# Capillary flow as the cause of ring stains from dried liquid drops

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/capillary-flow-as-the-cause-of-ring-stains-from-dried-liquid-drops

- **Authors:** Robert D. Deegan et al
- **Published:** 1997
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1649638079648-2w3c605lr59-19ab35aace3d0fa529c376f5288452c4%2FNagel.7.4.pdf
- **Pages:** 4
- **Annotations:** 5 comments in 5 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/capillary-flow-as-the-cause-of-ring-stains-from-dried-liquid-drops

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “James Franck Institute, 5640 South Ellis Ave, Chicago, IL 60637, USA”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2022-04-11):

> ### TL;DR
> Robert Deegan is a professor of physics at the University of Michigan. In 1997, Deegan and his colleagues developed a theory to explain why a drying drop of coffee typically leaves behind a ring-shaped stain.
>
> The ring is a consequence of the radially outward fluid flow induced by the so-called contact line pinning: the outer edge of a spilled coffee droplet grabs onto the solid surface and becomes pinned in place. The evaporating drop thus retains its pinned diameter and flattens while it dries.
>
> "That flattening, in turn, is accompanied by fluid flowing from the middle of the drop toward its edge to replenish evaporating water. Suspended particles—the coffee grounds—are carried to the edge of the drop by that flow. Once there, they pile up, one at a time, into a tightly jammed packing and produce the coffee ring. Deegan and company studied the ring growth empirically by following the individual frames in a video of plastic colloidal spheres suspended in an evaporating droplet"
>
> ![](https://lsa.umich.edu/content/michigan-lsa/physics/en/people/faculty/rddeegan/jcr:content/profileImage.transform/profile_portrait/image.jpg)

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “FIG. 1. a) A 2-cm-diameter drop of coﬀee containing one-weight-percent solids has dried to form a perimeter ring, accentuated in regions of high curvature. b) Video micrographs showing dispersion of ﬂuorescent one-micron polystyrene spheres in water during evaporation, as described in the text. Multiple exposure shows …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2022-04-11):

> Here's a video by Robert Reegan on the effect
>
> ![](https://i.imgur.com/W5KkRXy.gif)

### Annotation 3 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “10000”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2022-04-11):

> Ring deposition is a useful technology which can be used in printing, washing and coating processes. It might also be possible to stretch DNA using the strong shear flow that develops in ring forming drops when the evaporation rate is enhanced at the edge.

### Annotation 4 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “To test these predictions we used drops of distilled water which contained charge-stabilized surfactant-free polystyrene microspheres [Interfacial Dynamics, Portland, Oregon] at a starting volume fraction of 10 −4 . The spheres were so dilute that they could be regarded as an ideal solution except in the very narrow …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2022-04-11):

> In 2011, researchers from the University of Pennsylvania showed that the coffee-drop effect can be negated if the particles are not spherical - the more elongated the particles, the more uniform the deposition. The shape of the particles is actually a way to control the distribution of material on a surface.
>
>
> [Here's a video showing how deposition patterns depend on the shape of the particles.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZaCGoSTMHyc)

### Annotation 5 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Suspension Droplets during Drying” J. Phys II, 6 1111- 1119 (1996). [2] El Bediwi, A. B., Kulnis, W. J., Luo, Y., Woodland, D.,”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2022-04-11):

> This paper ended up being cited more than 5000 times to this day. It's a fantastic example of an everyday effect with a simple explanation that remained a mystery until 1997.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

Capillary ﬂow as the cause of ring stains from dried liquid drops

Robert D. Deegan, Olgica Bakajin, Todd F. Dupont, Greg Huber, Sidney R. Nagel, Thomas A. Witten

James Franck Institute, 5640 South Ellis Ave, Chicago, IL 60637, USA [Annotation 1]

typeset July 15, 1997

When a spilled drop of coﬀee dries on a solid surface, it leaves a dense, ring-like stain along the perimeter (Figure 1a). The coﬀee—initially dispersed over the entire drop—becomes concentrated into a tiny fraction of it. Such ring deposits are commonplace wherever drops containing dispersed solids evaporate on a surface. Thus ring deposits inﬂuence printing, washing and coating processes [1–5]. They provide a potential means to write or deposit a ﬁne pattern onto a surface. Here we ascribe the deposition to a previously unexplored form of capillary ﬂow: the contact line of the drying drop is pinned so that liquid evaporating from the edge must be replenished by liquid from the interior (Figure 2). The resulting outward ﬂow can carry virtually all the dispersed material to the edge. This mechanism predicts a distinctive power-law growth of the ring mass with time—a law independent of the particular substrate, carrier ﬂuid or deposited solids. We have veriﬁed this law by microscopic observations of colloidal ﬂuids.

FIG. 1. a) A 2-cm-diameter drop of coﬀee containing [Annotation 2] one-weight-percent solids has dried to form a perimeter ring, accentuated in regions of high curvature. b) Video micrographs showing dispersion of ﬂuorescent one-micron polystyrene spheres in water during evaporation, as described in the text. Multiple exposure shows diﬀerent times in diﬀerent colors to indicate the motion. Earliest time (blue) is 3 sec before latest time (red).

Our qualitative observations show that rings form for a wide variety of substrates, dispersed materials (solutes), and carrier liquids (solvents), as long as (1) the solvent meets the surface at a nonzero contact angle, (2) the contact line is pinned to its initial position, and (3) the solvent evaporates. In addition, we found that mechanisms typically responsible for solute transport—surface tension gradients, solute diﬀusion, electrostatic, and gravity eﬀects—are negligible in ring formation. Based on these

ﬁndings, we have identiﬁed the minimal ingredients for a quantitative theory. The phenomenon is due to a geometrical constraint: the free surface, constrained by a pinned contact line, squeezes the ﬂuid outward to compensate for evaporative losses. We ﬁrst describe the main features and results of our theory and then show our experimental tests of its validity.

a

J

r

h v

_

c

b

R

FIG. 2. Mechanism of outward ﬂow during evaporation. Pictures a and b show an increment of evaporation viewed in cross section. Picture a shows the result of evaporation without ﬂow: the droplet shrinks. Picture b shows the compensating ﬂow needed to keep the contact line ﬁxed. Picture c deﬁnes quantities responsible for ﬂow. Vapor leaves at a rate per unit area J(r). The removed liquid contracts the height h(r) vertically, vacating the vertically striped region in a short time ∆t. The volume of this striped region is equal to the volume removed by J. But in the shaded annular region the redstriped volume is smaller than the volume removed by J there (red arrows). Thus liquid ﬂows outward to supply the deﬁcit volume: ﬂuid at r sweeps out the blue-striped region in time ∆t. Its volume is the deﬁcit volume; its depth-averged speed is ¯v(r).

Figure 2 sketches the factors leading to outward ﬂow in a small, thin, dilute, circular drop of ﬁxed radius R slowly drying on a solid surface. The evaporative ﬂux J(r) reduces the height h(r) at every point r. If there were no ﬂow, the evaporation would alter the height pro-

1

#### Page 2

ﬁle as sketched in Figure 2a. At the perimeter, all the liquid would be removed and the drop would shrink. But the radius of the drop cannot shrink, since its contact line is pinned. To prevent the shrinkage, liquid must ﬂow outward as in Figure 2b. The complete ﬂow proﬁle ¯v(r) can be found as sketched in Figure 2c. The height proﬁle must maintain the spherical cap shape dictated by surface tension. Thus during a short time ∆t the vertically striped region must be removed from each point r of the surface. This is diﬀerent from the amount removed from that point owing to evaporation, shown in color in Figure 2a. Radial ﬂow must make up for this diﬀerence. If the evaporative ﬂux J(r) is known, the ﬂow velocity ¯v(r)is thereby determined.

The evaporative ﬂux has a universal form that depends only on the shape of the drop ( for example see: [6,?]). In the evaporation process liquid molecules interchange rapidly between the surface and the adjacent air, so that this air is saturated with vapor. Since the air at inﬁnity is not saturated, the vapor diﬀuses outward. At the surface of the drop (which is the only region where we need to calculate the evaporation current) the vapor quickly establishes a steady-state concentration proﬁle φ(~r) which obeys the steady-state diﬀusion equation ∇ 2 φ =0. At inﬁnity, φ is the ambient concentration φ ∞ . At the drop surface φ is ﬁxed at the saturation concentration φ s . The derivitive at the surface gives the desired evaporating ﬂux J(r)=−D∇φ, where D is the diﬀusivity of the vapor in air.

We may ﬁnd the ﬂux J by solving an equivalent electrostatic problem [8], wherein φ is an electrostatic potential and the drop, with its ﬁxed potential, is a conductor. (On the substrate surface beyond the drop there is no ﬂux, so that the normal derivitive of φ is zero there. That surface is in eﬀect a reﬂection plane of symmetry and the opening angle of the conducting wedge is twice the contact angle that the drop makes with the substrate.) The sharp wedge-shaped boundary of the drop and its reﬂection leads to a diverging normal derivitive (electric ﬁeld or evaporative ﬂux) as r approaches the contact line. For a drop with contact angle θ c , this divergence has the form [9]: J(r) ∼ (R − r) −λ , where λ = π−2θ c 2π−2θ c . As the contact angle decreases towards zero, λ increases towards 1/2.

The initial deposition over times much shorter than the drying time depends sensitively on this diverging ﬂux. To replace the diverging ﬂux requires a diverging velocity near the perimeter: ¯v ∼ J ∼ (R − r) −λ .Wenow consider the mass of solute, M(r, t) beyond distance r from the center at time t. Near the contact line the initial mass M(r, 0) is proportional to the volume of this wedge shaped region: M(r, 0) ∼ (R − r) 2 . All this mass will be entrained in the ring in the time t required for a point starting at r t to move to the contact line:

t =

Z R

r t

dr/¯v ∼ (R − r t ) 1+λ , (1)

since ¯v(r) ∼ (R − r) −λ . Substituting for r t in terms of t into M(r t , 0) yields a power law for the early time growth of the ring: M (R, t)=M(r t ,0) ∼ t 2/(1+λ) . At late times, the theory predicts complete transfer of the solute to the perimeter. As the time t approaches the drying time t f , the height h(r) decreases to zero as (t f −t). But the outward current h(r)¯v(r) must stay constant with time in order to replenish the constant evaporation ﬂux J.Thus¯vmust grow as (t f − t) −1 . This diverging velocity leads to a diverging displacement of any point r>0. Thus all initial points r>0 are carried to the perimeter before the drying time t f .

100

1000

10000 [Annotation 3]

M - M

o

10 100

t + t o

1.37

10 100 1000

1000

10

100

FIG 3. Double-logarithmic plot of ring mass M(R, t) versus time t for times from 10 to 250 seconds after placement of the drop on the surface, for three diﬀerent drops whose total drying time was about 800 sec. M(R, t) is measured in number of particles. Particle number is counted in a sector of the ring similar to that shown in Figure 1b. An oﬀset M 0 = 2 was subtracted from the lowest curve to account for early non-steadystate deposition. M 0 = 50 and 40 for the middle and upper curves. The upper curve coincided with the middle one and was shifted up by a factor of 2 for clarity. An oﬀset t 0 = 11 sec, 13 sec and 10 sec was added to the time axis. The solid lines show the power law (M −M 0 ) = const (t+t 0 ) 1.37 . Inset shows M(R, t) versus t for the entire 1300-sec drying time. Circles: data obtained from ten-micron spheres via counting. Roughly 90 percent of the particles were observed to go to the contact line. Solid line: theoretical prediction determined numerically.

To test these predictions we used drops of distilled [Annotation 4] water which contained charge-stabilized surfactant-free polystyrene microspheres [Interfacial Dynamics, Portland, Oregon] at a starting volume fraction of 10 −4 . The spheres were so dilute that they could be regarded as an ideal solution except in the very narrow ring region. Droplets with nominal radius 4 mm were deposited on glass microscope slides and allowed to dry in a large enclosure with measured ambient temperature and humid-

2

#### Page 3

ity. The volume of the droplet was inferred by weighing the slide during drying. The volume decreased at a rate which agreed within two percent with that expected for steady-state vapor-diﬀusion-limited evaporation, using tabulated values [10] for the water diﬀusivity in air and for the saturated vapor concentration.

In a separate experiment we observed the solute ring deposition by viewing the migration of one-micron microspheres in a video microscope during drying, as shown in Figure 1b. By automatically analyzing [11] the video record, the depth-averaged velocity ¯v(r) and the number of particles in the ring M(R, t) were measured. Contact line pinning is produced by surface irregularities and is much stronger with the solute than without it. The ring deposit can create surface unevenness as well as augment the surface imperfections that produced the initial pinning.

The depth-averaged velocity ¯v(r) for thin drops, with θ c ' 0, shows the predicted (R − r) −.5 divergence in the vicinity of the contact line. The measured ring mass M(R, t) is plotted in Figure 3. These drops had an initial contact angle θ c ' .25 radians. For this angle, our theory predicts an initial increase M(R, t) ∼ t 1.37 . This behavior is not expected at very early times (t < ∼ (4R) 2 /D ' 10 sec), before steady-state diﬀusion has been achieved. To account for transient eﬀects during this early period, we allow a shift in the eﬀective starting time of order 10 sec. We also include an oﬀset in the deposited mass in order to account for the particles deposited during the initial transient. Choosing the M and t oﬀsets to achieve the best straight line on a log-log plot yielded power-law ﬁts M − M 0 ∼ (t + t 0 ) p , where p =1.3±0.1. Thus the expected initial growth of the ring is consistent with observation. To predict the growth of the ring at later times, we ﬁrst determine ¯v(r) numerically from the known ﬂux J(r) of a thick drop and then use this ¯v(r) to determine M(R, t) as outlined after Eq. (1) above. This predicted M(R, t) is compared with the data in the inset of Figure 3. Again the prediction is in good agreement with the data.

Several eﬀects modify the simpliﬁed theory sketched above. Noncircular drops must have uneven deposition rates: highly convex regions have a stronger evaporating ﬂux and thus denser deposits, as corroborated by Figure 1a. If the solute is not dilute, the ring deposit is forced to have a nonzero width; higher initial concentration leads to a wider ring. Further thermodynamic effects may modify the ﬂow and the ring deposition. Some solutes may segregate to the solid surface and become immobilized. Others may segregate to the free surface where the outward ﬂow is faster than ¯v. The thermal and concentration gradients caused by evaporation can lead to circulating surface-tension-gradient driven (i.e., Marangoni) ﬂows. These can interfere with the outward ﬂow discussed above. Our experiments showed both surface segregation and circulating ﬂow but their impact was

minor (as we will discuss in detail elsewhere). High viscosity in the liquid can also modify the deposition by preventing the drop from attaining an equilibrium droplet shape. We estimate that in our experiments such viscous eﬀects should be negligible except within a few microns of the contact line.

Our measurements support this capillary ﬂow mechanism for contact-line deposition. They show that the deposition can be predicted and controlled without knowing the chemical nature of the liquid, solute or substrate. The model accounts in a natural way for the nearly complete transport of the solute to the periphery. By controlling the speed and spatial variation of the evaporation, this model predicts that we can control the shape and thickness of the deposit. Often it is desired to deposit solute particles in a conﬁned region as in for example the printing of ﬁne lines [5]. The commonplace ring stain appears to provide a simple and robust route to such conﬁnement.

[1] Parisse, F. and Allain, C., ”Shape Changes of Colloidal

Suspension Droplets during Drying” J. Phys II, 6 1111- [Annotation 5] 1119 (1996). [2] El Bediwi, A. B., Kulnis, W. J., Luo, Y., Woodland, D.,

and Unertl, W. N., ”Distributions of Latex Particles Deposited from Water Suspensions” Mat. Res. S oc. Symp. Proc., 372 277-282 (1995). [3] Denkov, N. D., Velev, O. D., Kralchevsky, P. A., Ivanov,

I. B., Yoshimura, H., and Nagayama, K. ”Mechanism of Formation of Two-Dimensional Crystals from Latex Particles on Substrates” Langmuir, 8 3183-3190 (1992). [4] Laden, P. ed.Chemistry and technology of water based

inks (London, Blackie Academic & Professional, 1997) [5] Society for Imaging Science and Technology, 1996 TAPPI

New Printing Technologies Symposium : proceedings (Atlanta, GA : Tappi press,1996) [6] Hisatake, K., Tanaka, S. Aizawa, Y., ”Evaporation of

Water in a Vessel” J. Appl. Phys. 73 7395-7401 (1993). [7] Peiss, C. N., ”Evaporation of Small Water Drops Main-

tained at Constant Volume” J. Appl. Phys 655235-5237 (1989). [8] Maxwell, J. C. Scientiﬁc Papers vol. 2 (Cambridge,

1890). [9] Jackson, J. D.Classical Electrodynamics, 2nd edition (J.

Wiley, New York, 1975) p. 77. [10] Lide, D. R. ed.CRC Handbook of Physics and Chem-

istry 77th edition, Chemical Rubber Publishing Company (Boca Raton FL, 1996). pp 6-218 6-8. [11] Crocker, J. C. and Grier, D. G. ”Methods of Digital

Video Microscopy for Colloidal Studies” J. Colloid and Interface Science, 179 298-310 (1996).

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS: The authors cordially thank Hao Li, Xiangdong Shi and Michelle Baildon for their

3

#### Page 4

early contributions to this project, John Crocker, David Grier, and Andy Marcus for sharing with us their expertise, their image analysis code, and their facilities, and to Steve Garoﬀ, L. Mahadevan, Sergei Esipov, Robert Leheny, Dan Mueth, Ed Ehrichs, Jim Knight, Sean Blanton, Narayanan Menon, Jeﬀ Cina and Leo Kadanoﬀ for

stimulating discussions. This work was supported by grants from NSF-MRSEC, NSF, and DOE.

CORRESPONDENCE should be addressed to RDD (rddeegan@control.uchicago.edu). Further information may be found on the internet at http://MRSEC.uchicago.edu/MRSEC

4

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/capillary-flow-as-the-cause-of-ring-stains-from-dried-liquid-drops. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
