# A simple proof that π is irrational

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/a-simple-proof-that-pi-is-irrational

- **Authors:** Ivan Niven (1946)
- **Topic:** Mathematics
- **Original:** http://www.ams.org/journals/bull/1947-53-06/S0002-9904-1947-08821-2/S0002-9904-1947-08821-2.pdf
- **Pages:** 1
- **Annotations:** 11 comments in 7 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/a-simple-proof-that-pi-is-irrational

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “A SIMPLE PROOF THAT TT IS IRRATIONAL”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2015-09-09):

> The first rigorous proof that π is irrational is from Johann Heinrich Lambert in 1761. He proved that if
> $x \not= 0$ is rational, then $tan(x)$ must be irrational. Since $tan(π /4) = 1$ is rational, then π must be irrational.
> The simpler proof given here is due to Ivan Niven in 1947, at the time a young mathematician at the University of Oregon. It only assumes a knowledge of basic Calculus.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Let 7T = a/6, the quotient of positive integers. We define the polynomials”

**Annotation** by David Prentiss (2015-12-31):

> That is, assume $\pi$ is rational.

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “x n (a — bx) n”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2015-09-09):

> To prove that $f(x)$ and its derivatives $f^{(j)}(x)$ have integral values for $x=0$ we should first note that  $f(x)$ is a polynomial with terms in $x$ from $x^n...x^{2n}$. To do that we just need to expand the polynomial $(a-bx)^{n}$ using the binomial expansion and note that we end up with a polynomial with terms from $x^0...x^{n}$. Finally, when multiplied by $x^{n}$ we end up with terms ranging from $x^n...x^{2n}$. Now let's divide the derivatives in 3 groups:
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> & \text{1.  } & j<n \\
> & \text{2.  } & n\leq j \leq 2n \\
> & \text{3.  } & j>2n
> \end{eqnarray*}
>
> For $j<n$ the terms in $f^{(j)}(x)$ will range from $x^{n-j}...x^{2n-j}$ and so $f^{(j)}(0) = 0 $. For $j>2n$ all the terms will vanish and again $f^{(j)}(0) = 0$. Finally for  $n\leq j \leq 2n$, there will be at least a term that doesn't vanish for $x=0$ -  the term in $x^{j}$ -  and so $f^{(j)}(0) = C_{j}$, where $C_j$ is a binomial coefficient multiplied by $\frac{j!}{n!}$. The binomial coefficient is an integer as well as $\frac{j!}{n!}$, because $j>n$ and so their product ($C_j$) will also be an integer.
>
> We finally proved that $f(x)$ and its derivatives $f^{(j)}(x)$ have integral values for $x=0$, for all $j$. Now if we observe that:
>
> \begin{eqnarray*}
> f(a/b-x) & =& (a/b-x)^{n}(a-b(a/b-x))^{n}/n!   \\
> & = & (a/b-x)^{n}(bx)^{n}/n! \\
> & = & (a-bx)^{n}x^{n}/n! \\
> & = & f(x)
> \end{eqnarray*}
>
> We verify that the results derived for $x=0$ are also applicable for $x=a/b=\pi$.

**Reply** by Joseph (2023-07-17):

> nice clarification.

### Annotation 4 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “F(x) = ƒ<» - fW(x) +/ (4) 0) + (- l) n / (2n) 0)>”

**Annotation** by Samuel Lê (2015-09-14):

> Shouldn't that be $F_n(x)$ ?

**Reply** by Mauris Van Hauwe (2015-09-15):

> No; $n$ is specified later in the proof to be a *sufficiently large* constant; the definition of $F(x)$ is simply in terms of  this constant $n$.

**Reply** by Eric Stucky (2016-09-11):

> In particular, this will work for all $n$ large enough such that $\pi^na^n<n!$. (So $f$ and $F$ in fact depend on $a$, but there's no harm in that since $a$ has already been chosen to be arbitrary and fixed)

### Annotation 5 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “the positive integer n being specified later. Since nlf(x) has integral coefficients and terms in x of degree not less than n, f(x) and its derivatives ƒ {j) (x) have integral values for # = 0; also for x*=ir~a/b, since ƒ(x) =f(a/b—x). By elementary calculus we have”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2015-09-09):

> \begin{eqnarray*} & F''(x) &=f^{2}(x)-f^{4}(x)+f^{6}(x) - ... \\
> & F''(x) & + F(x) = f^{2}(x)-f^{4}(x)+f^{6}(x) - ...  \\ &+& f(x)-f^{2}(x)+f^{4}(x)-f^{6}(x)+... \\
> & = & f(x)
>  \end{eqnarray*}

### Annotation 6 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “(1) ! ƒ(» sin xdx = [F'(a) sin x - i?(» cos #] 0 * = F(v) + F(0). J o”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2015-09-09):

> The idea now is to show that the integral of $f(x) sin(x)$ cannot always be an integer for all values of n, which will be in contradiction with $(1)$, thus proving that $\pi$ must be irrational.
>
> Consider a value of x that is between 0 and $\pi$. It's not difficult to see that $f(x)$ in this interval is always less than $\frac{\pi^{n}a^{n}}{n!}$. At the same time $sin(x)$ will always be less than 1 in the same interval and so $f(x)sin(x)<\frac{\pi^{n}a^{n}}{n!}$. As a consequence $\int_{0}^{\pi} f(x)sin(x)<\frac{\pi^{n+1}a^{n}}{n!}$.
>
> Now if we recall that $e^{\pi a}=\sum \frac{\pi^n a^n }{n!} $, and any term in a convergent series will have to tend to 0 as $n \rightarrow \infty $, we conclude that $\int_{0}^{\pi} f(x)sin(x)$ will have to tend to 0 for a sufficient large $n$, which contradicts the previous result stating that the integral must be an integer.
>
> By contradiction we can now conclude that $\pi$ needs to be irrational.

### Annotation 7 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “7r n a n 0 < ƒ(#) sin x < j”

**Annotation** by Mauris Van Hauwe (2015-09-15):

> We can see that $f(x)$ is positive over $(0, \pi)$, and since $\pi$ is the smallest positive zero of the sine function, $\sin x$ is positive there as well; thus their product also is. This is the first half of the inequality: $0 < f(x) \sin x$.
>
> For the other half, note that the zeroes of $f$ are at $0$ and $\pi$, and that the derivative of $f(x)$ is:
>
> $$f'(x) = \frac{n (a-2bx) \cdot x^{n-1} (a-bx)^{n-1}}{n!}$$
>
> It has zeroes at $0$, $\pi/2$, and $\pi$.
>
> Since $f$ is positive over $(0, \pi)$, we can deduce that over the interval $[0, \pi]$, the graph of $f$ is a Bell curve: it goes up from $0$ at $x=0$, to $f(\pi/2)$ halfway, and back down from there to $0$ at $x=\pi$.
>
> Thus over the interval $(0, \pi)$, we conclude that $$f(x) < f(\pi/2) = \frac{\pi^n a^n}{4n!} < \frac{\pi^na^n}{n!},$$
>
> completing the inequality.
>
> (Is there an easier way to show this half?)

**Reply** by Joe Koester (2015-09-15):

> Starting with $0<x<\pi$, we can raise to the $n$th power to get $0<x^n<\pi^n$. Starting again with $0<x<\pi$, multiply across by $-b$, add $a$, then raise to the $n$th power to get $a^n > (a-bx)^n>(a-b\pi)^n=0$. Multiplying both equations and dividing by $n!$ gets us $0 < \frac{x^n(a-bx)^n}{n!} < \frac{\pi^na^n}{n!}$.

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

A SIMPLE PROOF THAT [Annotation 1] TT IS IRRATIONAL

IVAN NIVEN

Let [Annotation 2] 7T = a/6, the quotient of positive integers. We define the polynomials

x n [Annotation 3] (a — bx) n

F(x) = ƒ<» - fW(x) +/ [Annotation 4] (4) 0) + (- l) n / (2n) 0)>

the positive integer n being specified later. Since nlf(x) has integral coefficients and terms in x of degree not less than n, f(x) and its [Annotation 5] derivatives ƒ {j) (x) have integral values for # = 0; also for x*=ir~a/b, since ƒ(x) =f(a/b—x). By elementary calculus we have

d — \F'(x) sin x — F(x) cos x\ = F"(x) sin x + F(x) sin x = f(x) sin # dx

and

(1) ! ƒ(» sin xdx = [F'(a) sin x - i?(» cos [Annotation 6] #] 0 * = F(v) + F(0). J o

Now F(TT)-{-F(fi) is aninteger, since ƒ ( #(?r) and/ (j,) (0) are integers. But for 0<x<7T,

7r n a n 0 < ƒ(#) sin x < j [Annotation 7]

n\ so that the integral in (1) is positive, but arbitrarily small for n sufficiently large. Thus (1) is false, and so is our assumption that TT is rational.

PURDUE UNIVERSITY

Received by the editors November 26, 1946, and, in revised form, December 20, 1946.

509

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/a-simple-proof-that-pi-is-irrational. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
