A brain-spine interface alleviating gait deficits after spinal cord injury in primates

By Capogrosso et al, 2016

Annotated on Fermat's Library with 0 comments. Text and annotations as Markdown Original paper

284 | NATURE | VOL 539 | 10 NOVEMBER 2016
LETTER
doi:10.1038/nature20118
A brain–spine interface alleviating gait deficits after
spinal cord injury in primates
Marco Capogrosso
1,2
*, Tomislav Milekovic
1
*, David Borton
1,3
*, Fabien Wagner
1
, Eduardo Martin Moraud
2
,
Jean-Baptiste Mignardot
1
, Nicolas Buse
4
, Jerome Gandar
1
, Quentin Barraud
1
, David Xing
3
, Elodie Rey
1
, Simone Duis
1
,
Yang Jianzhong
5
, Wai Kin D. Ko
5
, Qin Li
5,6
, Peter Detemple
7
, Tim Denison
4
, Silvestro Micera
2,8
, Erwan Bezard
5,6,9,10
,
Jocelyne Bloch
11
& Grégoire Courtine
1,11
Spinal cord injury disrupts the communication between the brain
and the spinal circuits that orchestrate movement. To bypass the
lesion, brain–computer interfaces
1–3
have directly linked cortical
activity to electrical stimulation of muscles, and have thus restored
grasping abilities after hand paralysis
1,4
. Theoretically, this strategy
could also restore control over leg muscle activity for walking
5
.
However, replicating the complex sequence of individual muscle
activation patterns underlying natural and adaptive locomotor
movements poses formidable conceptual and technological
challenges
6,7
. Recently, it was shown in rats that epidural electrical
stimulation of the lumbar spinal cord can reproduce the natural
activation of synergistic muscle groups producing locomotion
8–10
.
Here we interface leg motor cortex activity with epidural electrical
stimulation protocols to establish a brain–spine interface that
alleviated gait deficits after a spinal cord injury in non-human
primates. Rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) were implanted with
an intracortical microelectrode array in the leg area of the motor
cortex and with a spinal cord stimulation system composed of a
spatially selective epidural implant and a pulse generator with real-
time triggering capabilities. We designed and implemented wireless
control systems that linked online neural decoding of extension and
flexion motor states with stimulation protocols promoting these
movements. These systems allowed the monkeys to behave freely
without any restrictions or constraining tethered electronics. After
validation of the brain–spine interface in intact (uninjured) monkeys,
we performed a unilateral corticospinal tract lesion at the thoracic
level. As early as six days post-injury and without prior training of
the monkeys, the brain–spine interface restored weight-bearing
locomotion of the paralysed leg on a treadmill and overground. The
implantable components integrated in the brain–spine interface have
all been approved for investigational applications in similar human
research, suggesting a practical translational pathway for proof-of-
concept studies in people with spinal cord injury.
A century of research in spinal cord physiology has demonstrated that
circuits embedded in the lumbar segments of mammals can produce
coordinated patterns of leg motor activity without brain input
11,12
.
Various neuromodulation approaches have been developed to activate
these circuits after injury to re-establish locomotion
8,13–17
. For example,
epidural electrical stimulation (EES) of lumbar segments restored
adaptive locomotion in paralysed rats
8
. Recent studies showed that
EES is also capable of activating lumbar spinal circuits in people with
paraplegia
14,16
.
These empirical observations prompted us to develop an evidenced-
based framework to understand the interactions between EES and
spinal circuits
8–10
. We aimed to exploit this knowledge to optimize
stimulation protocols for clinical applications. Computational mod-
elling and functional experiments revealed that EES engages spinal
circuits through the modulation of proprioceptive feedback circuits
10
.
This framework guided the design of spatiotemporal neuromodulation
therapies that not only activate but also control the activity of spinal
circuits engaging synergistic muscle groups
8–10
, enabling robust mod-
ulation of locomotor movements in rats whose spinal cords were void
of brain input.
However, volitional locomotion requires the brain to control the
activity of spinal circuits. Brain–computer interface technologies
1–4,18
provide the tools to link the intended motor states to EES protocols
19–21
to re-establish voluntary control of locomotion after injury. For these
developments, nonhuman primates are more appropriate models than
rodents because they exhibit cortical engagement during locomotion
similar to humans
22
, analogous recovery mechanisms from injury
23
,
and comparable technological requirements
24
. Here, we decoded motor
states from leg motor cortex activity to trigger EES protocols facilitat-
ing extension and flexion of the corresponding leg. We show that this
brain–spine interface alleviated gait deficits after spinal cord injury in
nonhuman primates.
To support the development of the brain–spine interface, we estab-
lished a wireless recording and stimulation platform in freely behav-
ing, unconstrained and untethered nonhuman primates (Fig. 1 and
Supplementary Video 1). Rhesus monkeys (Supplementary Table 1)
were implanted with a microelectrode array into the leg area of the
left motor cortex to record spiking activity from neuronal ensembles.
Electromyographic signals were monitored using bipolar electrodes
implanted into antagonist muscles spanning each joint of the right
leg. Wireless modules enabled transmission of neural (20 kHz) and
electromyographic (2 kHz) signals to external receivers
25
. We simul-
taneously acquired video recordings (100 Hz) to reconstruct whole-
body kinematics
23
. To deliver EES, we used technologies previously
developed in rats
9
, which we adapted to the characteristics of spinal
segments and vertebrae measured in three monkeys (Extended Data
Fig. 1). These spinal implants were inserted into the epidural space over
lumbar segments, and connected to an implantable pulse generator
commonly used for deep brain stimulation therapy. We engineered
wireless communication modules that enabled control over the spatial
and temporal parameters of EES with a latency of about 100 ms
(Extended Data Fig. 2).
We first used well established methods
9,26
to identify the natural
spatiotemporal pattern of motoneuron activation underlying
locomotion. Our aim was to reproduce this pattern after injury.
1
Center for Neuroprosthetics and Brain Mind Institute, School of Life Sciences, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (EPFL), Lausanne, Switzerland.
2
Center for Neuroprosthetics and Institute of
Bioengineering, School of Bioengineering, EPFL, Lausanne, Switzerland.
3
School of Engineering, Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island, USA.
4
Medtronic, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
5
Motac
Neuroscience Ltd, Manchester, UK.
6
Institute of Lab Animal Sciences, China Academy of Medical Sciences, Beijing, China.
7
Mainz Institute for Microtechnology, Fraunhofer Institute for Chemical
Technology (ICT-IMM), Mainz, Germany.
8
The BioRobotics Institute, Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Pisa, Italy.
9
Institut des Maladies Neurodégénératives, University of Bordeaux, UMR 5293,
Bordeaux, France.
10
CNRS, Institut des Maladies Neurodégénératives, UMR 5293, Bordeaux, France.
11
Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois (CHUV), Lausanne, Switzerland.
* These authors contributed equally to this work.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
10 NOVEMBER 2016 | VOL 539 | NATURE | 285
We conducted an anatomical tracing to identify the spatial distribu-
tion of motoneuron pools innervating antagonist muscles spanning
each joint of the leg (Fig. 2a). We then projected the muscle activity
recorded during locomotion onto motoneuron locations to visualize
the spatiotemporal maps of motoneuron activation (Fig. 2c). These
maps showed that locomotion involves the successive activation of
well defined hotspots located in specific regions of the spinal cord
that were similar across monkeys (Extended Data Fig. 3). The most
intense hotspots emerged in the caudal (L6/L7) and rostral (L1/L2)
compartments of lumbar segments around the transitions between
stance and swing phases. We labelled these hotspots the extension and
flexion hotspots, respectively.
EES activates motoneurons through the recruitment of large-diameter
proprioceptive fibres within the dorsal roots
10,27
. To access the exten-
sion and flexion hotspots, we targeted the dorsal roots projecting to
spinal segments containing these hotspots. We reconstructed the spatial
trajectory of the dorsal roots innervating each lumbar segment, and
integrated this information together with motoneuron distribution
into a unified library (Fig. 2a). We used the entry points of the dorsal
roots as the targeted anatomical landmarks that guided the design
and positioning of spinal implants (Fig. 2b and Extended Data Fig. 1).
Experiments in three sedated monkeys confirmed that single EES
pulses delivered through the electrodes targeting the extension and
flexion hotspots led to spinal segment activation that correlated with
the activation of these hotspots during locomotion (Fig. 2c and d, and
Extended Data Fig. 3).
We next exploited cortical signals to decode the temporal struc-
ture of extensor and flexor hotspot activation. The spiking activity
recorded from the left motor cortex displayed cyclic modulations that
were phase-locked with right leg movements (Extended Data Fig. 4a).
We developed a decoder that calculated the probability of foot-strike
and foot-off events from this modulation to anticipate the activation
of extensor and flexor hotspots associated with right leg movements
(Extended Data Fig. 4b). Evaluations in two intact monkeys showed
that the decoder accurately predicted these gait events in real time over
extended periods of locomotion, including when initiating and termi-
nating gait, and during rest (Extended Data Fig. 5).
We then exploited our wireless platform to implement a brain–spine
interface—a system wherein the decoded motor states triggered EES
protocols targeting the extension and flexion hotspots. We tested the
capacity of the brain–spine interface to modulate the extension and
flexion hotspots independently and simultaneously in two intact mon-
keys during locomotion on a treadmill. We calibrated the decoder with
FluoroRuby
L1
L7
S1
L2
L5
L4
L3
L6
FHL
GLU
GM
ST
IPS
TA
EDL
RF
Motoneuron pools
GM
FastBlue
b
c
FastBlue
Spatial map of single pulse
motoneuron activation
IPS
Min
Max
μCT scan
L1
L7
L2
L5
L4
L3
L6
Foot off
d
Flexion
Extension
–1
1
Q1 Q2 P1
Hotspot correlation
Spatiotemporal map of
motoneuron activation
Bi-articular
Spinal implant
100 μm
Extensors
Flexors
–1
1
Foot strike
0
0
Flexion
stimulation
Extension
stimulation
Q1 Q2 P1
Extension
hotspot
Min Max
SwingStance
SwingStance
MonkeyMonkey
Lateral Dorsal
Value, r
Value, r
L3
L4
L2
L1
L5
F
as
t
Min
Max
L7
L1
L2
L5
L4
L3
L6
L7
L1
L2
L5
L4
L3
L6
Flexion
hotspot
Figure 2 | Development and validation of selective spinal cord
stimulation protocols. a, Diagram illustrating injections of retrograde
anatomical tracers into leg muscles to label motoneurons. The inset shows
a confocal photograph of labelled motoneurons. The 3D reconstruction
shows each labelled motoneuron innervating the iliopsoas (IPS) and
gastrocnemius medialis (GM) muscles. The same procedure was applied
to the gluteus medius (GLU), rectus femoris (RF), semitendinosus (ST),
extensor digitorum longus (EDL), and flexor hallucis longus (FHL)
muscles. The diagram reports the distribution of leg motoneurons within
the spinal cord (n = 1-2 monkeys per muscle). b, Representative micro-
computed tomography (μ CT) scans of the spinal implant (monkey Q1).
c, Electromyography of the recorded leg muscles (monkey Q1) was
projected onto the motoneuron locations in the spinal cord to compute the
mean (n = 73 gait cycles) spatiotemporal map of motoneuron activation
during locomotion. Maps recorded around foot off (- 10% to + 20% of
gait cycle) and foot strike (- 10% to + 30%) were extracted to highlight
extension and flexion hotspots (see data from other monkeys in Extended
Data Fig. 3). d, Median (n = 6 pulses) spatial map of motoneuron
activation resulting from single pulses of stimulation delivered through the
electrodes targeting the extension and flexion hotspots. For each monkey,
the bar plots report the correlation between these spatial maps and the
maps corresponding to the extension and flexion hotspots. L, lumbar.
Figure 1 | Conceptual and technological design of the brain–spine
interface. The monkeys were implanted with a microelectrode array into
the leg area of the left motor cortex. During recordings, a wireless module
transmitted broadband neural signals to a control computer. (1) A raster
plot recorded over three successive gait cycles. Each line represents spiking
events identified from one electrode, while the horizontal axis indicates
time. (2) A decoder running on the control computer identified motor
states from these neural signals. (3) These motor states triggered electrical
spinal cord stimulation protocols. For this, the monkeys were implanted
with a pulse generator featuring real-time triggering capabilities. (4) The
stimulator was connected to a spinal implant targeting specific dorsal
roots of the lumbar spinal cord. Electromyographic signals of an extensor
(grey) and flexor (black) muscles acting at the ankle recorded over
three successive gait cycles are shown together with a stick diagram
decomposition of leg movements during the stance (grey) and swing
(black) phases of gait. Copyright Jemère Ruby (2016).
Motor states decoding
Implantable
pulse generator
Motor cortex activity
1
2
3
4
Spinal cord
lesion
96 channels
μ-array
Leg kinematic
Wireless muscle activity
Epidural electrical
stimulation
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
286 | NATURE | VOL 539 | 10 NOVEMBER 2016
temporal offsets that were tuned to trigger and terminate stimulation
protocols concomitantly to the activation of each hotspot (Fig. 3a and
Supplementary Methods). We used data without and with stimulation
to calibrate the decoders
4
, which substantially improved decoding accu-
racy (Extended Data Fig. 5).
Without prior training of the monkeys, brain-controlled stimula-
tion of the extension and flexion hotspots immediately modulated
kinematic and muscle activity parameters related to the extension and
flexion of the leg ipsilateral to stimulation (Fig. 3). A gradual increase
in the frequency or amplitude of EES pulses led to a monotonic mod
-
ulation of these parameters (Extended Data Fig. 6). We previously
documented similar responses in rodents
8–10
, suggesting that the
mechanisms underlying the modulation of spinal activity with EES
are similar across mammals, including humans
14,16
.
Finally, we tested the ability of the brain–spine interface to alleviate
locomotor deficits after a lesion of the corticospinal tract extending into
the right dorsolateral column of mid-thoracic segments in two monkeys
(Fig. 4a). Additional pathways were damaged, including the rubrospinal
tract, dorsal column and reticulospinal fibres. This lesion initially led to
a paralysis of the leg ipsilateral to the lesion, followed by an extensive yet
incomplete spontaneous recovery (Fig. 4b and Extended Data Fig. 7).
During the first week after the lesion and without training of the
monkeys, the brain–spine interface restored weight-bearing locomotion
on a treadmill (Fig. 4b, c) and overground (Extended Data Fig. 8),
improving both the quantity and quality of steps performed by the
impaired leg (Fig. 4d, e and Extended Data Fig. 9 and Supplementary
Video 1). The quantity and quality of steps was directly linked to the
temporal structure of the stimulation (Extended Data Fig. 10).
Accuracy of decoded extension and flexion motor states from neural
activity declined shortly after the lesion and then improved during the
following week. This improvement suggested that the initial decrease
was probably due to the reorganization of cortical dynamics (Extended
Data Fig. 9). This recovery coincided with improvement in the
quantity and quality of steps, indicating that the monkeys had spon-
taneously regained some degree of neural control over the impaired
leg (Extended Data Fig. 7). At this stage, the brain–spine interface alle-
viated many of the remaining gait deficits (Fig. 4d, e). Tuning the EES
frequency maximized the quantity and quality of steps, whereas the
same stimulation protocols (that is, the same electrode configurations
at same amplitudes and frequencies of stimulation) applied continu-
ously failed to facilitate locomotion or were markedly less efficient
than brain-controlled stimulation (Extended Data Fig. 10).
The recovery of coordinated, weight-bearing locomotion in a primate
model of spinal cord injury emphasizes the therapeutic potential of
the brain–spine interface for clinical applications. We have integrated
intracortical arrays
2,3
, wireless modules
25
and pulse generators that have
Figure 3 | Brain-controlled stimulation modulates the extension
and flexion of the leg during locomotion in intact monkeys. a, Two
successive gait cycles recorded during locomotion without stimulation
and during brain-controlled stimulation of the flexion hotspot, extension
hotspot, or both (monkey Q2). From top to bottom: stick diagram
decompositions of right leg movements; example of single-channel neural
recording; probability of foot-off and foot-strike motor states; detected
motor states (cyan and magenta broken lines), periods of stimulation
through the electrodes targeting the flexion and extension hotspots;
electromyographic signals; and limb length calculated as the distance
from the hip to the fifth metatarsal joint. The grey and white backgrounds
correspond to stance and swing, respectively. b, Relationship between
frequency of brain-controlled flexion stimulation and step height, and
between the stimulation amplitude and the activity of the GM muscle
during brain-controlled extension stimulation (normalized to the GM
mean activity 1 for stimulation ‘OFF’). Values for individual gait cycles
(smaller dots) and mean values (larger dots) are shown. * * * P < 0.001,
Wilcoxon rank-sum test. c, Bar plots reporting the mean step height
and mean GM activity without stimulation and during brain-controlled
stimulation for monkeys Q1 (n = 125 steps) and Q2 (n = 119 steps).
* * * P < 0.001, Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Error bars, s.e.m. d, Decoder
confusion matrices calculated during brain-controlled stimulation for
monkeys Q1 (n = 125 steps) and Q2 (n = 119 steps).
Brain control (exion) Brain control (extension)
10 cm
Intact
RF
GM
0.5 s
Limb
length
10 cm
Neural
Signal
1 mV
100 μV
01
Kinematics
a
Stimulation
b
Brain control (both)
Brain control (both)
Extension stimulation
Flexion stimulation
Foot-strike detection
Foot-strike probability
Foot-off detection
Foot-off probability
Stance
Swing
Probabilities
1 mV
dc
Monkey Q1
0% 100%
Foot strike
Foot off
Neither
Monkey Q2
ON
94
06
0 81 19
1396
ON
Foot strike
Foot off
Neither
60 139
2 80 18
11 5 83
Step height of
monkey Q2 (cm)
6
22
***
***
***
Frequency (Hz)
Brain control
(exion)
OFF 8030 40 50
GM activity of
monkey Q2 (normalized)
1
3
***
***
Amplitude (V)
Brain control
(extension)
OFF 1.51.7 1.8
60 70
GM activity
(normalized units)
0
2
OFF ON
***
Q2
***
Q1
Step height (cm)
20
0
***
Q2
***
Q1
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
10 NOVEMBER 2016 | VOL 539 | NATURE | 287
been approved for research applications in humans, thus potentially
enabling proof-of-concept clinical studies.
Our brain–spine interface exploits neuronal ensemble modulation
that naturally occurs during locomotion, immediately linking cortical
dynamics with spatiotemporal neuromodulation therapies without
prior training of the monkeys. This ecological approach
28
enabled
a smooth cooperation between residual supraspinal signals and the
brain–spine interface in generating leg movements. Imaging
29
and
electrophysiological
4
studies have shown that leg motor cortex dynamics
is preserved in people with paralysis. Moreover, cortical activity modu-
lates with intended movements in people with long-lasting tetraplegia,
which has allowed them to control robotic arms
2,3
and neuromuscular
stimulators
4
. These results suggest that the decoding strategy employed
in this study may have useful application in people with paraplegia.
Our model of paralysis avoided many of the complications associated
with severe injuries that are difficult to manage and ethically debata-
ble in primates
24
. The use of a brain–spine interface to restore bipedal
locomotion in humans after severe injuries may require additional
interventions, including monoaminergic replacement therapies
13,19
compensating for the interrupted source of serotonin from brainstem
centres and robotic systems to sustain balance. Nevertheless, several
people with complete leg paralysis regained weight-bearing standing
and stepping movements during continuous EES
14,16
. Therefore, it
should now be possible to test the efficacy of the brain–spine interface
to enhance neuroplasticity
21,30
during rehabilitation in people with
spinal cord injury.
Online Content Methods, along with any additional Extended Data display items and
Source Data, are available in the online version of the paper; references unique to
these sections appear only in the online paper.
Received 10 May; accepted 27 September 2016.
1. Ethier, C., Oby, E. R., Bauman, M. J. & Miller, L. E. Restoration of grasp following
paralysis through brain-controlled stimulation of muscles. Nature 485,
368–371 (2012).
2. Collinger, J. L. et al. High-performance neuroprosthetic control by an individual
with tetraplegia. Lancet 381, 557–564 (2013).
3. Hochberg, L. R. et al. Reach and grasp by people with tetraplegia using a
neurally controlled robotic arm. Nature 485, 372–375 (2012).
4. Bouton, C. E. et al. Restoring cortical control of functional movement in
a human with quadriplegia. Nature 533, 247–250 (2016).
5. Mushahwar, V. K., Guevremont, L. & Saigal, R. Could cortical signals control
intraspinal stimulators? A theoretical evaluation. IEEE Trans. Neural Syst.
Rehabil. Eng. 14, 198–201 (2006).
BDA
a
Monkey Q2 Monkey Q3
Corticospinal tract
Lesion
d
Monkey Q2
0
100%
Steps
Day 6 Day 14
Q3
Day 16
***
Stepping quantity
T7
lesion
Stepping quality, performed on identied steps
Swing
Stance
Hanging
c
Q3
Stimulation OFF
Monkey Q2 (day 6)
e
BDA NeuN GFAP
b
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
*
(1)
(1)
(2)
(2)
T7
Left
Right
Left
Right
Stance
Stance
Distance fr
om intact in the kinematic space
Arbitrary units
***
Arbitrary units
4
11
Paralysis
412 35
41235
412
35
412
35
Monkey Q2
Paralysis / stumbling
*** ***
Steps
PC1 (18%)
PC2 (14%)
6
10
14
***
***
4
8
12
Day 6 Day 14
00
Intact
Intact
Intact
b
Brain Control
10 cm
10 cm
Stimulation OFF
Limb
Length
Neural
Signal
100 μV
Monkey Q2 (day 6)
Stimulation
0.5 s
0.5 s
Day 16
Extension stimulationFlexion stimulation
Brain control
Stimulation
OFF
Brain control
Day 6
Day 14
Day 6
Day 14
Figure 4 | The brain–spine interface alleviates gait deficits after
spinal cord injury. a, Diagram illustrating the location of the lesion and
corticospinal tract labelling using biotinylated dextran amine (BDA).
Right, anatomical reconstructions of spinal segments containing the lesion
(grey), for monkeys Q2 and Q3. Photographs including insets (1) and (2),
showing a longitudinal view of the lesioned spinal cord wherein astrocytes
(glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP); grey), neurons (anti-NeuN antibody
(NeuN); cyan) and corticospinal tract axons (BDA, pink) are labelled. The
asterisk indicates the lesion. The overview scale bar is 500 μ m and the inset
scale bars are 50 μ m. b, Gait cycles performed during locomotion without
stimulation and during brain-controlled stimulation of both flexion and
extension hotspots in monkey Q2 at 6 days post-lesion. Conventions are as
in Fig. 3. Limb paralysis is shown in red. c, Snapshots extracted from video
recordings showing a sequence of leg movements without stimulation and
during brain-controlled stimulation (monkey Q2, 6 days post-injury). The
timeline indicates video snapshot timing. The key refers to panels d and e.
d, Bar plots reporting the ratio between steps performed by the affected
versus unaffected leg by each monkey without stimulation (n = 6 for day 6
and n = 39 for day 14 for Q2, n = 68 for Q3) and during brain-controlled
stimulation (n = 12 for day 6 and n = 93 for day 14 for Q2, n = 31 for Q3).
* * *P < 0.001, bootstrap. Error bars, s.e.m. e, Principal component analysis
applied on 26 gait parameters for Q2. All the gait cycles corresponding
to limb paralysis or stumbling have been excluded from this analysis.
Each gait cycle is shown in the space defined by PC1 and PC2. Bar plots
reporting the mean Euclidean distance between pre-lesion and post-lesion
gait cycles corresponding to steps, calculated in the entire kinematic space.
* * *P < 0.001, Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Error bars, s.e.m.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
288 | NATURE | VOL 539 | 10 NOVEMBER 2016
6. Ho, C. H. et al. Functional electrical stimulation and spinal cord injury.
Phys. Med. Rehabilitation Clinics North Am. 25, 631–654 (2014).
7. Kapadia, N. et al. A randomized trial of functional electrical stimulation for
walking in incomplete spinal cord injury: eects on walking competency.
J. Spinal Cord Med. 37, 511–524 (2014).
8. Wenger, N. et al. Closed-loop neuromodulation of spinal sensorimotor circuits
controls rened locomotion after complete spinal cord injury. Sci. Transl. Med.
6, 255ra133 (2014).
9. Wenger, N. et al. Spatiotemporal neuromodulation therapies engaging muscle
synergies improve motor control after spinal cord injury. Nat. Med. 22,
138–145 (2016).
10. Moraud, E. M. et al. Mechanisms underlying the neuromodulation of spinal
circuits for correcting gait and balance decits after spinal cord injury. Neuron
89, 814–828 (2016).
11. Sherrington, C. S. Flexion-reex of the limb, crossed extension-reex, and reex
stepping and standing. J. Physiol. 40, 28–121 (1910).
12. Kiehn, O. Decoding the organization of spinal circuits that control locomotion.
Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 17, 224–238 (2016).
13. Holinski, B. J., Everaert, D. G., Mushahwar, V. K. & Stein, R. B. Real-time control
of walking using recordings from dorsal root ganglia. J. Neural Eng. 10, 056008
(2013).
14. Angeli, C. A., Edgerton, V. R., Gerasimenko, Y. P. & Harkema, S. J. Altering spinal
cord excitability enables voluntary movements after chronic complete
paralysis in humans. Brain 137, 1394–1409 (2014).
15. Gerasimenko, Y. P. et al. Noninvasive reactivation of motor descending control
after paralysis. J. Neurotrauma 32, 1968–1980 (2015).
16. Danner, S. M. et al. Human spinal locomotor control is based on exibly
organized burst generators. Brain 138, 577–588 (2015).
17. Barthelemy, D., Leblond, H. & Rossignol, S. Characteristics and mechanisms
of locomotion induced by intraspinal microstimulation and dorsal root
stimulation in spinal cats. J. Neurophysiol. 97, 1986–2000 (2007).
18. Shenoy, K. V. & Carmena, J. M. Combining decoder design and neural
adaptation in brain–machine interfaces. Neuron 84, 665–680 (2014).
19. Shanechi, M. M., Hu, R. C. & Williams, Z. M. A cortical-spinal prosthesis for targeted
limb movement in paralysed primate avatars. Nat. Commun. 5, 3237 (2014).
20. Zimmermann, J. B. & Jackson, A. Closed-loop control of spinal cord stimulation
to restore hand function after paralysis. Front. Neurosci. 8, 87 (2014).
21. Nishimura, Y., Perlmutter, S. I., Eaton, R. W. & Fetz, E. E. Spike-timing-
dependent plasticity in primate corticospinal connections induced during free
behavior. Neuron 80, 1301–1309 (2013).
22. Lemon, R. N. Descending pathways in motor control. Annu. Rev. Neurosci. 31,
195–218 (2008).
23. Friedli, L. et al. Pronounced species divergence in corticospinal tract
reorganization and functional recovery after lateralized spinal cord injury
favors primates. Sci. Transl. Med. 7, 302ra134 (2015).
24. Courtine, G. et al. Can experiments in nonhuman primates expedite the translation
of treatments for spinal cord injury in humans? Nat. Med. 13, 561–566 (2007).
25. Yin, M. et al. Wireless neurosensor for full-spectrum electrophysiology
recordings during free behavior. Neuron 84, 1170–1182 (2014).
26. Yakovenko, S., Mushahwar, V., VanderHorst, V., Holstege, G. & Prochazka, A.
Spatiotemporal activation of lumbosacral motoneurons in the locomotor step
cycle. J. Neurophysiol. 87, 1542–1553 (2002).
27. Rattay, F., Minassian, K. & Dimitrijevic, M. R. Epidural electrical stimulation of
posterior structures of the human lumbosacral cord: 2. Quantitative analysis
by computer modeling. Spinal Cord 38, 473–489 (2000).
Supplementary Information is available in the online version of the paper.
Acknowledgements G.C. holds the International Foundation for Research in
Paraplegia Chair in Spinal Cord Repair. S.M. holds the Bertarelli Foundation
Chair in Translational Neuroengineering. We thank X. Rulin and C. Yunlong for
providing support, taking care of the monkeys, performing behavioural training,
and collecting data; E. Pirondini, N. Pavlova and P. Musienko for help with
experiments; J. Courtine, I. Pitteloud, J. Rubattel, L. Dalang and R. Hasler for
help with kinematic reconstruction; J. Courtine for the voice-over in video;
J. Kreider for help with anatomy; and J. Laurens for discussions and
photographs. The illustrations were created by Jemère Ruby. This work was
supported by Medtronic, the European Community's Seventh Framework
Program (CP-IP 258654, NeuWALK), the International Paraplegic foundation,
a Starting Grant from the European Research Council (ERC 261247, Walk
Again), the Wyss centre in Geneva, a Marie Curie Fellowship to D.B. (331602,
e-WALK), Marie Curie COFUND EPFL fellowships to T.M. and F.W., a Morton Cure
Paralysis Fund fellowship to T.M., and the Swiss National Science Foundation
including the National Centre of Competence in Research in Robotics, the
Sinergia program (CRSII3_160696), the Sino-Swiss Science and Technology
Cooperation (IZLCZ3_156331), and the NanoTera.ch programme (SpineRepair).
Author Contributions M.C., T.M. and D.B. contributed equally to this work. F.W.
and E.M.M. contributed equally to this work. S.M., E.B. and J.B. contributed
equally to this work. M.C. developed the spinal cord stimulation protocols
and the routines for the identification of flexion and extension hotspots.
T.M. developed the brain decoder and the decoder calibration routines. D.B.
developed the experimental platform. M.C., T.M., F.W. and E.M.M. performed all
the behavioural experiments (with help from D.B., J.G., Y.J. and G.C.). M.C., T.M.
and F.W. analysed the data (with input from E.M.M., J.-B.M. and D.X.). M.C., T.M.,
F.W., E.M.M. and J.G. developed the real-time software application. N.B. and
T.D. developed the Neural Research Programmer (with input from M.C., D.B.,
T.M., F.W. and J.G.). Q.B. and E.R. processed the anatomical data. Y.J. trained all
the monkeys. W.K.D.K., Q.L. and E.B. managed the experimental protocols and
procedures. P.D. developed and produced the spinal implants (from designs
by M.C., D.B., J.B. and G.C.). J.B., D.B., Q.L. and G.C. performed the surgeries.
G.C., S.M., E.B., J.B. and P.D. secured funding for the study. G.C. conceived and
supervised the study. G.C. wrote the paper with M.C., T.M. and F.W., and all the
authors contributed to its editing.
Author Information Reprints and permissions information is available at
www.nature.com/reprints. The authors declare competing financial interests:
details are available in the online version of the paper. Readers are welcome to
comment on the online version of the paper. Correspondence and requests for
materials should be addressed to G.C. (gregoire.courtine@epfl.ch).
Reviewer Information Nature thanks A. Jackson, A. Prochazka, S. Scott and the
other anonymous reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work.
28. Courtine, G. & Bloch, J. Dening ecological strategies in neuroprosthetics.
Neuron 86, 29–33 (2015).
29. Shoham, S., Halgren, E., Maynard, E. M. & Normann, R. A. Motor-cortical activity
in tetraplegics. Nature 413, 793 (2001).
30. van den Brand, R. et al. Restoring voluntary control of locomotion after
paralyzing spinal cord injury. Science 336, 1182–1185 (2012).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
METHODS
No statistical methods were used to predetermine sample size. The experiments
were not randomized. The investigators were not blinded to allocation during
experiments and outcome assessment.
Animal husbandry. Experiments were approved by the Institutional Animal
Care and Use Committee of Bordeaux (CE50, France) under the license number
50120102-A and performed in accordance with the European Union directive of
22 September 2010 (2010/63/EU) on the protection of animals used for scien-
tific purposes in an AAALAC-accredited facility (Chinese Academy of Science,
Beijing, China). Nine healthy male rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta, China;
Supplementary Table 1) aged between 4 and 9 years old, and weighing between
4.3 kg and 8.4 kg (6.5 ± 0.5 kg) were housed individually in cages designed according
to European guidelines (2 m × 1.6 m × 1.26 m). Environmental enrichment
included toys and soothing music. All the monkeys are included in the manuscript.
Only two monkeys received a spinal cord injury.
Surgical procedures. All the surgical procedures were performed under full
anaesthesia induced with atropine (0.04 mgkg
-1
) and ketamine (10 mgkg
-1
,
intramuscular injection) and maintained under 1%–3% isofluorane after intu-
bation. A certified functional neurosurgeon (J.B.) supervised all the surgical
procedures. Surgical implantations were performed during a single operation lasting
approximately 8 h. We implanted a 96-channel microelectrode array (Blackrock
Microsystems, of pitch 1.5 mm) into the leg area of the left primary motor cortex
1
(F4, Supplementary Table 1). The monkeys also received a wireless system
2
(T33F-4,
Konigsberg Instruments, USA) to record electromyographic signals from the fol-
lowing leg muscles: gluteus medius (GLU), iliopsoas (IPS), rectus femoris (RF),
semitendinosus (ST), gastrocnemius medialis (GM), tibialis anterior (TA), extensor
digitorum longus (EDL), and flexor hallucis longus (FHL). A custom-made spinal
implant was inserted into the epidural space of the lumbar spinal cord according to
previously described methods
9
. The implant was inserted at the L4–L5 vertebrae
and pulled until it reached the T13–L1 vertebrae. Electrophysiological testing was
performed intra-operatively to adjust the position of the electrodes. Specifically,
we verified that a single pulse of stimulation delivered through the most rostral
and most caudal electrodes induced motor responses in the IPS and GM mus-
cles, respectively. The connector of the implant, enclosed into a titanium orthosis,
was secured to the vertebral bone using titanium screws (Vis MatrixMIDFACE,
of diameter 1.5 mm and length 8 mm, Synthes). The wires were routed subcuta-
neously to an implantable pulse generator inserted between intercostal muscles
(see Supplementary Information).
Monkeys Q2 and Q3 received a spinal cord injury. A partial laminectomy was
made at the level of the T7/T8 thoracic vertebrae. A micro-blade was used to cut
approximately two-thirds of the dorsoventral extent of the spinal cord. The lesion
was completed using micro-scissors under microscopic observation. Animals
retained bowel, bladder, and autonomic function after the injury. The veterinary
team continuously monitored the monkeys during the first hours after surgery,
and numerous times daily during the seven subsequent days. A few hours after
completion of surgical interventions, the animals were able to move around and
feed themselves unaided. Clinical rating and monitoring scales were used to
assess post-operative pain. Ketophen (2 mgkg
-1
; subcutaneous) and Metacam
(0.2 mgkg
-1
; subcutaneous) were administered once daily. Lidocaine cream was
also applied to surgical wounds twice per day. The antibiotics ceftriaxone sodium
(100 mgkg
-1
; intramuscular) was given immediately following surgery, and then
once daily for 7 days.
Experimental recordings. Monkeys were trained to walk on a treadmill and over-
ground along a corridor (300 cm × 35 cm × 70 cm). Plexiglas enclosures were used
to maintain the monkeys within the field of view of the cameras. Food pellets and
fruits rewarded appropriate behaviours. Additional food to complete daily dietary
requirements was provided after training.
Single-pulse stimulation in sedated monkeys. Monkeys were lightly sedated with
ketamine (3.5 mgkg
-1
), and suspended in the air using a jacket that did not impede
leg movements. Single pulses of cathodic monopolar, charge-balanced stimulation
(0.3 ms, 1 Hz) were delivered through the electrodes to elicit compound potentials
in leg muscles. We selected the active sites whose corresponding spatial maps of
motoneuron activation showed the highest correlation with the hotspots.
Brain-controlled stimulation during locomotion in intact monkeys. Brain-
controlled stimulation protocols were tested during locomotion on a treadmill at
a comfortable speed (Q1, 2.0 kmh
-1
; Q2, 1.6 kmh
-1
). Recording sessions were
organized as follows: first, we recorded two to five blocks each of duration 1–2 min
during stepping without stimulation. These baseline recordings were used to
calibrate the decoders for real-time detection of foot-off and foot-strike gait events.
Second, monkeys were recorded during brain-controlled stimulation protocols
involving (1) solely the electrode targeting the extensor hotspot, (2) solely the
electrode targeting the flexor hotspot, and (3) both electrodes. We tested the
effects of stimulation frequency and amplitude over functional ranges (30–80 Hz;
1.5–3.9 V). See Supplementary Table 2.
Brain-controlled stimulation during locomotion in injured monkeys. Monkeys
Q2 and Q3 were recorded after injury as soon as they were able to sustain inde-
pendent locomotion on the treadmill, which corresponded to 6 days and 16 days
post-injury, respectively. Q3 recovered more slowly than Q2, probably owing to
receiving more extensive ventral and lateral spinal cord damage (Extended Data
Fig. 9). Therefore, monkey Q3 could only be recorded when appropriate behav-
ioural and physical conditions were reached, which occurred two weeks post-in-
jury. Owing to restrictions on the total duration of the experiments (2 weeks), only
one entire session could be conducted with this monkey. Following this experi-
ment, the monkey rapidly recovered, which prevented evaluation of the efficacy
of the brain–spine interface. The monkeys were recorded on the treadmill at their
most comfortable speed (1.2–1.4 kmh
-1
for monkey Q2 and 1.0 kmh
-1
for mon-
key Q3). Recording sessions were organized as follows. First, we recorded two to six
blocks each of duration 1–2 min without stimulation. These recordings were used
to calibrate the decoders. Second, the decoders were used to test brain-controlled
stimulation of both the extension and flexion hotspots over a range of stimula-
tion frequencies. The effects of continuous stimulation using the same stimula-
tion features as during brain-controlled stimulation were also tested. Within the
functional range of stimulation parameters, brain-controlled stimulation did not
trigger undesired movements or spasms that impaired locomotor movements. See
Supplementary Table 2.
Data acquisition. Procedures to record kinematics and muscle activity have been
detailed previously
25,31
. Whole-body kinematics was measured using the high-
speed motion capture system SIMI (Simi Reality Motion Systems, Germany), com-
bining 4 or 6 video cameras (100 Hz). Reflective white paint was directly applied
on the shaved skin of the monkey overlying the following body landmarks of the
right side: iliac crest, greater trochanter (hip), lateral condyle (knee), lateral malle-
olus (ankle), 5th metatarsophalangeal (mtp), and the outside tip of the fifth digit
(toe). The Simi motion tracking software was used to obtain the three-dimensional
spatial coordinates of the markers. Joint angles were computed accordingly.
Electromyographic signals were recorded simultaneously (2 kHz, Kronisberg,
USA) and synchronized through the Blackrock Cerebrus system (Blackrock
Microsystems, USA), which also recorded neural signals. For this, the Cereplex
wireless system
25
was mounted on the head of the monkeys. Six antennae and a
receiver were used to transmit
25
broadband neural signals (0.1 Hz to 7.8 kHz band,
sampled at 22 kHz). The signals were band-pass filtered (500 Hz to 7.5 kHz) and
spiking events were extracted through threshold crossings
2,3,32–34
. Specifically, a
spiking event was defined on each channel (96 in total) if the signal exceeded
3.0–3.5 times its root-mean-square value calculated over a period of 5 s. This pro-
cedure resulted in a binary signal from 96 multiunits, each originating from one
of the 96 electrodes of the array. Signals from all 96 multiunits were integrated in
the decoder.
Decoding of motor states from neural signals. Our aim was to deliver stimulation
over the extensor and flexor hotspots around the times at which these hotspots
are active during natural locomotion. To this end, we decoded gait-related motor
states from neural activity and used those detections to trigger the stimulation
protocols at the appropriate times. The control computer was connected to the
local network and continuously received Used Datagram Protocol (UDP) packets
containing neural recordings. We designed a custom in-house software application
running on the control computer (Visual Studio C+ + 2010), which analysed the
neural signals in real time. Every 20 ms, the application made a decision: whether
or not to trigger one of the spinal cord stimulation protocols. The decision was
made based on probabilities of observing a foot-off or a foot-strike motor state
given the history of neural data (300 ms pre-lesion and 400 ms post-lesion), as
calculated by our decoders.
Natural activations of the extension and flexion hotspots were time-locked to
foot-off and foot-strike gait events, respectively). In turn, we defined the foot-off
and foot-strike motor states as the neural activity preceding foot-off and foot-strike
gait events by Δ t
FO
and Δ t
FS
temporal offsets, respectively. The offsets were derived
to maximize the overlap between the stimulation over the hotspots and the natural
activation of those hotspots. In effect, the offsets integrated the latencies between
the gait events and the hotspot activations, as well as latencies related to wireless
communication between our devices, into the design of our decoders.
Extraction of motor states used for decoder calibration. We calibrated the decoders
on data from two to seven no-stimulation blocks recorded at the beginning of each
session. Gait events were identified from electromyographic recordings (Q1) or
from video recordings (Q2 and Q3). Identification of foot-off and foot-strike gait
events from electromyographic recordings was performed using signals from the
iliopsoas muscle, which was active around the time of swing onset and remained
active throughout most of the swing phase of gait. The foot-off and foot-strike
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
gait events were estimated by thresholding the envelope of the rectified electro-
myographic signal. Identification of foot-off and foot-strike gait events from video
recordings was performed visually. After injury and while the monkeys exhibited
minimal movements only of the limb ipsilateral to lesion, foot-off and foot-strike
gait events were defined according to residual hip or knee oscillations, which
correlated with attempts to execute steps.
Calibration to account for stimulation-induced changes in neural signals.
Analysis of the decoding temporal precision in Q1 revealed that decoded foot-off
and foot-strike motor states during brain-controlled stimulation differed from the
times of the motor states estimated from the foot-off and foot-strike gait events
(median difference for foot-off was 68 ms and for foot-strike was - 90 ms). We
did not observe such a difference when detecting motor states in the absence of
stimulation (median difference for foot-off was 11 ms and for foot-strike was 3 ms).
A range of factors could have decreased decoding performance, including changes
in somatosensory feedback influenced by the stimulation, attempts by a monkey
to adapt its gait, changes in stability, and so on. To improve the temporal accuracy
of our decoder, we introduced a decoder recalibration process. The initial decoder,
trained on data without stimulation, was used to trigger stimulation through the
extension hotspot or flexion hotspot independently for 2 to 3 blocks each. The data
collected during these blocks was then combined with the blocks of no stimula-
tion to calibrate a new, second decoder. This decoder successfully compensated
for stimulation-induced changes in motor cortex activity (Fig. 3. and Extended
Data Fig. 5).
Duration of hotspot stimulation protocols. We sought to stimulate flexion and
extension hotspots throughout the duration of their natural activation during loco-
motion. We determined the duration of the flexion and extension hotspot stimu-
lation protocols by setting this duration to 300 ms. We then recorded a few steps
during brain-controlled stimulation, and adjusted the duration of the stimulation
protocols for each monkey when necessary in order to obtain a clear modulation of
leg kinematics. This procedure was performed only once for all pre-injury sessions
and was repeated for each post-injury session.
Blinding. Data analyses, except for identification of the steps and the marking of
foot-off and foot-strike gait events from video recordings, were performed by auto-
matic computer routines. When analyses required involvement of investigators,
these were blind to the experimental conditions.
Spatiotemporal map of motoneuron activation. To visualize spatiotemporal
maps of motoneuron activation, electromyographic signals were mapped onto
the rostrocaudal distribution of the motoneurons reconstructed from histological
analyses. This approach provides an interpretation of the motoneuron activation
at a segmental level rather than at the individual muscle level.
Identification of extensor and flexor hotspots activation. Flexion and exten-
sion hotspots were identified from the mean spatiotemporal map of motoneuron
activation for each monkey independently (n = 3 for Q1, P2 and P3). Single maps
computed between two consecutive foot-strike events were time-interpolated
to a 1,000-point map and averaged to obtain the mean spatiotemporal map of
motoneuron activation. Flexion and extension hotspots were then identified by
time-averaging the mean map around the foot-off event (- 10% + 20% of the gait
cycle) for the flexion hotspot and around the foot strike event (- 10% + 30% of the
gait cycle) for the extension hotspot.
Analysis of muscle recruitment curves. The compound potentials recorded in leg
muscles were rectified and integrated for each muscle and stimulation amplitude,
and represented in colour-coded spatial maps of motoneuron activation. Instead of
measuring specific flexor and extensor muscle selectivity we selected the electrodes
that elicited spatial maps similar to those extracted during activation of the flexion
and extension hotspots, regardless of muscle specificity. The correlation between
the resulting map and the maps recorded during locomotion was calculated for
each monkey to identify the voltage range over which the correlation was max-
imal. The derived voltage range was then used during behavioural experiments
(Extended Data Fig. 3c).
Decoding performance quantification. We quantified the performance of our
asynchronous decoders using confusion matrices and normalized mutual infor-
mation, as described in ref. 35.
Steps classification for kinematic analysis. To evaluate the efficacy of the brain-
spine interface and assess the importance of the timing of stimulation in correcting
gait deficits, we conducted a post-hoc classification of the steps based on the
temporal accuracy of the decoder to reproduce the desired hotspot activation
timings. We defined optimal and sub-optimal steps according to the initiation
of flexion and extension hotspot stimulation. All the gait cycles that contained
only one correct extension activation (stimulation occurring at foot-strike
± 125 ms) and only one correct flexion activation (stimulation occurring between
foot-off - 200 ms and foot-off + 50 ms) were defined as optimal steps (Extended
Data Fig. 10).
Stepping quantity. After the spinal cord lesion, the monkeys typically walked
using their three intact limbs while the leg ipsilateral to the lesion was either drag-
ging along the walking surface or maintained in a flexed posture. Occasionally,
monkeys hopped to move both legs forward and avoid bumping against the back
of the treadmill enclosure, owing to their inability to move at the selected treadmill
belt speed. We counted the numbers of these ‘hop’ and ‘bump’ steps as well as
the numbers of normal steps. Experimenters were blinded to stimulation condi-
tions during this analysis. To quantify the functional improvement mediated by
the brain–spine interface, we calculated the proportion of normal steps over all
recorded blocks on a given day. To quantify the ability of the monkeys to sustain
locomotion, we extracted all the events marked as steps, and measured the relative
number of steps that were not performed while bumping into the back of the
treadmill enclosure.
Stepping quality. A total of 26 parameters quantifying kinematics (Supplementary
Table 3) were computed for each step according to methods described previously
in refs 8, 9 and 31. We used principal component analysis to visualize the changes
in gait over time and for different conditions (Fig. 4, and Extended Data Figs 7
and 8). To quantify locomotor performance, we calculated the mean Euclidean
distance between steps corresponding to a given experimental condition and
the mean of steps recorded before the lesion in the same monkey in the entire
26-dimensional space of kinematic parameters.
Tissue processing. Monkeys were deeply anesthetized and perfused tran-
scardially with a 4% solution of paraformaldehyde. The spinal cord dura was
removed and the spinal cord was removed by cutting 40-μ m-thick sections using a
cryostat microtome, before storage at 4 °C in 0.1 M phosphate-buffered saline
azide (0.03%).
Anterograde tracing of motor cortex projections. Monkeys Q2 and Q3 under-
went anterograde tracing of corticospinal projections from the leg and trunk area
of the left motor cortex using anatomical tracers. All animals were anesthetized
as described above. Biotinylated dextran amine (BDA; 10% solution in water;
10,000 Da; Molecular Probes, TSA PLUS Biotin KIT PerkinElmer, catalogue number
NEL749A001KT) was injected at 300 nl per site into 40 sites spanning the leg and
trunk regions of the left motor cortex.
Quantification of the spinal cord lesion. Camera lucida reconstructions of the
lesion (Neurolucida 11.0, MBF Biosciences, USA) were performed using evenly
spaced horizontal sections (1:4) throughout the whole dorsoventral axis on
sections labelled for astrocytic (GFAP; 1:1000, Dako, USA, catalogue number
Z0334), NeuN (anti-NeuN; 1:300, Millipore, catalogue number MAB377) and
BDA reactivity. Immunoreactions were visualized with secondary antibodies
labelled with AlexaFluor 488 (1:400, Invitrogen, catalogue number A-11034) and
647 (1:300, Invitrogen, catalogue number A-21235).
Statistical procedures. All the computed parameters were quantified and com-
pared within each monkey. All data are reported as mean values ± standard error
of the mean (s.e.m.). Significance was analysed using the non-parametric Wilcoxon
rank-sum test, bootstrapping or a Monte Carlo approach.
Data availability. Data that support the findings and software routines developed
for the data analysis are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable
request.
31. Courtine, G. et al. Kinematic and EMG determinants in quadrupedal
locomotion of a non-human primate (Rhesus). J. Neurophysiol. 93, 3127–3145
(2005).
32. Fraser, G. W., Chase, S. M., Whitford, A. & Schwartz, A. B. Control of a brain-
computer interface without spike sorting. J. Neural Eng. 6, 055004 (2009).
33. Gilja, V. et al. Clinical translation of a high-performance neural prosthesis.
Nat. Med. 21, 1142–1145 (2015).
34. Aalo, T. et al. Decoding motor imagery from the posterior parietal cortex of a
tetraplegic human. Science 348, 906–910 (2015).
35. Milekovic, T., Ball, T., Schulze-Bonhage, A., Aertsen, A. & Mehring, C. Detection
of error related neuronal responses recorded by electrocorticography in
humans during continuous movements. PLoS One 8, e55235 (2013).
36. Marieb, E. N. Human Anatomy and Physiology 6th edn (Pearson Education,
2003).
37.
Kuypers, H. G. J. M. in Comprehensive Physiology Ch. 3 (John Wiley & Sons, 2011).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 1 | See next page for caption.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 1 | Design and fabrication of the spatially
selective spinal implant. Step 1: Quantification of the length of vertebrae
T12 to L4, and of spinal segments L1 to S1. The photographs show coronal
sections of the left halves of the L3 and S1 spinal segments, including
the dura mater, dorsal roots and spinal tissue. The complementary views
show camera lucida reconstructions of the dorsal roots, white and grey
matter. The dorsal roots projecting to the L1/L2 and L6/L7 spinal segments
are colour-coded to visualize their respective location. Step 2: Three-
dimensional reconstruction of the entire lumbosacral spinal cord and
dorsal roots. The dorsal roots innervating spinal segments containing the
targeted extension (L6, L7) and flexion (L1, L2) hotspots are colour-coded
to help visualize their respective spatial trajectory. The three-dimensional
reconstructions are displayed from a dorsal view, and from a view that is
rotated 45° leftward around the rostrocaudal axis to visualize the trajectory
of the dorsal roots along spinal segments. Step 3: Design of the spatially
selective spinal implants, including the location of the electrodes with
respect to the dorsal roots, and positioning of the implants with respect
to the vertebrae. The cyan and magenta shapes highlight the electrodes
targeting the flexor and extensor hotspots, respectively. Step 4: Mask
layout of the spatially selective epidural spinal implant. Step 5: Fabrication
of the spinal implants. Processing starts with deposition of a 40-μ m-thick
polyimide film by spin coating on the silicon substrate. The polyimide-
based bottom layer constituting the footprint of the implant is realized
through ultraviolet lithography. A 200-nm-thick gold layer is deposited
using vacuum evaporation and lithographically structured to create a
conductive seed pattern. An additional gold layer is electroplated to a
height of approximately 6μ m to create the electrodes and interconnects.
A 20-μ m-thick cover layer of photosensitive polyimide is then applied
by spin coating to uniformly cover the bottom and electrode structure.
A final ultraviolet lithography is applied to structure the top layer of the
implant, and to create openings over the electrodes and contact pads. The
implants are gently released from the carrier wafer. To create a connector,
the contact pads located at the extremity of the implant are glued to a small
support plate made of medical-grade poly-methyl methacrylate (PMMA)
sheet material. Precision milled alignment structures allow fine adjustment
of the support plate to the spinal implant, and to the extremity of the leads.
The support plate contains a seat in which a tiny printed circuit board
with conductive stripes is fixed. Stainless steel leads with silicone rubber
insulation are directly soldered to the contact pads of the implant via the
contact stripes located on the printed circuit board. The resulting implants
and connective leads were highly reliable mechanically and electrically. A
fixation structure was realized by using three-dimensional laser sintering
of medical grade titanium. Step 6: Photographs, including zoomed insets,
showing a fabricated spinal implant and a micro-computed tomography
scan performed after implantation. Photographs, copyright J. Laurens
(2016).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 2 | See next page for caption.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 2 | Protocols and technology of the spinal cord
stimulation system. Step 1: A Neural Research Programmer interface
(screen snapshot) encodes stimulation protocols that are pre-programmed
into a table uploaded to the implantable pulse generator. Each row of
this table corresponds to a specific electrode configuration (cathodes
and anodes) and stimulation features (amplitude, frequency, pulse width
and duration of stimulation). During experiments, the control computer
selects the rows to be executed. The plot reports the distribution of
temporal delays introduced by the communication between the decoder
and the Neural Research Programmer (n = 5,000). Step 2: Stimulation
commands are transmitted to the implantable pulse generator. Commands
are first broadcast via Bluetooth to a module that converts them into
infrared signals transferred to the stimulation programmer device. The
Bluetooth-to-infrared module and the stimulation programmer were
embedded into a jacket worn by the monkeys during the experiments.
The stimulation programmer transmitted the stimulation commands into
the implantable pulse generator via induction telemetry. The antenna
was placed under the jacket, in contact with the skin and aligned to the
implantable pulse generator. The plot reports the distribution of delays
needed to transmit the stimulation commands from the Neural Research
Programmer to the implantable pulse generator. Step 3: The implantable
pulse generator executed the selected stimulation protocols. After
execution of the stimulation command, the implantable pulse generator
switched to idle mode. The shape of a single charge balanced cathodic
pulse is shown in the inset. The plot reports the distribution of time delays
required to execute a single stimulation command by the implantable
pulse generator. Photographs, copyright Medtronic (2016); drawing,
copyright Jemère Ruby (2016).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 3 | See next page for caption.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 3 | Anatomical, computational and functional
experiments allowed the identification of stimulation protocols to
access flexion and extension hotspots. a, Computational procedure
to estimate spatiotemporal maps of motoneuron activation during
locomotion. Step 1: Four pairs of antagonist muscles spanning
each joint of the leg are implanted with bipolar electrodes to record
electromyographic signals during locomotion. Step 2: Muscle activity
recorded during locomotion on a treadmill is band-pass-filtered using a
Butterworth 3rd-order filter (30–800 Hz, monkey P3). Step 3: The signals
are rectified, filtered with a low pass at 10 Hz, normalized to the maximum
activity recorded across all the gait cycles, and then projected onto the
location of the corresponding motoneuron columns in the spinal cord
for each of the recorded muscles. The estimated motoneuron activation
is represented as a colour-coded spatiotemporal map of motoneuron
activation. b, Spatiotemporal maps of motoneuron activation recorded
in three intact monkeys (Q1, P2 and P3). The maps were obtained
by averaging electromyographic signals recorded during continuous
locomotion on a treadmill (n = 73, 25 and 24 steps for monkeys Q1, P2
and P3, respectively). The maps underlying the activation of extension and
flexion hotspots were extracted by averaging the estimated motoneuron
activation around the foot-strike and foot-off events, respectively. For this,
a window was defined from - 10% to + 30% of the gait cycle duration for
the foot-strike event, and from - 10% to + 20% of the gait cycle duration
for the foot-off event. The maps were reproducible across monkeys.
The correlation between monkeys Q1, P2 and P3 for the flexion hotspot
was 0.94, 0.90 and 0.90 for Q1–P2, Q1–P3 and P2–P3, respectively. The
correlation between monkeys Q1, P2 and P3 for the extension hotspot
was 0.88, 0.90 and 0.60 for Q1–P2, Q1–P3 and P2–P3, respectively. The
resulting maps were projected onto the reconstructed spinal segments
(Extended Data Fig. 1). c, Recruitment curves showing the relationships
between motor-evoked potentials elicited by single pulses of epidural
electrical stimulation in each of the recorded hindlimb muscles and
the stimulation amplitude for three intact monkeys (Q1, Q2 and P1).
Stimulation was delivered through the electrodes targeting the extension
and flexion hotspots. The compound responses elicited in leg muscles were
rectified and integrated to calculate the amplitude of the responses, and
then projected on the reconstructed spinal segments. The spatial maps of
motoneuron activation corresponding to the optimal range of stimulation
amplitudes to stimulate the hotspots are displayed for each monkey,
including the location of the electrodes with respect to spinal segments.
To compute the optimal range of stimulation amplitudes for each hotspot,
we extracted the stimulation amplitudes for which the spatial map of
motoneuron activation displayed the highest values of correlation with
the spatial maps of the targeted hotspots. The cyan and magenta shadings
highlight the functional range of stimulation amplitude for each hotspot
and monkey. (a.u., arbitrary units.)
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 4 | Procedure to calibrate the decoders for real-
time detection of motor states. Step 1: The locomotor movements of
the right leg were recorded using the video camera system. In parallel,
neural signals were recorded from the microelectrode array implanted
into the leg area of the primary motor cortex. The signals were band-
pass filtered (0.5–7.5 kHz). A threshold was at 3–3.5 times the standard
deviation in order to obtain spike events. The two data streams were saved
onto computers. Step 2: Visual inspection of the video frames allowed
the identification of foot-off and foot-strike gait events. We estimated
the spike rates from overlapping 150-ms bins that were updated every
20 ms. Gait events were then synchronized with the spike rate estimates
using a trigger saved with the neural data that marked the onset of video
recordings. Step 3: We extracted feature vectors that originated at foot-off
and foot-strike events and assigned them to ‘foot-off’ and ‘foot-strike’
motor state classes, respectively. All other feature vectors were assigned to
the ‘neither’ class. Step 4: Motor state classes of feature vectors were used
to calibrate a regularized linear discriminant analysis decoder. Step 5: The
decoder was uploaded into our real-time analysis application running on
the control computer. Neural data was collected in real time, processed
into spike-rate estimates, and passed through the decoder that calculated
the probabilities of foot-off and foot-strike motor states. When one of
the motor state probabilities crossed a threshold of 0.8, a command to
trigger the flexion or extension hotspot stimulation protocols was sent
to the Neural Research Programmer, which relayed this instruction to
the implanted pulse generator. Owing to the wireless communication,
the command was executed 178 ms (Q1) or 105 ms (Q2 and Q3) after the
detection of the motor states.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 5 | See next page for caption.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 5 | The real-time decoder accurately detected the
motor states and triggered stimulation protocols during locomotion
and when initiating and terminating it in intact monkeys. a, Example
of a continuous sequence of locomotion (20 s) during brain-controlled
flexion and extension stimulation in an intact monkey (Q2, pre-lesion
session 2; see Supplementary Table 2). Conventions are the same as in
Fig. 3. The real-time decoder correctly detected the succession of 22
foot-off and foot-strike motor states occurring in this sequence (vertical
dotted lines), and appropriately triggered the relevant stimulation
protocols throughout the locomotor sequence. b, Histograms showing the
distribution of the temporal differences between the actual occurrence
of foot-off and foot-strike events and the decoded occurrence of these
motor states for all the recording sessions of the tested intact monkeys
(Q1 and Q2). The dotted lines indicate the median for each distribution.
For monkey Q1, the decoders were calibrated using recordings without
stimulation only. For monkey Q2, we improved the accuracy of the
decoders by performing the calibration twice. First, the decoders were
recalibrated using recordings without stimulation. These decoders were
used to collect recordings during brain-controlled flexion or brain-
controlled extension independently. New decoders were then calibrated
using all the recording blocks together. c, Confusion matrices reporting
the accuracy of the real-time decoders without stimulation and during
brain-controlled stimulation, given a tolerance window of ± 125 ms. The
bar plots report the normalized mutual information calculated for the real-
time decoders compared to random decoders and chance level decoders.
Random decoders were the same decoders calibrated using shuffled gait
events. The chance level decoders randomly assigned motor states with
chance level probabilities, which were estimated from the data used to
calibrate the online decoders, and at the same rate as the online decoders.
* * *P < 0.001, bootstrap. Error bars, s.e.m. d, Two examples of recordings
collected while monkey Q1 and Q2 initiated or terminated sequences of
continuous locomotion on a treadmill. The green shaded area indicates
the period during which the treadmill was turned off. The brain–spine
interface was kept on throughout the recordings. Conventions are the
same as in Fig. 3. The probability of foot-strike and foot-off motor states
remained low during the periods of rest, and recommenced to modulate
with the occurrence of motor states when the monkey resumed continuous
locomotion. The decoder confusion matrices were calculated during
brain-controlled stimulation across all the sessions with intact monkeys
during which the treadmill was turned off (n = 345 and n = 127 temporal
windows for Q1 and Q2). False-positive detections were rare.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 6 | Modulation of leg locomotor movements
during brain-controlled stimulation in intact monkeys. a, Principal
component analysis was applied on individual gait cycles extracted
from locomotion on a treadmill without stimulation (n = 125 and
n = 119 for Q1 and Q2) and during brain-controlled stimulation of the
extension (n = 33 and n = 54 gait cycles with stimulation for Q1 and Q2,
respectively) or flexion (n = 98 and n = 120 total stimulation steps for
Q1 and Q2, respectively) hotspots for the intact monkeys Q1 and Q2.
Conventions are the same as in Fig. 3 and Extended Data Fig. 7. This
analysis emphasizes the graded modulation of gait parameters when
increasing the frequency or amplitude of stimulation for extension and
flexion hotspots independently. b, Plots showing relationships between
the amplitude or frequency of extensor (magenta) or flexor (cyan) hotspot
stimulation and relevant kinematic or muscle activity parameter related
to the extension or flexion of the right leg. The upper right plot shows
the average foot trajectories during each experimental condition,
illustrating the graded modulation of flexion during brain-controlled
stimulation of the flexion hotspot. The lower right plot highlights the
high degree of leg-specific modulation over the entire extent of tested
stimulation parameters. Results were comparable in monkeys Q1 and Q2.
*P < 0.05, **P < 0.001, Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Error bars, s.e.m.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 7 | See next page for caption.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 7 | Quantification and reconstruction of the
spinal cord lesions and quantification of gait deficits and spontaneous
recovery after the spinal cord lesion. a, Scheme illustrating the
anatomical experiments to quantify the lesion of the corticospinal tract.
The anterograde anatomical tracer BDA was injected into the leg and
trunk regions of the left primary motor cortex to label corticospinal tract
fibres in the spinal cord, shown in pink in the photographs. The top-right
scheme shows the approximate pathways of the dorsal ascending tract and
all descending tracts identified from refs 36 and 37. For monkeys Q2 and
Q3, the area of maximal damage was reconstructed in two dimensions by
identifying the border of the glia scar on evenly spaced sagittal sections
spanning the entire dorsoventral extent of the lesioned spinal cord.
b–e, For each monkey, confocal photographs show longitudinal sections
of the lesioned spinal cord at specific dorsoventral levels, as indicated
with dotted lines. In each photograph, the following anatomical elements
are labelled: astrocytes (GFAP, grey), neural cell bodies (NeuN, cyan) and
corticospinal tract axons (BDA, pink). The insets show high-resolution
photographs of selected regions (white squares) of the same photograph
that illustrates intact corticospinal tract axons above the injury, axon
retraction bulbs directly above the lesion, and the absence of axons below
the injury. Monkey Q2 displayed a small subset of spared corticospinal
tract axons in the more dorsal aspect of the dorsolateral column. The
asterisks indicate the location of the lesion. Overview scale bars, 500 μ m.
Inset scale bars, 50 μ m. f, Gait cycles were extracted from locomotion
recorded in monkeys Q2 and Q3 pre-lesion, during the first two weeks
after the lesion, and at 99 days after the lesion. Analysis was only applied
to gait cycles classified as steps, that is, gait cycles classified as limb
paralysis or stumbling were not included. The number of analysed
gait cycles is directly reported into the figure. The bar plots report the
mean Euclidean distance between all the steps on a given recording day
without stimulation and steps recorded before the lesion, computed in the
entire space of the 26 kinematic parameters. The other bar plots report
mean values of relevant kinematic parameters. This analysis illustrates
the progressive yet incomplete recovery of locomotion. * * * P < 0.001,
Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Error bars, s.e.m.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 8 | Restoration of leg locomotor movements
during overground locomotion after the spinal cord lesion.
a, Representative sequences of locomotion along a straight corridor
without stimulation and during brain-controlled stimulation recorded at
7 days and 13 days after the lesion for monkey Q2. Conventions are the
same as in Fig. 4. The bar plots report the mean step height of the right
(lesioned) leg during swing. * P < 0.05, Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Error
bars, s.e.m. b, Snapshots extracted from video recordings showing a
representative sequence of leg movements during one gait cycle without
stimulation and during brain-controlled stimulation at 7days post-injury
for monkey Q2. The stick diagrams overlying the right (lesioned side)
leg and the trajectory of the foot are colour-coded using the same colour
scheme as in the stick diagram decomposition in a. Without stimulation,
the monkey dragged the leg along the ground, whereas brain-controlled
stimulation restored weight-bearing locomotion with plantar placement.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 9 | See next page for caption.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 9 | Quantification of gait improvements and
decoding accuracy during brain-controlled stimulation after the spinal
cord lesion. a, Two successive gait cycles performed during locomotion on
a treadmill without stimulation and during brain-controlled stimulation
in monkey Q2 at 6 days and 14 days post-lesion, and in monkey Q3 at
16 days post-injury. Conventions are the same as in Fig. 4. In addition, the
average foot trajectories calculated over all the recorded gait cycles are
displayed for each experimental condition including during pre-lesion
locomotion, illustrating the marked improvement of foot movements
during brain-controlled stimulation. b, Bar plot reporting the mean values
of the total excursion of the angle, step height and foot trajectory area
for monkeys Q2 and Q3 during locomotion pre-lesion and post-lesion
without stimulation and with brain-controlled stimulation. Analysis was
only applied to gait cycles classified as steps, that is, gait cycles classified as
limb paralysis or stumbling were not included. (For monkey Q2: pre-lesion
n = 294, day 6 post-lesion no stimulation n = 6, brain control n = 12, day
14 no stimulation n = 39, brain control n = 93. For monkey Q3: pre-lesion
n = 185, day 16 post-injury no stimulation n = 98, brain control n = 31.)
 
* P < 0.05, ** P < 0.01, *** P < 0.001, Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Error bars,
s.e.m. c, Bar plots reporting the capacity of the monkeys to sustain walking
at the imposed treadmill belt speed. The functional score is computed as
the percentage of regular steps in which the animal is able to walk at the
treadmill belt speed; that is, the animal does not bump into the back of the
treadmill. Gait cycles classified as hops or stumbling were not included.
* P < 0.05, *** P < 0.001, bootstrap. Error bars, s.e.m. d, Decoding
accuracy increases during recovery after the spinal cord lesion. Decoder
confusion matrices calculated reporting the accuracy of the real-time
decoders and chance level decoder during brain-controlled stimulation
for monkey Q2 at day 6 (n = 76 foot-strikes, n = 74 foot-offs) and day
14 post-injury (n = 264 foot-strikes, n = 264 foot-offs) and for monkey
Q3 at 16 days post-injury (n = 319 foot-strikes, n = 321 foot-offs). The
tolerance window was set at ± 125 ms. The bar plots report the normalized
mutual information calculated for the real-time decoders compared
to random decoders and chance level decoders. * * * ,* * P < 0.001 and
P < 0.01, respectively. Bootstrap. Error bars, s.e.m. e, Top panels, from
left to right: mean event rate, modulation depth and preferred direction
for the neuronal spiking signal recorded obtained by regressing spike
rates against the phase of the gait cycle for monkeys Q1 to Q3. Preferred
direction was defined as the angle for which the fitted tuning function
was at a maximum. Bottom panels, from left to right: mean absolute
single-electrode difference for mean event rates, modulation depths and
preferred directions between two consecutive sessions shown in the top
panels. Analysis shows substantial changes both before and after the
spinal-cord lesion. Nevertheless, the rate of change between the last pre-
lesion and the first post-lesion sessions was substantially higher than
between any two other session pairs, thus indicating increased level of
plasticity following spinal cord lesion. ** P < 0.01, *** P < 0.001, Monte
Carlo, Wilcoxon rank-sum test, signed Wilcoxon rank-sum test and
bootstrap. Error bars, s.e.m.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
letter
reSeArCH
Extended Data Figure 10 | The temporal structure and features
of stimulation determine the quantity and quality of steps. a, Two
successive gait cycles performed during locomotion on a treadmill during
brain-controlled stimulation with optimal and suboptimal temporal
structures at 6 days post-injury, and during continuous stimulation at
14 days post-lesion for monkey Q2. The gait cycles were classified as
suboptimal temporal structures when stimulation occurred outside a
± 125 ms tolerance window. Conventions are the same as in Fig. 4. b, Bar
plots reporting the quantity of steps calculated during locomotion with
optimal and suboptimal temporal structures over a range of stimulation
frequencies and during continuous stimulation for monkeys Q2 and Q3
at 6 days, 14 days and 16 days post-injury. * P < 0.05, ** P < 0.01,  
*** P < 0.001, bootstrap. Error bars, s.e.m. c, Bar plots reporting the
quality of stepping for the same conditions as in b. The quality of stepping
was measured as the mean Euclidean distance between pre-lesion and
post-lesion gait cycles calculated in the kinematic space defined by the 26
gait parameters, as reported in Fig. 4. These results show that the optimal
temporal structure leads to an increased number of steps and improved
quality of stepping compared to sub-optimal temporal structures.
Moreover, brain-controlled stimulation with both optimal and suboptimal
temporal structure promoted markedly improved locomotor performance
compared to continuous stimulation delivered with the same stimulation
features. These results also highlight the ability to optimize locomotor
performance when tuning the stimulation frequency. * P < 0.05, 
 
** P < 0.01, *** P < 0.001, Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Error bars, s.e.m.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.

Discussion

Tap the paper where you want to comment