# A measurement of excess antenna temperature at 4080 mc/s

> An annotated edition of this paper on Fermat's Library, where scientists and readers explain its ideas, equations and history in the margins. Annotated edition: https://fermatslibrary.com/s/a-measurement-of-excess-antenna-temperature-at-4080-mc-s

- **Authors:** Penzias and Wilson
- **Topic:** Physics
- **Original:** https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/fermatslibrary/uploads%2F1527607175213-lj1tk06nnx-486f05bede544095f5f8ddd8167825b6%2F1965ApJ___142__419P.pdf
- **Pages:** 3
- **Annotations:** 7 comments in 7 threads
- **Featured:** Fermat's Library Journal Club
- **Annotated edition:** https://fermatslibrary.com/s/a-measurement-of-excess-antenna-temperature-at-4080-mc-s

## Annotations

### Annotation 1 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Alpher, R. A , Bethe, H. A , and Gamow, G 1948, Phys. Rev., 73, 803 Alpher, R A., Follín, J W., and Herman, R. C. 1953, Phys. Rev , 92, 1347. Bondi, H , and Gold, T. 1948, M N., 108, 252. Brans, C , and Dicke, R. H 1961, Phys. Rev., 124, 925. Dicke, R. H. 1962, Phys. Rev., 125, 2163. Dicke, R. H , Beringer, R., Kyhl, …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2018-06-19):

> This paper outlines the theoretical arguments behind the prediction of a background radiation. If you want to understand why this paper was published exactly before the Penzias and Wilson one please read the annotations below.

### Annotation 2 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “Measurements of the effective zenith noise temperature of the 20-foot horn-reflector antenna (Crawford, Hogg, and Hunt 1961) at the Crawford Hill Laboratory, Holmdel, New Jersey, at 4080 Mc/s have yielded a value about 3.5° K higher than expected. This excess temperature is, within the limits of our observations, …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2018-06-18):

> This is the paper for which Penzias and Wilson got awarded the Physics Nobel Prize in 1978. It's also one of the most understated titles of any scientific paper - the "excess temperature" mentioned in the title is in fact the **Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) radiation**. The experimental detection of the CMB was a very important milestone in cosmology since it is a landmark evidence of the Big Bang origin of the universe, in which the CMB is the residual heat of creation--the afterglow of the big bang.
>
>
> ![](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/3c/Ilc_9yr_moll4096.png)

### Annotation 3 (page 1)

Beside the passage: “© American Astronomical Society • Provided by the NASA Astrophysics Data System”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2018-06-18):

> When Penzias and Wilson went to work at Bell Labs there was a very special antenna lying around. This horn shaped antenna had been used to detect signals from the Echo balloon satellite, which had been launched in 1960. Its rare design had been optimized to pick up very weak signals from the high altitude Echo balloon, while minimizing the extraneous signals from any terrestrial sources.
>
> ![](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/3c/Bell_Labs_Horn_Antenna_Crawford_Hill_NJ.jpg)
>
> These features made this antenna ideal to search the sky for astronomical radio sources.

### Annotation 4 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “free from seasonal variations (July, 1964-April, 1965). A possible explanation for the observed excess noise temperature is the one given by Dicke, Peebles, Roll, and Wilkinson (1965) in a companion letter in this issue. The total antenna temperature measured at the zenith is 6.7° K of which 2.3° K is due to …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2018-06-18):

> If you go back and read the paper that precedes the result from Penzias and Wilson it concludes that, assuming the Big Bang theory is true, there should be a detectable afterglow radiation permeating today's Universe, with approximately the same temperature as the one detected by Penzias and Wilson. For anyone reading these two papers it might seem like an incredible coincidence that there happen to be two groups of researchers making two matching discoveries almost at the same time: the theoretical prediction of the CMB and it's experimental discovery.
>
> **Here's the story of why these 2 papers came to be published in the exact same Journal issue.**
>
> Near the end of 1964, Penzias went to a conference in Montreal where he talked about the "noise" problem with the horn antenna to the cosmologist Robert Burke. A few months after the conference Burke got a draft copy of a paper by his friends Robert Dicke and James Peebles of Princeton University in which they predicted that the Big Bang should have left an all-pervasive background radiation which today would be in the radio part of the spectrum.
>
> When Burke got the preprint from Dicke and Peebles he called Penzias, who confirmed that the "noise" was the same radiation that was being predicted in the paper. Penzias then called Dicke informing him of the signal he and Wilson had detected. Dicke was stunned and the 2 teams decided to publish back-to-back articles in the Astrophysical Journal of 1965. The first paper, entitled “Cosmic Black-Body Radiation” outlining the theoretical arguments behind the prediction of a background radiation and the second paper talking about the experimental detection of the previously mentioned radiation.

### Annotation 5 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “free from seasonal variations (July, 1964-April, 1965). A possible explanation for the observed excess noise temperature is the one given by Dicke, Peebles, Roll, and Wilkinson (1965) in a companion letter in this issue. The total antenna temperature measured at the zenith is 6.7° K of which 2.3° K is due to …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2018-06-19):

> Before Penzias and Wilson started using the antenna to try to find radio sources in the sky they decided to analyze the "noise" the antenna could be being subject to. This would include: radio signals from the ground, local radio interference, or electronic noise in the detection equipment.
>
> They even considered a pair of pigeons that were nesting in the horn of the antenna, and leaving a “white deposit” on the walls of the horn. Penzias and Wilson got rid of the pigeons and cleaned the horn to exclude any potential sources of noise.

### Annotation 6 (page 2)

Beside the passage: “The backlobe response to ground radiation is taken to be less than 0.1° K for two reasons: (1) Measurements of the response of the antenna to a small transmitter located on the ground in its vicinity indicate that the average back-lobe level is more than 30 db below isotropic response. The horn-reflector antenna was …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2018-06-19):

> Today we know, thanks to the data from COBE, that the CMB radiation has a temperature of 2.72548 ± 0.00057 K, which is compatible with Penzias and Wilson's measurements.
>
> Note that Penzias and Wilson only measured this excess at one wavelength - 7.35 cm. Later more data was collected at multiple wavelengths which proved that the CMB has a thermal black body spectrum, governed by the Stefan–Boltzmann law:
>
> $$
> P/A = \sigma T^4
> $$
>
> ![](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/cd/Cmbr.svg/600px-Cmbr.svg.png)

### Annotation 7 (page 3)

Beside the passage: “Crawford, A B., Hogg, D. C , and Hunt, L E 1961, Bell System Tech. /., 40, 1095. DeGrasse, R. W , Hogg, D C , Ohm, E A , and Scovil, H. E. D 1959, “Ultra-low Noise Receiving System for Satellite or Space Communication,” Proceedings of the National Electronics Conference, 15, 370. Dicke, R H , Peebles, P. J. E., Roll, …”

**Annotation** by Luís Batalha (2018-06-18):

> Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson were both radio astronomers who worked at the Bell Research Labs. Penzias had been born into a Jewish family in Munich in 1933, but due to the rise of Naziism his family escaped to the USA in 1939. Penzias was interested in physics from an early age, and majored in the subject at the City College of New York. He then went to Columbia University to study for a Ph.D. in radio astronomy. His advisor at Columbia was Charles Townes, who would later win a Nobel Prize for his invention of the maser. Wilson had grown up in Texas, and majored in physics at Rice University in Houston, and had then gone on to Caltech in 1957 to study for a Ph.D.
>
> ![](https://cdn.britannica.com/83/19183-004-033404B4.jpg)

## Full text

Extracted from the PDF. [Annotation N] marks where each annotation above sits.

#### Page 1

19

65ApJ.

. .142.

.419P

No. 1, 1965 LETTERS TO THE EDITOR 419

high pressure, such as the zero-mass scalar, capable of speeding the universe through the period of helium formation. To have a closed space, an energy density of 2 X 10 -29

gm/cm 3 is needed. Without a zero-mass scalar, or some other “hard” interaction, the energy could not be in the form of ordinary matter and may be presumed to be gravitational radiation (Wheeler 1958). One other possibility for closing the universe, with matter providing the energy content of the universe, is the assumption that the universe contains a net electron-type neutrino abundance (in excess of antineutrinos) greatly larger than the nucleon abundance. In this case, if the neutrino abundance were so great that these neutrinos are degenerate, the degeneracy would have forced a negligible equilibrium neutron abundance in the early, highly contracted universe, thus removing the possibility of nuclear reactions leading to helium formation. However, the required ratio of lepton to baryon number must be > 10 9 .

We deeply appreciate the helpfulness of Drs. Penzias and Wilson of the Bell Telephone Laboratories, Crawford Hill, Holmdel, New Jersey, in discussing with us the result of their measurements and in showing us their receiving system. We are also grateful for several helpful suggestions of Professor J. A. Wheeler.

R. H. Dicke P. J. E. Peebles P. G. Roll D. T. Wilkinson May 7, 1965 Palmer Physical Laboratory Princeton, New Jersey

REFERENCES

Alpher, R. A , Bethe, H. A , and Gamow, G 1948, Phys. [Annotation 1] Rev., 73, 803 Alpher, R A., Follín, J W., and Herman, R. C. 1953, Phys. Rev , 92, 1347. Bondi, H , and Gold, T. 1948, M N., 108, 252. Brans, C , and Dicke, R. H 1961, Phys. Rev., 124, 925. Dicke, R. H. 1962, Phys. Rev., 125, 2163. Dicke, R. H , Beringer, R., Kyhl, R L , and Vane, A B. 1946, Phys. Rev., 70, 340 Einstein, A, 1950, The Meaning of Relativity (3d ed.; Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press), p. 107. Hoyle, F. 1948, M N , 108, 372. Hoyle, F , and Tayler, R J 1964, Nature, 203, 1108 Liftshitz, E M., and Khalatnikov, I. M 1963, Adv. in Phys , 12, 185. Oort, J H 1958, La Structure et Involution de Vuniverse (11th Solvay Conf [Brussels: Éditions Stoops]), p. 163. Peebles, P J. E. 1965, Phys. Rev. (in press). Penzias, A. A., and Wilson, R. W. 1965, private communication. Wheeler, J. A , 1958. La Structure et involution de Vuniverse (11th Solvay Conf. [Brussels: Éditions Stoops]), p. 112. 1964, in Relativity, Groups and Topology, ed C. DeWitt and B. DeWitt (New York: Gordon & Breach). ZePdovich, Ya. B. 1962, Soviet Phys.—J.E.T.P., 14, 1143.

A MEASUREMENT OF EXCESS ANTENNA TEMPERATURE AT 4080 Mc/s

Measurements [Annotation 2] of the effective zenith noise temperature of the 20-foot horn-reflector antenna (Crawford, Hogg, and Hunt 1961) at the Crawford Hill Laboratory, Holmdel, New Jersey, at 4080 Mc/s have yielded a value about 3.5° K higher than expected. This excess temperature is, within the limits of our observations, isotropic, unpolarized, and

© American Astronomical Society • Provided by the [Annotation 3] NASA Astrophysics Data System

#### Page 2

19

65ApJ.

. .142.

.419P

420 LETTERS TO THE EDITOR Vol. 142

free from seasonal variations (July, 1964-April, 1965). A possible explanation for the observed excess noise temperature is the one given by Dicke, Peebles, Roll, and Wilkinson (1965) in a companion letter in this issue. The total antenna temperature measured at the zenith is 6.7° K of which 2.3° K is due to atmospheric absorption. The calculated contribution due to ohmic losses in the antenna and back-lobe response is 0.9° K. The radiometer used in this investigation has [Annotation 4] been described elsewhere (Penzias and Wilson [Annotation 5] 1965). It employs a traveling-wave maser, a low-loss (0.027-db) comparison switch, and a liquid helium-cooled reference termination (Penzias 1965). Measurements were made by switching manually between the antenna input and the reference termination. The antenna, reference termination, and radiometer were well matched so that a round-trip return loss of more than 55 db existed throughout the measurement; thus errors in the measurement of the effective temperature due to impedance mismatch can be neglected. The estimated error in the measured value of the total antenna temperature is 0.3° K and comes largely from uncertainty in the absolute calibration of the reference termination.

The contribution to the antenna temperature due to atmospheric absorption was obtained by recording the variation in antenna temperature with elevation angle and employing the secant law. The result, 2.3° ± 0.3° K, is in good agreement with published values (Hogg 1959; DeGrasse, Hogg, Ohm, and Scovil 1959; Ohm 1961). The contribution to the antenna temperature from ohmic losses is computed to be 0.8° ± 0.4° K. In this calculation we have divided the antenna into three parts: (1) two non-uniform tapers approximately 1 m in total length which transform between the 2f-inch round output waveguide and the 6-inch-square antenna throat opening; (2) a double-choke rotary joint located between these two tapers; (3) the antenna itself. Care was taken to clean and align joints between these parts so that they would not significantly increase the loss in the structure. Appropriate tests were made for leakage and loss in the rotary joint with negative results. The possibility of losses in the antenna horn due to imperfections in its seams was eliminated by means of a taping test. Taping all the seams in the section near the throat and most of the others with aluminum tape caused no observable change in antenna temperature.

The backlobe response to ground radiation is taken to be less than 0.1° K for two reasons: (1) Measurements of the response of the antenna to a small transmitter located on the ground in its vicinity indicate that the average back-lobe level is more than 30 db below isotropic response. The horn-reflector antenna was pointed to the zenith for these measurements, and complete rotations in azimuth were made with the transmitter in each of ten locations using horizontal and vertical transmitted polarization from each position. (2) Measurements on smaller horn-reflector antennas at these laboratories, using pulsed measuring sets on flat antenna ranges, have consistently shown a back-lobe level of 30 db below isotropic response. Our larger antenna would be expected to have an even lower back-lobe level. From a combination of the above, we compute the remaining unaccounted-for antenna temperature to be 3.5° ± 1.0° K at 4080 Mc/s. In connection with this result it should be noted that DeGrasse el at. (1959) and Ohm (1961) give total system temperatures at 5650 Mc/s and 2390 Mc/s, respectively. From these it is possible to infer upper limits to the [Annotation 6] background temperatures at these frequencies. These limits are, in both cases, of the same general magnitude as our value.

We are grateful to R. H. Dicke and his associates for fruitful discussions of their results prior to publication. We also wish to acknowledge with thanks the useful comments and advice of A. B. Crawford, D. C. Hogg, and E. A. Ohm in connection with the problems associated with this measurement.

© American Astronomical Society • Provided by the NASA Astrophysics Data System

#### Page 3

No. 1, 1965 LETTERS TO THE EDITOR 421

Note added in proof.—The highest frequency at which the background temperature of the sky had been measured previously was 404 Mc/s (Pauliny-Toth and Shakeshaft 1962), where a minimum temperature of 16° K was observed. Combining this value with our result, we find that the average spectrum of the background radiation over this frequency range can be no steeper than X o 7 . This clearly eliminates the possibility that the radiation we observe is due to radio sources of types known to exist, since in this event, the spectrum would have to be very much steeper.

A. A. Penzias R. W. Wilson May 13, 1965 Bell Telephone Laboratories, Inc Craweord Hill, Holmdel, New Jersey

REFERENCES

Crawford, A B., Hogg, D. C , and Hunt, L E 1961, Bell [Annotation 7] System Tech. /., 40, 1095. DeGrasse, R. W , Hogg, D C , Ohm, E A , and Scovil, H. E. D 1959, “Ultra-low Noise Receiving System for Satellite or Space Communication,” Proceedings of the National Electronics Conference, 15, 370. Dicke, R H , Peebles, P. J. E., Roll, P G., and Wilkinson, D. T. 1965, Ap /., 142, 414. Hogg, D C 1959, J Appl Phys , 30, 1417 Ohm, E A 1961, Bell System Tech. J , 40, 1065 Pauliny-Toth, I I K., and Shakeshaft, J. R. 1962, M.N., 124, 61. Penzias, A. A 1965, Rev Sei. Instr., 36, 68. Penzias, A A , and Wilson, R W. 1965, Ap J (in press).

ERRATUM

In the paper “Stellar Evolution. I. The Approach to the Main Sequence^ {Ap. 141, 993), the following corrections are to be made: page 993, line 1, replace “popuation” by “population”; page 997, line 18, delete the last word “energy”; page 999, line 2, replace “expanding” by “contracting”; page 1007, section heading VI—replace “8” by “9”; page 1007, line 1, replace “Figure 12” by “Figure 17”; page 1017, line 5, replace “equation (19)” by “equation (B9)”; page 1018, line 6, replace “W. Z. Fowler” by “W. A. Fowler.”

Icko Iben, Jr. June 7, 1965 Massachusetts Institute or Technology

© American Astronomical Society • Provided by the NASA Astrophysics Data System

---

Source: [Fermat's Library](https://fermatslibrary.com/) — https://fermatslibrary.com/s/a-measurement-of-excess-antenna-temperature-at-4080-mc-s. More annotated papers: https://fermatslibrary.com/llms.txt
