# An elementary treatment of the Feynman sprinkler

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/an-elementary-treatment-of-the-reverse-sprinkler

- **Authors:** Alejandro Jenkins
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1461534517506-cuij8i3z37yhij9d-7df6bd4d2c2ea5d1dc8ccd0c72ee72d1%2FAn+elementary+treatment+of+the+reverse+sprinkler.pdf
- **Pages:** 8
- **Annotations:** 8 comments in 8 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/an-elementary-treatment-of-the-reverse-sprinkler

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “There was a problem in a hydrodynamics book, 3 that was b e ing discusse d by all the physics students. The problem is this: You have an S-shaped lawn sprinkler . . . and the water squirts out at right angles to the axis and makes it s pin in a cer tain direction. Everybody knows which way it goes around; it backs …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-04-30):

> When the sprinkler sprays water it will spin counterclockwise. But what happens when the sprinkler sucks water in?
>
> ![](http://i.imgur.com/TINhcXw.png)

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “There was a problem in a hydrodynamics book, 3 that was b e ing discusse d by all the physics students. The problem is this: You have an S-shaped lawn sprinkler . . . and the water squirts out at right angles to the axis and makes it s pin in a cer tain direction. Everybody knows which way it goes around; it backs …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-04-30):

> In 1966, Feynman turned down an offer from the editor of Physics Teacher to discuss the problem in print and objected to it being called "Feynman's problem," pointing instead to the discussion of it in Mach's textbook.
>
> ![](http://i.imgur.com/AI9jCCy.png)

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Feynman went on to say that many P rinceton physicists, when presented with the problem, judged the solution to be obvious, only to ﬁnd that others arrived with equal conﬁdence at the opposite ans wer, or tha t they had changed their minds by the following day. Feynman claims that after a while he ﬁnally decided what …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-04-30):

> Physicist Edward C. Creutz, who was in charge of the Princeton cyclotron at the time of the incident, and the only person present in the lab besides Feynman, revealed
>
> > "We watched the sprinkler as the pressure built up, forcing water into the top of the sprinkler, and in a few minutes the sprinkler head turned about 5 degrees in the direction a sprinkler usually turns when water is forced into it through its base. There was a little tremor, as Dick called it, and the sprinkler head rapidly moved back to its original position and stayed there. The water flow continued with the sprinkler stationary. We adjusted the pressure to increase the water flow, about five separate times, and the sprinkler did not move, although water was flowing freely through it in the backwards direction, which is consistent with the analysis of Jenkins. The carboy then exploded, due to the internal pressure. A janitor then appeared and helped me clean up the shattered glass and mop up the water. I don’t know what Dick had expected to happen, but my vague thoughts of a time-reversal phenomenon were as shattered as the carboy."

### Annotation 4 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “FIG. 1: A sprinkler submerged in a tank of water as seen from above. The L-shaped sprink ler is closed, and the forces and torques exerted by the water pressure balance each other.”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-04-30):

> Note that the hydrostatic pressure is the same in every direction in a fluid at a given depth, otherwise the fluid would start to move.

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “because whatever left-pointing momentum the incoming water picks up, it will have to transfer to the inner left wall upon hitting it. Therefore A(P 1 − P 2 ) is the force that the incoming water exerts on the inner sprinkler wall in Fig. 2 by virtue of the mo mentum it has gained in traveling down the intake pipe.”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-05-01):

> If we analyze the forces acting on the sprinkler and the water we end up with the following diagrams:
>
> ![](http://i.imgur.com/SAF8Dm2.png?)
>
> where $A\Delta P=A(P_2-P_1)$ is the force on the water due to the pressure difference, $m$ and $v$ are the mass and velocity of the water inside the sprinkler and $F_f$ is the friction force arising from the flow of water inside the sprinkler.
>
> We can write the total force acting on the sprinkler in the horizontal direction as:
>
> $$
> F_T = A\Delta P - v \frac{\Delta m}{\Delta t}-F_f
> $$
>
> In the case of an ideal fluid $F_f=0$ and assuming that we are already in the phase where the water is flowing continuously inside the sprinkler the condition to get to steady-state motion (a state in which the properties of the system do not change with time) is that $A\Delta P = v \frac{\Delta m}{\Delta t}$ and so $F_T=0$. Since the reaction force $v \frac{\Delta m}{\Delta t}$ when the water hits the sprinkler's inner wall is exactly $A\Delta P$ the total force acting on the sprinkler will be zero.
>
> Note that before getting to the steady state the motion of the sprinkler will be in the direction of $A\Delta P$ since initially there's no water hitting the wall ($v \frac{\Delta m}{\Delta t}=0$) and so $F_T=A\Delta P$.
>
> In the steady state the sprinkler will move in the direction of $A\Delta P$ with constant angular velocity since the total force acting on it is zero.
>
> When we stop sucking in water through the sprinkler the pressure difference ($\Delta P$) is removed and so the total force $F_T=-v \frac{\Delta m}{\Delta t}<0$ acting on the sprinkler in the opposite direction until the fluid and the sprinkler stop moving.

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “How much momentum is being transferred by the incoming water to the inner sprinkler wall in Fig. 2? If water is moving across a pressure gradient, then over a diﬀerential time dt, a given “chunk” of water will pass from an area of pressure P to an area of pressure P − dP as illustrated in Fig. 3. If the water travels …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-05-01):

> Although this argument is correct it is worth noting that the cross section (A) of an incompressible fluid flowing along a pressure gradient is not constant. A simple way to see this is using the continuity equation (when a fluid is in motion, it must move in such a way that mass is conserved)
>
> $$
> A_1v_1 = A_2 v_2
> $$
>
> If $A_1=A_2$ it would mean that $v_1=v_2$ and the fluid would not accelerate.
>
> The author did an oversimplification that it's not completely accurate but doesn't impact the argument. The conservation is enough to prove the magnitude of the momentum transfer but the cross section of the fluid is indeed way more complex.

### Annotation 7 (page 4)

Beside the passage: “How does non- ideal ﬂuid behavior aﬀect this analysis ? Viscosity, turbulence, and other such phenomena all dissipate mechanical energy. Therefore, a non-ideal ﬂuid rushing into the reverse sprinkler would acquire less momentum with respect to the pivot, for a given pressure diﬀerence, than predicted by the analysis …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-05-01):

> Using the same forces analysis we used above but this time for a non-ideal fluid ($F_f\neq 0$) we end up with:
>
> $$
> F_T = A\Delta P - v \frac{\Delta m}{\Delta t}-F_f
> $$
>
> where $F_T$ is the total force acting on the sprinkler.
>
> In this case since there's friction between the fluid and the  sprinkler we will have momentum and energy transferred from the fluid to the walls of the sprinkler even in the steady state. As a result the pressure difference effect is not completely canceled and  $F_T>0$, making the sprinkler move in the direction of the incoming water.

### Annotation 8 (page 5)

Beside the passage: “(a)”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2016-04-25):

> In the following video you can see someone doing the experiment for the normal and reversed sprinkler.
>
>
>  [![IMAGE ALT TEXT](https://slack-imgs.com/?c=1&o1=wi400.he300&url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FpkKwSEseJXk%2Fhqdefault.jpg)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkKwSEseJXk&feature=youtu.be&t=470
>  "The Feynman Sprinkler")

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

arXiv:physics/0312087v3 [physics.flu-dyn] 3 May 2004

An elementary treatment of the reverse sprinkler

Alejandro Jenkins ∗ California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, C alifornia 91125 (Dated: CALT-68-2470, Dec. 2003; to appear in the American Journal of Physics)

We discuss the reverse sprinkler problem: How does a sprinkler turn when submerged and made to suck in water? We propose a solution that requires only a k nowledge of mechanics and ﬂuid dynamics at the introductory university level. We argue that as the ﬂow of wat er starts, the sprinkler brieﬂy experiences a torque that would make it turn toward the incoming water, while as the ﬂow of water ceases it brieﬂy experiences a torque in the opposite direction. No torque is expected when water is ﬂowing steadily into it unless dissipative eﬀects, such as viscosity, are considered. Dissipative eﬀects result in a small torqu e that would cause the sprinkler arm to accelerate toward the steadily incoming water. Our conclusions are discussed in light of an analysis of forces, conservation of angular momentum, and the experimental results reported by others. We review the conﬂicting published treatments of this problem, some of which have bee n incorrect and many of which have introduced complications that obscure the basic physics involved.

I. INTRODUCTION

In 1985, R. P. Feynman, one of most distinguished theoretical physicists of his time, published a collection of autobiographical anecdotes that attracted much attention on account of their humor and outrageousnes s. 1 While describing his time at Princeton as a graduate student (1939–1942), Feynman tells the following story: 2

There was a problem in a hydrodynamics book, [Annotation 1] 3 that was b e ing discusse d by all the physics students. The problem is this: You have an S-shaped lawn sprinkler . . . and the water squirts out at right angles to the axis and makes it s pin in a cer tain direction. Everybody knows which way it goes around; it [Annotation 2] backs away from the outgoing water. Now the question is this: If you . . . put the sprinkler completely under water, and sucked the water in . . . which way would it turn?

Feynman went on to say that many P rinceton physicists, when presented with the problem, judged the solution to be obvious, only to ﬁnd that others arrived with equal conﬁdence at the opposite ans wer, or tha t they had changed their minds by the following day. Feynman claims that after a while he ﬁnally decided what the answer should be and proceeded to test it experimentally by using a very large water bottle, a piece of coppe r tubing, a rubber hose, a cork, and the air pressure supply from the Princeton cyclotron laboratory. Instead of attaching a vacuum to suck the water, he applied hig h air pressure inside of the water bottle to push the water out through the sprinkler. According to Feynman’s account, the experiment initially went well, but after he cranked up the setting for the pressure supply, the bottle exploded, and “. . . the whole thing just blew glass and water in all di- [Annotation 3] rections throughout the laboratory . . . ” 4

Feynman 1 did not inform the reader what his answer to the reverse sprinkler problem was or what the exp e riment revealed before exploding. Over the years, and

particularly after Feynman’s autobiographical recollections appea red in print, ma ny people have oﬀered their analyses, both theoretical and experimental, of this reverse sprinkler problem. 5 The solutions presented often have been contradictory and the theoretical treatments, even when they have been correct, have introduced unnecessary conceptual complications that have obscur e d the basic physics involved.

All physicists will probably know the frustration o f being c onfronted by an elementary question to which they cannot give a ready answer in spite of all the time dedicated to the study of the subject, often at a much higher level of sophistication than what the problem at hand would seem to re quire. Our intention is to oﬀer an elementary treatment of this problem which should be accessible to a bright se c ondary school student who has learned basic mechanics and ﬂuid dynamics. We believe that our answer is ab out as simple as it can be made, and we discuss it in light of published theoretica l and exp erimental treatments.

II. PRESSURE DIFFERENCE AND

MOMENTUM TRANSFER

Feynman spe aks in his memoirs of “an S-shaped lawn sprinkler.” It should not be diﬃcult, however, to convince yourself that the problem does not depend on the exact shape of the sprinkler, and for simplicity we shall refer in our argument to an L-shaped structure. In Fig. 1 the sprinkler is closed: water cannot ﬂow into it or out of it. Because the water pressure is equal on opposite sides of the sprinkler, it will not turn: there is no net torque around the sprinkler pivot.

Let us imagine that we then remove part of the wall on the right, as pictured in Fig. 2, opening the sprinkler to the ﬂow of water. If water is ﬂowing in, then the pressure marked P 2 must be lower than the pressure P 1 , because water ﬂows from higher to lower pressure. In both Fig. 1 and Fig. 2, the pressure P 1 acts on the left. But because a piece of the sprinkler wall is missing in

#### Page 2

2

FIG. 1: A sprinkler submerged in a tank of water as seen from [Annotation 4] above. The L-shaped sprink ler is closed, and the forces and torques exerted by the water pressure balance each other.

Fig. 2, the rele va nt pressure on the upper right part of the open sprinkler will be P 2 . It would seem then that the reverse sprinkler should turn toward the water, because if P 2 is less than P 1 , there would be a net force to the right in the upper part of the sprinkler, and the resulting torque would make the sprinkler turn clockwise. If A is the cross section of the sprinkler intake pipe, this torqueinducing force is A(P 1 − P 2 ). But we have not taken into account that even though the water hitting the inside wall of the sprinkler in Fig. 2 has lower pr e ssure, it also has left-pointing momentum. The incoming water transfers that momentum to the sprinkler as it hits the inner wall. This momentum transfer would tend to make the sprinkler turn c ounterclockwise. One of the reasons why the reverse sprinkler is a confusing problem is that there are two eﬀects in play, each of which, acting on its own, would make the sprinkler turn in opposite directions. The problem is to ﬁgure out the net result of these two eﬀects.

How much momentum is being transferred by the incoming water to the inner sprinkler wall in Fig. 2? If water is moving across a pressure gradient, then over a diﬀerential time dt, a given “chunk” of water will pass from an area of pressure P to an area of pressure P − dP as illustrated in Fig. 3. If the water travels down a pipe of cross-section A, its momentum gain per unit time is [Annotation 6] A dP . Therefore , over the entire length of the pipe, the water picks up momentum at a rate A(P 1 − P 2 ), where P 1 and P 2 are the values of the pressure at the endpoints of the pip e . (In the language of calculus, A(P 1 − P 2 ) is the to tal force that the pressure gradient across the pip e exerts on the water. We obtain it by integrating over the diﬀerential force A dP .)

The rate A(P 1 − P 2 ) is the same rate at which the water tra ns fers momentum to the sprinkler wall in Fig. 2,

FIG. 2: The sprinkler is now open. If water is ﬂowing into it, then the pressures marked P 1 and P 2 must satisfy P 1 > P 2 .

because whatever left-pointing momentum the incoming [Annotation 5] water picks up, it will have to transfer to the inner left wall upon hitting it. Therefore A(P 1 − P 2 ) is the force that the incoming water exerts on the inner sprinkler wall in Fig. 2 by virtue of the mo mentum it has gained in traveling down the intake pipe.

Because the pressure diﬀerence and the momentum transfer eﬀects cancel each other, it would seem that the reverse sprinkler would not move at all. Notice, however, that we considered the reverse sprinkler only after water was already ﬂowing continuously into it. In fact, the sprinkler will turn toward the water initially, because the forces will balance only after water has begun to hit the inner wall o f the sprinkler, a nd by then the sprinkler will have begun to turn towa rd the incoming water. That is, initially only the pressure diﬀerence eﬀect and not the momentum transfer eﬀect is relevant. (As the water ﬂow stops, there will be a brief period during which only the momentum transfer and not the pressure diﬀerence will be acting on the sprinkler, thus producing a momentary torque opposite to the one that acted when the water ﬂow was be ing es tablished.)

Why can’t we similarly “prove” the patently false statement that a non-sucking sprinkler submerged in water will not turn as water ﬂows steadily out of it? In that case the water is going out and hitting the upper inner wall, not the left inner wall. I t exerts a force, but that force produces no torque around the pivot. The pressur e diﬀerence, on the other hand, does exe rt a torque. The pressure in this case has to be higher inside the sprinkler than outside it, so the sprinkler turns counterclockwise, as we expect from experience.

#### Page 3

3

FIG. 3: As water ﬂows down a tube with a pressure gradient, it picks up momentum.

III. CONSERVATION OF ANGULAR

MOMENTUM

We have argued that, if we ignore the transient effects fr om the switching on and switching oﬀ of the ﬂuid ﬂow, we do not expect the reverse sprinkler to turn at all. A pertinent questio n is why, for the case of the regular sprinkler, the sprinkler-water system clearly exhibits no net angular momentum around the pivot (with the angular momentum of the o utg oing water cancelling the angular momentum of the rotating sprinkler), w hile for the reverse spr inkler the system would appear to have a net angular momentum given by the incoming water. The answer lies in the simple observa tion that if the water in a tank is ﬂowing, then something must be pushing it. In the regular sprinkler, there is a hig h pressure zo ne near the sprinkler wall next to the pivot, so it is this lower inner wall that is doing the original pushing, as shown in Fig. 4(a).

For the reverse sprinkler, the highest pres sure is outside the spr inkler, so the pushing originally comes from the right wall of the tank in which the whole system sits, as shown in Fig. 4(b). The for c e on the regular spr inkler clearly causes no torque around the pivot, while the force on the re verse sprinkler does. That the water should acquire a net angular momentum around the sprinkler pivot in the absence of an external torque might seem a violation of Newton’s laws, but only because we are neglecting the movement of the tank itself. Consider a water tank with a hole in its side, such as the one pictured in Fig. 5. The water acquires a net angular mo mentum with respect to any point on the tank’s bottom, but this angular momentum violates no physical laws because the tank is not inertial: it recoils as water ﬂows out of it. 6 But there is one further complication: in the reverse sprinkler shown in Fig. 4, the water that has acquired left-pointing momentum from the pushing of the tank wall will transfer that momentum back to the tank when

(a)

(b)

FIG. 4: The force that pushes the water must originally come from a solid wall. The force that causes the water ﬂow is shown for both the regular and the reverse sprinklers when submerged in a tank of water.

it hits the inner sprinkler wall, so that once water is ﬂowing steadily into the reverse sprinkler, the tank will stop exp eriencing a recoil forc e . The situation is analogous to that of a ship inside of which a machine gun is ﬁred, as shown in Fig. 6. As the bullet is ﬁred, the ship recoils , but when the bullet hits the ship wall and becomes embedded in it, the bullet’s momentum is transferred to the ship. (We assume that the collision of the bullets w ith the wall is completely inelastic.)

If the ﬁring rate is very low, the ship periodically acquires a velocity in a direction opposite to that of the

#### Page 4

4

FIG. 5: A tank with an opening on its side will exhibit a ﬂow such that the water will have an angular momentum with respect to the tank’s bottom, even though there is no external source of torque corresponding to the angular momentum. The apparent paradox is resolved by noting that the tank bottom oﬀers no inertial point of reference, because the tank is recoiling due to the motion of the water.

ﬁred bullet, only to stop when that bullet hits the wall. Thus the ship moves by small steps in a direction opposite that of the bullets’ ﬂight. As the ﬁring rate is increased, eventually one reaches a rate such that the interval between successive bullets being ﬁred is equal to the time it takes fo r a bullet to travel the length of the ship. If the machine gun is set for this exa c t rate from the be ginning, then the s hip will move back with a constant velocity from the moment that the ﬁrst bullet is ﬁred (when the ship picks up momentum from the recoil) to the moment the last bullet hits the wall (when the ship comes to a stop). In between those two events the s hip’s velocity will not change be c ause every ﬁring is simultaneous to the previous bullet hitting the ship wall.

As the ﬁring rate is made still higher, the ship will again move in steps, because at the time that a bullet is

FIG. 6: In this thought experiment, a ship ﬂoats in the ocean while a machine gun with variable ﬁring rate is placed at one end. Bullets ﬁred from the gun will travel the length of the ship and hit the wall on the other side, where they stop.

being ﬁred, the previous bullet will not have quite made it to the ship wall. Eventually, when the rate of ﬁring is twice the inverse of the time it takes for a bullet to travel the length of the ship, the motion of the ship will be such that it picks up speed upon the ﬁrst two shots, then moves uniformly until the penultimate bullet hits the wall, whereupon the ship looses half its velocity. The ship will ﬁnally come to a stop when the last bullet has hit the wall. At this point it should be clear how the ship’s motion will change as we continue to increase the ﬁring rate of the gun. 8

For the case of continuous ﬂow of water in a tank (rather tha n a discrete ﬂow of machine gun bullets in a ship), there clearly will be no intermediate steps, regardless of the rate of ﬂow. Figur e 7 shows a water tank connected to a shower head. Water ﬂows (with a co ns equent linear and angular momentum) between the points marked A and B, before exiting via the shower head. When the faucet valve is opened, the tank will experience a recoil from the outgoing water, until the water reaches B and begins exiting through the s hower head, at which point the forces on the tank will balance. By then the tank will have acquired a left-pointing momentum. It will lose that momentum as the valve is closed or the water tank becomes empty, when there is no lo nger water ﬂowing away from A but a ﬂow is still impinging on B.

A. K. Schultz 9 argues that, at each instant, the water ﬂowing into the reverse sprinkler’s intake carries a constant angular momentum around the sprinkler pivot, and if the sprinkler could turn without any resistance (either from the friction of the pivot or the viscosity of the ﬂuid) this angular momentum would be counterbalanced by the a ngular momentum that the sprinkler picked up as the water ﬂow was being switched on. As the ﬂuid ﬂow is switched oﬀ, such an ideal sprinkler would then lose its angular momentum and come to a halt. At every instant, the angular momentum o f the sprinkler plus the incoming water would be zero.

Schultz’s discussion is cor rect: in the absence of any resistance, the sprinkler arm itse lf move s so as to cancel the momentum of the incoming water, in the same way that the ship in Fig. 6 moves to cancel the momentum of the ﬂying bullets. Resistance, o n the other hand, would imply that some of that momentum is picked up not just by the sprinkler, but by the tank as a whole. If we cement the pivot to prevent the sprinkler from turning at all, then the tank will pick up all of the momentum that cancels that of the incoming water.

How does non- ideal ﬂuid behavior aﬀect this analysis ? Viscosity, turbulence, and other such phenomena all dissipate mechanical energy. Therefore, a non-ideal ﬂuid rushing into the reverse sprinkler would acquire less momentum with respect to the pivot, for a given pressure diﬀerence, than predicted by the analysis we carried out [Annotation 7] in Sec. II. Thus the pressure diﬀerence eﬀect would outweigh the momentum transfer eﬀect even in the steady state, leading to a small torq ue on the s prinkler even

#### Page 5

5

FIG. 7: A water tank is connected to a shower head, so that water ﬂows out. Water in the pipe that connects the points marked A and B has a right-pointing momentum, but as long as that pipe is completely ﬁlled with water there is no net horizontal force on the tank.

after the ﬂuid has begun to hit the inside wall of the sprinkler. Total a ngular momentum is conserved because the “missing” momentum of the incoming ﬂuid is being transmitted to the surrounding ﬂuid, and ﬁnally to the tank.

IV. HISTORY OF THE REVERSE SPRINKLER

PROBLEM

The literature on the subject of the reverse sprinkler is abundant and confusing. Ernst Ma ch speaks of “reaction wheels” blowing o r sucking air where we have spoken of regular or reverse sprinklers respectively: 10

It might be supposed that sucking on the reaction wheels would produce the opposite motion to that resulting from blowing. Yet this does not usually take place, and the reason is obvious . . . Generally, no perceptible rotation takes place on the sucking in of the air . . . If . . . an e lastic ball, which has one escapetube, be a ttached to the reaction- w hee l, in the manner represented in [Fig. 8(a)], and be alternately squeezed so that the same quantity of air is by turns blown out and sucked in, the wheel will continue to revolve rapidly in the same direction as it did in the case in which we blew into it. This is partly due to the fact that the air sucked into the spokes must participate in the motion of the latter and ther efore can produce no reactional rotation, but it also r e sults partly from the diﬀerence of the motion which the air outside the

(a) [Annotation 8]

(b)

FIG. 8: Illustrations from Ernst Mach’s Mechanik 10 : (a). Figure 153 a in the original. (b). Figure 154 in the original. (Images in the public domain, copied from the English edition of 1893.)

tube assumes in the two cases. In blowing, the air ﬂows out in jets, and per fo rms rotations. In sucking, the air comes in from all sides, and has no distinct rotation. . .

Mach appears to base his tr e atment on the observation that a “reaction wheel” is not seen to turn when sucked on. He then sought a theoretical rationale for this observation without arriving a t one that satisﬁed him. Thus the bluster about the explanation being “obvious,” accompanied by the tenta tive language ab out how “generally, no pe rceptible rotation ta kes place” and by the equivocation about how the lack of turning is “partly due” to the air “participating in the motion” of the wheel and partly to the air s ucked “coming in from all sides.”

Mach goes on to say that 11

if we per fo rate the bottom of a hollow cylinder . . . and place the cylinder on [a pivot], after the side has b e en slit and bent in the manner indicated in [Fig. 8(b)], the [cylinder]

#### Page 6

6

will turn in the direction of the long arrow when blown into and in the direction of the short arrow when sucked on. The air, here, on entering the cylinder can continue its r otation unimpeded, and this motion is accordingly compe nsated for by a rotation in the opposite direction.

This observation is correct and interesting: it shows that if the incoming water did not give up all its a ngular momentum upon hitting the inner wall of the reverse sprinkler, then the device would turn toward the incoming water, as we discus sed at the be ginning of Sec. III. 12 In his introduction to Mach’s Mechanik, mathematician Karl Menger describes it a s “one of the great scientiﬁc achievements of the [nineteenth] century,” 13 but it seems that the passage we have quoted was not well known to the twentieth century scientists who commented publicly on the reverse sprinkler. Feynman 1 gave no answer to the problem and wrote as if he expected and observed rotation (though, as some have pointed out, the fact that he cranked up the pressure until the bottle exploded suggests another explanatio n: he expected rotation and didn’t see it). In Refs. 14 and 15 the authors discuss the problem and claim that no rotation is observed, but they pursue the matter no further . In Ref. 16, it is suggested that students demons trate as an exercis e that “the direction of rotation is the same whether the ﬂow is supplied through the hub [of a submerged sprinkler] or withdrawn from the hub,” a result which is discounted by almost all the re st of the literature.

Shortly after Feynman’s memoirs appeared, A. T. Forrester published a paper in which he concluded that if water is sucked out of a tank by a vacuum attached to a sprinkler then the sprinkler will not rotate. 17 But he also made the bizar re claim that Feynman’s original experiment at the Princeton cyclotron, in which he had high air pres sure in the bottle push the water out, would actually cause the sprinkler to rotate in the direction of the incoming water. 17 An exchange on the issue of conservation of a ngular momentum between A. K. Shultz and Forr e ster appeared shortly thereafter. 9,18 The following year L. Hsu, a high school student, published an exp erimental analysis which found no rotation of the reverse sprinkler and questioned (quite sensibly) Forre ster’s claim that pushing the water out of the bottle was not equivalent to sucking it out. 19 E. R. L indgren also published an experimental result that supported the claim that the reverse sprinkler did not turn. 20 After Feynman’s death, his graduate research advisor, J. A. Wheeler, published some reminiscences of Feynman’s Princeton days from which it would appear that Feynman observed no motion in the sprinkler before the bottle exploded (“a little tremor as the pressure was ﬁrst applied . . . but as the ﬂow c ontinued there was no rea c tion”). 21 In 1992 the journalist James Gleick published a biography of Feynman in which he states that both Feynman and Wheeler “were scrupulous about never revealing the answer to the orig inal question” and

then claims that Feynman’s answer all along was that the sprinkler would not turn. 22 The physical justiﬁcation that Gleick o ﬀers for this answer is unenlightening and wrong. (Gleick e choes one of Mach’s comments 10 that the water entering the reverse sprinkler comes in from many dire c tions, unlike the water le aving a regular sprinkler, which forms a narrow jet. Although this observation is correct, it is not particularly relevant to the question at hand.)

The most detailed and pertinent work on the subject, b oth theoretical and experimental, was published by Berg, Collier, and Fe rrell, who claimed tha t the reverse sprinkler turns toward the incoming wa ter. 24,25 Guided by Schultz’s arguments about conservation of angular momentum, 9 the authors oﬀered a somewhat convoluted statement of the correct observation that the sprinkler picks up a bit of angular momentum before reaching a steady state of zero torque once the water is ﬂowing steadily into the sprinkler. When the water stops ﬂowing, the sprinkler c omes to a halt. 31

The air-sucking reverse sprinkler at the Edgerton Center at MIT shows no movement at all. 27 As in the setups used by Feynman and others, this sprinkler arm is no t mounted on a true pivot, but rather turns by twisting or bending a ﬂexible tube. Any tra ns ie nt torque will therefore cause, at most, a brief shaking of such a device. The University of Maryland’s Physics Lecture Demonstration Facility oﬀer s video evidence of a reverse sprinkler, mounted on a true pivot of very low friction, turning slowly toward the incoming water. 26 According to R. E. Berg, in this particular setup “while the water is ﬂowing the nozzle rotates at a constant angular sp e e d. This would be consistent with conservation of angular momentum exce pt for one thing: while the water is ﬂowing into the nozzle, if you reach and stop the nozzle rotation it should remain still after you release it. [But, in practice,] after [the nozzle] is released it starts to r otate again.” 37

This behavior is consistent with non-zero dissipation of kinetic energy in the ﬂuid ﬂow, as we have discussed. Angular momentum is conserved, but only after the motion of the tank is taken into account. 38

V. CONCLUSIONS

We have oﬀered an ele mentary theoretical treatment of the behavior of a reverse sprinkler, and concluded that, under idealized conditions, it should e xperience no torque while ﬂuid ﬂows steadily into it, but as the ﬂow commences, it will pick up an angular momentum opposite to that of the incoming ﬂuid, which it will give up as the ﬂow e nds. However, in the pres e nce of viscosity or turbulence, the reverse sprinkler will expe rience a small torque even in steady state, which would cause it to accelerate toward the incoming water. T his torque is balanced by an opposite torque acting on the surrounding ﬂuid and ﬁnally on the tank itself.

Throughout our discussion, our foremost concern was

#### Page 7

7

to emphasize physical intuition and to make our treatment as simple as it could be made (but not simpler). Surely a question about what L. A. Delsasso called, according to Feynman’s recollection, “a freshman exp eriment” 4 deserves an answer presented in a langua ge at the corresponding level of complication. More important is the principle, famously put forward by Feynman himself when discussing the spin statistics theorem, that if we can’t “reduce it to the freshman le vel,” we don’t really understand it. 39

We also have commented on the perplexing history of the reverse sprinkler problem, a history which is interesting not only because physicists of the stature of Mach, Wheeler, and Feynman enter into it, but also because it oﬀers a startling illustra tion of the fallibility of great scientists faced with a question about “a freshman experiment.”

Surely, as the Duchess said to Alice during one of her

adventures in Wonderland, “everything’s g ot a mor al, if you can only ﬁnd it.” 40

Acknowledgments

The historical section of this paper owes a great deal to the list of references on the reverse sprinkler that is given at the Web site for the University of Maryland’s Physics Lecture Demonstration Facility. 26 Thanks are due to several readers who commented on this paper after it ﬁrst appeared in manuscript form, particularly to J. M. Dlugosz, who took it upon himself to clarify the relationship between this discussion and the account of the experimental results at the University of Maryland. The result of his inquiries was a useful exchange with R. E. Berg.

∗ Electronic address: jenkins@theory.caltech.edu 1 R. P. Feynman, Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman, (Norton, New York, NY, 1985), pp. 63–65. 2 R. P. Feynman, Ibid., p. 63. 3 It has not been possible to identify the book to which Feynman was referring. As we shall discuss, the matter is treated in Ernst Mach’s Mechanik, ﬁrst published in 1883. 10 Yet this book is not a “hydrodynamics book” and the reverse sprinkler is presented as an example, not a problem. In Ref. 21, J. A. Wheeler suggests that the problem occurred to them while discussing a diﬀerent question in the undergraduate mechanics course t hat Wheeler was teaching and for which Feynman was the grader. 4 R. P. Feynman, Ibid., p. 65. 5 In the literature it is more usual to see this problem identiﬁed as the “Feynman inverse sprinkler.” Because the problem did not originate with Feynman and Feynman never published an answer to the problem, we have preferred not to attach his name to the sprinkler. Furthermore, even though it is a pedantic point, a query of the Oxford English Dictionary suggests that “reverse” (opposite or contrary in character, order, or succession) is a more appropriate description than “inverse” (turned up-side down) for a sprinkler that sucks water. 6 This observation might seem trivial, but its consequences can be counterintuitive. The Zapruder ﬁlm of the 1963 assassination of U.S. president J. F. Kennedy, shows Kennedy’s head snapp ing backward after the fatal shot, even though the oﬃcial theory of the assassination asserts that the shot was ﬁred from behind Kenned y by gunman L. H. Oswald. For several decades, conspiracy theorists have seized on this element of the Zapruder ﬁ lm as evidence that the fatal shot could not have been ﬁred by Oswald and must have come instead from in front of the president’s motorcade. In 1976, L. W. Alvarez published an analysis of the Zapruder ﬁlm in which he explained that the jet of brain tissue that emerged from president’s exit wound might easily have thrown his head in the direction opposite to that of the incoming bullet. Alvarez demonstrated this to his satisfaction both theoretically and experimentally,

the latter by ﬁring at a melon and photographing it as it moved in the direction opposite to what one would naively have expected. 7 7 L. W. Alvarez, “A physicist examines the Kennedy assassination ﬁlm,” Am. J. Phys. 44, 813–827 (1976). 8 Two interesting problems for an introductory un iversitylevel physics course suggest themselves. O ne is to show that the center of mass of the bullets-and-ship system will not move in the horizontal direction regardless of the ﬁring rate, as one expects from momentum conservation. Another would be to analyze this problem in the light of Einstein’s relativity of simultaneity. 9 A. K. Schultz, “Comment on the inverse sprinkler problem,” Am. J. Phys. 55, 488 (1987). 10 E. Mach, Die Mechanik in Ihrer Entwicklung Historisch- Kritisch Dargerstellt (1883). First published in English in 1893 as The Sci ence of Mechanics: A Critical and Historical Account of its Development (Open Court, La Salle, IL , 1960), 6th ed., pp. 388–390. 11 E. Mach, Ibid., p. 390. 12 In Ref. 23, P. Hewitt proposes a physical setup identical to the one shown in Fig. 8(b), and observes that the device turns in opposite directions depend ing on whether the ﬂuid pours out of or into it. Hewitt’s discussion seems to ignore the important diﬀerence between such a setup and the reverse sprinkler. 13 E. Mach, Op. cit., p. v. 14 P. Kirkpatrick, “A neglected lesson from the Cartesian diver,” Am. J. Phys. 10, 160 (1942). 15 H. S. Belson, “‘Empty’ hero’s en gine,” Am. J. Phys. 24, 413–414 (1956). 16 Proceedings of the National Science Foundation Conference on Instruction in Fluid Mechanics, 5–9 September 1960, Exp. 2.2, p. II–20. 17 A. T. Forrester, “Inverse sprink lers: A lesson in the use of a conservation principle,” Am. J. Phys. 54, 798–799 (1986). 18 A. T. Forrester, “Comments on a letter by A. K. Schultz,” Am. J. Phys. 55, 488–489 ( 1987). 19 L. Hsu, “Two simple experiments and the resolution of the Feynman-Forrester conﬂict,” Am. J. Phys. 56, 307–

#### Page 8

8

308 (1988). 20 E. R. Lindgren, “The transport of momentum t heorem,” Am. J. Phys. 58, 352–357 ( 1990). 21 J. A. Wheeler, “The young Feynman,” Phys. Today 42 (2), 24–28 (1989). 22 J. Gleick, Genius: The Life and Science of Richard Feynman (Pantheon, New York, NY, 1992), pp. 106–108. 23 P. Hewitt, “Figuring physics,” Phys. Teach. 40, 390, 437 (2002). 24 R. E. Berg and M. R. Collier, “The Feynman inverse sprinkler problem: A demonstration and quantitative analysis,” Am. J. Phys. 57, 654–657 ( 1989). 25 R. E. Berg, M. R. Collier, and R. A. Ferrell, “The Feynman inverse sprinkler problem: A detailed kinematic study,” Am. J. Phys. 59, 349–355 ( 1991). 26 R. E. Berg et al., University of Maryland Physics Lecture Demonstration Facility, <http://www.physics.umd.edu/lecdem/services/demos/demosd3/d3-22.htm>. 27 MIT Edgerton Center Corridor Lab: Feynman Sprinkler, <http://web.mit.edu/Edgerton/www/FeynmanSprinkler.html>. 28 M. Kuzyk, “Letter,” Phys. Today 42 (11), 129–130 (1989). 29 R. E. Berg and M. R. Collier, “New dev ice lets you unwater your lawn,” Phys. Today 43 (7), 13 (1990). 30 A. Mironer, “The Feynman sprinkler,” Am. J. Phys. 60, 12 (1992). 31 There are other references in the literature to t he reverse sprinkler. For a rather humorous exchange, see Refs. 28 and 29. Already in 1990 the American Journal of Physics had received so many conﬂ icting analyses of the problem that the editor prop osed “a moratorium on p ublications on Feynman’s sprinkler.” 30 In one of her 1996 columns for Parade Magazine, Marilyn vos Savant, who bills herself as having the highest recorded IQ, oﬀered an account of Feynman’s experiment which, she claimed, settled that the

reverse sprinkler does not move. 32 Vos Savant’s column emphasized the confusion of Feynman and others when faced with the problem, leading a reader to respond with a letter to his local newspaper in which he questioned the credibility of physicists who address matters more complicated than lawn sprinklers, such as the origin of the universe. 33 32 M. vos Savant, “Ask Marilyn,” Parade Magazine, Oct. 6, 1996. 33 A. de Gruyter, “Big Bang Theorists Can’t Simulated Water Sprinkler Reversal,” Houston Chronicle, Oct. 26, 1996, p. A35. 34 J. S. Miller, “Physics in a toy boat,” Am. J. Phys. 26, 199 (1958). 35 R. S. Mackay, “Boat driven by thermal oscillations,” Am. J. Phys. 26, 583–584 (1958). 36 I. Finnie and R. L. Curl, “Physics in a toy boat,” Am. J. Phys. 31, 289–293 (1963). 37 R. E. Berg, private communication with J. M. Dlugosz and A. Jenkins (2004). 38 In the late 1950’s and early 1960’s, there was some interest in the related physics problem of the so-called “puttputt” (or “pop-pop”) boat, a fascinating toy boat that propels itself by heating (usually with a candle) an inner tank connected to a submerged double exhaust. Steam bubbles cause water to be alternately blown out of and sucked into the tank. 34,35,36 The ship moves forward, much like Mach described the “reaction wheel” turning vigorously in one direction as air was alternately blown out and sucked in. 39 R. P. Feynman, Six Easy Pieces, (Perseus Books, Cambridge, MA, 1994), p. xxi. 40 L. Carroll and M. Gardner (ed.), The Annotated Alice: The Deﬁnitive Edition, (W. W. Norton, New York, NY, 2000), p. 91.

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/an-elementary-treatment-of-the-reverse-sprinkler. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
