# A Demonstration concerning the Motion of Light

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/demonstration-concerning-the-motion-of-light

- **Authors:** O. Rømer
- **Published:** 1677
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1457322311578-zly28ash5g3c8fr-e158a6c0365a3103504aaa57297a85ce%2FRomer_1677.pdf
- **Pages:** 3
- **Annotations:** 0 comments in 0 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/demonstration-concerning-the-motion-of-light

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

( 893 )

A Demonstration concerning the Motion o f Light, communicated,

from Paris, in the Journal des Scavan, and here made Englijh.

P h ilosophers have been labouring for many years to decide by some Experience, whether the actio n of Light be con veyed in an instance to distant places, or whether it requireth time. M. Romer of the R .Academy o f the Sciences hath devi sed a way, taken from the Observations o f the first Satellit o f Jupiter, by which he demonstrates , that for the d istance of a bout 3000 leagues, such as is very near the bigness o f the Dia meter of the Earth, Light needs not one second of time.

Let (in Fig. I I .) A be the Sun, B Jupiter, C the first Satellit o f Jupiter, which enters into the shadow of Jupiter, to come out o f it at D ; and let EFGHKL be the Earth placed at divers d istances from Jupiter.

Now, suppose the Earth, being in L towards the second Quadrature o f Jupiter, hath seen the first Satellit at the time of its emersion or issuing out of the shadow in D ; and that about 4 2 1/2 hours after, (vid. after one revolution of this Satel lit,) the Earth being in K, do fee it returned in D ; it is mani fest , that if the Light require time to traverse the interval LK, the Satellit will be seen returned later in D , than it would have been if the Earth had remained in L , so that the revolution of this Satellit being thus observed by the Emersions, will be re tarded by so much time, as the Light shall have taken in passing from L to K, and that, on the contrary, in the other Quadrature FG , where the Earth by approaching goes to meet the Light, the revolutions of the Immersions will appear to be shortned by so much, as those of the Emersions had appeared to be length ned, And becaufe in 42 1/2 hours, which this Satellit very near takes to make one revolution, the distance between the Earth and Jupiter in both the Quadratures varies at least 210 Diame ters of the Earth, it follows, that if for the account o f every Diameter of the Earth there were required a second o f time, the Light would take 3 1/2 minutes for each o f the intervals G F, KL; which would cause near half a quarter o f an hour be tween two revolutions of the firft Satellit, one obferved in FG, and the other in KL, whereas there is not o b s erved any sensib le difference.

Yet

#### Page 2

Yet doth it not follow hence, that Light demands no time. For, after M. R om e r bad examin’d the thing more nearly, he found, that what was not sensible in two revolutions, became very considerable in many being taken together, and that, for example, forty revolutions observed on the sid e F , might be sensibly shorter, than forty others obferved in any place o f the Zodiack where Jupiter may be met with ; and that in propor tion of twenty two for the whole interval of H E, which is the double o f the interval that is from hence to the Sun.

The necessity of this new Equation of the retardment of. Light, is established by all the observations that have been made in the R .Academy, and in the Observatory, for the space of eight years, and it hath been lately confirmed by the Emersion o f the first Satellit observed at Paris the 9th o f November last at 5 a Clock, 35' 4 5 ". at Night, 10 minutes later than it was tobe expected, by deducing it from those that had been observed in the Month of August, when the Earth was much nearer co Jupi t e r : Which M.Romer had predicte d to the said Academy from the beginning of September.

But to remove all doubt, that this inequality is caused by the retardment o f the Ligh t, be demonstra te s, that it cannot come from any excentricity, or any other cause o f those that are commonly alledged to explicate the irregularities o f the Moon and the other Planets; though he be well aware, that the first Satellit of Jupiter was excentrick, and that, besides, his revo lutions were advanced or retarded according as Jupiter did approach to or recede from the Sun, as also that the revoluti ons o f the primum mobile were unequal; yet faith he, these three last causes of inequality do not hinder the first from being mani fest .

( 894 )

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/demonstration-concerning-the-motion-of-light. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
