# Decoding the ancient Greek astronomical calculator known as the Antikythera Mechanism

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/decoding-the-ancient-greek-astronomical-calculator-known-as-the-antikythera-mechanism

- **Authors:** T. Freeth et al.
- **Published:** 2006
- **Topic:** Computer Science
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1570390074161-vsth0osp6j-85340db74b11c603eb7846d6c5f45ea3%2Fantik2.pdf
- **Pages:** 5
- **Annotations:** 11 comments in 11 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/decoding-the-ancient-greek-astronomical-calculator-known-as-the-antikythera-mechanism

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The Antikythera Mechanism is a unique Greek geared device, constructed around the end of the second century BC. It is known 1–9”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-07):

> The **Antikythera mechanism** was found among the remains of a ship wreck (from around 60 BC) off the coast of the Greek island of Antikythera, in the straits between Crete and the Peloponnese. Mentions of the dangers of those waters go back to Homer’s Odyssey, where Ulysses also struggled to navigate the passage.
>
> The ship wreck of Antikythera was only discovered in the spring of 1900 by local sponge divers. The exact character of the ship is not known, but it was likely a large merchant ship, perhaps 40 meters long. Among the wreckage, divers found amphorae, marble and bronze statues, lamps, coins, jewelry and many other things. Initially the Antikythera mechanism didn’t receive a lot of attention. Most scholars considered the device to be prochronistic (i.e. not dating from the same time as the ship wreck). It wouldn’t be until decades later, that with the help of X-ray and gamma-ray images that the Antikythera mechanism would be carefully studied.
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/c7foS4Z.png)
> *Antikythera, Greece and the Aegean sea*

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “that it calculated and displayed celestial information, particularly cycles such as the phases of the moon and a luni-solar calendar. Calendars were important to ancient societies 10 for timing agricultural activity and fixing religious festivals. Eclipses and planetary motions were often interpreted as omens, while …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-08):

> #### Luni-solar calendar
> The Greek calendar was **luni-solar**, as opposed to for instance the Islamic calendar, which was purely lunar. The Greek year began with the first sighting of the new moon after the summer solstice. A year had twelve lunar months, which total about 354 days, eleven days short of a full solar year. As a consequence, an extra month had to be inserted about every third year, leading to a leap year of 384 days.
>
> It was important for the Greeks to be able to predict the beginning of seasons in order to plan for things like when to harvest or when to set sail. At the same time, many aspects of Greek life were influenced by the phases of the moon. For instance, official public office positions often changed with specific lunar events, and debts would become payable on the new moon.

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “that it calculated and displayed celestial information, particularly cycles such as the phases of the moon and a luni-solar calendar. Calendars were important to ancient societies 10 for timing agricultural activity and fixing religious festivals. Eclipses and planetary motions were often interpreted as omens, while …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-07):

> Mechanisms with similar complexity did not reappear until the development of mechanical astronomical clocks in Europe in the 14th century.
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/fGzcHnd.jpg)
> *The Prague Astronomical Clock (installed in 1410)*

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “that it calculated and displayed celestial information, particularly cycles such as the phases of the moon and a luni-solar calendar. Calendars were important to ancient societies 10 for timing agricultural activity and fixing religious festivals. Eclipses and planetary motions were often interpreted as omens, while …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-08):

> Babylonians were avid astronomers who kept careful records of astronomical events. Over centuries, their meticulous record keeping gave them a great insight into celestial bodies. They observed for instance, that eclipses seemed to have a period of about 18 years. This is called the Saros cycle.
>
> Some of the Babylonian astronomical knowledge made its way to ancient Greece and was incorporated into the Antikythera mechanism.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/UeUZBk9.jpg)
> *Babylonian tablet recording an observation of Halley’s Comet*

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “that it calculated and displayed celestial information, particularly cycles such as the phases of the moon and a luni-solar calendar. Calendars were important to ancient societies 10 for timing agricultural activity and fixing religious festivals. Eclipses and planetary motions were often interpreted as omens, while …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-08):

> The Moon’s orbit is an ellipse with the Earth at one focus. The distance from from the Earth to the Moon varies by about 13% as the Moon travels in its orbit around us. As a consequence, when the Moon is closest to the Earth (at the perigee), it moves faster, while when it is furthest from the Earth (at the apogee), it moves slower.
>
> Greek astronomers like Hipparchus of Nicaea were aware of this variability in the Moon’s movement and accounted for it in their models.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/4aBhnVC.gif)
> *Depiction of the moon’s Orbit*

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “The bronze mechanism (Fig. 1), probably hand-driven, was originally housed in a wooden-framed case 1 of (uncertain) overall size 315 3 190 3 100 mm (Fig. 2). It had front and back doors, with astronomical inscriptions covering much of the exterior of the mechanism. Our new transcriptions and translations of the Greek …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-08):

> If you trace the movement of planets in the night sky, you will notice that sometimes a planet will start "moving” in an opposite direction only to resume the original direction of its motion a while later. This is called the "apparent retrograde motion”. The stationary points are the points at which the planet seems to stop in order to change direction.
>
> At the time of the Antikythera mechanism, astronomers were still using a geocentric model and therefore interpreted this as the actual motion of planets.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/URiB6Ri.jpg)
> *Retrograde motion of Mars*
>
> Here is a video depiction of what retrograde motion looks in the night sky:
> ![](https://thumbs.gfycat.com/RemoteInformalIrishwaterspaniel-size_restricted.gif)

### Annotation 7 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Box 1 | Astronomical cycles known to the Babylonians The lunar (or synodic) month is the interval between the Moon being at the same phase—for example, full moon to full moon. The Metonic cycle results from the close equality of 19 years to 235 lunar months. It represents the return to the same phase of the Moon on …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-08):

> ### Synodic vs Sideral lunar month
>
> - A **synodic month** (~29.5 days) is the period of lunar phases i.e. the length of time between successive full moons.
> - A **sideral month** (~27.3 days) is the time the Moon takes to complete one full revolution around the Earth with respect to the background stars.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/H2ynoHX.jpg)
> *Synodic vs Sideral lunar month*

### Annotation 8 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “Turning to the dials themselves, the front dial displays the position of the Sun and Moon in the zodiac, and a corresponding calendar 1 of 365 days that could be adjusted for leap years. Previously 1 , it was suggested that the upper back dial might have five concentric rings with 47 divisions per turn, showing the …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-08):

> In front face of the Antikythera Mechanism there were two rings. One was a zodiac dial split into the 12 sections representing the 12 zodiacs. The other ring was a moveable 12 month calendar ring with 365 days. Every 4 years the user would have to move the calendar ring by one day and fix it into place using a pin.
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/rs6aogG.png)

### Annotation 9 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “The functions of the mechanism are determined by the tooth counts of the gears. These are based mainly on the CT, using angular measurement from a nominal centre to the remains of tooth tips. In a few cases all teeth can be seen, but many gears are incomplete. Counts are established by fitting models with regularly …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-08):

> The gears in the Antikythera mechanism are the earliest preserved gears in Europe. The oldest examples of gears date from the 4th century BC in China.

### Annotation 10 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Figure 4 | Reconstruction of the back dials. A composite of fragments A, B, E and F. The Metonic calendar is at top, with its subsidiary Callippic dial. The Saros eclipse cycle is below, with its subsidiary Exeligmos dial. The 16 observed eclipse glyphs are shown in turquoise on the Saros dial, with 35 hypothetical …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-08):

> ### Olympic games indicator
>
> After this paper was published [researchers discovered](https://www.nature.com/articles/nature07130) that the bottom dial on the back of the Antikythera mechanism indicated the occurrence of several panhellenic athletic games, including the Ancient Olympic Games, which happened every 4 years. It has been suggested that this indicator for the olympic games could function both as a quick sanity check to make sure you set the instrument correctly both also as a counter of 4 years so that you can keep track of leap years and adjust the front face calendar ring accordingly.
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/pYxaQCw.png)
> *Back dials of Antikythera mechanism*

### Annotation 11 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “Figure 6 | The ‘Hipparchos’ lunar mechanism mounted on gear e3. The figure is based on a CT slice of part of fragment A, showing (top) shaft e and (bottom) shaft k. The complete geometry cannot be seen in a single CT slice. The two gears on the e axis (e5 and e6) are coaxial, while the two k gears rotate on slightly …”

**Annotation** by João Batalha (2019-10-08):

> You can watch a detailed explanation of what it would take to build this section of the mechanism [here](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v19cu2hj2Ms)

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

LETTERS

Decoding the ancient Greek astronomical calculator

known as the Antikythera Mechanism

T. Freeth 1,2

, Y. Bitsakis 3,5

, X. Moussas 3 , J. H. Seiradakis 4 , A. Tselikas 5 , H. Mangou 6 , M. Zafeiropoulou 6 , R. Hadland 7 ,

D. Bate 7 , A. Ramsey 7 , M. Allen 7 , A. Crawley 7 , P. Hockley 7 , T. Malzbender 8 , D. Gelb 8 , W. Ambrisco 9

& M. G. Edmunds 1

The Antikythera Mechanism is a unique Greek geared device, constructed around the end of the second century [Annotation 1] BC. It is known 1–9

that it calculated and displayed celestial information, particularly cycles such as the phases of the moon and a luni-solar calendar. [Annotation 2] Calendars were important to ancient societies 10 for timing agricultural activity and fixing religious festivals. Eclipses and planetary motions were often interpreted as omens, while the calm regularity of the astronomical cycles must have been philosophically attractive in an uncertain and violent world. Named after its place of discovery in 1901 in a Roman shipwreck, the Antikythera Mechanism is technically more complex than any known device for at least a millennium afterwards. Its specific functions have [Annotation 3] remained controversial 11–14 because its gears and the inscriptions upon its faces are only fragmentary. Here we report surface imaging and high-resolution X-ray tomography of the surviving fragments, enabling us to reconstruct the gear function and double the number of deciphered inscriptions. The mechanism predicted lunar and solar eclipses on the basis of Babylonian arithmetic- [Annotation 4] progression cycles. The inscriptions support suggestions of mechanical display of planetary positions 9,14,15 , now lost. In the second century BC, Hipparchos developed a theory to explain the irregularities of the Moon’s motion across the sky caused by its elliptic [Annotation 5] orbit. We find a mechanical realization of this theory in the gearing of the mechanism, revealing an unexpected degree of technical sophistication for the period.

The bronze mechanism (Fig. 1), probably hand-driven, was originally housed in a wooden-framed case 1 of (uncertain) overall size 315 3 190 3 100 mm (Fig. 2). It had front and back doors, with astronomical inscriptions covering much of the exterior of the mechanism. Our new transcriptions and translations of the Greek texts are given in Supplementary Note 2 (‘glyphs and inscriptions’). The detailed form of the lettering can be dated to the second half of the second century BC, implying that the mechanism was constructed during the period 150–100 BC, slightly earlier than previously suggested 1 . This is consistent with a date of around 80–60 BC for the wreck 1,16 from which the mechanism was recovered by some of the first underwater archaeology. We are able to complete the reconstruction 1 of the back door inscription with text from fragment E, and characters from fragments A and F (see Fig. 1 legend for fragment nomenclature). The front door is mainly from fragment G. The text is astronomical, with many numbers that could be related to planetary motions; the word ‘‘sterigmos’’ (STGRICMOS, translated as ‘sta- [Annotation 6] tion’ or ‘stationary point’) is found, meaning where a planet’s apparent motion changes direction, and the numbers may relate to

planetary cycles. We note that a major aim of this investigation is to set up a data archive to allow non-invasive future research, and access to this will start in 2007. Details will be available on www.antikythera-mechanism.gr.

The back door inscription mixes mechanical terms about construction (‘‘trunnions’’, ‘‘gnomon’’, ‘‘perforations’’) with astronomical periods. Of the periods, 223 is the Saros eclipse cycle (see Box 1 for a brief explanation of astronomical cycles and periods). We discover the inscription ‘‘spiral divided into 235 sections’’, which is

1 Cardiff University, School of Physics and Astronomy, Queens Buildings, The Parade, Cardiff CF24 3AA, UK. 2 Images First Ltd, 10 Hereford Road, South Ealing, London W5 4SE, UK. 3 National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Department of Astrophysics, Astronomy and Mechanics, Panepistimiopolis, GR-15783, Zographos, G reece. 4 Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Department of Physics, Section of Astrophysics, Astronomy and Mechanics, GR-54124 Thessaloniki, Greece. 5 Centre for History and Palaeography, National Bank of Greece Cultural Foundation, P. Skouze 3, GR-10560 Athens, Greece. 6 National Archaeological Museum of Athens, 1 Tositsa Str., GR-10682 Athens, Greece. 7 X-Tek Systems Ltd, Tring Business Centre, Icknield Way, Tring, Hertfordshire HP23 4JX, UK. 8 Hewlett-Packard Laboratories, 1501 Page Mill Road, Palo Alto, California 94304, USA. 9 Foxhollow Technologies Inc., 740 Bay Road, Redwood City, California 94063, USA.

Figure 1 | The surviving fragments of the Antikythera Mechanism. The 82 fragments that survive in the National Archaeological Museum in Athens are shown to scale. A key and dimensions are provided in Supplementary Note 1 (‘fragments’). The major fragments A, B, C, D are across the top, starting at top left, with E, F, G immediately below them. 27 hand-cut bronze gears are in fragment A and one gear in each of fragments B, C and D. Segments of display scales are in fragments B, C, E and F. A schematic reconstruction is given in Fig. 2. It is not certain that every one of the remaining fragments (numbered 1–75) belong to the mechanism. The distinctive fragment A, which contains most of the gears, is approximately 180 3 150 mm in size. We have used three principal techniques to investigate the structure and inscriptions of the Antikythera Mechanism. (1) Three-dimensional X-ray microfocus computed tomography 24 (CT), developed by X-Tek Systems Ltd. The use of CT has been crucial in making the text legible just beneath the current surfaces. (2) Digital optical imaging to reveal faint surface detail using polynomial texture mapping (PTM) 25,26 , developed by Hewlett- Packard Inc. (3) Digitized high-quality conventional film photography.

Vol 444 | 30 November 2006 | doi:10.1038/nature05357

587 Natu re Pu blishin g Gro u p ©2 0 0 6

#### Page 2

the key to understanding the function 6 of the upper back dial. The references to ‘‘golden little sphere’’ and ‘‘little sphere’’ probably refer to the front zodiac display for the Sun and Moon—including phase for the latter.

The text near the lower back dial includes ‘‘Pharos’’ and ‘‘from south (about/around)….Spain (ISPANIA) ten’’. These geographical references, together with previous readings 1 of ‘‘towards the east’’, ‘‘west-north-west’’ and ‘‘west-south-west’’ suggest an eclipse function for the dial, as solar eclipses occur only at limited geographical sites, and winds were often recorded 17–19 in antiquity with eclipse observations. Possibly this information was added to the mechanism during use.

Turning to the dials themselves, the front dial displays the position of the Sun and Moon in the zodiac, and a corresponding calendar 1 of 365 days that could be adjusted for leap years. Previously [Annotation 8] 1 , it was suggested that the upper back dial might have five concentric rings with 47 divisions per turn, showing the 235 months of the 19-year Metonic cycle. A later proposal 5 augments this with the upper subsidiary dial showing the 76-year Callippic cycle. Our optical and X-ray microfocus computed tomography (CT) imaging confirms these proposals, with 34 scale markings discovered on the upper back dial. On the basis of a statistical analysis analogous to that described for gear tooth counts below, we confirm the 235 total divisions. We also find from the CT that the subsidiary dial is indeed divided into quadrants 1,6 , as required for a Callippic dial. In agreement with the back door inscription, we also substantiate the perceptive proposal 5,20

that the dial is in fact a spiral, made from semicircular arcs displaced

Figure 2 | A schematic view of the mechanism to illustrate the position of major inscriptions and dials. The front dial has two concentric scales. The inner scale shows the Greek zodiac with 360 divisions. There are occasional Greek letters denoting references to the Parapegma inscription, and we add three further reference letters (Z, H, H) to Price’s description 1 . The Parapegma is a star almanac showing rising and settings at dawn or evening of particular stars or constellations, which we will discuss elsewhere. Its form is consistent with a date of late second century BC. The outer (originally) movable scale is a calendar carrying the Egyptian names of the months with Greek letters. The Egyptian calendar of 365 days, with twelve 30-day months and 5 extra (epagomenai) days was in standard use in Greek astronomy. The effect of the extra quarter day in a year could be corrected by turning the

scale one day every four years—and a sequence of holes to take a locking pin is observed under the scale. We find that spacing of the holes is indeed what would be expected for a total of 365 days, with a possible range 363–365. The position of the Sun and Moon would have been indicated by pointers across the dial scales, and a device 7 showing the phase of the Moon was probably carried round on the lunar pointer. It is not clear whether the Sun position pointer would have been separated from a date pointer, or whether any planetary positions might have been displayed. The spiral upper back dial displays the luni-solar Metonic sequence of 235 lunar months with a subsidiary dial showing the Callippic cycle, while the spiral lower back dial displays the 223-lunar-month Saros eclipse cycle with a subsidiary dial showing the Exeligmos cycle.

Box 1 | Astronomical cycles known to the Babylonians The lunar (or synodic) month is the interval between the Moon being at the same phase—for example, full moon to full moon. The Metonic [Annotation 7] cycle results from the close equality of 19 years to 235 lunar months. It represents the return to the same phase of the Moon on the same date in the year. After the cycle, the Sun, Moon and Earth are back in nearly the same relative orientations. The Moon appears to return to the same point in the sky relative to the zodiac in a sidereal month, and in 19 years there are 235 1 19 5 254 sidereal months. The 76-year Callippic cycle is four Metonic cycles minus one day—and improves the accuracy of reconciling solar years with whole numbers of lunar months.

The Saros is an eclipse repeat cycle. If either a solar or lunar eclipse occurs, a very similar eclipse will occur 223 lunar months later 23 .A record of past eclipses can thus be used to predict future occurrences. The cycle arises from the coincidence of three orbital periods of the Moon. These are: (1) same phase to same phase, 223 synodic months—eclipses will of course only occur at new or full Moon in the month; (2) the lunar crossing of the Earth – Sun orbital plane, 242 draconitic months—eclipses can only occur near these points (nodes) of co-alignment; (3) similar Earth – Moon distances which occur on the period from apogee to apogee of the Moon’s orbit, 239 anomalistic months. The distance will determine the magnitude of the eclipse, ensuring the similarity of eclipses at the period of the cycle. The Saros cycle is not an integer number of days (6,585M), causing the eclipses in successive cycles to be displaced by eight hours in time (and solar eclipses, only visible at limited geographical locations, to be displaced by 120u in longitude). True repeats come after 3 Saros cycles, the 54-year Exeligmos cycle, but not with identical solar eclipse paths.

LETTERS NATURE | Vol 444 | 30 November 2006

588

Natu re Pu blishin g Gro u p ©2 0 0 6

#### Page 3

to two centres on the vertical midline. In the CT of fragment B we find a new feature that explains why the dial is a spiral: a ‘pointer-follower’ device (Fig. 3) travelled around the spiral groove to indicate which month (across the five turns of the scale) should be read.

From our CT data of the 48 scale divisions observed in fragments A, E and F, we establish 223 divisions in the four-turn 5,20 spiral on the lower back dial, the spiral starting at the bottom of the dial. This is the Saros eclipse cycle, whose number is on the back door inscription. The 54-year Exeligmos cycle of three Saros cycles is shown on the lower subsidiary dial.

Between the scale divisions of the Saros dial we have identified 16 blocks of characters, or ‘glyphs’ (see Supplementary Note 2 (‘glyphs and inscriptions’)) at intervals of one, five and six months. These are eclipse predictions and contain either S for a lunar eclipse (from SELGNG, Moon) or G for a solar eclipse (from GLIOS, Sun) or both. A correlation analysis (analogous to DNA sequence matching) with historic eclipse data 21 (all modern eclipse data and predictions in our work are from this reference) indicates that over a period of 400– 1 BC, the sequence of eclipses marked by the identified glyphs would be exactly matched by 121 possible start dates. The matching only occurs if the lunar month starts at first crescent, and confirms this choice of month start in the mechanism. The sequences of eclipses can then be used to predict the expected position of glyphs on the whole dial, as seen in Fig. 4. The dial starts and finishes with an eclipse. Although Ptolemy indicates that the Greeks recorded eclipses in the second century BC, the Babylonian Saros canon 17–19 is the only known source of sufficient data to construct the dial.

The functions of the mechanism are determined by the tooth counts of the gears. These are based mainly on the CT, using angular [Annotation 9] measurement from a nominal centre to the remains of tooth tips. In a few cases all teeth can be seen, but many gears are incomplete. Counts are established by fitting models with regularly spaced teeth and minimising the r.m.s. deviation from the measurements—varying the centre in software (when unclear) to find the best-fit solution

or solutions (see Supplementary Note 3 (‘gears’)). We have adopted a systematic nomenclature of lower case letters for the axis of the gear, with numbering increasing with ordering from the front of the mechanism. Hypothetical (lost) gears are denoted by italics.

Several models have been proposed for the gear trains 1,2,4–6,8 . We agree with the assumption of four missing gears (n1, n2, p1, p2) to drive the Metonic and Callippic dials 4 . We propose a new reconstruction for the other trains, which uses all extant gears (except the lone r1

0 1 2 3 4 5 cm

Figure 4 [Annotation 10] | Reconstruction of the back dials. A composite of fragments A, B, E and F. The Metonic calendar is at top, with its subsidiary Callippic dial. The Saros eclipse cycle is below, with its subsidiary Exeligmos dial. The 16 observed eclipse glyphs are shown in turquoise on the Saros dial, with 35 hypothetical glyphs in violet. The hypothetical glyphs are based on the criterion that 99% of the 121 sequences exactly matching the observed glyphs have an eclipse at the month position. Both main dials would have a ‘pointer-follower’ (see Fig. 3) to indicate the relevant lunar month on the spiral. The monthly divisions on the Metonic upper back dial are not simply scribed directly across all five turns, as might be expected for simplicity of construction. There are small misalignments, implying a systematic attempt at marking full (30-day) and hollow (29-day) months. The incomplete data do not allow good analysis, other than a hint of bimodality in the interval distribution. If the marking out of the scale were carried out using the mechanism’s gearing, then this would greatly pre-date known ‘dividing engines’ 27 by many centuries.

Figure 3 | The ‘pointer-follower’ lunar month indicator of the upper back dial. On the left, false-colour sections through CT images, analysed with VGStudio Max software by Volume Graphics GmbH. These show two views at right angles of the pointer-follower in the Metonic dial in fragment B. On the right, a computer reconstruction of the device from two different angles (with the Metonic scale omitted for clarity). The pin was constrained to follow the groove between the spiral scales (the scale is shown in Fig. 4), causing the device to slide along the month pointer to indicate which ring on the spiral scale specified the month. A similar pointer-follower would have been present on the lower back (Saros) dial. The Metonic dial would have required resetting every 19 years, the Saros dial after 18 years. The groove-pin may have been held in place by the small pin through the front of the device, enabling its removal for re-setting.

NATURE | Vol 444 | 30 November 2006 LETTERS

589 Natu re Pu blishin g Gro u p ©2 0 0 6

#### Page 4

from the separate fragment D). The proposed model is shown in Fig. 5. We require the assumption of only one further gear (m3), whose proposed shaft is clearly broken off in the CT. A detailed description is contained in Supplementary Note 3 (‘gears’).

Of particular note is the dual use of the large gear, e3, at the back of the mechanism, which has found no use in previous models. In our model, it is powered by m3 as part of a fixed-axis train that turns the Saros and Exeligmos dials for eclipse prediction, and also doubles as the ‘epicyclic table’ for the gears k1, k2. These are part of epicyclic

gearing that calculates the theory of the irregular motion of the moon, developed by Hipparchos some time between 146 and 128 BC (ref. 22)—the ‘first anomaly’, caused by its elliptical orbit about the Earth. The period of this anomaly is the period from apogee to apogee (the anomalistic month). To realize this theory, the mean sidereal lunar motion is first calculated by gears on axes c, d and e and this is then fed into the epicyclic system. As explained in Fig. 6, a pinand-slot device on the epicyclic gears k1 and k2, clearly seen in the CT, provides the variation. This was previously identified 4 , but rejected as a lunar mechanism. The remarkable purpose of mounting the pin-and-slot mechanism on the gear e3 is to change the period of variation from sidereal month (that is, the time taken for the Moon to orbit the Earth relative to the zodiac), which would occur if k1 and k2 were on fixed axes, to anomalistic month—by carrying the gears epicyclically at a rate that is the difference between the rates of the

Front dials

Lunar phase

Lost epicyclic gearing

Pin and slot Hipparchos’ lunar mechanism

Possibly Hipparchos’ solar mechanism and planetary mechanisms

Hipparchos sidereal month Year

Back dials

Luni-solar calendar

Input

Eclipse prediction

Saros × 4Metonic × 5Callippic Exeligmos

Zodiac • Egyptian calendar • Parapegma

Figure 5 | New reconstruction of the gear trains. A schematic sectional diagram (not to scale) of the gearing, following the style of Price 1 and Wright 4 . The viewpoint is looking down from the top right of the mechanism, and is stretched in the direction of the main axes to show the structure. Features that are outlined or labelled in red are hypothetical. Gears are lettered with their shaft, and numbered with increasing distance from the front dial. The two-or-three digit number on the gear is its actual or assumed tooth count (see Supplementary Note 3 (‘gears’)). Hypothetical gears n1, n2, p1, p2 have been proposed previously, the gear m3 on the

broken-off shaft m is our addition. All gears, except the lone one in fragment D, are now accounted for in the mechanism. The function of the trains is outlined in the text. We find no evidence in the CT for an idler wheel carried on e3 and between e5 and k1 or between k2 and e6, as has been previously proposed 1,2,4 . The CT shows a pin through axis e between gears e1 and e2. We believe its purpose is to retain the square-bossed e1 on the shaft, but its passage right through the axis rules out previous reconstructions 1,2,4 where e1 and e2 were joined by an outer pipe rotating around the shaft e.

Figure 6 | The ‘Hipparchos’ lunar mechanism mounted on gear e3. The figure is based on a CT slice of part of fragment A, showing (top) shaft e and [Annotation 11] (bottom) shaft k. The complete geometry cannot be seen in a single CT slice. The two gears on the e axis (e5 and e6) are coaxial, while the two k gears rotate on slightly displaced axes. k1 has a pin on its face that engages with a radial slot in k2 (and this was previously reported 5 ). In the figure the pitch circles of e5 and k1 are shown in turquoise and those of e6 and k2 in pink. The gear e5 drives k1, which drives k2 via the pin-and-slot, introducing a quasi-sinusoidal variation in the motion, which is then transmitted to e6. Our estimate of the distance between the arbors on the k gears is about 1.1 mm, with a pin distance of 9.6 mm, giving an angular variation of 6.5u. According to Ptolemy 28 , Hipparchos made two estimates for a lunar anomaly parameter, based on eclipse data, which would require angular variations of 5.9u or 4.5u here—although estimates of the anomaly from Babylonian astronomy were generally larger. The difference from our estimated value is probably not significant given the difficulty of precise measurement of the axes in the CT. The harmonic variation, together with the effect of carrying the gears on e3 (which rotates at the period of the Moon’s apogee around the Earth), would simulate the correct variation for the Moon’s mean (sidereal) rotation rate on the front dial. An (unexplained) regular pentagon is visible at the centre of gear e5. It is tempting to associate the conception of the mechanism with Hipparchos himself, but he was not the first to assume eccentric or epicyclic models.

LETTERS NATURE | Vol 444 | 30 November 2006

590

Natu re Pu blishin g Gro u p ©2 0 0 6

#### Page 5

sidereal and anomalistic months, that is, at the rate of rotation of about 9 years of the Moon’s apogee.

Gears with 53 teeth are awkward to divide. So it may seem surprising that the gearing includes two such gears (f1, l2), whose effects cancel in the train leading to the Saros dial. But the gearing has been specifically designed so that the ‘epicyclic table’ e3 turns at the rate of rotation of the Moon’s apogee—the factor 53 being derived from the calculation of this rotation from the Metonic and Saros cycles, which are the bases for all the prime factors in the tooth counts of the gears. The establishment of the 53-tooth count of these gears is powerful confirmation of our proposed model of Hipparchos’ lunar theory. The output of this complex system is carried from e6 back through e3 and thence, via e1 and b3, to the zodiac scale on the front dial and the lunar phase 7 mechanism. Our CT confirms the complex structure of axis e that this model entails.

The Antikythera Mechanism shows great economy and ingenuity of design. It stands as a witness to the extraordinary technological potential of Ancient Greece, apparently lost within the Roman Empire.

Received 10 August; accepted 17 October 2006.

1. Price, D. de S. Gears from the Greeks: The Antikythera Mechanism — A calendar

computer from ca. 80 BC. Trans Am. Phil. Soc. New Ser. 64, 1 – 70 (1974); reprinted by Science History Publications, New York (1975). 2. Wright, M. T. Epicyclic gearing and the Antikythera Mechanism, Part I. Antiquar.

Horol. 27, 270 – 279 (2003). 3. Wright, M. T., Bromley, A. G. & Magou, H. Simple X-ray tomography and the

Antikythera Mechanism. PACT J. Eur. Study Group Phys. Chem. Biol. Math. Tech. Appl. Archaeol. 45, 531 – 543 (1995). 4. Wright, M. T. The Antikythera Mechanism: a New Gearing Scheme. Bull. Sci.

Instrum. Soc. 85, 2 – 7 (2005). 5. Wright, M. T. Epicyclic gearing and the Antikythera Mechanism, Part II. Antiquar.

Horol. 29, 51 – 63 (2005). 6. Wright, M. T. Counting months and years: The upper back dial of the Antikythera

Mechanism. Bull. Sci. Instrum. Soc. 87, 8 – 13 (2005). 7. Wright, M. T. The Antikythera Mechanism and the early history of the moon-

phase display. Antiquar. Horol. 29, 319 – 329 (2006). 8. Wright, M. T. in Proc. 2nd Int. Conf. on Ancient Greek Technology (ed. Tassios, Th.)

49 – 60 (Technical Chamber of Greece, Athens, 2006). 9. Wright, M. T. A planetarium display for the Antikythera Mechanism. Horol. J.

144(5), 169 – 173 (2002); erratum 144, 193 (2002). 10. North, J. D. The Fontana History of Astronomy and Cosmology (Fontana, London,

1994). 11. Bromley, A. G. The Antikythera Mechanism. Horol. J. 132, 412 – 415 (1990). 12. Bromley, A. G. in Bassernet Vol. 2, No. 3 (Basser Department of Computer Science,

Univ. Sydney, June, 1993). 13. Freeth, T. The Antikythera Mechanism: 1. Challenging the classic research.

Mediterr. Archaeol. Archaeom. 2, 21 – 35 (2002). 14. Edmunds, M. & Morgan, P. The Antikythera Mechanism: still a mystery of Greek

astronomy? Astron. Geophys. 41, 6.10 – 6.17 (2000).

15. Freeth, T. The Antikythera Mechanism: 2. Is it Posidonius’ orrery? Mediterr.

Archaeol. Archaeom. 2, 45 – 58 (2002). 16. Illsley, J. S. History and Archaeology of the Ship—Lecture Notes. Æhttp://

cma.soton.ac.uk/HistShip/shlect36.htmæ (1998). 17. Stephenson, F. R. Historical Eclipses and Earth’s Rotation (Cambridge Univ. Press,

Cambridge, UK, 1997). 18. Steele, J. M. Observations and Predictions of Eclipse Times by Early Astronomers

(Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 2000). 19. Steele, J. M. Eclipse prediction in Mesopotamia. Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 54, 421 – 454 (2000). 20. Wright, M. T. The Scholar, the Mechanic and the Antikythera Mechanism. Bull.

Sci. Instrum . Soc. 80, 4 – 11 (2003). 21. Espenak, F. NASA Eclipse Home Page. Æhttp://sunearth.gsfc.nasa.gov/eclipse/

eclipse.htmlæ (2005). 22. Jones, A. The adaptation of Babylonian methods in Greek numerical astronomy.

Isis 82, 440 – 453 (1991). 23. Britton, J. P. in Die Rolle der Astronomie in den Kulturen Mesopotamiens (ed. Galter,

H. D.) 61 – 76 (rm-Druck & Vergansgesellschaft, Graz, 1993). 24. X-Tek Systems Ltd. 3-D computed tomography. Æhttp://www.xtek.co.uk/ct/æ

(2006). 25. Malzbender, T. & Gelb, D. Polynomial texture mapping. Æhttp://

www.hpl.hp.com/research/ptm/æ (2006). 26. Brooks, M. Tricks of the light. New Sci. 170, 38 – 49 (2001). 27. Chapman, A. Dividing the Circle (Wiley, Chichester, 1995). 28. Toomer, G. J. Ptolemy’s Almagest (transl. Toomer, G. J.) (Princeton Univ. Press,

Princeton, New Jersey, 1998).

Supplementary Information is linked to the online version of the paper at www.nature.com/nature.

Acknowledgements This work was financed by the Leverhulme Trust, the Walter Hudson Bequest, the University of Athens Research Committee and the Cultural Foundation of the National Bank of Greece. For essential support we thank the Ministry of Culture, Greece (P. Tatoulis), and the National Archaeological Museum of Athens (N. Kalts as). We acknowledge help and advice from J. Ambers, J. Austin, G. Dermody, H. Forsyth, I. Freestone, P. Haycock, V. Horie, A. Jones, M. Jones, P. Kipouros, H. Kritzas, J. Lossl, G. Makris, A. Ray, C. Reinhart, A. Valassopoulos, R. Westgate, T. Whiteside, S. Wright and C. Xenikakis.

Author Contributions T.F. carried out most of the CT analysis of structure and its interpretation. Y.B., A.T. and X.M. read, transcribed and translated the inscriptions. H.M and M.Z. catalogued the fragments, provided guidance on X-ray examination, and measured the fragments with J.H.S. R.H. led the team (D.B., A.R., M.A., A.C. and P.H.) that built and operated the Bladerunner CT machine, and provided CT reconstructions and advice. T.M., D.G. and W.A. built, operated and provided software for the PTM. M.G.E. was academic lead, and undertook the statistical analysis. T.F. and Y.B. organised the logistics of the experimental work, with inter-agency liaison by X.M. and J.H.S. The manuscript was written by T.F. and M.G.E. including material from Y.B., A.T., X.M., J.H.S., H.M. and M.Z. T.F. designed the illustrations.

Author Information Reprints and permissions information is available at www.nature.com/reprints. The authors declare no competing financial interests. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to M.G.E. (mge@astro.cf.ac.uk).

NATURE | Vol 444 | 30 November 2006 LETTERS

591 Natu re Pu blishin g Gro u p ©2 0 0 6

View publication statsView publication stats

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/decoding-the-ancient-greek-astronomical-calculator-known-as-the-antikythera-mechanism. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
