness of the responses, so introducing the word term creative usefulness may have confused matters such that it cannot be certain that the most useful responses were being selected and rated, as oppose to the most creative responses (which might not be the same thing) . Usefulness is considered by some to be more important than creativity, as ideas that are bizarr e and impractical are not always seen as evidence of creativity when compared with ideas that have practical value (Zeng, Proctor, & Salvendy, 2011).

Future studies could also examine originality of answers, which was alluded to in our studies but not objectively measured, or other more objective measures such as those enco mpassed in A. Snyder et al.’s (2004) creativity quotient, which incorporates both ﬂuency and ﬂexibility of ideas. Zeng et al. (2011) reviewed a range of DT measures of creative potential and concluded that assessing appropriateness and novelty are key.

A further important limitation in Study 2 was in the temporal relation of the three creative tasks wi th the boredom task. The boredom task was carried out ﬁrst, then Creative Task 1, then Creative Task 2, then

DOES BEING BORED MAKE US MORE CREATIVE? 171

#### Page 8

Creative Task 3. This meant that by Creative Task 3, two creative tasks had intervened since the boring task and this might have negated the effects of the boring task. It would be useful in future studies to precede eac h place, namely a church. Although the relationship between religiosity and creativity has rarely been explored in the literature, links between them have been theoretically proposed (Zysberg & Schenck, 2013), so future research could ensure greater external validity by ensuring a wider mix of participants.

REFERENCES

Alfredsson, L., Karasek, R., & Theorell, T. (1982). Myocardial

infraction risk and psychosocial work environment: An analysis of the male Swedish workforce. Social Science Medicine, 16, 463–467. Andrade, J. (2010). What does doodling do? Applied Cognitive

Psychology, 24(1), 100–106. Begley, S., Bailey, H., Sone, D., & Interlandi, J. (2009). Will the

BlackBerry sink the presidency? Newsweek, 153(7), 36–39. Bell, G. (2011). The value of boredom. TEDxSydney Conference. Ret-

rieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ps_YUElM2EQ Branton, P. (1970). A ﬁeld study of repetitive manual work in relation

to accidents in the workplace. International Journal of Production Research, 8 , 93–107. Brisset, D., & Snow, R. P. (1993). Boredom: Where the future isn’t.

Symbolic Interaction, 16, 237–256. Caplan, R. D., Cobb, S., French, J. R. P., van Harrison, R., &

Pinneau, S. R. (1975). Job demands and worker health. Washington, DC: US Department of Health, Education and Welfare. Cox, T. (1980). Repetitive work. In C. L. Cooper & R. Payne (Eds.),

Current concerns in occupational stress (pp. 23–41). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons. Dehlinger, R. (1975). The yawning student. In F. Goetzel (Ed.),

Boredom: Root of discontent and aggression (pp. 44–54). Berkely, CA: Grizzly Peak Press. Drory, A. (1982). Individual differences in boredom proneness and

task effectiveness at work. Personnel Psychology, 35, 141–151. Farmer, R., & Sundberg, N. D. (1986). Boredom proneness: The

development and correlates of a new scale. Journal of Personality Assessment, 50 (1), 4–17. Fisher, C. D. (1993). Boredom at work: A neglected concept. Human

Relations, 46(3), 395–417. Furnham, A., Crump, J., Batey, M., & Chamorro-Premuzic, T. (2009).

Personality and ability predictors of the ‘consequences’ test of divergent thinking in a large non-student sample. Personality and Individual Differences, 46, 536–540. Gaylin, W. (1979). Feeling bored. In W. Gaylin (Ed.), Feelings: Our

vital signs (pp. 113–129). New York, NY: Harper and Row. Grabe, M. (2005). Voluntary use of online lecture notes: Correlates

of note use and note use as an alternative to class attendance. Computers and Education, 44, 409–421. Grose, V. L. (1989). Coping with boredom in the cockpit before it’s

too late. Professional Safety, 34(7), 24–26. Hamilton, J. (1983). Development of interest and enjoyment in

adolescence. Part 11. Boredom and psychopathology. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 12, 363–372. Handelsman, M. M., Briggs, W. L., Sullivan, N., & Towler, A. (2005).

A measure of college student course engagement. Journal of Educational Research, 98 (3), 184–191.

Harris, M. B. (2000). Correlates and characteristics of boredom

proneness and boredom. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 30 , 576–598. Hoover, M. (1986). Extreme individualisation, false subjectivity and

boredom. Virginia Journal of Sociology, 2, 35–51. Isen, A. M., Daubman, K. A., & Nowicki, G. P. (1987). Positive affect

facilitates creative problem solving. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52(6), 112–1131. Klapp, O. (1986). Overload and boredom. New York, NY: Greenwood

Press. Klinger, E. (1987). Imagery and logotherapeutic techniques in

psychotherapy. In W. M. Cox (Ed.), Treatment and prevention of alcohol problems: A resource manual (pp. 139–156). New York, NY: Academic Press. Larson, R. W., & Richards, M. H. (1991). Daily companionship in late

childhood and early adolescence: Changing developmental contexts. Child Development, 62, 284–300. Mann, S., & Robinson, A. (2009). Boredom in the lecture theatre: An

investigation into the contributors, moderators and outcomes of boredom amongst university students. British Educational Research Journal, 35(2), 243–258. Maroldo, G. K. (1986). Shyness, boredom, and grade point

average among college students. Psychological Reports, 59, 385–398. Martin, M., Sadlo, G., & Stew, G. (2006). The phenomenon of

boredom. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3, 193–211. Mikulas, W. L., & Vodanovich, S. J. (1993). The essence of boredom.

Psychological Record, 43(1), 3–12. O’Hanlon, J. F. (1981). Boredom: Practical consequences and a theory.

Acta Psychologica, 49, 53–82. Plucker, J. A. and Renzulli, J. S. (1999). Psychometric approaches to

the Study of Human Creativity. In R. J. Sternberg (Ed.) Handbook of Creativity, pp. 35–62. London, UK: Cambridge University Press. Runco, M. A., & Smith, W. R. (1992). Interpersonal and intrapersonal

evaluations of creative ideas. Personality and Individual Differences, 13, 295–302. Schank, R. C. (1982). Dynamic memory. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge

University Press. Schank, R. C. (1999). Dynamic memory revisited. Cambridge:

Cambridge University Press. Scott, M., & Lyman, S. (1968). Accounts. American Sociological

Review, 31, 46–62. Silvia, P. J., Winterstein, B. P., Willse, J. T., Barona, C. M., Cram,

J. T., Hess, K. I., ... Richard, C. A. (2008). Assessing creativity with divergent thinking tasks: Exploring the reliability and validity of new subject scoring methods. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity and the Arts, 2(2), 68–85. Singer, J. L. (1975). The inner world of daydreaming. New York, NY:

Harper & Row. Singer, J. L. (1981). Towards the scientiﬁc study of imagination.

Imagination, Cognition and Personality, 1(1), 5–28. Smallwood, J. (2011). Mind-wandering while reading: Attentional

decoupling, mindless reading and the cascade model of inattention. Language and Linguistics Compass, 5(2), 63–77. Smallwood, J. S., & Schooler, J. W. (2006). The restless mind.

Psychological Bulletin, 132, 946–958. Smith, R. P. (1981). Boredom: A review. Human Factors, 23(3), 329–340. Snyder, A., Mitchell, J., Bossamaier, T., & Pallier, G. (2004). The

creativity quotient; an objective scoring of ideational ﬂuency. Creativity Research Journal, 16, 415–420. Toohey, P. (2011). Boredom: A lively history. New Haven, CT: Yale

University Press. Tushup, R. J., & Zuckerman, M. (1977). The effects of stimulus

invariance on daydreaming and divergent thinking. Journal of Mental Imagery, 1(2), 291–301.

172 MANN AND CADMAN

#### Page 9

Vodanovich, S. J. (2003). Psychometric measures of boredom: A

review of the literature. Journal of Psychology, 137 , 569–595. Watt, J. D., & Vodanovich, S. J. (1999). An examination of race

and gender differences in boredom proneness. Journal of Social Behaviour and Personality, 7 , 169–175. Weisberg, R. W. (2006). Creativity: Understanding innovation in

problem solving, science, invention and the arts. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

Zeng, L., Proctor, R. W., & Salvendy, G. (2011). Can traditional

divergent thinking tests be trusted in measuring and predicting real-world creativity? Creativity Research Journal, 23(1), 24–37. Zuckerman, M. (1977). Sensation seeking: Beyond the optimal level of

arousal. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Zysberg, L., & Schenk, T. (2013). Creativity, religiosity, and political

attitudes. Creativity Research Journal, 25, 228–231.

DOES BEING BORED MAKE US MORE CREATIVE? 173

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/does-being-bored-make-us-more-creative. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
